Defining Crime: The perspective of farmers Elaine Barclay and Robyn Bartel University of New England, Armidale, NSW, Australia.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Human Impacts on the Colorado Life Zones
Advertisements

Grass Fed, Dry Aged Beef Crosby, Texas Ray Law. What is Grass Fed or Pasture Fed Beef? Put simply, American grass fed beef is exactly that--cattle that.
Catchment Management Protecting Sydney’s Water Supply.
Human-Environment Interaction
Agricultural Practices in Kansas Comparing Agricultural Practices before and after the dust storms of the 1930’s.
Livestock and the Environment Johanna Davis A.Agricultural Concerns Federal & State Environmental Laws Endangered Species Act.
Chapter 12 Food, Soil, and Pest Management
Primary Industries the collecting of natural resources F. Ciangura.
The Impact of Crime. How does crime impact on people? The immediate impact – physical harm, loss of / damage to property The ‘aftermath’ (fear of crime)
Hot Deserts. Deserts around the world. Hot Deserts This is a very harsh environment...there are many issues faced by plants, animals and people... Nomad:
Crop Rotation Growing the same crop in the same place for many years drains the soil of certain nutrients. Crop rotation gives various benefits to the.
Africa’s Environment SS7G2
This training was prepared by the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) team of Sarah Librea-USDA Foreign Agricultural Service (Team Leader), Jon Fripp.
University of South Australia – School of International Business Water Markets: Lessons From Australia Dr. Henning Bjornlund School of International Business.
Humans Impacts on Land Objective 2.07
Problems Caused By Agriculture In MEDC’s. The Common Agricultural Policy The Common Agricultural Policy, whilst guaranteeing to farmers that there would.
By Ali Brooks and Sarah Anderson.  Agro forestry- crops and trees are grown together.  Alley cropping- see agro forestry  Aquaculture- raising and.
1 Livestock-Environment Interactions Why a concern ?
Bellringer What makes water hard?. Freshwater Pollution Notes.
Disappearing Resources Are we running out of time?
Land and Soil Conservation By: Alexandra Hulvalchick
Humans are causing the sahel region to shrink, making the desert grow larger each year.
Determining How To Prevent Agricultural Pollution
Participatory research Balancing skills with local knowledge On-farm actions and trials Review and evaluation.
Environmental Problems Patten & Valdner Global History II Mepham High School Patten & Valdner Global History II Mepham High School.
Types of Agriculture and Farming Practices
Day 1 Environment Issues in Africa EQ: What environmental issues does Africa face? How do they affect the population?
Tree planting for carbon sequestration: Are landholders interested? Dr Jacki Schirmer and Dr Lyndall Bull.
Gas drilling, farming, & public health Living and producing food in an industrial zone.
Environmental Issues in Africa
How does the amount of fertilizer used by farmers affect the surrounding water for shrimp catchers? Nitrogen pollution has become a major problem around.
Schools Property Planning Competition 2013 “Waitara”
Mission 5 By Poseidon's Goldfish (Ellie, Shin Be, Mike and Dyson)
By: Krystal Brostek What’s the Issue Waste from animal agriculture is an increasing environmental problem. This waste Is one of the biggest problems.
Watersheds Human activities and structures, as depicted
Soil is the earth’s fragile skin that anchors all life on Earth. It is comprised of countless species that create a dynamic and complex ecosystem and is.
Environmental issues Australia’s rivers and landscapes are under threat from rising salinity. Many people feel that salinity is the most serious environmental.
Unit C. Basic Principles of Agricultural/Horticultural Science.
What do you need to know? This resource looks at the difference between Hazard, Risk and Disaster!
Soil Abuses and Conservation. Case Study (Cunningham) Farming the Cerrado.
Water Pollution Thirsty?.
人教修订版 高中二年级 ( 上 ) Unit 9. Writing There are many big problems facing the earth. In my opinion, pollution is the most serious one. The most serious environmental.
Environmental Issues of Africa. Clean Water Many do not have clean drinking water Nile River is contaminated with human and industrial waste Most people.
Young Farmer and Eco Champion ~ 2013 ~.  With the average age of Australian farmers border lining 53, and their sons and daughters not taking up the.
Week 7! Warm up: Discuss how you spent National Week with a partner. Ask your partner about his/her vacation.
STORM DRAINS. STORM DRAIN Water that enters storm drains goes directly into the lake. The water is not cleaned or filtered before it enters the lake.
Soil 5.2.
Monday Warm Up Q’s Write what country each number is indicating.
Agriculture Deforestation By Ranser J Rivera Alers.
Listening. chemical fertilizer cow dung radish 用化学肥料和有机肥料的区别 :
Using Plants Sustainably. Sustainable Agriculture in Canada The two main agricultural practices used by Canadian farmers to increase crop yields are the.
Human Impacts Part 2- Watersheds. What’s a Watershed? An area of land that drains into a common body of water.
Lockyer Valley Oct 2013 Damien Ferguson AgForce Mob: “Coordinating groups to carry out control over the Landscape”
Unit 9 Lesson 34 Saving the earth --By Gu Bingyu.
1.5 - Describe the environmental impact of primary production management 11 Ag/Hort.
Máistir Ó Míocháin An Tíreolas
Human Impact on Land, Air and Water Resources
Hydrosphere Notes Part 9-Land Use.
Social and Political Discourse Water Management Murray Darling System
Agriculture in Australia
Agriculture in Australia
THE ENVIRONMENT OF AFRICA
Rangelands and Grazing
Damaging the Land.
Consumption and Resource Management
Environmental Issues of Africa
Saving the earth --By Gu Bingyu
Environmental Concerns in Africa
The Impact of Agriculture
Developing Country – Semi Arid Area.
Presentation transcript:

Defining Crime: The perspective of farmers Elaine Barclay and Robyn Bartel University of New England, Armidale, NSW, Australia

1.What is the rate of environmental crime on Australian farms? 2.Do farmers consider incidents that cause environmental harm on farms as ‘crimes’ or do they qualify such acts in other ways? 3.Do they see themselves as ‘victims’? “Rural” refers to areas under agricultural production Research Questions:

Method: Part 1: Mail survey and follow up phone interviews. 5,235 farmers across Australia surveyed by mail in Participants stratified by state and industry. 41% response rate 1926 respondents (80.4%) male and (19.6%) female. Aged between 21 and 91 years (Average age: 58yrs). 40% were livestock operations, 40% were mixed farming, 20% were cropping enterprises.

2. Walgett, New South Wales 1. Moira, Victoria 3. Whitsunday, Queensland Part 2: Three Case Studies:

Environmental Crime on farms (N=1926)

Attitudes to pollution People who knowingly pollute the countryside are just as criminal as people who steal.

The high cost of irrigation water and tough times on the land makes the unauthorised taking of water justifiable. Attitudes to water theft

Unauthorised land clearing on farms is wrong. Attitudes to land clearing

Defining crime Acts which were accidental were generally not criminal, but wilful or negligent acts were. Negligence was a factor in defining the mismanagement of weeds and pest animals as a ‘crime’. Too many grey areas - each case should be judged according to the particular nuances of the event.

What about chemical spray drift? Agricultural chemical spray drift from aerial or ground spray rigs, or contaminated run-off from farmland causes contamination of land, animals or plants and waterways. I don’t know whether spray drift is an environmental crime –it is more of a malpractice or unprofessionalism

People spreading weeds onto your property I would say would be an environmental crime. Knowingly; definitely. Well, the onus is on you to keep your property clean. So the cost becomes yours and the control is your expense. The dumping of rubbish causes me problems because it blows out in my paddock and for some reason cattle eat plastic. This area is notorious for heavy winds. We continually pick up rubbish. Land mismanagement

Includes the pumping, impoundment or diversion of water from irrigation channels, river systems, dams or ground-water bores without a licence that cause changes to flows and reduces water access to neighbouring farms, livestock and riparian zones. Water becomes like gold when it gets dry and people get a bit cut throat to get water to fill their dams. I don’t say that in a bad way, but if you haven’t got water you can’t have stock - even if you’ve got a bit of feed, well if you’ve got no water, your feed is no good to you. Stock is their livelihood and that’s driving them to do what they have to do. What about water theft?

What about land clearing? Any act that harms native vegetation without permission is an offence. With concerns about high rates of land clearance, regulations limit vegetation clearance for agricultural expansion. Some of the clearing would be crime, certainly. But in terms of farming in this area, I think it’s absurd to think it’s a crime when you look at real crime like burglary and all the other crimes that we experience. They go on and nothing happens. I think it’s a funny world we live in when we are starting to look at environmental crimes as such - when cutting down a tree is a bigger crime than abusing a woman or breaking into someone’s house.

Informal ‘crimes’ Overstocking is an environmental crime because pasture goes back to bare dirt and never gets a chance to recover - even if you get a lot of rain, you don’t get a full array of grasses. We are very aware that we can’t overstock our property. Because we have had so many droughts you have to buy feed for stock or lease grazing land or sell. It’s also an issue of animal welfare with huge fines and consequences. There was divergence as well as convergence between farmers’ appreciation of environmental crime and those actions legally recognised as criminal. Sometimes farmers’ appreciations were leading formal law.

Victimisation 47% of respondents to the mail survey were victims of some type of environmental crime. In the case studies: - Farmers, their land and enterprises, as well as the environment, were acknowledged to be the victims of environmental crime Participants hesitant to label farmers as ‘victims’ - implies powerlessness…… Participants more likely to describe farmers who might offend as victims of ongoing drought or financial stress. Problems are ‘managed’ within the community by subtle means of persuasion and shaming; including appealing to extension agents to encourage deviant landholders to poor land management.

Key Findings Research needs to include the perspectives of rural communities in studies of environmental crime. Further research on environmental victimisation within the social structure of small rural communities is needed to better understand how victimisation is perceived, reported and managed. As farmers are necessarily managing large areas of the environment, their perspectives are important. We need to listen to them, to find a balance; understand and learn from their working knowledge and develop better ways of working with them toward better environmental management. Farmers’ perspectives are also important to include in any future determinations future law and policy responses designed to prevent environmental crime. Environmental crimes are a relatively new concept and definitions are unclear. We need more clarity.

Questions?..... Acknowledgments: A CERF significant project funded by QUESTIONS?