Evidence is the six-stone weakling of the policy world … confronted by … the four-hundred pound brute called politics (Ray Pawson)

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Enhancing evidence-based policy making through Country-Led M&E Systems* Marco Segone, Regional Chief, Monitoring and Evaluation, UNICEF CEE/CIS, and former.
Advertisements

Enhancing evidence-based policy making through Country-Led M&E Systems* Marco Segone, Regional Chief, Monitoring and Evaluation, UNICEF CEE/CIS, and former.
Good governance for water, sanitation and hygiene services
Types and models of research impact Sandra Nutley University of St Andrews.
Making it work: co-producing impact evaluation. Professor Imogen Taylor Department of Social Work and Social Care.
Assessing student learning from Public Engagement David Owen National Co-ordinating Centre for Public Engagement Funded by the UK Funding Councils, Research.
Developing an Evaluation Strategy – experience in DFID Nick York Director – Country, Corporate and Global Evaluations, World Bank IEG Former Chief Professional.
Keele Management School
Understanding Incentives within Social Accountability Endeavour Asia Governance Learning Event – CARE International 12 June 2013, Kathmandu Naimur Rahman.
Recap – 15 October. Considerations o All facets of sustainability – clear endorsement; o Inclusion of all key stakeholders – should contribute to a ‘voice’
Telling the Story of Canada’s Children A Comprehensive Approach to Accountability National Children’s Alliance November 26, 2004.
Strategies and Structures for Research and Policy Networks: Presented to the Canadian Primary Health Care Research Network, 2012 Heather Creech, Director,
Role of RAS in the Agricultural Innovation System Rasheed Sulaiman V
Connections and issues in the European evaluation context Professor Murray Saunders President of the European Evaluation Society.
PRESENTATION TO IRISH AID 20 TH SEPTEMBER Working Definition of Development Education For the purposes of the audit, the following ‘working definition’
Knowledge Translation Curriculum Module 1: An Introduction to KT Lesson 1 - Knowledge Translation: The Basics.
National Association of local youth offices. National Association of local youth offices ˃Association in numbers ˃What is the Association? ˃Structure.
UNDP CO MONTENEGRO UNDP CO MONTENEGRO Gender Programme IPA 2010 Support to Women’s Entrepreneurship Sub Regional Workshop on Employment and Social Inclusion.
Evaluation. Practical Evaluation Michael Quinn Patton.
Influencing Health Care Policy
Country-led Evaluation Capacity Development Marco Segone, Regional Monitoring & Evaluation Advisor, UNICEF Regional Office for Central and Eastern Europe.
On models of donor support and good practices Council for People's Development and Governance Regional Workshop on CSOs and Aid Effectiveness, Ha Noi,
Establishing Research and Evaluation Network on Child Issues in Indonesia Nuning Akhmadi Indonesia Research and Evaluation Network Manila, 7 – 8 November.
Professor Huw Davies Outgoing Director Social Dimensions of Health Institute (SDHI) Universities of Dundee & St Andrews Director Knowledge Mobilisation.
Door opening aspects for Culture and Development.
1 UNISDR Secretariat Asia and Pacific IAP meeting 25 March Learning from the HFA progress review.
Enhancing evidence-based policy making through Country-Led M&E Systems* Marco Segone, Regional Chief, Monitoring and Evaluation, UNICEF CEE/CIS, and former.
Making and demonstrating research and evaluation impact (in an era of austerity) Sandra Nutley.
Chapter 1 Assurance Services. Need for Assurance Why do you need assurance? Potential bias in providing information. Remoteness between a user and the.
Inclusive Business in Agrifood Markets: Evidence and Action FANRPAN Model – A Regional Multi-stakeholder Platform for Research, Knowledge Sharing and Policy.
European Broadband Portal Phase II Application of the Blueprint for “bottom-up” broadband initiatives.
How evidence is used: implications for thinking about quality Professor Sandra.Nutley University of Edinburgh Research Unit for Research Utilisation (RURU)
Nef (the new economics foundation) Co-producing Lambeth what’s possible? Lucie Stephens and Julia Slay nef, October 2011.
What does Public Policy ask of Complexity Science? Peter Dick Department of Health, UK Government ECCS ’12, Brussels, September 2012.
RAPID Outcome Mapping Approach Simon Hearn, ODI 16 April 2010 Bern, Switzerland.
Understanding and improving research use in social services Sandra.Nutley.
Knowledge Mobilization: Research Administrators as Brokers in the New Knowledge Systems By Paul J Graham, MLIS Harley D Dickinson, PhD University of Saskatchewan.
Towards comprehensive responses to interrelated global challenges Dr Ir. Paul G.H. Engel Director ECDPM 12 November 2014.
THE WORLD BANK Sustainable Quality Framework for a Developing Professional Economy Gian E. Casartelli – Consulting Services Advisor- Vice Presidency for.
CFNZ sustainable growth. The challenge We fleshed out 3 ideas “How can we sustainably fund CFNZ strategic plan so we remain viable across next 3 years?”
Fife Partnership…Strengthening Fife’s Future Research can make a difference! Workshop on communicating and disseminating research Facilitation - Chris.
National Oceanography Centre, Southampton European Way, Southampton SO14 3ZH, UK Tel: National Marine Coordination Office.
Communication in Governance PREM Core Course Public Sector Governance April 2007 Paul Mitchell Development Communication Division The World Bank.
Climate Services: The Pacific Climate Information System (PaCIS) Approach Eileen L. Shea NOAA IDEA Center 31 st Climate Diagnostics.
Dr. Gopakumar K Thampi, Public Affairs Foundation, Bangalore CITIZEN REPORT CARDS & REFORMS Exploring the Scope.
Local Government Local Leadership Training Municipal Front Office Independent Audit Debt Management Disclosure of Assets Vulnerability Assessment Building.
The role of statistics in evidence-based policy making
2013 Fall Forum Improving Health Outcomes : Finding Options for Better Access to Care Health Policy Advocacy & Action Plan Development.
European Personnel Selection Office EPSO Development Programme DGs Mini Seminar - 5 June 2008 David Bearfield, Director.
Dr. Shahram Yazdani 1 Policy Support Function Dr. Shahram Yazdani Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Sciences School of Medical Education Strategic.
Seminar on Public Private Partnerships February PPP Experiences – Challenges and Way Forward Administrative Staff College of India.
+ Welcome to PAHO/WHO Sustainable Development and Health Toolkit for the UN Global Conference RIO + 20 Welcome to PAHO/WHO Sustainable Development and.
Shaping the Global Evaluation Agenda A networked global multi-stakeholders consultative processes to frame the future priorities of the global.
Fairleigh Dickinson University Summer Program August 1, 2015 Welcome Kyung Hee University Students
International Standards of Supreme Audit Institutions (ISSAIs) Jennifer Thomson Director OPSPF & Chief Financial Management Officer World Bank.
Supporting Knowledge Flows in Networks Heather Creech Terri Willard.
Global and regional programmes in support of 2020 Round Population and Housing censuses United Nations Regional Workshop on the 2020 World Programme on.
UNFPA ESARO Technical Adviser, Population Data Policy
Evidence to action: Issues, challenges and solutions
Curriculum (Article 6) Teachers should be involved in all phases of curriculum development ..(design, piloting, implementation and review). Promote understanding.
Thursday 2nd of February 2017 College Development Network
Students in Governance What is Student Engagement?
EuropeAid Co-operation Office
Effective Quality Assurance in Healthcare, Kyrgyzstan
Knowledge Translation
IMPACT SPECIAL INTEREST GROUP
The Role of Bilateral Donors in supporting capacity-building in the area of ICT Open Consultations on Financing Mechanisms for Meeting the Challenges.
CFOA Performance & Improvement Directorate
Gender & Equity Issues.
The Global Evaluation Agenda
Presentation transcript:

Evidence is the six-stone weakling of the policy world … confronted by … the four-hundred pound brute called politics (Ray Pawson)

Diverse forms of knowledge and evidence Research & evaluation reports Audit & inspection findings/data Routine monitoring data, stats and PIs Local & international exemplars Costings data Client & user experience data Expert views & insider knowledge Surveys, opinion polls & stakeholders consultations System capacity data Models & forecasts

Many active players in policy networks PoliticiansCivil servantsPolitical advisors Professional bodies Media Lobbyists and advocacy groups Audit, inspection and scrutiny regimes Government analysts University and college researchers Research institutes and independent evaluators Think tanks and knowledge brokers Wider community Loc govt officers Service providersService users Challenge of opening up to many voices, loosening control, tolerating diverse views on evidence…

F What image best represents how you think about the main challenges? A E D CB

Improving evidence use: addressing supply, demand, and that in between Improving stocks or reservoirs of evidence-based knowledge Increasing demand in political and professional worlds, and wider society Research translation, knowledge management and knowledge pools, research brokering and boundary spanning, co-location, secondments and role cycling, partnerships of all kinds, sustained interactivity…

The importance of context Interaction with other types of knowledge (tacit; experiential) Multi-voiced dialogue Use as a process not an event Moving away from ideas of packaging knowledge and enabling knowledge transfer – recognising instead: Addressing that in between