Introduction Recent measles outbreak in British Columbia and Alberta demonstrates a dire need for policy-makers to become more proactive in engaging citizens.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Stop. Think. Connect. National Cybersecurity Awareness Campaign October 2010.
Advertisements

On-line media tools for strategic communications purposes When using media tools for communication we try to use the latest technologies such us blogging,
Marketing Strategies for the Use of HINARI (module 6.1)
Nudging parents to vaccinate their children
We Have a Program for That… NGLA Annual Conference 2013 Kim Novak, CEO #NGLA13.
Elementary Implementation November 13, Create integrated STEM learning opportunities at every grade level Research and Slaybaugh Pilot 2013-
The Big Idea for the “Emerging Young Artists” is to do SMART marketing using digital marketing avenues. The idea is to create awareness and increase.
Delivering effective campaigns through social media.
Tanya Headley, MS Health Communication Specialist, NIOSH Mansi Das, MPH, MBA Health Communication Specialist, NIOSH NIOSH Social Media in Action.
1 GROUP-8. 2 PPT downloaded from
Engaging Patients through Social Media Kenan Omurtag, MD Assistant Professor, Reproductive Endocrinology and infertility Washington University St Louis.
Preparing Our Future Teachers for Learning and Teaching with Technology Patricia Boechler, U of A Sharon Friesen, U of C Marlo Steed, U of L Karen Andrews,
The changing Role of Social Media in Emergencies Communications & Resilience Workshop Falkirk, 28 th February 2012 Stefan Raue School of Computing Science.
UIA Associations Round Table – Europe 2014 Dublin, November 2014 Achieving impact and finding the funds Dr Dragana Avramov PSPC, Brussels 14/11/2014www.avramov.org1.
This webinar is brought to you by CLEONet CLEONet is a web site of legal information for community workers and advocates who work with low-income.
Web 2.0 and Libraries in the 21 st Century Caroline Kerbyson Cambridge University Press.
Degree Programs in Public Health: A Canadian Perspective Sylvie Stachenko Dean, School of Public Health Global Summit on Education and Training in Heart.
Use of emerging technologies in provision of Cancer Information Services: an international snap shot Dr Amanda Hordern PhD Director, Cancer Information.
Educational Research: Action Research in Schools
Technology for Nonprofits Social Media & Web 2.0 Natalia Smirnov Media Productions & Communications Coordinator University Community Collaborative of Philadelphia.
What does the course cover:  The course is a practical guide to use digital marketing to effectively reach out to internet audience while building your.
Your Professional Network Powered by NCURA By: Stephanie Moore NCURA Community Curator.
“Consistency is Key!” A Quick Guide to Online Marketing By Virtual Marketing Empire, LLC
McMaster Optimal Aging Portal Laura Harrington Managing Director Labarge Optimal Aging Initiative McMaster University.
National Public Health Performance Standards Local Assessment Instrument Essential Service:3 Inform, Educate, and Empower People about Health Issues.
CHUCK YOUNG MANAGING DIRECTOR OFFICE OF PUBLIC AFFAIRS GOVERNMENT ACCOUNTABILITY OFFICE to AGA BOSTON CHAPTER PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT CONFERENCE MARCH.
TECHNOLOGICAL ENABLERS TO ASSIST YOUR LIBRARY'S MARKETING STRATEGIES: THE POWER OF SOCIAL MEDIA PRESENTED BY MS MOSHIANE RAMAUBE MS MANDISA LAKHENI.
THE MYSTERY OF GETTING RESEARCH INTO USE… THE ONGOING MYSTERY OF GETTING RESEARCH INTO USE.
MARKETING THAT WORKS David Camp SVP Business Development.
Hearts, Minds and Online Donations Wednesday 10 th of March 2010 Bristol Fundraising Group Talk by Tickbox Marketing.
Going where consumers are!
Utilizing Social Media & Multimedia Communications.
Web site Comps & Global Architecture Round One Review July 21, 2010.
Review of Professional Resource Will Jiang U
Structure of Course  Written paper (25%)  Essay (30%)  Presentation (45%)
Attract & More... Blogging Easily create remarkable content that will help your business get found. Social Inbox Publish and see Social Analytics across.
Why Physicians Must Be Online Sharing Expertise Online & Mommy Blogging Wendy Sue Swanson, MD, MBE, FAAP Pediatrician, Blogger, Speaker,
Shifting resources: disinvestment and re-investment Craig Mitton, PhD Centre for Clinical Epidemiology and Evaluation, Vancouver Coastal Health Research.
Created by: Samuel Butt, Stacy Pease, and Ian Woglom.
Health Insurance and Libraries: An Oregon Update Nikki Dettmar, MSIS, Education and Assessment Coordinator National Network of Libraries of Medicine, Pacific.
Network Comparison Edutopia Facebook Page and Epsilen Project Share EDLD 5362 By Janet Kelly Cohort 13/ ET 8027 Dr. Sheryl Abshire.
SOCIAL MEDIA AND COMMUNICATIONS FOR THE 21 ST CENTURY —Jacquelyn Askins University of Wisconsin-Extension, Cooperative Extension.
Google Analytics Top 10 Metrics By: Errett Cord Website:
Key Stakeholder Interviews Assessing Effectiveness of Washington State Board of Education Communications with Key Stakeholders.
The Benefits of Membership: Online Services. New Website On April 1, we are launching a new version of our website! It’s yours to use at:
1 Wellbeing for Children with a Disability in New Zealand: A conceptual framework By Maree Kirk BRCSS Award 2007 Department of Societies and Cultures University.
Content + Intent = Change A formula for catalyzing social change using documentary film.
 Digital PR combines traditional PR with content marketing, social media and search engine optimization  Converts static news into conversations by.
4-H Youth Development Program Using Technology to Market Your Fair Project Matthew T. Portillo, PhD. Butte County 4-H Youth Development Program April 16,
The Role of Communication in Transforming Statistics into Knowledge Enrico Giovannini Chief Statistician - OECD.
Open Access Journals (OAJ): Use and Awareness Among Scientific Community Mr. Subhash Reddy Librarian PES University, Bangalore Dr. Rajendra Babu H Tumkur.
The Editor’s Perspective on Reviewing and Selecting Manuscripts for Publication Samuel F. Posner, PhD Editor in Chief, Preventing Chronic Disease Deputy.
SEARCH ENGINE OPTIMIZATION (SEO) Pamela Drake ENG 2720 Writing with New Media.
Maryland Humanities Council Grant Application Information.
Jo’s Cervical Cancer Trust Rebecca Shoosmith, Services Development Manager Digital Communication WACC International Network Forum,
Caring, Ethics, Science. Caring Physicians of the World (CPW) Medical Leadership Communication and Medical Advocacy Course Monday, 2 nd May.
Social Media: Best Practices Michelle Pulaski Behling Pace University, Pleasantville.
+ Welcome to PAHO/WHO Sustainable Development and Health Toolkit for the UN Global Conference RIO + 20 Welcome to PAHO/WHO Sustainable Development and.
PP 620: Public Policy and Health Administration Unit One Seminar Kris R. Foote, J.D., M.P.A., M.S.W. Kaplan University.
Personal Branding. Objectives How do you see yourself? How do others see you? What is your personal brand?
Strategy Document. Road Map Total Population: 190 million (1.6% annual growth) Internet Users: 30 million (Penetration: 15%) Mobile Subscribers: 120.
Use Content Marketing to Grow Your Business
Multiple literacy Standards for the 21st-Century learner
Introduction Of Digital Marketing
Individualized research consultations in academic libraries: Useful or useless? Let the evidence speak for itself Karine Fournier Lindsey Sikora Health.
Social Media Marketing
The Second World War Conflict that changed the World
Important Steps for a Successful SEO Campaign
Presentation about BILAT USA 4.0
Evaluating Web Resources
Presentation transcript:

Introduction Recent measles outbreak in British Columbia and Alberta demonstrates a dire need for policy-makers to become more proactive in engaging citizens in decision-making. Anti-vaccination movements are not a new problem nor is it an objective phenomenon. Instead, they are the interpretations from particular perspectives (Mannheim, 1936). Medicine in the 21 st century is a post- modernist challenge to Evidence-Based Medicine (EBM) because it signifies that decision-making processes are subject to form opinions based on both evidence and values (Gray, 1999). This research aims to identify the social constructs on target groups in the online community, explore the gaps of Web engagement by pro-vaccination and Anti- vaccination groups, and explore future steps for entrepreneurship in health-policy countering Anti-vaccination movements. Materials and methods Using the theory of social construction of target groups (Schneider and Ingram, 1993), this study identifies the quadrants of social hierarchy of key supporters and opponents in the online Anti-vaccination community. This research navigated contents online to calculate the use of web 1.0 (unilateral informational posts) and web 2.0 (real-time interactive feeds) for the above groups using ww.soicalmention.com and other crowd- sourcing websites. Applying multiple streams framework, this study examined the means through which agencies can engage in policy entrepreneurship to create opportunities to merge three streams to counter Anti- vaccination movements (Kingdon, 2002). Acknowledgments My sincere thanks to supervisor Dr. Julia Abelson for providing invaluable guidance and funding throughout the research. I thank Anna Kata for a fruitful discussion on her research on Anti-vaccination claims. Special thanks to my colleagues at CHEPA and the philosophy department at McMaster for proof-reading, and anonymous social media savvy bloggers who have exchanged dialogues with me. Results Preliminary research shows that government agencies belong to the advantaged quadrant in the social construction in the online community. Non- profit organizations are perceived as either contenders or advantaged advocates for the dependents (i.e. target subject for vaccines and their decision makers). Agencies supporting Anti- vaccination movements are perceived as deviants and advocates for the dependents. As of March, 2014, results for measuring agency engagement shows mainly neutral (see Chart 1), although there is a lack of engagement for pro-vaccination agencies in Web 2.0 activities (see Chart 2). Chart 1. Sentiments of Anti-vaccine claims on Web 1.0 and Web 2.0 (March, 2014) Based on keyword on Google search engine, fourteen methods of engagement emerged. In Web1.0, methods include setting up websites allowing contact by , websites with downloadable brochures, informational websites with FAQs, blogs with professional information, websites containing vaccine information with a recognizable spokesperson, applications on portable devices with immunization alerts. These forms of engagement are unilateral and provide no opportunity for direct feedback or bilateral engagement. As chart 2 demonstrates, Anti- vaccination agencies occupy the internet by engaging in Web 1.0 and Web 2.0 services. Chart 2. Engagement on Web 1.0 and Web 2.0 Conclusions In the advent of media 2.0, the role of government agencies’ involvement or its lack thereof on the internet needs re-evaluation. This research analyzes the multitude of social media engagement channels health policy-makers could use to counter saliency on health misinformation in online communities in a Canadian context. Melodie Yun-Ju Song Health Policy PhD student, Department of Clinical Epidemiology and Biostatistics, Center for Health Economics and Policy Analysis, McMaster University Literature cited Mannheim, K. (2013). Ideology and utopia. Routledge. Gray, J. A. (1999). Postmodern medicine. The Lancet, 354(9189), Kata, A. (2010). A postmodern Pandora's box: Anti-vaccination misinformation on the Internet. Vaccine, 28(7), Schneider, A., & Ingram, H. (1993). Social construction of target populations: Implications for politics and policy. American political science review, 87(02), Kingdon, J. (2002). The reality of public policy making. Ethical dimensions of health policy, Further information Inquiries on research results welcomed, you may reach me at or follow me on Twitter Policy Entrepreneurship – Is There Room for Public Health Professionals to Speak Up Against Anti-vaccination Movements in Cyberspace? On the other hand, Web 2.0 engagements are prominent in the form of active interactions on Twitter, Facebook, and blogs where authors respond to the questions of the community, websites with direct number for informational inquiry, discussion forums, webpages allowing comments and feedback, applications on mobile devices with personalized immunization plans and live newsfeed, and presence of recognizable spokespersons engaging in social media. Web 2.0 creates real-time interactive dialogues with readers, and, often, throughout the process, allows for constant feedback and re-iteration of information/misinformation. In multiple streams framework, policy entrepreneurship from government agencies in the political stream are less prominent than non-profit agencies. Policy entrepreneurship from agencies supporting Anti-vaccination movements have successfully created issues in the problems stream, presented solutions in the policies stream, and gained momentum in the politics stream. Discussion Social construction of target groups indicate that parent-initiated non-profit groups on the internet poses great threats for pro-vaccination agencies. It is common in Anti-vaccination websites to use tactics such as skewing the science, shifting hypothesis, censorship, attacking the opposition to counter pro- vaccination information (Kata, 2012). These tactics promotes Anti-vaccination salience in social media, more specifically, under the name of non-profit organizations found by parents; these organizations easily appeal to the audience by updating readers on the newest campaigns, evidence in its favor and referrals to trusted sources. Policy-makers have failed to thwart online Anti- vaccination movements partly due to (1) a failed policy-reaction towards a moving ‘arena’ of dialogue in cyberspace, (2) a paradigm shift of postmodernism of interpretation on vaccines that Evidence-Based Medicine alone cannot solve, (3) lack of coherent action plans for policy windows to open to counter Anti-vaccination movements.