The Added Value and Financial Savings of Contextually-Relevant Assessments Paul Gibbs, Anu Sachdev & Whitney Szmodis Abstract Researchers assessed 260.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Action Research Not traditional educational research often research tests theory not practical Teacher research in classrooms and/or schools/districts.
Advertisements

LINDSAY CLARE MATSUMURA HELEN GARNIER BRIAN JUNKER LAUREN RESNICK DONNA DIPRIMA BICKEL June 30, 2010 Institute of Educational Sciences Conference Evidence.
Pennsylvania’s Continuous Improvement Process. Understanding AYP How much do you know about AYP?
Constructing the Foundations of Capacity Building An Activity Theory Analysis of the English in Action Baseline Studies Jan Rae and Adrian Kirkwood.
A Look at ESL History of the English language Current users of English What is “English as a Second Language?” ESL in the classroom Misconceptions The.
Alignment of Teacher Evaluation to the School Improvement Process Dr. Kathleen M. Smith Almost Former Director of the Office Of School Improvement Retiring.
FAMU ASSESSMENT PLAN PhD Degree Program in Entomology Dr. Lambert Kanga / CESTA.
The Impact of Immersion in a Local Research Problem on Technology Skills and Use CENTRAL WASHINGTON UNIVERSITY PREPARING TOMORROW’S TEACHERS TO USE TECHNOLOGY.
Good teaching, good teachers and comparative analysis Fernando Reimers.
Meeting the Needs of English Learners With Reading Difficulties Through a Multitiered Instructional Framework OSEP Project Directors’ Meeting July 2014.
Grade 12 Subject Specific Ministry Training Sessions
E NGLISH L ANGUAGE L EARNERS Diverse Learners Spotlight Presentation University of New England By: Erin Dilla.
Assessment in Language Teaching: part 2 Today’s # 24.
Continuing dominance of “language of instruction” debate.
INTRODUCTION.- PROGRAM EVALUATION
The Impact of a Faculty Learning Community Approach on Pre-Service Teachers’ English Learner Pedagogy Michael P. Alfano, John Zack, Mary E. Yakimowski,
+ Hybrid Roles in Your School If not now, then when?
Foreign language and English as a Second Language: Getting to the Common Core of Communication. Are we there yet? Marisol Marcin
From Qualitative to Quantitative Menken, K, & Tatyana, K. (2009) The long-term impact of subtractive schooling in the educational experiences of secondary.
ESL Phases & ESL Scale Curriculum Corporation 1994.
SIOP: Sheltered Instruction Observation Protocol Dr. Kelly Bikle Winter 2007.
Creating Assessments with English Language Learners in Mind In this module we will examine: Who are English Language Learners (ELL) and how are they identified?
FACT OVERVIEW. 22 Inquiry Focus and Number /Year Program Level Decision  CONTEXT FOR TEACHING Class, School, District, and Community Conversation Guides.
The Effects of Professional Learning Communities on Student Achivement Erin N. Fyffe School of Teacher Education, Western Kentucky University Methods and.
1 / 27 California Educational Research Association 88 th Annual Conference Formative Assessment: Implications for Student Learning San Francisco, CA November.
Innovative Teaching and Learning MOVING FROM THEORY TO ACTION 6 th June 2012.
Food Safety Professional Development for Early Childhood Educators Evaluation Plan.
How can teachers be supported to provide quality learning in emergency and conflict situations? Voices of teachers in South Sudan By John Lujang Wani Deputy.
Learnings from Classroom Connections Findings and Conclusions from Two Studies on the Statewide Laptop Initiative Dr. Wade Pogany – South Dakota DOE –
In METRO CENTRAL EDUCATION DISTRICT An Intervention of the Literacy and Numeracy Strategy ( ) By Faith Engel.
The Effects of Authentic Audience on ESL Writers: A Task-Based, Computer-Mediated Approach By Julian Chen & Kimberly Brown.
Aligning Interventions with Core How to meet student needs without creating curricular chaos.
National tests in Norway – a contested standard in education? Elisabeth Hovdhaugen, Department of Education, University of Oslo/NIFU Idunn Seland, NIFU,
NCATE Standard 3: Field Experiences & Clinical Practice Monica Y. Minor, NCATE Jeri A. Carroll, BOE Chair Professor, Wichita State University.
Findings from the Perceptions of Success Inventory for Beginning Teachers Northeast Collaborative July 10, 2007 Presented by: Alan Reiman Kristen Corbell.
Assessment of an Arts-Based Education Program: Strategies and Considerations Noelle C. Griffin Loyola Marymount University and CRESST CRESST Annual Conference.
Davis Junior High Action Plan English Department Tier II Indicator: Writing 2010 – 2011.
Diana Boland Rebekah Gerard Philip Dixon May 2013.
The Effects of Authentic Audience on ESL Writers: A Task-Based, Computer-Mediated Approach By Julian Chen & Kimberly Brown.
WORKING TOGETHER TO IMPROVE SCIENCE EDUCATION PRESENTED BY GIBSON & ASSOCIATES A CALIFORNIA MATH AND SCIENCE PARTNERSHIP RESEARCH GRANT WISE II Evaluation.
MAP the Way to Success in Math: A Hybridization of Tutoring and SI Support Evin Deschamps Northern Arizona University Student Learning Centers.
NCATE STANDARD I STATUS REPORT  Hyacinth E. Findlay  March 1, 2007.
An Introduction to Formative Assessment as a useful support for teaching and learning.
Section 1. Introduction Orientation to Virginia’s QRIS.
Maine Department of Education Maine Reading First Course Session #1 Introduction to Reading First.
The Action Research of the Teaching Effectiveness of Native English Teacher in BSTWLMC.
An Assessment of the Readiness of a Tertiary Healthcare Organization in Saudi Arabia, in Adopting Effective Online Staff Development Programs Adnan D.
By: HANIM MOHAMED (MP ) SITI FATIMAH ZAINI (MP091421)
The Literacy and Numeracy Secretariat Le Secrétariat de la littératie et de la numératie October – octobre 2007 The School Effectiveness Framework A Collegial.
OKLAHOMA EARLY READING FIRST What We Are Learning Priscilla Griffith University of Oklahoma Go Sooners!
Where Do You Stand? Using Data to Size Up Your School’s Progress Michael C. McKenna University of Virginia.
The School Effectiveness Framework
Writing Workshop with ELLs in mainstream first grade classes An Effective pedagogical practice for Few Good teachers? A Qualitative Study Jayne Sherman.
The Literacy and Numeracy Secretariat Le Secrétariat de la littératie et de la numératie October – octobre 2007 The School Effectiveness Framework A Collegial.
AUTHOR: NADIRAN TANYELI PRESENTER: SAMANTHA INSTRUCTOR: KATE CHEN DATE: MARCH 10, 2010 The Efficiency of Online English Language Instruction on Students’
Collaboration & Integrated Content-Based Instruction.
The effect of teachers' staff development in the use of higher-order questioning strategies on third grade students' rubric science assessment performance.
Purpose of Teacher Evaluation and Observation Minnesota Teacher Evaluation Requirements Develop, improve and support qualified teachers and effective.
Interim report from the ELFE 2 study visits in Slovenia, Poland and Latvia: analysis of practices and experiences in schools and Teacher Education Institutions.
CONNECT WITH CAEP | | Measures of Teacher Impact on P-12 Students Stevie Chepko, Sr. VP for Accreditation.
“What Works” Study for Adult ESL Literacy Students Conducted by: American Institute for Research Presented at the 2004 CASAS National Summer Institute.
PLCs Professional Learning Communities Staff PD. Professional Learning Committees The purpose of our PLCs includes but is not limited to: teacher collaborationNOT-
Case Study of the TOEFL iBT Preparation Course: Teacher’s perspective Jie Chen UWO.
CaMSP Science Assessment Webinar Public Works, Inc. Sharing Lessons Learned in the Development and Use of Science Assessments for CaMSP Teachers and Students.
Pre-Referral to Special Education: Considerations
Merit & Incentive Pay Based on High Stakes Testing
Melanie Taylor Horizon Research, Inc.
Performance Indicator F: Performance Indicator G
PLCs Professional Learning Communities Staff PD
K-2 Teaching Artist Project:
Presentation transcript:

The Added Value and Financial Savings of Contextually-Relevant Assessments Paul Gibbs, Anu Sachdev & Whitney Szmodis Abstract Researchers assessed 260 students to determine language and vocabulary skills using the LAS-O Assessment Survey developed in the United States by McGraw-Hill publishing. Students in 4 th, 5 th, 6 th, and 8 th grades at Caring for Cambodia (CFC) schools, a nongovernmental organization located in Siem Reap, Cambodia, were tested to determine both language performance in English and also to examine the cultural and contextual relevance of the LAS-O assessment to the student’s learning environments. As the team visited classrooms, conducted teacher observations, and administered the LAS-O, the misfit between this expensive exam and the school’s learning goals became clear. Results indicated a lack of continuity between the concepts tested in the LAS-O assessment and the lessons taught during English instruction in CFC schools. Additionally, the team found that students in CFC schools performed at varied levels on the LAS-O, both within schools and across the sample, leading school administrators to a lack of confidence in the test’s validity. Some results proved informative, but the lack of connection between the test and the instructional program led to uncertainty as to which program components led to the observed effects, both positive and negative: performance on the listening section of the LAS- O was significantly higher across the sample than vocabulary scores; students at one school (Kong Much School) scored twice as high on the LAS-O than their counterparts at another school (Aranh Primary School). While teacher interviews and classroom observations led the researchers to tentatively attribute some of the LAS-O results to teacher, student population, class size, and gender, better alignment between the classroom and the test is needed to interpret variations in assessment results. These team’s research implies the need to create a valid and reliable assessment tool that recognizes the contextual relevance of the targeted population. In the next phase of the project, the team will create its own assessment to fill this need. Results Methods A mixed methods approach was used in the data collection and analysis. Participants in the program include five Cambodian English teachers in five schools, and 260 randomly-selected 4 th, 6 th, and 8 th grade students in those schools. The team employed a pragmatic, sequential mixed-methods design (Johnson & Onwuegbuzie, 2004; Tashakkori & Teddlie, 2010) which combines qualitative analysis of teacher methodologies with pre/post quantitative language proficiency measures of both the students and teachers to determine the interactive effects of these data. Teacher methodologies are assessed by team-designed teacher self-surveys and researcher observations. McGraw-Hill’s LAS-O is an oral assessment of English language fluency, developed in isolation from the Cambodian classroom context. CFC schools use the Let’s Go! Textbook series (Oxford University Press), and the LAS-O is not aligned to it in any way. In contrast, the team-developed instrument, Contextualized Oral Language Assessment (or “COLA”), will be an oral assessment developed on the basis of the team’s qualitative on-site teacher methodology study. Both the LAS-O and the COLA and are normed against native speaking populations. Background of the Study The use of standardized ESL assessments created by U.S. publishers is a common practice among schools. However, for many international schools, particularly those with limited funding, incompatibilities between mainstream tests and the schools’ own pedagogical values and goals may contribute to a lack of precision in testing. Often, acquiring the funding to administer these tests with sufficient levels of frequency can be challenging. Much international educational development happens on a small, grass-roots scale, through small voluntary groups and foundations working with limited resources and yet still seeking high-quality instruments to inform their practice. Our project aims to serve the broader educational development community by demystifying the process of assessment creation and providing an essential roadmap toward the development of affordable, relevant, quality ESL assessment. Facts  Unlike traditional Ministry of Education schools in Cambodia, where English language instruction begins in 7 th grade, schools partnering with CFC begin teaching English in 4 th grade.  This early language instruction is implemented in the hopes that students will build a strong foundation of English language skills before they enter secondary school.  The average class size in CFC schools is 45 (compared to 60 in non-CFC Ministry of Education schools).  English teachers employed by CFC to teach 4 th -6 th grades are not formally trained teachers but have ongoing professional development and weekly team meetings with the director of teaching training.  CFC uses the Let’s Go series for instruction in 4 th through 6 th grades.  English classes in Cambodia are required by the Ministry of Education. Conclusion CFC’s English program is a frontrunner in language programs in Cambodian primary schools. Many schools, both international and Ministry of Education schools, struggle to provide competitive salaries to qualified native or non-native English speakers, adversely impacting the quality of teaching and learning. CFC’s English teachers lack formal pedagogical training, and this deficit poses an obstacle to instructional effectiveness. Nevertheless, despite this challenge, CFC schools provide intensive, ongoing professional development in relevant and applicable teacher strategies for classroom instruction. These faculty development efforts should result in student learning gains, but, with the LAS-O, it is difficult to tell whether weaknesses are due to instructional methods or curricular deficiencies. Our research suggests the need for developing a contextually relevant assessment tool for CFC schools in order to properly assess teacher performance and student knowledge. By implementing a low-cost assessment which is connected to teaching materials and normed to a native speaking population, CFC schools will have the data needed to inform classroom practice and improve student learning.