Project Planning Committee (PPC): Session #68 Closing Report IEEE Presentation Submission Template (Rev. 9) Document Number: IEEE ppc-10/0010 Date Submitted: Source: Jose Puthenkulam Project Planning Committee Chair Venue: San Diego, USA Base Contribution: None Purpose: Project Planning Committee Session #68 Closing Report of activities Notice: This document does not represent the agreed views of the IEEE Working Group or any of its subgroups. It represents only the views of the participants listed in the “Source(s)” field above. It is offered as a basis for discussion. It is not binding on the contributor(s), who reserve(s) the right to add, amend or withdraw material contained herein. Release: The contributor grants a free, irrevocable license to the IEEE to incorporate material contained in this contribution, and any modifications thereof, in the creation of an IEEE Standards publication; to copyright in the IEEE’s name any IEEE Standards publication even though it may include portions of this contribution; and at the IEEE’s sole discretion to permit others to reproduce in whole or in part the resulting IEEE Standards publication. The contributor also acknowledges and accepts that this contribution may be made public by IEEE Patent Policy: The contributor is familiar with the IEEE-SA Patent Policy and Procedures: and. Further information is located at and.

23/13/2016 Outline PPC plan and agenda this week Project planning discussion: New study areas M2M PAR & 5C comments Motions GRIDMAN and PPC joint session update M2M requirements TDD co-existence study item Hierarchical Networks study item Updated Project Planning Map Next steps Backup

33/13/2016 PPC Plan and Agenda this week Time slotsAgenda Tue: PM1 (1-4PM) Opening Project Planning Discussion M2M PAR & 5C TDD Co-existence Study Report Tue: PM2 (4-6PM) Hierarchical Networks Study Report Wed: AM2 (10AM-12 PM) Joint session with GRIDMAN Discussion on Requirements Overlap issues between M2M (P802.16p) and GRIDMAN (P802.16n) M2M Requirements Input contributions discussion Discussion on Project planning aspects Wed: PM1 (1-4PM) M2M PAR & 5C Comments Wed: PM2 (4-6PM) M2M PAR & 5C Comments Hierarchical Networks Study Report Thu: AM (9AM-12PM) M2M Requirements Project Planning Map Update Call for contributions Closing

43/13/ Evolution new study areas We identified some new areas for study –Smart Transport Active transport safety, Tracking, Vehicular M2M –Location Finding/Ranging GPS Augmentation Using Peer to Peer Communication Much higher accuracy than E911 Indoor Location –Mobile Wallets –Mobile Gaming –Systems beyond IMT-Advanced Oct ITU-R Workshop - Plan for Contribution by Sept session #69 Recommendation: –Issue Call for contributions for New areas of Evolution and any study items required for future sessions

53/13/2016 M2M PAR & 5C Comments We had 2 input contributions on the M2M PAR & 5C – Comments –C80216ppc-10_0037.ppt - Security considerations for M2M –C80216ppc-10_0045.doc - Comment on Machine to Machine (M2M) Communication PAR Form and Five Criteria We also received comments from , and Pat Thaler. As a result we revised the PAR form: – We also drafted a response to the comments from , and Pat Thaler. – We also received some additional comments based on our response that we need to address. – 16p-new-par-july-2010.ppthttps://mentor.ieee.org/802.11/dcn/10/ comments-for p-new-par-july-2010.ppt

63/13/2016 Motion Motion: To submit ppc-0003r7 as the draft p PAR & 5C for 802 EC approval, and to approve the substitute version ppc-0003r8 as well. Moved: Jose Puthenkulam Second:

73/13/2016 GRIDMAN and PPC joint session update We had a joint session with GRIDMAN on Wed AM2. –Agenda : Requirements Overlap issues between M2M (P802.16p) and GRIDMAN (P802.16n) –M2M Requirements Input contributions discussion Discussion on Project planning aspects Outcome: –We reviewed some of the M2M requirements contributions –There was some understanding that: Some of the smart metering requirements could be addressed in p. Both projects p and n would address different aspects of support for Smart Grid applications –Also plan to continue requirements co-ordination between the two projects to address overlap concerns

83/13/2016 M2M Requirements Discussion We had 5 contributions on the M2M Requirements (802.16p SRD) –C80216ppc-10_0038r2.doc - Outline of p System Requirements Document –C80216ppc-10_0041r1.doc - M2M Requirements from Vehicular Use Cases –C80216ppc-10_0042r2.ppt - Smart Grid Requirements for IEEE M2M Network –C80216ppc-10_0043.doc - Proposed p System Requirements Document –C80216ppc-10_0046.doc - Requirements for M2M communication We drafted an initial working document (802.16ppc-10/0011) for the p SRD: –

93/13/2016 TDD Co-existence study item We received 1 contribution on the Study Item –C80216ppc-10_0040.doc - Draft Study Report for Study Item on Co- existence with non-802 TDD systems After discussion the proposal was to adopt it is a baseline document using a motion. –Motion to create TDD Co-existence Study Report working baseline (802.16ppc-10/007) based on C80216ppc-10_0040.doc Moved: Yanxiu Zheng Second: Huying Fang Approved with unanimous consent Plan is to issue a Call for comments & contributions for further development after this session towards the Sept. session.

103/13/2016 Hierarchical Networks study item We received the following contributions for the Hierarchical Networks study item –C80216ppc-10_0039.doc - Multi-tier Simulation Methodology –C80216ppc-10_0044.doc - Contribution for Hierarchical Network Study Report –C80216ppc-10_0047.doc - Proposed Table of Content & Usage Models for Hierarchical Networks Study Report There was some drafting done offline to combine the contributions and then we create a baseline and adopted it with a motion. –Motion to create Hierarchical Networks Study Report (802.16ppc- 10/0008) as working baseline Moved: Shilpa Talwar Second: Ronny Kim Approved with unanimous consent Plan is to issue a Call for further comments & contributions towards the Sept. session.

113/13/ Project Planning Map (1/2) Study Items DescriptionProject Target TimeLine M2M First Phase: New requirements for massive number of devices to be connected over 16 Networks. Study Item started: Mar 2010 WG PAR Approval: May 2010 EC PAR Approval: Jul 2010 TG Start: Sep 2010 Std Completion: Jul, 2012 Later Phase: More Advanced M2M capabilitiesTBD Hierarchical Networks Same RAT: Extensions to Advanced Air Interface (802.16m) for multi-tier deployments 802 Multi-RAT: Advanced network topologies offering high capacity at low cost Client Collaboration: Co-operation amongst clients Study item started: May 2010 WG PAR Approval: Jan 2011 EC PAR Approval: Mar 2011 TG Start: TBD Std Completion: TBD Co-existence with non- 802 TDD systems Co-existence with non-802 TDD systems. Example: TDS-CDMA, TD-LTE Study item started: May 2010 WG PAR Approval: Sep 2010 EC PAR Approval: Nov 2010 TG Start: Jan 2011 Std Completion: TBD

123/13/ Project Planning Map (2/2) Study Items DescriptionProject Target TimeLine Enhanced QOE Improved quality of experience for mobile internet applications WG PAR Approval: 2011 EC PAR Approval: TBD TG Start: TBD Std Completion: TBD Ultra High Speed Networks (>1-5Gbps) Advanced MIMO, Higher Order Modulation, Higher Bandwidths, Multicarrier WG PAR Approval: 2011 EC PAR Approval: TBD TG Start: TBD Std Completion: TBD Green RANEnergy savings at Client and Network WG PAR Approval: 2011 EC PAR Approval: TBD TG Start: TBD Std Completion: TBD

133/13/2016 Next Steps Call for contributions for: –Study Report for TDD Co-existence –Study Report for Hierarchical networks –M2M System Requirements Document –New Study Items (ex: Smart Transport…) Conference calls –For developing p M2M System Requirements Document – Aug 25 th : 5-7PM Pacific Time – Sept 8 th : 5-7PM Pacific Time

143/13/2016 Backup

153/13/2016 List of Input Contributions (1/2) M2M PAR & 5C – Comments –C80216ppc-10_0037.ppt - Security considerations for M2M –C80216ppc-10_0045.doc - Comment on Machine to Machine (M2M) Communication PAR Form and Five Criteria TDD Co-existence Study Item –C80216ppc-10_0040.doc - Draft Study Report for Study Item on Co- existence with non-802 TDD systems Hierarchical Networks Study Item –C80216ppc-10_0039.doc - Multi-tier Simulation Methodology –C80216ppc-10_0044.doc - Contribution for Hierarchical Network Study Report –C80216ppc-10_0047.doc - Proposed Table of Content & Usage Models for Hierarchical Networks Study Report

163/13/2016 List of Input Contributions (2/2) M2M Requirements (SRD) –C80216ppc-10_0038r2.doc - Outline of p System Requirements Document –C80216ppc-10_0041r1.doc - M2M Requirements from Vehicular Use Cases –C80216ppc-10_0042r2.ppt - Smart Grid Requirements for IEEE M2M Network –C80216ppc-10_0043.doc - Proposed p System Requirements Document –C80216ppc-10_0046.doc - Requirements for M2M communication