Cost benefit analysis of climate change: coping with risk, uncertainty and policymaker’s preference changes Roel Jongeneel (coord., LEI), Martijn vd Heide.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Implementation Challenges Mozaharul Alam Regional Climate Change Coordinator Regional Office for Asia and the Pacific Bangkok, Thailand.

Advertisements

Reflections on Cross-cutting issues in Climate Change Impact Assessment Alistair Hunt University of Bath & Metroeconomica, UK Global Forum on the Economic.

The SimForTree Frontends Relatie met en de werking van de begeleidingscommissies.

Cost benefit analysis of climate change: coping with risk and uncertainty LEI Roel Jongeneel (presenter/coordinator), Rene Verburg, Kees van Kooten, Aris.

AIACC Regional Study AS07 Southeast Asia Regional Vulnerability to Changing Water Resources and Extreme Hydrological due to Climate Change.

CCB: Economic and policy aspects March 2002 Ekko van Ierland Environmental Economics and Natural Resources Group Wageningen University and Research Centre.

A stocks and flows approach An Integrated Assessment Framework for Considering Climate Change: 1. the principal domains Society and Economy Greenhouse.

Evaluation of adaptation scenarios Follow-up committee meeting 6 October, Leuven.

Ecosystem Services What Nature Does for Us.

An assessment of the global land use change and food security effects of the use of agricultural residues for bioenergy production Edward Smeets, Andrzej.

Srdjan Stankovic, PhD student

America’s Water Upmanu Lall water.columbia.edu.

Towards a Sustainable Energy Future for Australia Prof Paul E HardistyAugust 2008.

Water, sustainability and climate for south Florida

Panel on Water, Food and Energy Overview of the Water & Energy issues and their linkages with food Richard Taylor, Executive Director, International Hydropower.

Ecosystem Valuation Ecosystems offer benefits to current and future generations. Ecosystem services are defined as the flow of benefits from nature to.

A Tool for Economic Valuation of Ecosystem Services in Flanders Sara Ochelen – Flemish Ministry of Environment, Nature and Energy.

Eftec Economics for the Environment Consultancy Using ecosystem services for cost benefit analysis of forestry decisions Roundtable on Cost / Benefit of.

Africa Adaptation Programme Republic of Mauritius Informed decision-making for Climate Change adaptation Activities and lessons learned in Mauritius 15.

Partnership for Urban South Hampshire Sustainable Growth.

Understanding „the nexus“ in the MENA region Holger Hoff Stockholm Environment Institute Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research Beirut, 22 January.

Understanding the Legal Mandates for DRRM and LCCA planning.

Innovation and Knowledge Transfer for a Productive and Sustainable EU Agriculture Martin Scheele Directorate General for Agriculture and Rural Development.

Linking social, economic and ecological systems in the countryside: rural resilience Wim Heijman, Paul Opdam, Marleen Schouten & Martijn van der Heide.

Adaptation knowledge needs and response under the UNFCCC process Adaptation Knowledge Day V Session 1: Knowledge Gaps Bonn, Germany 09 June 2014 Rojina.

Ecosystem Services: Perspectives on the Bottom Line for Business and Industry Marcus Lee, Millennium Ecosystem Assessment FIDIC 2005, 6 September, Beijing.

SESSION 2 Identifying Synergies Among MEAs Using IEA Tools.

International Component - Ecosystem-based Adaptation Annelieke Douma (BE), Henri Roggeri (IUCN NL)‏ January 8th, 2013.

SEA Change CoP Analyzing our Network November 9 & 10, 2011 Bangkok.

Vincenzo Artale ENEA Energy and Environment Modeling, ENEA Technical Unit (UTMEA, CR Casaccia, Rome (Italy)

Alexander Belokurov, WWF International

CBI Adaptation Methodology Dave Proctor CBI Wales.

Climate Change Risk Assessment Tool. Weather & Climate.

Dr. A.K.M. Saiful Islam Dr. Sujit Kumar Bala Associate Professor, IWFM Bangladesh University of Engineering and Technology Staff Training program on Water.

Regional Approaches to Risk Management Roger N. Jones Living with our Changing Climate IOCI Seminar and Workshop 16 August 2005.

Assessment work under the UNECE Water Convention and SEIS Annukka Lipponen Environmental Affairs Officer Secretariat of the UNECE Water Convention.

Conservation management for an uncertain future Mike Morecroft.

1 Meeting of technical expert group on ecosystem accounts London, 5-7 December 2011 Issue 9 – prioritisation of ecosystem services Discussant: Anton Steurer,

UK perspective: role of economics in biodiversity policy EEA Workshop on biodiversity and economics 5 October 2006 Helen Dunn, Defra, UK.

Contribution 9 Institutional mechanism: matching demand and supply sides Jorge Gutiérrez University of Heidelberg, Germany January 3, 2016 International.

CIS SSG Climate Change and Water – 5 September Activities for first RBMP Information exchange on a climate check of the first Programme of Measures.

Project update Each step builds on the previous step Each step builds on the previous step Your problem statement uses your literature review to tell a.

ISI-MIP Introduction to Energy Sector Joint LandMIP – ISI-MIP workshop, October , Zurich Coordinators: Ioanna Mouratiadou (PIK), Franziska Piontek.

Integrating SEA into Decision Making: An Economic Approach Dan Biller The World Bank East Asia and Pacific Region.

Monetary Valuation for Ecosystem Accounting Glenn-Marie Lange Environment Dept, World Bank 5-7 December, 2011.

How do people want to pay for e coystem and landscape services ?

Environmental Priority Setting in SEA Anders Ekbom, Environmental Economics Unit, Department of Economics, University of Gothenburg

BioEnergy Sustaining The Future 2 BESTF2 Briefing Event 11 th December 2013 Dr Megan Cooper, BESTF co-ordinator.

Landscape cluster project (SELS) Roel Jongeneel & Martijn van der Heide (LEI/WUR/AEP - The Hague, Wageningen, Netherlands) 21 September 2009, Room 4.19.

National and regional policies that limit the development and implementation of new, innovative technologies and further exacerbate the energy-water nexus.

TOOLS FOR MINING DEVELOPMENT POLICY AND IMPLEMENTATION

5th Follow up Committee Meeting HIVA-KUL, 6th October 2009

Model Summary Fred Lauer

CSU/Riverside Global Water & Climate Initiative

Greening the economy - The Roadmap to a resource-efficient Europe

Challenges in a Changing World

The Third National Climate Assessment

Climate Change and River Basin Planning

Progress of the preparations for a White Paper on Adaptation to Climate Change Water Directors’ meeting Slovenia June 2008 Marieke van Nood, Unit.

GCF business model.

Agriculture’s contribution to a carbon neutral Europe

River Basin Management Plans

Including climate change in river basin planning

Linking Biodiversity and Natural Ccapital to CE

Adaptation in the Netherlands

Challenges in a Changing World

Anna-Stiina Heiskanen Luc Feyen

River Basin Management Plans

And now the Framework WP4.

River basin management plans in Europe

Presentation transcript:

Cost benefit analysis of climate change: coping with risk, uncertainty and policymaker’s preference changes Roel Jongeneel (coord., LEI), Martijn vd Heide (LEI, PBL), Kees van Kooten (Univ.of Victoria, Ca), René Verburg (LEI-WOT) SELS & KB2 4 November 2008

Project aims 1) SCBA methodology for climate change 2) How to apply SCBA to an ecosystems approach? 3) Valuation and its evolution: a critical assessment 4) A case study: water storage, biodiversity, bio- energy (climate change: adaptation & mitigation) 5) Risk assessment: explore different approaches (note) 6) Policy preference shifts and SCBA

SCBA methodology and climate change

Apply CBA to ecosystems approach Established conventional wisdom: don’t mix up direct and indirect effects (avoid biased measurement and flawed analysis) Main exemption: jointness in production (e.g. multifunctionality model of the EC) Ecosystem services: Connectedness / jointness Non linearities (complex interactions, tresholds, …) Uncertainties Ecosystem => functions => goods & services <= valuation

Valuation: critical assessment Public and private goods & services Public and private preferences (policy vs. people) The limits of aggregation Historical evolution of valuation techniques and some lessons drawn from this Critical assessment of some valuation studies

Case study: water, biodiversity, bio-energy Climate change: temperature & water Adaptation: phased deployment of water (storage/retention, river discharge, sea or IJsselmeer) Mitigation: renewable energy (10% in 2010; bio-energy share >40%) Biodiversity (WTP, AES) Water purification and buffer (drought)

Risk What is it: risk (some notion), uncertainty (unforeseen, unknowable a-priori), ‘in between’ (Bayesian probs might be constructable) Decision criteria No info: Pessimism (MaxMin), Optimism (MaxMax), Regret (Min MaxRegret) Info: Expected value, Expected opportunity cost Risk and SCBA (fuzzy CBA, MCA, …)

Shifting policy preferences Valuation and (relative) scarcity Interaction of supply, demand and policy Welfare economics: valuation depends on preferences (SWF) Example: bio-energy policy & food crises Examples: role ‘accidents’ in policy formation (risk, endogenous preferences)

Outputs Note on methodological issues Paper (scientific article submission) on case study Congress presentations (EAAE 2008 Ghent; paper + OS Climate Change) Toolkit (excel + matlab chain) Note on risk treatment Recommendations wrt to research agenda

Thank you / Questions © Wageningen UR