1. T-76.115 Project Review Groupname [PP|…|DE] Iteration 30.10.2003

2. T-76.115 Project Review 2 Agenda  Project status (x min)  achieving the goals of the iteration  project metrics  Used work practices (x min)  Completed work (x min)  presenting the iteration’s results  demo  Plans for the next iteration (5 min)  This template contains the minimum set of topics covered in the reviews, you may add new slides, but consider the available time

3. T-76.115 Project Review 3 Status of planned goals of the iteration  Goal 1: Specify the goals of the project from all perspectives  OK  Goal 2: Select and adapt work practices to be used in the project  NOT OK, because …  Goal 3: Make the contract with the customer  DISCARDED/ MOVED LATER, because …

4. T-76.115 Project Review 4 Status of planned deliverables of the iteration  Project Plan  OK, except chapter 1.3, because …  Requirements document  OK, most important requirements in general, and sub system X in detail  Use cases 1,3,6,12,15 implemented and tested  OK

5. T-76.115 Project Review 5 Realization of the tasks  Explain the reasons for major discrepancies  estimation problems  new/deferred tasks  unplanned work Tip! Ctrl+Alt+PrintScrn in Trapoli Ctrl+V in PowerPoint Use Crop (Drawing toolbar) Tip! Ctrl+Alt+PrintScrn in Trapoli Ctrl+V in PowerPoint Use Crop (Drawing toolbar)

6. T-76.115 Project Review 6 Working hours by person  Explain the reasons for major discrepancies in realizations  Explain the reasons for changes in the plan RealPlanDiff Member1 2334-11 M2 2434-10 M3 2530-5 M4 26242 M5 27234 M6 26242 M7 2532-7 Total 176201-25 Realized hours in this iterationPlan in the beginning of this iteration PP Subtot I1I2I3DETotal M1 50 3460 50190 M2 22 3460 20190 M3 23 3060 20190 M4 24 60 20190 M5 25 2360 20190 M6 26 2460 20190 M7 16 3260 20190 Total 119 201420 1701330 Latest plan (inc. realized hours and other updates) PPI1 Subtot I2I3DETotal M1 502373756050190 M2 222446706020190 M3 23254860 20190 M4 24265060 20190 M5 25275160 20190 M6 26 5260 20190 M7 16254160 20190 Total 1191762954454201701330

7. T-76.115 Project Review 7 Quality metrics  Description of blocker and critical bugs found and open  other QA metrics  unit test coverage  code reviews  source code metrics ... I1I2I3DETotal Reported 107585 Closed 54550 Open 535 … or make a more detailed table/graph, where you show per module bugs, and/or classifications per criticality, origin (own system testing, code reviews, customer, peer group) etc. Bug metrics BlockersCriticalMajorMinorTrivialTotal Total open 125101735 This iteration reported 0110154975

8. T-76.115 Project Review 8 Quality assessment  Evaluate the quality of the different functional areas of the system  how much effort has been put on test execution  what is the coverage of testing  what can you say about the quality of the particular component based on your test results and ’gut feeling’ during testing  is the number of reported bugs low because of lack of testing or high because of intensive testing  Assess the quality status of the system against the goals of the iteration Functional areaCoverageQualityComments File conversions2 Only few minor defects found, very efficient implementation. GUI editor0  Not started Encoder3  2 critical bugs found during last test round, lots of small problems Admin tools1  Nothing serious yet Legend Coverage: 0 = nothing 1 = we looked at it 2 = we checked all functions 3 = it’s tested Quality:  = quality is good  = not sure  = quality is bad

9. T-76.115 Project Review 9 Software size in Lines of Code (LOC)  Any remarks on this metric?  lots of new functinality was implemented  refactoring reduced LOC PPI1I2I3DE Total (NCLOC + COM) 010004000 Comments (COM) 0100200 PPI1I2I3DE Total – part A 010004000 Com – part A 0100200 Total – part B Com – part B Total – part C Com – part C Total 010004000 Comments 0100200 … or make a more detailed table, where you can show per module LOCs, or proportion of real code vs. test code

10. T-76.115 Project Review 10 Changes to the project  Any other major changes to the project, not yet discussed  goals of the project  goals of the coming iterations  project organization  requirements  technologies  …

11. T-76.115 Project Review 11 Risks  How have you done risk management?  What is the current situation regarding the risks?  materialized risks?  new risks identified?

12. T-76.115 Project Review 12 Work practices  How have you been using the planned work practices, what are the experiences of  mandatory practices: time reporting, version control, …  personal SE assignments  not all in every review, but when there are some interesting findings etc.  other practices  Are you going to  adopt some new practices  change the use of the current practices  stop using some adopted practices

13. T-76.115 Project Review 13 Example: Test-first approach (N.N.)  Test-first was adopted by 3 coders after short training by N.N.  They used it first for all new code, but later only in modules x,y,z, because …  Metrics  the amount of unit test code is 1000 LOC (20% of total LOC)  80% of test code was written before the real code  effort N.N. spent on preparing the adoption (reading about test-first, planning, training) was 12h  effort the team spent on learning the practice was 7h  Positive experiences  …  Negative experiences  it does not work when xxx because yyy  Overall  the practice seems to be useful  In the next iteration the use of the practice will be slightly changed by adopting the JUnit tool  …

14. T-76.115 Project Review 14 Results of the iteration  Briefly describe the substance of the major deliverables of the iteration, e.g., the following in the relevant iterations (avoid repeating the stuff you have already told in project status and concentrate on elaborating what was done)  project plan  requirements  system architecture  implemented use cases (will be demonstrated later)  user’s manual  studies made  Demonstrate the developed software  first tell briefly to the audience what you are going to demonstrate (perhaps distribute a demo script to the audience)  concentrate on new functionality in each review

15. T-76.115 Project Review 15 Example: Project plan  Background of the project  Project organization  Project goals  Project resources  Project practices and tools  Iterations  Risk management plan  …

16. T-76.115 Project Review 16 Example: Demo  System Administrator  function X  function Y  …  Basic user  function Z1  function Z2  …

17. T-76.115 Project Review 17 Plan for the next iteration  Goals  Goal 1  Goal 2  Goal 3 ...  Goal N  Deliverables  Deliverable 1  Deliverable 2 ...  Deliverable N  Priorities between goals  Risks / uncertainties  Schedule  task dependencies  internal deadlines