DLAE Conference, Berlin, 1st December 2004 Authors: Lutz P. Michel / Julia Flasdick / Lorenza Leita 1 „How about accrediting your e-learning courses?“

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Vatican City, 14 th November 2007 Gemma Rauret Director ESG and the current QA trends in Southern Europe: Spain Current trends in the European Quality.

Advertisements

Tandem learning method for professional training Basic Ideas, Concepts and Methods.

HELPING THE NATION SPEND WISELY Performance audit and evaluation: common ground with Internal Audit ? The UK National Audit Office experience Jeremy Lonsdale.

Institute of Construction Management European Real Estate Conference 2011 University of Stuttgart To the term efficiency by Public.

Joint Degree Programmes: QA across national borders – ideas and strategies Nick Harris Quality Assurance Agency for HE UK.

Quality Assurance: Dimension of the Bologna Process Gayane Harutyunyan Bologna Secretariat June 10-11, 2014 Munich.

In Europe, When you ask the VET stakeholders : What does Quality Assurance mean for VET system? You can get the following answer: Quality is not an absolute.

Training Institute of Public Administration Tirana, ALBANIA

1 RECOGNITION OF NON-FORMAL AND INFORMAL EDUCATION IN SLOVENIAN HIGHER EDUCATION 3 rd Annual EFYE Conference, University of Wolverhampton, Telford Campus,

Recognition and Accreditation of Adult Educators` Competences: The Model of Weiterbildungsakademie Österreich – wba (Austrian Academy of Continuing Education)

“Electrical engineers vocational education transparency - ELEVET” „Przejrzystość kształcenia zawodowego inżynierów elektryków”

USING THE METHODOLOGY FOR EXTERNAL LEGAL EDUCATION QUALITY ASSESSMENT Training on behalf of USAID FAIR Justice project – 27 th and 28 th May 2015.

Integrating Project Work into Distance Education Courses Prof. Dr. Ing. habil. Christian-Andreas Schumann University of Zwickau, Germany International.

Enhancing the quality of distance learning at Western Balkan higher education institutions Danijela Milošević University of Kragujevac, Faculty of Technical.

Quality assurance in IVET in Romania Lucian Voinea Mihai Iacob Otilia Apostu 4 th Project Meeting Prague, 21 st -22 nd October 2010.

Meeting at the Ministry of Education and Science Thursday, December 14, 2006.

USING FLLLEX RESULTS IN DEVELOPING AN INSTITUTIONAL STRATEGY ON LIFELONG LEARNING: EXISTING IMPLEMENTATIONS AND DISCOVERED IDEAS GÖKAY ÖZERİM YAŞAR UNIVERSITY.

ZUZANA STRAKOVÁ IAA FF PU Pre-service Trainees´ Conception of Themselves Based on the EPOSTL Criteria: a Case Study.

TCTrainNet LocalizationWorld Silicon Valley 2011 Dr. Michael Fritz, CEO tekom / tcworld GmbH.

Authors: Göran Karlsson, Lutz Michel EDEN 2005 Annual Conference 20 June, 2005 The Market Request for Quality and/or Accreditation in Lifelong e-Learning.

The value of library services : estimation of effectiveness Viveca Nyström 7th Northumbria International Conference on Performance Measurement.

1st December 2004 Author: Göran Karlsson, Anders Ambrén, Matteo Uggeri, Marianne Salomón Expectation and design of the experiment SIG DLAE and its focus.

1 European Lifelong Guidance Policy Network Work Package 1 – Career Management Skills Synthesis Meeting NATIONAL PROGRAMME FOR CAREER GUIDANCE Aleksandra.

Development and Evaluation of Joint Study Programmes Almantas Šerpatauskas Center for Quality Assessment in Higher Education.

EQARF Applying EQARF Framework and Guidelines to the Development and Testing of Eduplan.

Avicenna Pedagogical Model Prof. Mohamed Bettaz ICT Director, MESRS, Algiers Algeria Avicenna Virtual Campus in Iraq 1 st workshop Amman.

Quality Assurance in the European Higher Education Area Tibor Szanto ENQA Rogaska Slatina, 30 November 2007.

1st QUALLL Conference Bled, March 24th, Switzerland 8 Mio. inhabitants Area km 2 20% migrants 3.8% unemployed adults 5.5% unemployment among.

Credential evaluation – criteria and procedure Workshop: Boosting quality: International Credential Evaluation and Higher Education Quality Assessment.

Eurydice Presentation at the Conference ‘Europe needs Teachers’ organised by ETUCE Brussels, 12 June 2006.

TEMPUS IV- SIXTH CALL FOR PROPOSALS NATIONAL AND REGIONAL PRIORITIES 1 TEMPUS Modernising Higher Education TEMPUS INFORMATION DAY Podgorica, December 18,

Quality Management (WP5) Roman CHIRCA Agency for Innovation and Technological Transfer TecTNet ………... This project has been funded with support from the.

1 Women Entrepreneurs in Rural Tourism Evaluation Indicators Bristol, November 2010 RG EVANS ASSOCIATES November 2010.

Work in Progress at MMB Dr. Lutz P. Michel DLAE Madrid Meeting, 26th March 2004.

Asst. Prof. Thapanee Thammetar, Ph.D. Director of Thailand Cyber Univ. Quality Assurance, e-Learning content development and operation ASEAN-ROK Session.

Education Schemes as an Integration Tool - A European Comparison Meeting Brescia,

Professional Development for Citizenship Teachers and Leaders Professor Michael Totterdell Mike Mitchell.

King Saud University, College of Science Workshop: Programme accreditation and quality assurance Riyadh, June 15-16, 2009 I.2 Relevant Documents

The national system of qualifications and interests of the stakeholders in the development of higher education Rimma Seidakhmetova Bologna Process and.

ENPC, Altran SDB 1 1st December 2004 The DLAE Project: Aims, Methods and First Results Distance Learning Accreditation in Europe Amaury Legait – ENPC (

Business model Educational institutes (Universities, schools, hospitals) Community of Practice (EANN, member associations & (scientific) focus groups)

„How about accrediting your e-learning courses?“ A Survey of e-learning providers DLAE Centra Meeting, 13th May 2004.

Summary of Local Seminars & Focus Groups 20/06/ Athens WP8 – TESTING II coordinated by IFI.

WHAT MAKES A SUCCESSFUL QUALITY ASSURANCE AGENCY? CEENQA WORKSHOP FRIDAY, 23 MAY 2014 Hotel Sirius-Pristina.

Information Systems for Production and Operations Management Perspectives on European Quality Initiatives and Programs and their Impacts and Implications.

CERTIFIED Preliminary results of the survey on existing certification and accreditation systems CERTIFIED Coordination Meeting Frankfurt, 14/02/2007 Elisa.

Dr Vladimir Radevski Ohrid, 4 April 2012 National Frameworks and their associated Quality Assurance.

ERASMUS Erasmus+ Erasmus+ is a EU programme in the areas of education, training, youth and sport. It’s purpose is to address the multiple.

1st QALLL Conference. VN NN. Bled March 24 th st QALLL CONFERENCE on Quality Assurance in Lifelong Learning focussing on Vocational.

ENCHASE “ENHANCING ALBANIAN SYSTEM OF QUALITY ASSURANCE IN HIGHER EDUCATION: APPLICATION OF THE PROCESS AND OUTCOME BASED METHODOLOGY ”

© 2008, Tod O' Dot Productions EUROPEAN UNIVERSITY – ENTERPRISE COOPERATION NETWORK Socrates Erasmus Programme Project No: Ref LLP

What Current Research May Mean for the Future of Quality Management Systems LoD Meeting Zurich, Dr. Sabine Seufert.

Results of WP 4: Implementation, experimentation of teacher training actions Open University of Catalonia - From November 4th to December 19th.

Czech Republic Czech Trade Inspection CAF Project © CZECH TRADE INSPECTION 2005 AIM : SURVEIILANCE ACTIVITIES UNIFICATION INSTRUMENT.

BANKING SUPERVISORS AND XBRL 11th XBRL International Conference José María Roldán Director General of Regulation, Banco de España Chair of XBRL España.

„How about accrediting your e-learning courses?“ Results of a survey of e-learning providers DLAE Conference, Stockholm, 10th & 11th June 2004.

King Saud University, College of Science Workshop: Programme accreditation and quality assurance Riyadh, June 13-14, 2009 III.1 The accreditation report:

QUALITY IN TRAINING: AN INSIGHT INTO SELF-ASSESSMENT – LINKING POLICY TO PRACTICEROME, 25 NOVEMBER Project Reference: LI-05-B-F-PP Contract.

External Cooperation in University Training “DZEMAL BIJEDIC” UNIVERSITY OF MOSTAR Gent, 12. – TEMPUS Project No.: SCM-C024A

Quality Assurance in Education - Independence - Responsibility - Transparency - Openness - Regularity (Periodic Review)

Strengthening of Internationalisation in B&H Higher Education Analysis of current state in internationalization from the accreditation aspect of HEIs Maja.

Ecdc.europa.eu The European Qualifications Framework and European transparency instruments DISCO project seminar Prague, 28 February 2008 Carlo Scatoli,

DEVELOPMENT OF STUDY PROGRAMS IN UNIVERSITY OF PRISHTINA/KOSOVO

BUYING QUALITY PRIVATE SECURITY SERVICES

DISCO project seminar Prague, 28 February 2008

The Malta Qualifications Framework (MQF)

The Amended ESS Statistical Law - Regulation (EC) 223/2009

Social Dialogue on Education and Training ESF Committee 10 March 2011

Recognition Tools and Practices – Criteria and Procedure

Lifelong Learning and Validation Procedures

Presentation transcript:

DLAE Conference, Berlin, 1st December 2004 Authors: Lutz P. Michel / Julia Flasdick / Lorenza Leita 1 „How about accrediting your e-learning courses?“ Highlights of a survey of e-learning providers in Europe

1st December 2004Authors: L.P. Michel / J. Flasdick / L. Leita2 Methodological background 31 providers of eLearning courses took part in our survey 21 universities 10 private providers of vocational training Function of interviewees: e.g. director of studies, CEO, research associate Kind of courses offered by the interviewees: e.g. European Net Trainer, Business Information Technologies, Tele Trainer, Master of Business Administration Note This survey is exploratory and does not claim to give representative results

1st December 2004Authors: L.P. Michel / J. Flasdick / L. Leita3 Accreditation in e-learning Is your course accredited? Reasons for renouncement no legal requirement at time being no strong regulation to accredit courses without BA /MA- certificate quality is implicit in the course no national standard up to now no advantages for the market Yes (16) No (14)

1st December 2004Authors: L.P. Michel / J. Flasdick / L. Leita4 Criteria of accreditation judgement

1st December 2004Authors: L.P. Michel / J. Flasdick / L. Leita5 Aspects of accreditation judgement

1st December 2004Authors: L.P. Michel / J. Flasdick / L. Leita6 General object of accreditation... the course (nominated 26 times) easier to accreditate the accreditation procedure doesn‘t take so much time it is a quality criteria for the client / the customer... the institution (nominated 17 times): it is a quality criteria for the client / the customer if an institution has proved a high level of quality about some years, the accreditation body should take this into consideration Accreditation should testify...

1st December 2004Authors: L.P. Michel / J. Flasdick / L. Leita7 Vocational training institutes Management, Pedagogy/Didactics Communication Other: Concept as a whole, formal framework, e.g. contracts, cost benefit analysis Universities Management, Pedagogy/Didactics Communication Other: Quality of education, content, target group, concept as a whole, location, staff (teachers, tutors, etc.), platform of the provider, support, services, learner outcomes, market relevance, cooperation Favourite objects of accreditation

1st December 2004Authors: L.P. Michel / J. Flasdick / L. Leita8 Accreditation: Test-methods

1st December 2004Authors: L.P. Michel / J. Flasdick / L. Leita9 Accreditation: Preferences

1st December 2004Authors: L.P. Michel / J. Flasdick / L. Leita10 Accreditation: Reasonable price The reasonability of the price depends on several aspects: accreditation object (course or institution) Number, volume and duration of the course(s) expenditure of the accreditation suggestion: dynamic model: price of the accreditation is based on the price of the course

1st December 2004Authors: L.P. Michel / J. Flasdick / L. Leita11 Accreditation: Problems & Requirements External evaluators have external criteria which do not always fit with the realities of the institution Students and alumni should be taken into account much stronger Unique definition of „quality“ E-learning is quite new to most of the evaluators, this leads to inconsistent criteria Extreme standardisation may lead to arbitrariness (anything can be accreditated) Not always enough information about the reputation of the accreditation body (important for the acceptance in the market) The evaluator‘s „e-pedagogical“ competences should be as good as the provider‘s

1st December 2004Authors: L.P. Michel / J. Flasdick / L. Leita12 Requirements on the optimal accreditation It should be: Fast, to make sure that the provider has no drawbacks in business Standardized, to make it fast Transparent, to make it comparable to others Affordable

1st December 2004Authors: L.P. Michel / J. Flasdick / L. Leita13 Thank you very much for your attention! For more information: dlae.enpc.fr