The Changing Economics of Coal Case Study: Tata Mundra Justin Guay, World Bank Annual Meetings September 21 st, 2011.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

World Energy Outlook Dr. Fatih Birol IEA Chief Economist Brussels, 29 April 2014.

Advertisements

SHALE AND THE US ECONOMY Kathleen B. Cooper October 22, 2013.

…Message Box ( Arial, Font size 18 Bold) Presentation Title ( Arial, Font size 28 ) Date, Venue, etc..( Arial, Font size 18 ) Impact of Shortage of Coal.

Energy and the Pakistani Economy: An Expletory Analysis to 2035 Dr. Robert Looney Professor, Naval Postgraduate School Woodrow Wilson International Center.

1 Energy Systems Integration Otto Doering Professor Purdue University.

ETHANOL PRODUCTION IN SOUTH AFRICA.  World leader in agricultural processing, including ethanol  Looking to expand and diversify bioenergy product portfolio.

AAA Minerals Int’l China’s coal supply/demand and their impact on international coal market George Guanghua Liu AAA Minerals International.

© OECD/IEA POWER SECTOR OUTLOOK IN OECD COUNTRIES 28 May 2010 Roundtable: Russian Federal Tariff Service Ian Cronshaw, Head, Energy Diversification.

OIL PRICES In what has been defined as “The New Economy of oil”, oil prices in the past did not follow a steady trend, and the record shows a behavior.

© OECD/IEA NATURAL GAS MARKET REVIEW 2006 Towards a Global Gas Market TOWARDS A GLOBAL GAS MARKET APEx CONFERENCE, Seoul 31 October 2006 Session.

WORLD ENERGY INVESTMENT OUTLOOK

An overview of the Australian Mining Industry AMN, Thursday 10 October 2013.

Freight market and coal imports by India 4th International Conference on Coal market in India Nazneen Fatima Sr. Research Analyst 22.

Globalisation Effects on Singapore’s Trade

ITALIA E RUSSIA – FORO DI DIALOGO Vekselberg V. Marzo 2007.

Commodity Market Outlook WBFI Annual Meeting T. Randall Fortenbery Professor School of Economic Sciences Washington State University.

Cheap Affordable Coal? Case Study: Tata Mundra Justin Guay, World Bank AGM, 2013.

© OECD/IEA 2011 COAL AND CHINA’S CHOICES Jonathan Sinton China Program Manager International Energy Agency Washington, D.C., 12 January 2011.

Industrials Sector Jason Kraynak and Wade Guzdanski.

Indiana and Coal. Global electricity demand is expected to grow by 70% between 2010 and This is the equivalent to adding the population of U.S.,

UBS MLP Conference Las Vegas, Nevada September 18 & 19, 2008.

The China Factor in Coal Pricing – Implications for imported Coal in India 19 th November, 2012 Hotel Ashok, New Delhi Ashish Gupta, Associate Fellow,

Future Global Trends – Resource security: How Sovereign Wealth Funds will benefit.

Indonesia - The World’s Next Economic Power Chairul Tanjung Chairman of National Economic Committee (KEN) KOMITE EKONOMI NASIONAL REPUBLIK INDONESIA July.

Global Opportunities for Energy Security Presentation By R S Butola MD ONGC Videsh Limited.

The Future of Coal Hal Quinn President & CEO National Mining Association Annual State of the Energy Industry United States Energy Association January 18,

Natural Resource Partners L.P. RBC Capital Markets Energy Conference New York June 3, 2008.

1 9/15/2015 Gogita Todradze National Statistics Office of Georgia Institutional Arrangements for Energy Statistics in Georgia.

1 Status of and Outlook for Coal Supply and Demand in the U.S. Imagine West Virginia Spring 2010 Board of Governors Meeting April 13, 2010 Scott Sitzer.

Investor Meetings West Coast November 10-12, 2008.

Why consider other Energy options for SingaporeWhy consider other Energy options for Singapore? In electricity tariffs in Singapore went up by 21.

Natural Resource Partners L.P. SMH Capital Investor Growth Conference New York, NY November 8-9, 2007.

Financial Issues Affecting Energy Security Gail E. Tverberg – Oct. 26, 2012 – AES 2012.

Economic and Social Update April 2008 William E. Wallace, Lead Economist World Bank, Indonesia April 1, 2008.

Coal and Sustainable Development David Cain of Rio Tinto for the World Coal Institute UNECE Ad Hoc Group of Experts on Coal and Thermal.

Natural Resource Partners L.P. Wachovia Capital Markets 18 th Annual Nantucket Equity Conference Nantucket, MA June 26, 2008.

1 National Security Consequences of U.S. Oil Dependency Independent Task Force Report COUNCIL ON FOREIGN RELATIONS.

Development indicators Gianni Vaggi University of Pavia September 2013 On the causes of economic growth.

NS4054 Fall Term 2015 Coal Markets. Coal Markets: Overview Oxford Analytica, “Coal Market Will Stay Oversupplied” September 15, 2015 Seaborne thermal.

NS4054 “Japan, Southeast Asia, and Australia” Mikkal E. Herberg.

1 Office of the Chief Economist Global economic growth The outlook for the Australian resources sector Mark Cully APPEA Tax and Commercial Conference 29.

Report: Power Boilers, 2013 Update - Global Market Size, Average Pricing, Equipment Market Share and Competitive Landscape Analysis to 2020 Category: Energy.

© OECD/IEA 2010 A better energy future Dr. Fatih Birol IEA Chief Economist 19 September 2011.

International Gas Union Security of Supply; Another Perspective Ernesto A. López Anadón President of International Gas Union World Forum Regulation III.

1 Commodity price increases: causes, effects and policy responses G20 Conference on Commodity Price Volatility Istanbul, 13 th September 2011 Jonathan.

The Energy Issue America faces a major energy supply crisis over the next two decades. The failure to meet this challenge will threaten our nation's economic.

8 Must-Know Facts About The Swiss Time Piece Industry.

QUESTION 1 : THE PROSPECT OF THE MARKET AND RESPECTIVE SECTOR IN THE SHORT RUN AND LONG RUN From the Independent market research report by FROST & SULLIVAN:

© 2006, Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries 1 The Role of OPEC in Oil Market Stability presented by Mohammad Alipour-Jeddi Head, Petroleum.

1 Energy Security Global Issues Seminar Series November 8 th 2006.

Opportunities and Challenges Abraham Kim, Ph.D. Maureen & Mike Mansfield Center University of Montana Growing Energy Supply & Demand.

Overview of the Korean Economy September 2009 Joong Shik Lee Research Department The Bank of Korea.

ГММ -1( а ) Li Jianfei. By 2040, the world and, in particular, countries which have large and technologically advanced economies – such as the USA,

© 2016 Global Market Insights, Inc. USA. All Rights Reserved Gas Turbine Market Price, Packaging Trends, Industry Outlook & Forecast.

NS4960 Spring Term 2017 China: Shift Away from Coal

Future Energy Consumption: Economic Growth and Climate Policy

Primary energy and energy intensity Energy consumption growth.

NS4301 Summer Term 2015 China Devaluation: Implications for Africa

Asia’s Access to Energy: Challenges in the IOR

WHY INDIA? September 2004.

2-1 BAU Demand Atit Tippichai APERC Workshop at EWG 50

NS4960 Spring Term 2017 Coal Markets

European Power Markets: Performance and Prospects

Highlights of Energy Stats 2016 & Outlook 2035

NS4960 Spring Term 2018 China: Shift Away from Coal

Growth in primary energy and CO2 emissions Primary energy.

WV Energy Plan Public Hearing West Virginia Division of Energy

Title Why Invest In Vietnam: Key Economic Priorities And Foreign Investment Policy.

Global economic growth

Palm Oil Market Review and Outlook 2020

Presentation transcript:

The Changing Economics of Coal Case Study: Tata Mundra Justin Guay, World Bank Annual Meetings September 21 st, 2011

- Structural Drivers of Rising Coal Prices: oil prices, demand, and supply constraints - Coal Price Behaviour in Key Markets: Surging and volatile -The Fallout: Economically unviable power plants (Tata Mundra, Krishnapatnam) Overview

- Emerging Market Demand - Supply constraints - Oil Prices Why Coal Prices Are Rising

Source: IEA Coal Statistics 2011 Coal Consumption Growth Strong Coal Demand in Emerging Asian Markets

Stagnating Coal Production Source: Heinberg and Fridley, Nature 2010Source: IEA World Energy Outlook 2010

Spot Prices During 2008 Oil Price Shocks Source: US EIA The Price of Coal is Volatile

- In Key markets the price of coal rose saw 13% CAGR over the past decade - Chinese prices rose 15% CAGR - Export prices doubled from Coal Prices Are Rising in all Major Markets

Coal is Expensive The Price of Coal rose at a 13% CAGR Source: EIA Selected Steam Coal Prices Average CAGR 13%

Chinese Coal Prices The Price of Coal rose at a ~ 15% CAGR from

Newcastle Benchmark Coal Prices Internationally Traded Coal Doubled in Price from

Coal Production in Asian Marine Markets A 25% shortfall Provides Enormous Rent Seeking Opportunities

- Indian Import Vulnerability - Tata Electricity Impacts - Unviable Coastal Coal Plants The Fallout

Indian Vulnerability to Import Price Surges Source: Government of India Planning Commission

Source: EIA Indian Steam Coal Prices CAGR 4% Imported Coal Cost Premium CAGR 35% Indian Vulnerability to Import Price Surges

Tata Plant Economics Coal Price Impact on Electricity Prices 20-60% Rise in Electricity Prices O&M Fuel Costs

Unviable Coastal Coal Plants 4 GW Tata Mundra UMPP: - Faces losses of 270% - Forced to double rates charged to consumers - Even with requested price revision project unviable for at least the next five years. - Tata CEO on whether Mundra is viable at the moment: “ No. At this moment, we have tremendous impact due to imported coal on Mundra because the price of coal has increased multi- fold….Indonesia will not change its stance for Tata Power or for any other company…In fact, all the three countries exporting coal have changed rules in recent times. South Africa, Australia and Indonesia are in sync as far as exporting coal is concerned.” 4 GW Krishnapatnam UMPP: Construction halted immediately after Indonesian price revision. $30 billion exposure to coal projects for Indian Banking Industry. Of this - 14 GW of projects face imported coal risk

Thank you Justin Guay, World Bank Annual Meetings September 21 st, 2011