EU – Lifetime / Universität Karlsruhe (TH) / TMB-FM / Prof. Kunibert Lennerts – Dipl.-Ing. Karin Diez / Lyon Nr.1 1 THEMATIC NETWORK LIFETIME - WP1: Best practice and knowledge of lifetime engineering final presentation WP 1 leader: Universität Karlsruhe (TH), TMB/FM Prof. Dr.-Ing. Kunibert Lennerts Dipl.-Ing. Karin Diez COMPETITIVE and SUSTAINABLE GROWTH PROGRAMME

EU – Lifetime / Universität Karlsruhe (TH) / TMB-FM / Prof. Kunibert Lennerts – Dipl.-Ing. Karin Diez / Lyon Nr.2 2 WP 1: Best practice and knowledge of lifetime engineering Working steps Questionnaire sent out in August 2002 Follow up questionnaire sent out in November 2002 Design of a database on basis of results of questionnaires Second call for data in May 2004 to NDG Leaders Refinement of database Upload of database into Netspace for Member’s use Analysis and Benchmarking of data

EU – Lifetime / Universität Karlsruhe (TH) / TMB-FM / Prof. Kunibert Lennerts – Dipl.-Ing. Karin Diez / Lyon Nr.3 3 WP 1: tasks structured database Task 1: Exploring and benchmarking of best practices Task 2: Listing of competencies and current practices Task 3: identifying gaps in competence, education and training Task 4: identifying gaps in transfer activities Task 6: Collecting and finishing Deliverable 1 Task 5: Concluding state of the art in R&D, dissemination, exploitation, education and training Keywords

EU – Lifetime / Universität Karlsruhe (TH) / TMB-FM / Prof. Kunibert Lennerts – Dipl.-Ing. Karin Diez / Lyon Nr.4 4 WP 1: 2 nd call for data research projects – example excel sheet Sent out to all NDG leaders

EU – Lifetime / Universität Karlsruhe (TH) / TMB-FM / Prof. Kunibert Lennerts – Dipl.-Ing. Karin Diez / Lyon Nr.5 5 WP 1: 2 nd call for data research projects – example: completed data Name of Project:OPIK Participants:Universität Karlsruhe, TMB-FM; several hospitals Start:2000 End:2003 Short description:processes in hosptials, benchmarking Website: Keywords out of list:3,5,7,23 Keyword own definition (optional):benchmarking Area (Buildings, Infrastructures, B&I): Buildings Language:German Partners from industry (Y/N):Y Product development (Y/N):N ID-Country, member, ID-Project: Germany, 5, 1

EU – Lifetime / Universität Karlsruhe (TH) / TMB-FM / Prof. Kunibert Lennerts – Dipl.-Ing. Karin Diez / Lyon Nr.6 6 WP 1: 2 nd call for data Educational courses – example excel sheet Sent out to all NDG leaders

EU – Lifetime / Universität Karlsruhe (TH) / TMB-FM / Prof. Kunibert Lennerts – Dipl.-Ing. Karin Diez / Lyon Nr.7 7 WP 1: 2 nd call for data Educational courses – example: completed data Name of Course:Life cycle engineering of buildings Member:64 Area (Buildings, Infrastructures, B&I): Buildings Language:Finnish ID-Country: 8 Finland Institution giving course:Helsinki University of Technology/Structural engineering and building physics Keywords out of list:1, 3, 4, 7, 12, 13, 14, 15, 19, 20, 25, 29

EU – Lifetime / Universität Karlsruhe (TH) / TMB-FM / Prof. Kunibert Lennerts – Dipl.-Ing. Karin Diez / Lyon Nr.8 8 WP 1: 2 nd call for data Training courses – example excel sheet Sent out to all NDG leaders

EU – Lifetime / Universität Karlsruhe (TH) / TMB-FM / Prof. Kunibert Lennerts – Dipl.-Ing. Karin Diez / Lyon Nr.9 9 WP 1: 2 nd call for data Training courses – example: completed data Name of Course:Plumbing and Heating Institution giving course: FAS Training Centre, Baldoyle, Dublin 13 Member:82 Area (Buildings, Infrastructures, B&I): Buildings ID-Country: Ireland Language:English Keywords out of list:8, 10, 15, 25, 31, 34

EU – Lifetime / Universität Karlsruhe (TH) / TMB-FM / Prof. Kunibert Lennerts – Dipl.-Ing. Karin Diez / Lyon Nr WP 1: 2 nd call for data ACCESS database Why using ACCESS? challange: - Complex data from different sources - relationship of data (1:1; n:m) - need for a searching function Access provides all possibilities for the design of a well structured database.

EU – Lifetime / Universität Karlsruhe (TH) / TMB-FM / Prof. Kunibert Lennerts – Dipl.-Ing. Karin Diez / Lyon Nr Database Structure Structured searching routines can be executed in terms of: research projects educational courses training courses standards, handbooks All data is referenced to: keyword country language member responsible for data / contact address

EU – Lifetime / Universität Karlsruhe (TH) / TMB-FM / Prof. Kunibert Lennerts – Dipl.-Ing. Karin Diez / Lyon Nr Database Queries Example: Query on educational courses for language shall be German

EU – Lifetime / Universität Karlsruhe (TH) / TMB-FM / Prof. Kunibert Lennerts – Dipl.-Ing. Karin Diez / Lyon Nr Database Queries Example: Query on educational courses for language shall be English

EU – Lifetime / Universität Karlsruhe (TH) / TMB-FM / Prof. Kunibert Lennerts – Dipl.-Ing. Karin Diez / Lyon Nr Database Queries Example: Query on educational courses for language shall be German and keyword shall be “3 whole life costing”.

EU – Lifetime / Universität Karlsruhe (TH) / TMB-FM / Prof. Kunibert Lennerts – Dipl.-Ing. Karin Diez / Lyon Nr Benchmarking The data collected in the database concerning research, education and training has been benchmarked under the following aspects: competence (keywords and main topics) general national gaps (keywords and main topics) general national Transfer of research into praxis Procedure: Each entry in the database is referenced to one or more keywords. In terms of benchmarking we are comparing how many times the keywords have been named to reference the entries.

EU – Lifetime / Universität Karlsruhe (TH) / TMB-FM / Prof. Kunibert Lennerts – Dipl.-Ing. Karin Diez / Lyon Nr Definition Competence Centres - Gaps We define competence within the Lifetime Network on basis of the following aspects: A search in the database to one of those topics will give a good starting point and contacts for further investigation new research can build on published work Education / Training can be derived We define gaps within the Lifetime Network on basis of the following aspects: A search in the database to one of those topics gives very little or none results education or training is (nearly) not available

EU – Lifetime / Universität Karlsruhe (TH) / TMB-FM / Prof. Kunibert Lennerts – Dipl.-Ing. Karin Diez / Lyon Nr Benchmarking to Use of keywords for Research Projects At this state of the project there are 293 entries listed in the database. The middle value of the “Use of keyword” of all keywords is 19. The standard deviation is 14 where the minimal value is 3 and the maximal value is 60. We take a closer look at all keywords where the Use of keyword is over 30 or under 8.

EU – Lifetime / Universität Karlsruhe (TH) / TMB-FM / Prof. Kunibert Lennerts – Dipl.-Ing. Karin Diez / Lyon Nr Competence Centres Keywords named more often than 30 times (Use of keyword >30): 1 investment planning (50) 100 lifetime design (48) 14 economy of nature, environmental impact assessment technology (45) 300 recycling technology (43) 400 lifetime management and maintenance (60) 24 modernisation planning and execution (32) 21 maintenance planning and execution (32) 45 optimisation of materials and components (35)

EU – Lifetime / Universität Karlsruhe (TH) / TMB-FM / Prof. Kunibert Lennerts – Dipl.-Ing. Karin Diez / Lyon Nr Gaps Keywords that are underrepresented (Use of keyword <8): 13 multiple attribute decision making (e. g. MADA) (5) 18 selective demolition for recycling (7) 23 “Infrastructural management” (security, cleaning) (4) 25 analysis of the requirements of owner/user (e. g. QFD method) (5) 28 network (=total sample of the managed objects) planning (5) 500 Culture (5) 31 Building traditions (5) 32 Life style (5) 33 Business culture (5) 34 Aesthetics (6) 35 Architectural styles and trends (3) 36 Image (5) 39 sustainable city/regional planning (5)

EU – Lifetime / Universität Karlsruhe (TH) / TMB-FM / Prof. Kunibert Lennerts – Dipl.-Ing. Karin Diez / Lyon Nr Benchmarking to use of keywords per country Amount of data for each country available in the database

EU – Lifetime / Universität Karlsruhe (TH) / TMB-FM / Prof. Kunibert Lennerts – Dipl.-Ing. Karin Diez / Lyon Nr Use of keywords for all countries Use of keywords for each country’s research projects; at the same time the summed up use of keywords for all countries. We can derive for which keywords there seem to be existing competence centres and at the same time we can allocate them. Further investigation is possible via searching routine in database

EU – Lifetime / Universität Karlsruhe (TH) / TMB-FM / Prof. Kunibert Lennerts – Dipl.-Ing. Karin Diez / Lyon Nr Transfer from research into praxis From 293 projects in total we have information about involvement of industry partners only for 98 projects. The share of projects where industry partners are involved is 65%.

EU – Lifetime / Universität Karlsruhe (TH) / TMB-FM / Prof. Kunibert Lennerts – Dipl.-Ing. Karin Diez / Lyon Nr Benchmarking to Use of keywords for Education At this state of the project 109 educational courses are listed in the database. The middle value of the “Use of keyword” of all keywords is 5,9. The standard deviation is 4,2 where the minimal value is 0 and the maximal value is 20. We take a closer look at all keywords where the Use of keyword is over 10 or under 2.

EU – Lifetime / Universität Karlsruhe (TH) / TMB-FM / Prof. Kunibert Lennerts – Dipl.-Ing. Karin Diez / Lyon Nr Competence Centres Keywords named more often than 10 times (Use of keyword >10): 1 Investment planning (12) 3 Whole life costing (11) 6 Performance data of materials and products (13) 7 Service life planning (11) 8 Durability limit states and service life design (12) 13 Energy efficiency in use (15) 21 maintenance planning and execution (20) 24 modernisation planning and execution (14)

EU – Lifetime / Universität Karlsruhe (TH) / TMB-FM / Prof. Kunibert Lennerts – Dipl.-Ing. Karin Diez / Lyon Nr Gaps Keywords that are underrepresented (Use of keyword <2): 500 Culture (1) 31 Building traditions (1) 32 Life style (1) 33 Business culture (1) 37 thematic network (0)

EU – Lifetime / Universität Karlsruhe (TH) / TMB-FM / Prof. Kunibert Lennerts – Dipl.-Ing. Karin Diez / Lyon Nr Benchmarking to Use of keywords for Training At this state of the project 83 training courses are listed in the database. The middle value of the “Use of keyword” of all keywords is 4,5. The standard deviation is 4,4 where the minimal value is 0 and the maximal value is 16. We take a closer look at all keywords where the Use of keyword is over 9 or under 1.

EU – Lifetime / Universität Karlsruhe (TH) / TMB-FM / Prof. Kunibert Lennerts – Dipl.-Ing. Karin Diez / Lyon Nr Competence Centres Keywords named more often than 9 times (Use of keyword >9): 1 Investment planning (15) 7 Service life planning (12) 14 Economy of nature, environmental impact assessment technology (12) 15 Energy efficiency in use (15) 21 Maintenance planning and execution (16) 23 Infrastructural management (security, cleaning) (10)

EU – Lifetime / Universität Karlsruhe (TH) / TMB-FM / Prof. Kunibert Lennerts – Dipl.-Ing. Karin Diez / Lyon Nr Gaps Keywords that are underrepresented (Use of keyword <1): 4 usability, functionality and obsolescence analysis and design (0) 12 design for reuse (0) 28 network planning (0) 29 multiple attribute decision making (0) 32 Life style (0) 33 Business culture (0) 35 Architectural styles and trends (0) 36 Image (0) 37 thematic network (0)