Disorganized attachment, trauma- related disorders and the therapeutic relationship Giovanni Liotti Scuola di Psicoterapia Cognitiva Roma (Italy)

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Dissociative Disorders Dissociation…the human minds capacity to mediate complex mental activity in channels split off from or independent of conscious.
Advertisements

Childhood attachment and parental bonding in bipolar disorder Kevin Clarkson, MBBS 3, Kings College London MRC Social Genetic.
Attachment Theory and Psychopathology. What is Attachment? Enduring emotional tie Internal working model Secure base for exploration Foundation for future.
Thomas Coram Adoption Project:
Conceptual Models of Child Psychopathology. Models and theories Set of principles used to analyze or explain a set of phenomena Set of principles used.
Understand psychological approaches to health and social care
Separation and Reunification: Using Attachment Theory and Research to Inform Decisions Affecting the Placement of Children in Foster Care David Oppenheim,
Write down what you think is meant by the term Write down what you think is meant by the termATTACHMENT.
Sexual Abuse and Borderline Personality Disorder: The Process of Therapy M. Sc. Teja Bandel Psychologist.
A Developmental Model of Childhood Traumatic Stress.
REACTIVE ATTACHMENT DISORDER. CONTROVERSY-In General  Little evidence to support DX or TX.  Comorbidity with other Axis I & II is so significant that.
Empirical Perspectives on Object Relations Constructs
Revictimization & Self Harm in Females Who Experienced Childhood Sexual Abuse.
Attachment Theory II Geoff Goodman, Ph.D.. I. Three Influential Attachment Theorist A. John Bowlby B. Mary Ainsworth C. Mary Main.
Patterns of Attachment Secure (about 65%) –Infants actively seek proximity to caregivers upon reunion –Communicate their feelings of stress and distress.
1 Birth to Six Initiative Topic One: Introduction to Birth to Six.
CHILD PSYCHIATRY Fatima Al-Haidar Professor, child & adolescent psychiatrist College of medicine - KSU.
BORDERLINE PERSONALITY DISORDER. CAUSES -Genetic factors since twins and families member might inherit them from others in their family or strong associated.
Theories of Counseling: Object Relations Theory
Attachment and Adoption Todd Nichols Family Attachment and Counseling Center of Minnesota.
Minding the Baby. Summary Minding the Baby is an intensive home-visiting programme for vulnerable, first-time pregnant women and their families. It is.
Attachment Theory and Research
Dissociative Identity Disorder (Multiple Personality Disorder)
Somatoform and Dissociative Disorders. Somatoform Disorders Somatoform disorders – Psychological problems appearing in the form of bodily symptoms or.
Chapter 8: Emotional Development.  Attachment Theory- VideoVideo  John Bowlby and Mary Ainsworth  Attachment- the emotional link that binds a person.
Trauma, Stressor-related, and Dissociative Disorders
Model of Maltreatment Explain pattern of occurrences and non- occurrences of maltreatment Describe process by which maltreatment is transmitted from one.
Dissociative Identity Disorder. Dissociative Identity Disorder is a condition in which a person displays multiple identities or personalities. This means.
ATTACHMENT From Alan Sroufe University of Minnesota.
Copyright © 2007 by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved. Chapter 8 Somatoform and Dissociative Disorders Movie 2/27: “Amelie” (extra credit)
©2008 National Association of Social Workers. All Rights Reserved. 1 HIV/AID’S and Orphaned and Vulnerable Children: Consideration from an Attachment Perspective.
Part 2. Psychological maltreatment: abuse, neglect and rejection
ADOLESCENTS IN CRISIS: WHEN TO ADMIT FOR SELF-HARM OR AGGRESSIVE BEHAVIOR Kristin Calvert.
Nurses working with difficult families and vicarious trauma - dealing with their emotional health.” Mandy Seyfang 2014.
Development Social Development Attachment Stranger anxiety & Attachment By nature human beings are social animals –Bonds are formed at birth with care.
Dissociative Disorders Dissociative Amnesia Dissociative Identity Disorder Depersonalization-Derealization Disorder.
Dissociative Disorders. Disorders in which conscious awareness becomes separated (dissociated) from previous memories, thoughts and feelings.
R.A.D Reactive Attachment Disorder Nicole Kramer & Kathleen Miller.
By Nora Gonzalez Period 5 Schizophrenia. Discussion Question: Define Schizophrenia.
Stages of psychotherapy process
Attachment Theory: An Overview. Attachment Description Variant of object relations Initially focused on development of affectional ties between infants.
Mike Mawby Independent Consultant Working with Adults in Children’s Lives 1 Mike Mawby Consultancy Limited SC
MARILYN K. GALE, LISW-S JULIE M. SHEEHAN, LSW FAMILY THERAPY MEETS CRISIS INTERVENTION.
Chapter 9 – Suicide Assessment. Chapter 9 This chapter focuses on a contemporary approach to conducting a suicide assessment interview—as well as brief.
Infancy and Toddlerhood
Quality Education for a Healthier Scotland Psychology SoFMH School of Forensic Mental Health Brief Overview of CAT Mark C. Ramm, NHS Lothian Integrative.
1 Birth to Six Initiative Topic Two: The Emotional and Developmental Needs of Young Children.
Psychological Therapies. Introduction Psychotherapy Emotionally charged, confiding interaction between a trained therapist and someone who suffers from.
Copyright © 2011 Wolters Kluwer Health | Lippincott Williams & Wilkins.
© Raija-Leena Punamäki 2007 Psychosocial Preventive Interventions among War Traumatized Families: Infat and Adolescent Development Raija-Leena Punamaki.
Dissociative Disorders Dissociative Amnesia Dissociative Fugue Dissociative Identity Disorder.
Describe and evaluate one treatment or therapy from each of the approaches Joelle Cornwall.
SAOL, March, 2016 The impact of trauma on children Rosaleen McElvaney
Dissociative Identity Disorder (DID) Created by: Wilberth Reyes.
Logia- study of Psychology psyche- breath, spirit, soul.
Mental Health. Review The four healthy characteristics of mental and emotional people include… A sense of control Being able to not overreact or being.
Explanations Cognitive Psychodynamic Treatments Cognitive psychodynamic.
Anxiety & Mood Disorders In Children. Anxiety Disorders Common among children – 9.7% in a community-based school sample More girls than boys Fears are.
Psychological Disorders. Module Overview Defining Disorder Understanding Disorders Classifying Disorders Labeling Disorders Click on the any of the above.
WOMEN’S HEALTH ISSUES : WHAT YOU REALLY NEED TO KNOW ABOUT DEPRESSION AND SUICIDE.
Dissociative Amnesia.
Object Relations Family Therapy
Mentalization/Reflective Function
Attachment Theory Geoff Goodman, Ph.D..
Attachment behaviour is a self protective strategy designed to elicit protection and comfort from a caretaking figure.
Insecure Attachments & Female Drug Misuse
Psychoanalytic Therapy
Psychological explanations for schizophrenia 1
Psychological explanations for schizophrenia 1
Attachment Theory: What Does It Mean for Children in the System?
Presentation transcript:

Disorganized attachment, trauma- related disorders and the therapeutic relationship Giovanni Liotti Scuola di Psicoterapia Cognitiva Roma (Italy)

Main theme of the presentation Developmental psychopathology may provide the psychotherapist with models of mental disorders that help devising effective interventions Disorganized attachment (DA) during infancy and/or childhood may be involved in the genesis of trauma-related disorders (Complex PTSD, BPD, Dissociative Disorders, and other disorders that have traumatic memories among their antecedents) These disorders often involve fragmentation of the sense of self (dissociation)

Structure of the presentation Summary of empirical evidence on the genesis of early attachment disorganization Review of evidence linking early disorganized attachment to adult psychopathology An attachment based model of the development of disorders related to complex* trauma (* repeated and unavoidable) Reflections on some implications of these empirical studies for the psychotherapy of people with a fragmented self

Research on early D.A. (Disorganized Attachment) Infant D.A. is statistically linked to caregiver’s: unresolved traumas and/or losses non-integrated hostile and helpless representations of self and the attachment figures aggressive, frightened and dissociative caregiving behaviour (genetic influences play a moderating role)

Theories on the genesis of attachment disorganization conflict between two inborn control systems, attachment and fight-flight  fright without solution (Main & Hesse, 1990) early relational trauma  abnormal construction of the stress coping system in the infant’s right brain ( Schore, 2003 ) flickering switch mechanism in the infant contingency detection module  dissociative type of attention (Koos & Gergely, 2001)

Sequels of infant attachment disorganization proneness toward dissociative experiences (Ogawa et al., 1997) deficits in emotion regulation, stress- coping capacity and control of impulses (Schore, 2003) mentalization deficits (Fonagy et al., 2003) risk factor in the development of a wide range of DSM mental disorders ( Levy, 2005; Liotti 2004) controlling strategies

D.A. and psychopathology If early D.A. is essentially a disaggregated way of processing socio- emotional information … … then it may be more often linked to disorders characterized by severe dissociation, splitting among ego states and fragmentation of the self (than to other psychiatric disorders)

Studies on traumas/losses in the life of adult patients’ mothers AAI studies cannot reliably assess the early attachment pattern of the responder (as evidenced by longitudinal studies  Grossmann, Grossmann & Waters, 2005). Studies of traumas/losses suffered by the patients’ mothers in the 2 years before and after the patient’s birth may provide better hints at the specific role of infant DA in the genesis of adult pathologically disaggregated mental states

Traumas/losses in mothers and mental disorders in offspring Mothers of adult BPD and dissociative patients (cases) report two times more traumas/losses than mothers of other psychiatric patients (controls) in the 2 years interval around the patients’ birth (Liotti et al., 2000; Pasquini et al., 2002) Mother’s losses and children’s traumas act as independent risk factors, (each of them increases vulnerability to dissociative disorders) The statistical difference between cases and controls disappears if the control group comprises schizophrenic patients (Miti & Chiaia, 2003)

DA and psychopathology: a neo- dissociationist hypothesis DA is an essentially dissociative process It may direct development toward a high number of mental disorders Many mental disorders are based on the disruption of integrative processes, but only a few are characterized by explicit symptoms of dissociation or of other types of non- integrated mental functions (e.g. splitting) Other risk factors, besides DA, must intervene in the genesis of disorders characterized by fragmentation of the self  traumas

Not only early attachments Bowlby’s metaphor: branching railways lines Any untoward itinerary stemming from early attachment insecurity can be gradually reversed pointing at mental health, and any favourable pathway can be left behind, due to later negative influences, to follow the railroads leading to psychopathological developments.

Early DA and later traumas (1): genesis of the fragmented self the quality of pre-existing attachments (IWMs) is an important factor in children’s capacity to cope with trauma traumas suffered at the hand of attachment figures throughout childhood and adolescence have a damaging effect on the quality of existing attachments and IWMs

Early DA and later traumas (2): genesis of the fragmented self A pre-existing DA instigates dissociative reactions to traumas Traumas inflicted by family members are likely to cause fright without solution throughout childhood, and therefore to reinforce disorganization of earlier attachments, or to induce anew DA, both toward the abuser and toward other family members who fail to protect the victim (betrayal trauma: Freyd, 1997)

Early DA and later traumas (3): genesis of the fragmented self The IWM of DA is intrinsically dramatic (fright without solution) and un-integrated Trauma  pain  activation of the attachment system  secure IWM  successful coping Trauma  pain  activation of the attachment system  disorganized IWM  peritraumatic dissociation  cumulative effect  fragmentation of the self

A closer look at the IWM of DA a structure of implicit memory, hardly accessible to consciousness represents unpredictable, uncontrollable, and frightening caregivers’ responses, and… …switches in the child’s state of mind that are equally uncontrollable and oscillate between the polarities of craving for protective closeness, defensive rage, fright without solution and helplessness. tendency to invert the direction of the attachment relationship

Defences against the mental state of DA : controlling strategies (1) Before reaching school age, disorganized children develop organized behavioural/ attentional strategies, aimed at controlling their caregivers and deactivating the attachment system. These strategies may be uncerstood as a defence from the unbearable experience of fragmentation Two main types of controlling strategies: Controlling-punitive (domineering) Controlling-caregiving (inverted attachment)

Defences against the mental state of DA: controlling strategies (2) The defensive inhibition of the attachment system… …obtains through the activation of another inborn motivational system: Care-giving system (controlling-caregiving strategy) Social ranking system (controlling-punitive strategy) {Sexual mating system?}  (oedipal defences)

Collapse of controlling strategies and experience of fragmentation When separations, losses and traumas activate the attachment system, the inhibiting influence of other social motivational systems is overpowered: the controlling strategies collapse. Clinical symptoms characterized by fragmentation of the self emerge.

DEVELOPMENTAL PSYCHOPATHOLOGY OF DA X FF and/or HH Caregiver Disorganized Attachment Multiple IWM + Fright without solution Controlling Strategies Attachment Deactivation Collapse of controlling strategies (e.g. traumas, separations, etc.) Reactivated Attachment Fright + dissociative symptoms Intergenerational transmission Externalizing or internalizing disorders

clinical example Diana, 33, a physician, daughter of a woman suffering from bipolar disorder  Att. Dis. Remembers incest throughout adolescence and adulthood Controlling-caregiving toward mother, firmly believes having successfully prevented father abusing of sister (6 years younger) Professional vocation linked to compulsive care-giving Recurrent depressive episodes (  self-prescribed antidepressants), but no dissociative symptoms until 32 Dissociative symptoms (depersonalization, hypnagogic hallucinations) emerge when sister reveals she needs psychotherapy because father abused her sexually during her childhood The need for personal therapy is accompanied in Diana by almost delusional fantasies of rejection and danger

Relevance for psychotherapy Symptoms related not only to intrapsychic defences from painful memories, but also to: Multiplicity of non-integrated, dramatic representations of self-with-other Hindered “mentalizing” capacities Complex relational dilemmas All the above problems are contingent upon the activation of the attachment system (they may subside when interactions are governed by another motivational system)

An understanding of the therapeutic relationship Whenever multiple shifting transferences and mentalizing deficits are noticed during clinical dialogues, they are attributed to attachment needs directed toward the therapist. Fright without solution and the dissociated, dramatic IWM of AD underlies this extremely problematic expression of attachment needs This explains the repetition of typical relational dilemmas in the therapeutic relationship

Relational dilemmas Avoidance of attachment feelings toward therapist, obtained by rehearsing punitive or sexualized controlling strategies Alternating “phobia of attachment” and clinging, insecure dependency (Steele et al., 2001) Memories of frightening interactions with attachment figures are dissociated in order to preserve the attachment relationship. At the same time, attachment feelings are disavowed to protect the self from anticipated repetition of abuse (Blizard, 2001) Searching for the meaning of symptoms fosters the patient’s sense of mastery/security, but at the same time may arouse terrifying memories of attachment trauma (Holmes, 2004)

Ugo’s relational dilemma: (first part) Ugo, 27, primary pulmonary hyperten. (4 years life expectancy) Previously diagnosed BPD, U begins new psychotherapy  “ I wish to know who I am before I die” U states on session 1 he’ll refuse heart and lung transplant (because of suffering in the prospect of unlikely positive outcome). T empathizes saying he understands U’s position U idealizes therapist’s (T) empathic listening and comments Moist, cold hands at the end of every session U’s suicidal ideation escalates. From session 48, U says he decided to kill himself (therapy is still seen as a very positive experience). Frightening OBE, Out of the Body hallucinatory Experience: U sees a figure (himself) with a knife, going to kill him.

Ugo’s relational dilemma: (second part) T takes the OBE experience as evidence of disorganized attachment in the therapeutic relationship. Plans a classical intervention aimed at showing that he values U’s life without becoming unduly solicitous or looking “frightened” (which would further activate the patient’s attachment system and re- traumatize the patient  repetition of attachment trauma). During session 51, T opposes the idea of suicide, saying it is illogical to value a relationship more than one’s own life. Asks for U’s decision to stay alive in order to continue therapy. Furious, U refuses to decide pro-life. States T has ruined the only opportunity he ever had of “real dialogue”. Says he’ll quit treatment. T reacts by confirming next appointment. A sequence of three sessions (all in the same vein) follows.

Ugo’s relational dilemma: (third part) At the end of session 54, T became aware that Ugo’s hand had been warm and dry since the end of session 51  U had been very anxious during all the “idealizing” sessions, even before the beginning of suicidal ideation (  since session 1, U had been unconsciously testing T’s concern for his life, and until session 51 T failed the test) U’s response to T’ s intervention allowed for U resorting to a controlling-punitive strategy, able to re-organize his thoughts and feelings while he felt attachment feelings toward T U may have intuited T’s new understanding: on the following session, he said he’ll continue treatment  Insight on mother suicidal threats. Treatment continued until 3 years later, when U died while he was hospitalized, waiting for transplant (he had accepted to be enrolled in the waiting list for transplant)

Benefits of parallel, integrated interventions Modulation of separation anxiety and therefore of the intensity of activation of attachment needs linked to disorganization The “secondary” therapist may examine critically the multiple, dramatic, negative transference with the first (“primary”) therapist The primary therapist feels supported from the secondary therapist  less likely repetition of early relational trauma (meeting a frightened/frightening attachment figure) Witnessing cooperation on equal grounds between two attachment figures