Comparability and equivalence of Higher Education : Bologna as an example Patricia Pol AERES, Université Paris Est Arab-Euro.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

trends, progress report and

Advertisements

CURRENT DEVELOPMENTS IN BOLOGNA PROCESS Vlasta Vizek Vidović Vicerector for international relations University of Zagreb Zagreb, November, 2004.

The Challenges of Joint Programmes The View of the Universities Tia Loukkola 10 June, 2010.

BOLOGNA PROCESS CARDIFF- 18 MAY BOLOGNA PROCESS CARDIFF 18 MAY 2009 BACKGROUND - ERASMUS SORBONNE DECLARATION 1998 (FRANCE, GERMANY, ITALY, UK)

Erasmus Coordinators Workshops British Council, Cardiff 24 June 2009 Huw Morris Academic Registrar and Bologna Expert Swansea University,

1 Bologna Shaping the Agenda Bologna today and tomorrow Lesley Wilson Secretary-General, European University Association.

Attractiveness of the HEIs in the EHEA An Introduction to WG 3 Pavel Zgaga University of Ljubljana Bologna Conference Fostering student mobility: next.

The European Higher Education Area – A journey…

ENQA’S CONSULTATIVE MEMBERSHIP IN THE BFUG - WHAT DOES IT ENTAIL

BFUG Work Program on QA Agenda Gayane Harutyunyan Basel,

ENQA, Bologna, London and beyond

Executive Director of the Danish Evaluation Institute (EVA)

European Quality Assurance in Higher Education after the London ministerial meeting: moving towards 2010 (and beyond) Sofia, 9 November 2007 Emmi.

European Developments in Quality Assurance – an Overview Achim Hopbach ENQA Vice President.

The Bologna Process and the Scottish Credit and Qualifications Framework Dr Gillian Mackintosh Head of Registry.

1 BFUG meeting in Manchester, Oct Stocktaking introduction to discussion Andrejs Rauhvargers, Latvia.

FRAMEWORK FOR QUALIFICATIONS OF THE EUROPEAN HIGHER EDUCATION AREA Tirana, March 2005.

Bologna Process Development of Qualifications Frameworks 9-10 November 2009.

Erasmus Mundus The programme in brief.

BRITISH COUNCIL WORKSHOPS HIGHER EDUCATION REFORM IN EUROPENOVEMBER 2012 HIGHER EDUCATION ACADEMY.

Axel Aerden 17 April Set up in the framework of the Bologna Process Bi-national organisation Established by treaty Safeguards for independence procedures,

Higher education policy, main developments in Europe Empower European Universities Annual conference The State of Universities for Progress Parkhotel.

«Bologna Structural Reforms: History, Problems and Perspectives» INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE Astana February 13-14, 2014.

EAC HIGHER EDUCATION POLICY

The Political Framework of Erasmus Centralised Actions

The Modernisation of Higher Education Introduction Anthony Vickers 27 th June 2012.

Compatibility of NQFs with QF-EHEA: Analysis of Verification Reports Bryan Maguire 2 nd Regional Meeting of Ministers of Education Strasbourg, November,

Axel Aerden 19 May Source: Cohen, E.B., Winch, R., Diploma and Accreditation Mills: New Trends in Credential Abuse, March 2011.

Website: Bologna Secretariat Transparency Tools in The European Higher Education Area Viorel Proteasa 2010.

Europe, Bologna and Erasmus: Update on Developments UK HE International Unit.

The role of students alongside other stakeholders in the Bologna Process Colin Tück 26/27 May 2008, Baku Council of Europe seminar.

Quality and the Bologna Process Andrée Sursock Deputy Secretary General European University Association (EUA) EPC Annual Congress, March 2005, Brighton.

How quality and competitiveness of European universities are reflected in global academic rankings a Bologna perspective on competitiveness: it can help.

EUA Convention of European Higher Education Institutions Graz, May 2003 Theme I European higher education in a globalised world.

BOLOGNA PROCESS and the COUNCIL OF EUROPE CONTRIBUTION RUDN, Moscow, 12 December December 2007 Katia Dolgova-Dreyer, Council of Europe.

The “Bologna Process” and the European Higher Education Area in the global setting. Donatella Palomba - Università di Roma “Tor Vergata ” YICGG 2008 –

Bregenz, Austria 7 June 2015 Shaping our future: higher education helping create the society we want Gayane Harutyunyan.

1 Education in Europe: Quality Enhancement and Setting Standards Dr Marie Donaghy Head of School of Health Sciences.

Developing a National Qualifications Framework: the Georgian experience General Overview Nodar Surguladze Deputy Minister Ministry of Education and Science.

Bologna Process  A co-ordinated reform process in more than 30 signatory countries.  Co-ordinated by the common platform in the Bologna Declaration of.

The role of European standards and guidelines for the development of the national system of independent assessment of the quality of higher education Seidakhmetova.

The Bologna Process The UK HE Europe Unit Tish Bourke.

Strategic Framework for European cooperation in education and training

Higher Education and Research: Mission and Interaction David Crosier CONFERENCE TO LAUNCH WORK ON A MASTER PLAN FOR HIGHER EDUCATION IN ALBANIA Tirana,

The European Dimension of Quality Assurance Henrik Toft Jensen EUA Conference “Quality Assurance in Higher Education and Vocational Education and Training.

Neoliberal Policy and Higher Education in Europe: The case of Greece Toliou Rosa Mid-term conference in Ljubljana June 29-30, 2007.

The London Communiqué and its relation to the UNESCO/OECD Guidelines on Quality Provision in CBHE Dr. Marie-Anne Persoons General coordinator Benelux Bologna.

QF-EHEA EURODIACONIA 4-5 October 2007 Brussels Dr. Marlies Leegwater Head Benelux Bologna Secretariat

EUA – Bologna 1 The Bologna Process – Towards the European Higher Education Area Pierre de Maret EUA Board Member Former Rector of Brussels University.

The Bologna Process and the Syrian Context Dr. Ali Saud Hasan Prof. of Applied linguistics (ELT) Faculty of Education, Damascus university

Academic cooperation and competitiveness. University ranking methodologies TRANSPARENCY TOOLS VS. RANKINGS Prof. univ. dr. Radu Mircea Damian Chair, CDESR.

Andrée Sursock, PhD Mexico–EU Policy Dialogue Seminar on transparency tools, internationalisation and excellence in higher education September 2015.

European Higher Education in Flux – challenges for the next decade - Lesley Wilson Secretary General, EUA EAIR, Vilnius, 24 August 2009.

After the Bologna Bucharest Conference: What is new on the way to Bologna New Developments in European QA CEENQA-Workshop in Sarajevo 11 and 12 May 2012.

Bob Johnson, ECBE, SEEC 11 Nov Qualification Frameworks and Credit - Articulation with Europe Bob Johnson Commissioner for Credit Rating European.

An overview in slides. A: the intergovernmental process Step 1: Sorbonne Declaration 1998 Step 2: Bologna Declaration 1999 Step 3: Prague Communiqué 2001.

University autonomy and governance Baku Bologna Seminar - Current issues in the Bologna process Bastian Baumann, Baku, 26 May 2008.

Bologna Follow-up Group Programme: Challenges and expectations Gayane Harutyunyan Bologna Secretariat Astana, Kazakhstan February 13-14, 2014.

1 EAN CONFERENCE June 30 – July 2, 2008, Berlin. 2 „Challenges for Europe: European Higher Education in a Global Setting“ Barbara Weitgruber Austrian.

“Three Cycle System in the Framework of Bologna Process”, Summer School, Erevan, Armenia, 2008 The Three-Cycle System Algirdas Vaclovas Valiulis, Bologna.

Role of Quality Assurance in the Establishment of the EHEA presentation given at the conference ”Bologna Process Implementation in Turkey after 10 Years”,

European Higher Education Area: focus from structures to better learning Head of Higher Education Unit Helka Kekäläinen, PhD.

Reconsidering the EHEA Principles: Perspectives for the Second Decade EHEA WORKING GROUP ON STRUCTURAL REFORM 1 st Meeting of the EHEA Working Group on.

Bologna Process - objectives and achievements Ms. Sirpa Moitus, FINEEC Mr. Kauko Hämäläinen Baku, 29 September 2015.

Bologna Promoters’ Presentation Material (to be adapted as needed)

TOWARDS THE YEREVAN 2015 MINISTERIAL CONFERENCE: A NEW AGENDA FOR THE EHEA Hayk Sargsyan 11 March 2015 Moscow, Russian Federation.

Senior project leader at CIEP Former President of ENQA

Quality assurance of higher education in the European Higher Education Area - developments and ways forward Paula Ranne, Deputy Director European Association.

Ministry of Education and Science of the Republic of Armenia

Ministry of Education and Science of the Republic of Armenia

Presentation transcript:

Comparability and equivalence of Higher Education : Bologna as an example Patricia Pol AERES, Université Paris Est Arab-Euro Conference on Higher Education, Barcelona May 2013

Outlines The European Higher Education Area (EHEA) : a reality and not a chimera But a diverse reality At the crossroads : consolidation or new deal ? Arab-Euro Conference on Higher Education, Barcelona May 2013

1. A reality and not a chimera Initiated by a regional starting point and a political willingness of the Ministers of HE From La Sorbonne (4) to Bologna (19) and Budapest- Vienna (47) Implemented by a participative organisation BFUG, E4 (EUA-ESU-ENQA-EURASHE) and others… Benchmarked all over the world Arab-Euro Conference on Higher Education, Barcelona May 2013

From 4 to 47 national HE systems put together Arab-Euro Conference on Higher Education, Barcelona May 2013

To build a European common house of higher education (P. Zgaga, 2012) (11) Partnership (9) the European dimension (8) the social dimension (10) the global dimension THE SECOND FLOOR (7) higher education structures (the EHEA technical condition sine qua non): the comparability and compatibility of systems, quality assurance, recognition of qualifications etc. THE FIRST FLOOR (4) higher education as a public good; public responsibility for HE (5) the responsibility of HE; accountability; responsiveness to society (6) the full range of purposes of HE THE BASEMENT (1) democracy and democratic values (2) academic values (university autonomy and academic freedom) (3) international co-operation (mobility)

2. But a diverse reality - Based on national differences Because of structural features (nb of students, type of system and profile of institutions, participation rate, public expenditure, historical international attractivity..) Reforms more focused on national considerations of governance or research than EHEA principles - Leading to unbalanced and incomplete results Different cycles ( ECTS / ECTS) Student workload, mobility, employability (bachelor) Arab-Euro Conference on Higher Education, Barcelona May 2013

The implementation of the two-cycle structure

Arab-Euro Conference on Higher Education, Barcelona May 2013

Joint programmes Arab-Euro Conference on Higher Education, Barcelona May 2013

Shanghaï ranking ! Consolidation (BFUG) or time for a new deal ? (ESU) 2000 Lisbon strategy The EU 2020 Strategy 2010 Vienna Budapest La Sorbonne Bologna 2012 Bucharest 2015 Erevan 2018 Global competition National excellence initiatives National strategies of HE &R more transparency/ and « better » diversity Most competitive knowledge economy by 2010 Smart Sustainable Inclusive growth 40% graduated 2020 ERA+EHEA Arab-Euro Conference on Higher Education, Barcelona May 2013 Cooperation for

Acronyms EHEA: European Higher Education Area HE&R : Higher Education and Research BFUG : Bologna Follow Up Group ESU : European Student Union EUA: European University Association ENQA: European Network for Quality Assurance EURASHE: European Assocation for Short Cycle Education Arab-Euro Conference on Higher Education, Barcelona May 2013

References Report on the implementation of the Bologna process (2011) Bologna with student eyes 2012, ESU. The Bologna process at the crossroads, A. Curaj, P. Scott, L.Vlasceanu, L. Wilson, Editors, Springer, 2012 Arab-Euro Conference on Higher Education, Barcelona May 2013