Results For both samples, we found that those who wrote comments focused on the strengths of the volunteer program (76% in Sample 1 and 63% in Sample 2)

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Customer Satisfaction Dimensions of a Bank in Malaysia
Advertisements

ORGANIZATIONAL BEHAVIOR
Nicholas Strong Illinois State University Problem Adolescent work experiences that may be stressful were first examined in detail in the 1980s (e.g., Greenberg.
Conflict, Supportive Communication, and Group Satisfaction Katlynn Balson, Laura Turner, Virgil Ward II, Alexandra Zaic Faculty Mentor: Dr. Martha Fay.
Nicholas Strong Illinois State University Abstract Adolescent work experiences may undermine development (e.g., Mortimer & Staff, 2004) and influence adolescents’
WORK ATTITUDES ©Nancy Brown Johnson JOB SATISFACTION pleasurable feeling perception of fulfillment of job values varies by values varies by employee.
UGA Libraries Compensation Satisfaction Consulting Project Carrie McCleese Starr Daniell.
One Road to Turnover: An Examination of Work Exhaustion in Technology Professionals.
Motivation III Motivation in practice Organizational Behaviour The Individual.
Motivation III Motivation in practice Organizational Behaviour The Individual.
Chapter 13 Survey Designs
Shelter Diagnostic Survey Shelter Name Results and Planning.
Evaluation of Health Promotion CS 652 Sarah N. Keller.
Employee Attitudes and Their Effects
Employee Satisfaction Survey Report Introduction OIRA administered the Employee Satisfaction Survey (ESS) in November-December 2003 to all AUB employees,
Research method & design in I-O Psychology Lecture 2 (Jan 28, 2002) Major ref: Riggio, Ch 2 (w/o appendix); Supplementary reading: Spector, Ch 2 (p. 22-
Chapter 13 Survey Designs
Introduction to Industrial/Organizational Psychology by Ronald E
UHCL Support Staff Association (SSA) and Professional and Administrative Staff Association (PASA) In consultation with Dr. Lisa M. Penney RAs: Lisa Sublett,
Survey Designs EDUC 640- Dr. William M. Bauer
450 PRESENTATION NURSING TURNOVER.
Keeping older workers committed and employed by means of in/formal HRD initiatives Dr. A.A.M. (Ida) Wognum M. (Martine) Horstink MSc. Wognum-HorstinkCedefop.
1. Surveys 2. When/When Not To 3. When is the Information Valid 4. What Information do you need 5. What to do with the Information 6. Communicate the.
Abstract Mara Pearson & Samantha Peterson Faculty Mentor: Martha Fay  Communication & Journalism  University of Wisconsin-Eau Claire Mara Pearson & Samantha.
Industrial and Organizational Psychology Feelings About Work: Job Attitudes and Emotions Copyright Paul E. Spector, All rights reserved, March 15, 2005.
Power Point Slides by Ronald J. Shope in collaboration with John W. Creswell Chapter 13 Survey Designs.
Commitment Profiles of Intercollegiate Athletes Brian A. Turner, Ph.D. The Ohio State University Simon M. Pack, Ph.D. University of Louisville.

Kimberly T. Schneider, Eros DeSouza, & Renee N. Durst
Transformational leadership, goal difficulty, and job design: Independent and interactive effects on employee outcomes Article Presentation Course 614.
Template provided by: “posters4research.com” Introduction and relevance Research problem and purpose Research methodology Statistical analysis-Validity.
Nicholas Strong Illinois State University Problem Most of the literature on adolescent work focuses on the experience in relation to adolescents’ academic.
Results H1 was supported. Paired samples t-tests revealed statistically significant (p
1 The Role of Perceived Support and Employee Commitment in Employee- Customer Encounters: A Study in the Fast-Food Industry Christian Vandenberghe Canada.
Abstract: This study investigated organizational factors that motivate employees. Organizational scholars are interested in understanding how expectations.
Determinants of successful virtual communities: Contributions from system characteristics and social factors Nova Novita Ira Geraldina Intan Oviantari.
Supervisor-Subordinate Friendships The Effects of Promotion on Peer Relationships Katie Nichols, Stefanie Ress, Jessica Rudd with Dr. Martha Fay Department.
Welcome to the December TLC Chat! A Conversation on Qualitative Research Your Hosts: Kelly and Roberta A Conversation on Qualitative Research Your Hosts:
1 ORGANIZATIONAL BEHAVIOR STEPHEN P. ROBBINS Chapter 3 Attitudes and Job Satisfaction Reporter: Yen-Jen Angela Chen 2007/09/20.
Introduction Wellness Programs and the Effects on Job Satisfaction Alexiss Jeffers, Kendra Jirschele, Molly O’Hearn, April Palmer, Alyssa Wichman, Dr.
Friends (Temporarily) Forever: Frequency of Facebook Use, Relationship Satisfaction, and Perception of Friendship Zack Hayes, Jerad Hill, Heather Jacobson,
Problem Burnout and job satisfaction have been shown to be related to each other as well as turnover (Lee & Ashforth, 1996). Burnout is primarily viewed.
Background Method Discussion References Acknowledgments Results  RateMyProfessors.com (RMP.com) launched in 1999 as an avenue for students to offer public.
C ULTURE & C LIMATE S URVEY. Sample Employee Survey Report Findings ACME Widgets.
Attitude and Job Satisfaction. Attitude A state of mind or feeling with regard to some matter Attitude - a psychological tendency expressed by evaluating.
Assessing Peer Support and Usability of Blogging Technology Yao Jen Chang Department of Electronic Engineering Chung-Yuan Christian University, Taiwan.
The Development and Validation of the Evaluation Involvement Scale for Use in Multi-site Evaluations Stacie A. ToalUniversity of Minnesota Why Validate.
Janis L. Whitlock Cornell University.   Previous research show that human beings develop in multiple social ecologies but school connectedness and the.
Louise Tourigny, Ph.D. University of Wisconsin-Whitewater Occupational Mental Health among Hospital Nurses in China and India In collaboration with Dr.
Attachment and Development in Adolescent Romantic Couples’ Relationship Quality Sharon C. Risch University of Tennessee.
Contingent Work, Organizational Commitment and Job Satisfaction: The Case of UOC Associate Teachers Joan Llobet 1, Ma Àngels Fitó 1, Pep Simó 2 1 Department.
Attitudes - Job Satisfaction Organizational Behaviour The Individual.
Joint Warfare Analysis Center 360 Degree Feedback Process Rater Orientation.
Slide 4- Starter Question Think about the worst job you have ever held in your life.  How do you feel during the course of the day?  How do those feelings.
Copyright © 2008 by Pearson Education, Inc. Upper Saddle River, New Jersey All rights reserved. John W. Creswell Educational Research: Planning,
Healthcare Organization Employee Experience Michael Mabanglo, PhD, LCSW February 16, 2016.
Equal Opportunity Climate Strength as a Moderator of Climate-Outcome Relationships Mitchell H. Peterson & Marinus van Driel Defense Equal Opportunity Management.
( Riggio, 2009). ◦ Voluntary absenteeism is when employees miss work because they want to do something else (i.e., not because they are ill or unable.
Role Characteristics and their Relationships to Job Attitudes Among Workers in Maryland Adolescent Behavioral Treatment Centers Michael J. Walk University.
Enlisting your partner versus dealing with it yourself: A comparison of married couples in the United States and India Ashley K. Randall 1, Shannon A.
2012 Employee Engagement Survey September What is Employee Engagement? Employee engagement is about: Motivated employees Employees who are passionate.
Job Satisfaction and Subjective Well-Being: Test of a Moderated Mediational Model Serdar Karabati, Ph.D., Istanbul Bilgi University & Nurcan Ensari, Ph.D.,
The Role of Biological Sex in Student Evaluation of Influential Educators’ Transformational Leadership, Emotional Intelligence, and Charisma. Katie Buntrock,
Forgiving In the Moment
Perception of discriminatory organizational relationships
David Brougham & Associate Professor Jarrod Haar University of Waikato
Participants & Procedure
Volunteer Perceptions of Upward and Downward
Motivation: Putting it to Work
Wanlee Putsom and Damrong Sattayawaksakul
Presentation transcript:

Results For both samples, we found that those who wrote comments focused on the strengths of the volunteer program (76% in Sample 1 and 63% in Sample 2) were significantly more satisfied with volunteering and felt they had more voice (see Table 1). Those who wrote comments focused on the weaknesses of the program (63% in Sample 1 and 47% in Sample 2) were less committed, felt they had less voice, and reported more burnout and role ambiguity. These job attitudes should be of critical importance to volunteer coordinators as we also found that volunteers’ intentions to quit were related to perceptions of having less voice in the organization (r = -.50**), lower commitment (r = -.24**), and higher levels of burnout (r =.43**) and role ambiguity (r =.47**).Discussion We found significant differences in responders and non-responders for important organizational correlates. Results varied based on comments related to strengths or weaknesses of the program. We will examine whether engagement moderates the relationship between tone of comments and correlates. This study extends previous research to samples of volunteers. It is important to understand volunteers' experiences and motivations to better support those who donate their time to hospitals, animal shelters, and other organizations.Problem Organizations have long incorporated the use of both close-ended and open- ended responses to surveys to better assess employees' satisfaction. In samples of paid employees, less satisfied employees are more likely to respond to optional open-ended items and comments tend to be relatively negative in tone (Borg & Zuell, 2012; Poncheri et al., 2008). Previous research has focused on paid employees' responses; the aim of our study was to focus on samples of volunteers and distinguish between questions aimed at program strengths and weaknesses. It is important to understand volunteers' experiences and feedback given differences in motivations for volunteering versus engaging in paid work.Hypotheses We hypothesized that responders to optional open-ended survey items focused on strengths of the program would report higher levels of job satisfaction. We hypothesized that those commenting on weaknesses would be more likely to report feelings of burnout than those who had no comments to offer.Method Sample The study included two samples of volunteers who completed online surveys. Sample 1 included 248 volunteers from three animal shelters in the Pacific Northwest Sample 2 included 139 volunteers at a large hospital in the Midwest. Measures and Procedures Optional open-ended questions allowed volunteers to list three strengths and three weaknesses of the volunteer program. Independent raters coded whether volunteers commented on open-ended questions and assessed the tone of the comments on a 5-point scale. Inter-rater reliability was.8-.9 for these measures. Closed-ended scales assessed various dimensions of satisfaction (with tasks, with communication, voice), role ambiguity, commitment, and burnout.Results Table 1 Group Comparisons between Responders and Non-Responders to both ‘Strengths’ and ‘Weaknesses’ of the Program Open-Ended Questions for Sample 1. Sample 1 (Animal Shelter volunteers, N=248) Mean (SD) for Responders to ‘Strengths’ of the Program Question (n=189) Mean (SD) for Non- Responders to ‘Strengths’ of the Program Question (n=59) tEffect size (d) Perceptions of Voice3.54 (.88)3.26 (.90)-2.12*0.32 Satisfaction with Work 4.62 (.55)4.39 (.78)-2.51*0.38 Mean (SD) for Responders to ‘Weaknesses’ of the Program Question (n=157) Mean (SD) for Non- Responders to ‘Weaknesses’ of the Program Question (n=91) tEffect size (d) Perceptions of Voice3.32 (.83)3.73 (.92)3.53***-0.48 Satisfaction with Communication 3.97 (.64)4.28 (.75)3.54***-0.46 Role Ambiguity1.88 (.82)1.62 (.72)-2.53*0.33 Burnout1.69 (.67)1.46 (.62)-2.53*0.35 *p <.05 **p <.01 ***p <.001 Table 2 Group Comparisons between Responders and Non-Responders to both ‘Strengths’ and ‘Weaknesses’ of the Program Open-Ended Questions for Sample 2. *p <.05 **p <.01 ***p <.001 Sample 2 (Midwest hospital volunteers, N=139) Mean (SD) for Responders to ‘Strengths’ of the Program Question (n=93) Mean (SD) for Non- Responders to ‘Strengths’ of the Program Question (n=44) tEffect size (d) Satisfaction with Work 4.46 (.67)4.38 (.81)1.99*0.11 Mean (SD) for Responders to ‘Weaknesses’ of the Program Question (n=66) Mean (SD) for Non- Responders to ‘Weaknesses’ of the Program Question (n=73) tEffect size (d) Satisfaction with Communication 3.92 (.68)4.21 (.61)2.67**-0.45 Burnout1.43 (.60)1.26 (.35)-1.30**-1.22 Poncheri, R.M, Lindberg, J.T, Thompson, L.F., & Surface, E.A. (2008). A comment on employee negativity bias in open-ended responses. Organizational Research Methods, 11, Borg, I., & Zuell, C. (2012). Write-in comments in employee surveys. International Journal of Manpower, 33, References Volunteers' Responses to Open-Ended Survey Questions: Evidence of Negativity Bias? Kamila A. Gabka, Ashley S. McCarthy, Kimberly T. Schneider, Aaron Whitely, Cassi M. Heider, Jacqueline C. Masso, Erin R. White, and Taylor Weismann Illinois State University Example of Weakness Comment: “The volunteer office is disorganized and loses records required for volunteering qualification.” Example of Strength Comment: “The volunteer coordinators and staff members take the time to ‘catch people doing good work’ and praise volunteers weekly.”