Brazil - Training and Tutoring Feedback Second Coordination Meeting Alexandre Gromann de Araujo Góes, D.Sc. Safety Analysis Section (SEASE) Brazilian National Nuclear Energy Commission (CNEN) 15 – 16 June 2016, Thon Hotel EU, Brussels, Belgium

Brazil - Training and Tutoring Feedback Second Coordination Meeting National Regulatory Authority (NRA): Brazilian National Nuclear Energy Commission (CNEN) Directorate of Radioprotection Safety and Security - DRS Regulatory Body 220 workforces 01 Laboratory Directorate of Research and Development - DPD Technical Support Organization 2000 workforces 04 Institutes, 02 Regional Centers, 05 District Offices 15 – 16 June 2016, Thon Hotel EU, Brussels, Belgium

Brazil - Training and Tutoring Feedback Second Coordination Meeting Bilateral Projects: BR – EC Project BR3.01/09 Nuclear Safety Cooperation with the Regulatory Authority of Brazil (CNEN) Finalized: November 2013 BR – EC Project BR3.01/12 Support to the Nuclear Safety Regulator of Brazil Begin: 2015 Finalization: Foreseen 2018 COBEN Brazil – Argentine Practical & Knowledge Exchange in the Nuclear Field Ongoing Project 15 – 16 June 2016, Thon Hotel EU, Brussels, Belgium

Cooperation Projects in T&T 2014 - 2015: Brazil - Training and Tutoring Feedback Second Coordination Meeting Cooperation Projects in T&T 2014 - 2015: European Commission Projects 2014 - Training of 16 specialists 2014 – Tutoring of 01 specialist 2015 - Training of 28 specialists 2015 – Tutoring of 02 specialists IAEA Projects 2014 - training of 01 specialist 2014 – training of 02 specialists (Regional TC, Brazil) 2015 - training of 02 specialists 2015 - training of 08 specialists (Regional TC, Brazil) 15 – 16 June 2016, Thon Hotel EU, Brussels, Belgium

Cooperation Projects in T&T 2014 - 2015: Brazil - Training and Tutoring Feedback Second Coordination Meeting Cooperation Projects in T&T 2014 - 2015: National Training Projects 2014 – training of 12 specialists (NRA Brazil, theory & practice) 2014 – training of 01 specialist (GRS, Brazil) 2015 – training of 04 specialists (NRA Brazil, theory & practice) 2015 – training of 03 specialists (GRS, Brazil) 2015 – training of 05 specialists (Operator Angra-2, Brazil) 2015 – training of 02 specialists (Operator Angra-1, Brazil) 15 – 16 June 2016, Thon Hotel EU, Brussels, Belgium

Where we are in Brazil today? Brazil - Training and Tutoring Feedback Second Coordination Meeting Where we are in Brazil today? Political View Unstable Political Situation, President, Vice - President Political Uncertainties for the Future Nuclear / Technical View Recent and future changes in the Ministry of Science, Technology and Innovation affecting NRA Nuclear Projects ongoing, delayed but not stopped New Nuclear Projects expected for 2025 – 2030 Existing National Training Plan (NTP) for the period 2016 - 2020, based on the NRA revised Strategic Plan Growing retirement rate at NRA Hiring of new staff foreseen in 2017 NRA decided to invest in training possibilities 15 – 16 June 2016, Thon Hotel EU, Brussels, Belgium

Future Needs Training & Tutoring Brazil - Training and Tutoring Feedback Second Coordination Meeting Future Needs Training & Tutoring Topic Comment Evaluation of Safety Culture 02 specialist Induction to Nuclear Safety 05 specialists Safety Assessment for NRA 01 specialist Management Systems and Safety Management Principles in the Execution of the Regulatory Function 02 specialists Regulatory Control of Nuclear Site Evaluation and Inspection during the Siting and Construction Phase EU-Acquis and Radiation Protection, Regulation … 03 specialists 15 – 16 June 2016, Thon Hotel EU, Brussels, Belgium

Future Needs Training & Tutoring Brazil - Training and Tutoring Feedback Second Coordination Meeting Future Needs Training & Tutoring Topic Comment Human and Organizational Factors 02 specialist Review and Assessment of Nuclear Facilities … 02 specialists Application of IAEA Regulation in the Transport of Radioactive Material 01 specialist Radiation Protection and Confinement Systems Radiation Protection in Medical Applications Design, Conduct and Follow-up … Radiation Protection 15 – 16 June 2016, Thon Hotel EU, Brussels, Belgium

Future Needs Training & Tutoring Brazil - Training and Tutoring Feedback Second Coordination Meeting Future Needs Training & Tutoring Topic Comment Design, Conduct and Follow-up … Environmental 02 specialist Basic Safety Related Aspects and Regulatory Oversight on NPP Operation 09 specialists Nuclear Safety – 1 Safety in PWR, … for Regulators, Operators and Licensors 06 specialists Nuclear Reactor Safety for GEN II 02 specialists Nuclear Reactor Safety for GEN III & IV 15 – 16 June 2016, Thon Hotel EU, Brussels, Belgium

Future Needs Training & Tutoring Brazil - Training and Tutoring Feedback Second Coordination Meeting Future Needs Training & Tutoring Topic Comment SOFIA Simulator Training – PWR Operation, Physics and Safety 02 specialists Probabilistic Safety Assessment of NPPs 02 specialists Application of Nuclear Safety Concepts in the Development of Regulation and Guidance 03 specialists Evaluation of Safety Assessment Reports of RR&NPP Fire Safety in NPPs 15 – 16 June 2016, Thon Hotel EU, Brussels, Belgium

Future Needs Training & Tutoring Brazil - Training and Tutoring Feedback Second Coordination Meeting Future Needs Training & Tutoring Topic Comment Investigation, Reporting and Follow-up of Operating Events 02 specialists Site Evaluation 02 specialists ASTEC - Accident Source Term Evaluation Code Design, Conduct, Reporting and Follow-up of Inspection Programmes Related to Reactor Structures, Systems and Components Important to Safety 05 specialists I&C and Electrical Systems 15 – 16 June 2016, Thon Hotel EU, Brussels, Belgium

Future Needs Training & Tutoring Brazil - Training and Tutoring Feedback Second Coordination Meeting Future Needs Training & Tutoring Topic Comment Lessons learned from the Fukushima Daiichi Incident and EU Stress Tests 02 specialists Ageing and Mechanical Analysis 01 specialist Legal Basis and Regulatory Processes for Nuclear and Radiation Safety 03 specialists Nuclear Fuel Cycle Safety 02 specialists Safety Assessment and Regulation of Decommissioning of Nuclear Facilities 15 – 16 June 2016, Thon Hotel EU, Brussels, Belgium

Future Needs Training & Tutoring Brazil - Training and Tutoring Feedback Second Coordination Meeting Future Needs Training & Tutoring Topic Comment Review and Assessment of Nuclear Facilities by the regulatory Body 02 specialists Final Disposal Safety 02 specialists Decommissioning Safety Emergency Preparedness and Response 03 specialists Nuclear Security 01 specialist EXTREME – External Threat Response Management … 15 – 16 June 2016, Thon Hotel EU, Brussels, Belgium

Future Needs Training & Tutoring Brazil - Training and Tutoring Feedback Second Coordination Meeting Future Needs Training & Tutoring Topic Comment PSA Level 1 & 2 03 specialists Seismic PSA and other External Events 02 specialists PSA Application (Technical Specifications,…) 03 specialists Severe Accidents 15 – 16 June 2016, Thon Hotel EU, Brussels, Belgium

Lessons Learned: Good Practices Brazil - Training and Tutoring Feedback Second Coordination Meeting Lessons Learned: Good Practices Organizational aspects Any relevant aspect related to administrative and organizational aspects have been reported or identified until today Relevance and completeness of the offer The existing offer is adequate considering the Brazilian needs for the 2016 – 2020 period EC Involvement Involvement, support and dedication describes the relationship between EC-BR Training aspects Considerable amount of high level knowledge information 15 – 16 June 2016, Thon Hotel EU, Brussels, Belgium

Lessons Learned: What could be improved? Brazil - Training and Tutoring Feedback Second Coordination Meeting Lessons Learned: What could be improved? Organizational aspects No relevant aspect related to administrative and organizational aspects have been identified Relevance and completeness of the catalogue No additional training or tutoring areas can be suggested considering the existing Brazilian situation EC Involvement The relationship between EC-BR is until now adequate Training aspects Include when applicable technical visits and practical overviews 15 – 16 June 2016, Thon Hotel EU, Brussels, Belgium

Brazil - Training and Tutoring Feedback Second Coordination Meeting Remarks: Sharing of the training A new process is being developed by the NRA for the adequate sharing / transferring the knowledge received by the trainees Relevance of the training The training obtained is and important tool for the improvement of regulatory activities (fire protection area, safety analysis, project modifications, surveillance modifications, control of the radiation monitoring programme) related to the licensing process of NPPs, Research and Test Reactors. Modification of existing procedures for data collection of operational experience overview. Improvement in the PSA Safety Review, PSA Application Analysis. Resident inspection activities as on-site regulatory inspections and the inspection programme have been improved. 15 – 16 June 2016, Thon Hotel EU, Brussels, Belgium

Brazil - Training and Tutoring Feedback Second Coordination Meeting Conclusions: It should be stated that the opportunity and possibility of the overseas training and tutoring, allows the country to fill in existing knowledge gaps, develop a common understanding, knowledge and sense; to develop a networking, work contacts and cooperation among trainees; maintaining a state of the art knowledge, enhancing the efficiency of the existing regulatory processes, resulting in the improvement of safety. 15 – 16 June 2016, Thon Hotel EU, Brussels, Belgium

Brazil - Training and Tutoring Feedback Second Coordination Meeting Thank you! www.cnen.gov.br gromann@cnen.gov.br