1. I TEM 13 B – CDP N UMBER 5-14-1213 Balboa Pier Area Corona del Mar State Beach Newport Dunes Waterfront Resort & Marina Newport Beach Orange County C ALIFORNIA C OASTAL C OMMISSION S OUTH C OAST D ISTRICT S LIDE 1 http://savethefirerings.org/history/

2. I TEM 13 B – CDP A PPLICATION N UMBER 5-14-1213S LIDE 2 P ROJECT D ESCRIPTION Existing temporary fire ring plan Reduce number of fire rings from 60 to 56 Relocate fire rings Limit fuel to charcoal-only in 30 fire rings Proposed permanent fire ring plan Increase number of fire rings to 64 Relocate fire rings Limit fuel to charcoal-only in 24 fire rings Make 12 fire rings ADA accessible Request after-the-fact approval of existing ADA concrete path and 4 existing fire rings

3. I TEM 13 B – CDP A PPLICATION N UMBER 5-14-1213S LIDE 3 P ROJECT L OCATION Newport Dunes Waterfront Resort & Marina Corona del Mar State Beach East and West of Balboa Pier

4. I TEM 13 B – CDP A PPLICATION N UMBER 5-14-1213S LIDE 4 H ISTORIC F OOTPRINT : B ALBOA P IER 15 Fire Rings 18 Fire Rings

5. I TEM 13 B – CDP A PPLICATION N UMBER 5-14-1213S LIDE 5 H ISTORIC F OOTPRINT : C D M 27 Fire Rings

6. I TEM 13 B – CDP A PPLICATION N UMBER 5-14-1213S LIDE 6 AQMD R ULE 444 (3) A person is prohibited from open burning for: (G) Effective March 1, 2014, beach burning, unless: (i) PM2.5 AQI of 100 or less has been forecast for the coastal source receptor area; and (ii) beach burning occurs in devices that are: (I) at least 700 feet from the nearest residence; or (II) at least 100 feet apart from one another…

7. I TEM 13 B – CDP A PPLICATION N UMBER 5-14-1213S LIDE 7 T EMPORARY P LAN : B ALBOA P IER East Balboa 13 wood-burning fire rings West Balboa 18 charcoal-only fire rings West of Balboa Pier East of Balboa Pier

8. I TEM 13 B – CDP A PPLICATION N UMBER 5-14-1213S LIDE 8 T EMPORARY P LAN : C D M Corona del Mar State Beach 13 wood-burning fire rings 12 charcoal-only fire rings

9. I TEM 13 B – CDP A PPLICATION N UMBER 5-14-1213S LIDE 9 P ERMANENT P LAN : B ALBOA P IER East Balboa 7 wood-burning fire rings 4 ADA accessible 8 charcoal-only fire rings Existing ADA path West Balboa 9 wood-burning fire rings 4 ADA accessible 8 charcoal-only fire rings Existing ADA concrete path East of Balboa Pier West of Balboa Pier

10. I TEM 13 B – CDP A PPLICATION N UMBER 5-14-1213S LIDE 10 P ERMANENT P LAN : C D M Corona del Mar State Beach 16 wood-burning fire rings 4 ADA accessible 8 charcoal-only fire rings

11. I TEM 13 B – CDP A PPLICATION N UMBER 5-14-1213S LIDE 11 N EWPORT D UNES W ATERFRONT R ESORT & M ARINA Public Parking Lot RV Guest Parking Pedestrian Access 4 Fire Rings

12. I TEM 13 B – CDP A PPLICATION N UMBER 5-14-1213S LIDE 12 P ERMANENT P LAN : N EWPORT D UNES Newport Dunes 8 wood-burning fire rings 4 existing 4 new

13. I TEM 13 B – CDP A PPLICATION N UMBER 5-14-1213S LIDE 13 C HARCOAL - ONLY E XPERIENCE Benefits of Charcoal Less visible smoke More even heat for cooking Drawbacks of Charcoal No real flame without lighter fluid Need flashlight after sunset Less heat generated Higher price Shorter burn time

14. I TEM 13 B – CDP A PPLICATION N UMBER 5-14-1213S LIDE 14 R ECOMMENDATION Approval with nine special conditions (see staff report page 5 for Motion)