I TEM T H 12 A – A-6-CII Tierra Del Oro Carlsbad San Diego County C ALIFORNIA C OASTAL C OMMISSION S AN D IEGO C OAST D ISTRICT S LIDE 1

I TEM T H 12 A – CDP A PPLICATION N UMBER A-6-CII S LIDE 2 A PPROVED P ROJECT Demolition of existing 3,056 square foot single- story single-family residence with basement Partial demolition of existing detached 528 square foot two-car garage with 432 square foot guest house Construction of a new two-story 8,845 square foot single-family residence with basement and new pool and deck

I TEM T H 12 A – CDP A PPLICATION N UMBER A-6-CII S LIDE 3 P ROJECT L OCATION

I TEM T H 12 A – CDP A PPLICATION N UMBER A-6-CII S LIDE 4 E XISTING C ONDITIONS

I TEM T H 12 A – CDP A PPLICATION N UMBER A-6-CII S LIDE 5 A PPEAL C ONTENTIONS The City did not apply correct rear-yard or “Stringline” setbacks for home or pool/deck area The Geologic stability analysis failed to review the proposed homes stability without benefit of the existing revetment The location of the Bluff edge as accepted by the City is inconsistent with surrounding properties.

I TEM T H 12 A – CDP A PPLICATION N UMBER A-6-CII S LIDE 6 S TRINGLINE S ETBACK A PPROVED BY C ITY = Deck Stringline = Area beyond stringline = Existing patio to be replaced in kind

I TEM T H 12 A – CDP A PPLICATION N UMBER A-6-CII S LIDE 7 CCC S TRINGLINE S ETBACK = Deck Stringline = Additional setback provided by applicant = Area remaining beyond stringline = Existing patio to be replaced in kind

I TEM T H 12 A – CDP A PPLICATION N UMBER A-6-CII S LIDE 8

I TEM T H 12 A – CDP A PPLICATION N UMBER A-6-CII S LIDE 9 R ECOMMENDATION ON DE N OVO Approval with Conditions Motion and Resolution on Page 15

I TEM T H 12 A – CDP A PPLICATION N UMBER A-6-CII S LIDE 10

I TEM T H 12 A – CDP A PPLICATION N UMBER A-6-CII S LIDE 11 O CEAN S ETBACK “S TRINGLINE ” Section B (Coastal Shoreline Development Overlay Zone) of the City’s IP states: New development fronting the ocean shall observe at a minimum, an ocean setback based on “stringline” method of measurement. No enclosed portions of a structure shall be permitted further seaward than allowed by a line drawn between the adjacent structure to the north and south, no decks or other appurtenances shall be permitted further seaward than those allowed by a line drawn between those on the adjacent structure to the north and south. A greater ocean setback may be required for geological reasons and if specified in the Local Coastal Program.

I TEM T H 12 A – CDP A PPLICATION N UMBER A-6-CII S LIDE 12 G EOLOGIC A NALYSIS LUP Policy 4-1, Subsection III. (Shoreline Structures) & Section B. (Conditional Beach Uses) of the City’s IP: Revetments, breakwaters, groins, harbor channels, seawalls, cliff retaining walls, and other such construction that alters natural shoreline processes shall be permitted when required to serve coastal-dependent uses or to protect existing structures or public beaches in danger from erosion, and when designed to eliminate or mitigate adverse impacts on local shoreline sand supply.