A New Plan of Government date____ oduction=shayshttp:// oduction=shays#
A New Plan of Government date____ Problems would convince citizens that there must be another way….
The Constitutional Convention (Carpenter’s Hall) (Philadelphia – 1787)
The Constitutional Convention (Carpenter’s Hall) (Philadelphia – 1787) -55 delegates (planters, lawyers, governors, etc)
The Constitutional Convention (Carpenter’s Hall) (Philadelphia – 1787) -55 delegates (planters, lawyers, governors, etc) -26 college graduates!
The Constitutional Convention (Carpenter’s Hall) (Philadelphia – 1787) -55 delegates (planters, lawyers, governors, etc) -26 college graduates! -No women, African or Native Americans
The Constitutional Convention (Carpenter’s Hall ) (Philadelphia – 1787) -55 delegates (planters, lawyers, governors, etc) -26 college graduates! -No women, African or Native Americans -Washington chosen to preside over the convention
CHOICES… I. THE VIRGINIA PLAN Who? -
CHOICES… I. THE VIRGINIA PLAN Who? -Edmund Randolph presented the plan (tall, imposing)
CHOICES… I. THE VIRGINIA PLAN Who? Consisted mostly of James Madison’s ideas. He believed in a strong but fair system of government.
CHOICES… I. THE VIRGINIA PLAN WHAT? - Randolph proposes a Supreme National Government
CHOICES: CHOICES -Two houses with both having PROPORTIONAL REPRESENTATION.
CHOICES: CHOICES -Two houses with both having PROPORTIONAL REPRESENTATION. - (lower voted by people) - (upper voted by lower)
CHOICES: CHOICES (Virginia Plan) -PEOPLE 10,000=1 REPS
CHOICES: CHOICES (Virginia Plan) -PEOPLE 10,000=1 REPS -Virginia 750,000
CHOICES: CHOICES (Virginia Plan) -PEOPLE 10,000=1 REPS -Virginia ,000
CHOICES: CHOICES (Virginia Plan) -PEOPLE 10,000=1 REPS -Virginia ,000 -Delaware 60,000
CHOICES: CHOICES (Virginia Plan) -PEOPLE 10,000=1 REPS -Virginia ,000 -Delaware 60,000 6
CHOICES: CHOICES (Virginia Plan) -PEOPLE 10,000=1 REPS -Virginia ,000 -Delaware 60, Pennsylvania 430,000
CHOICES: CHOICES (Virginia Plan) -PEOPLE 10,000=1 REPS -Virginia ,000 -Delaware 60, Pennsylvania 430,000 43
CHOICES: CHOICES ( Virginia Plan) -PEOPLE 10,000=1 REPS -Virginia ,000 -Delaware 60, Pennsylvania 430, Rhode Island 70,000
CHOICES: CHOICES (Virginia Plan) -PEOPLE 10,000=1 REPS -Virginia ,000 -Delaware 60, Pennsylvania 430, Rhode Island 70,000 7 Figures are approximate population for 1790
(The Virginia Plan) Based on a system of checks and balances: Each branch balances the other by checking against any abuse of power!
(The Virginia Plan) Bicameral Legislature, Supreme Court and a President (chosen by the legislature)
THE NEW JERSEY PLAN WHO? Introduced by William Patterson (New Jersey)
THE NEW JERSEY PLAN WHO?? Introduced by William Patterson (New Jersey)
THE NEW JERSEY PLAN a.k.a The Small State Plan
THE NEW JERSEY PLAN Small States wanted a one-house congress with equal representation.
THE NEW JERSEY PLAN Small States wanted a one-house congress with equal representation. State Reps
THE NEW JERSEY PLAN Small States wanted a one-house congress with equal representation. State Reps Virginia
THE NEW JERSEY PLAN Small States wanted a one-house congress with equal representation. State Reps Virginia 1
THE NEW JERSEY PLAN Small States wanted a one-house congress with equal representation. State Reps Virginia 1 N.J.
THE NEW JERSEY PLAN Small States wanted a one-house congress with equal representation. State Reps Virginia 1 N.J. 1
THE NEW JERSEY PLAN Small States wanted a one-house congress with equal representation. State Reps Virginia 1 N.J. 1 Penn
THE NEW JERSEY PLAN Small states wanted a one-house Congress with equal representation. State Reps Virginia 1 N.J. 1 Penn 1
How should we compromise?
The Great Compromise - Also known as the “The Connecticut Compromise”
The Great Compromise -Under Franklin’s guidance and
The Great Compromise -Under Franklin’s guidance and Roger Sherman’s suggestions…..
The Great Compromise - COMBINES THE NEW JERSEY AND THE VIRGINIA PLANS
The Great Compromise -Gives EQUAL REPRESENTATION in the Senate
The Great Compromise -Gives EQUAL REPRESENTATION in the Senate -Based the representation in the House of Representatives on POPULATION
The Great Compromise -Gives EQUAL REPRESENTATION in the Senate -Based the representation in the House of Representatives on POPULATION
THE 3/5ths COMPROMISE -Northern states don’t want slaves to count in population. -Southern states do!
THE 3/5ths COMPROMISE MORE PEOPLE = MORE REPS = MORE SAY = MORE POWER
THE 3/5ths COMPROMISE - It is decided that every 5 slaves will be counted as 3 people toward population (which determines the House)
THE 3/5ths COMPROMISE - Neither side argues that the slaves should be able to vote!
Trading Slaves Slaves can be traded for 20 years (after that congress limits) Agreement was made to keep the southern states in the union
WHAT ABOUT INDIVIDUAL RIGHTS?
Work Finished SEPTEMBER 17, 1787.
Sent to states for approval!
Work Finished SEPTEMBER 17, Sent to States for Approval! 9 out of 13 approved! (New Hampshire is ninth)