Center for Energy and Environment Cost Effectiveness Determination & Benefits and Resources Russ Landry, PE, LEED® AP Center for Energy and Environment.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

4 basic approaches to determining energy efficiency benefits (savings) 1.Stipulated or deemed savings 2.Individual Building Metering – Measurement and.

Advertisements

1 Conservation Program Cost-Effectiveness Tests Presentation to the: Florida Public Service Commission Workshop on Energy Efficiency Initiatives November.

ENERGY PERFORMANCE CONTRACTS Field Office Staff Training November 17, 2010 Tedd T. Termunde, P.A Joseph E. Nemedi, F.A.

Opportunities to Collaborate with Electric Utilities on Energy Efficient Vending Machines.

1/14 Policies/Programmes to Promote the Development of ESCO 5 March, 2012 APERC Workshop, Kuala Lumpur Bing-Chwen Yang Team Leader Asia Pacific Energy.

SPA Control A systematic process to manage the SPA process JIGSAW SYSTEMS INC.

State Incentives for Energy Efficiency Commercial and Industrial New Jersey Board of Public Utilities Office of Clean Energy Mona L. Mosser Bureau of Energy.

Green Building – Green Business Devin Saylor, LEED ® AP Cost and benefits of green building in Bulgaria.

TRP Chapter Chapter 4.2 Waste minimisation.

System Reliability Procurement: Non-wires Alternatives in Rhode Island Tim Roughan National Grid.

Upstate Energy Expo 2010 NYSERDA Program Overview March 30, 2010 Cheryl Glanton, Project Manager.

SAINT PAUL SUSTAINABLE BUILDING POLICY Saint Paul Sustainable Building Policy Training Module Three Building energy requirements.

Genesis Solar Module Brochure ™

Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA): Overview

1 Energy Efficiency and Conservation in Thailand Department of Alternative Energy Development and Efficiency (DEDE) Ministry of Energy 6 th January 2005.

1 Ex Ante Review of the SBD Program Energy Division Staff and Contractors Energy Efficiency Industrial/Agricultural Programs and Portfolio Forecasting.

PTCS Service Provider Review 0 Background RTF assumed responsibility for maintaining PTCS specifications in March 2003  Developed PTCS Service Provider.

Module 4: Association Personnel – The Executive Director Presented by the Southern Early Childhood Association.

1 SB 2030 Project Advisory Group June, 2009 Introduction and Overview John Carmody, CSBR Development of a Building Energy Benchmarking Protocol Tom McDougall.

Phoenix Convention Center Phoenix, Arizona Introduction to UESC Webinar Project Financing UESC Basics: Project Financing Through your Utility Julia Kelley.

Pg. 1 Energy Intelligence Program Monitor your industrial facility and save energy! Tool that provides real-time feedback to help you manage energy in.

DTE Energy Commercial & Industrial Energy Optimization Program Energy Efficient, Sustainable Detroit DTE Energy Headquarters December 9, 2010.

Performance Metrics for Weatherization UGI LIURP Evaluation Yvette Belfort Jackie Berger ACI Home Performance Conference April 30, 2014.

Lisa F. | May 20, 2014 Introduction to Lighting Incentives & Process for Medium/Large Customers.

Department of Education 1. Improving Transparency & Accountability  President tasked ED to provide relevant information to students and families to help.

UESC Project Implementation Construction & Installation ä Issue TO for construction ä The pre-construction meeting ä Review/accept final construction package.

OPA Office Professionals Assist, LLP Contracts, Proposals and Estimating.

0 0 Six Sigma – Financial Overview. 1 1 Roles and Responsibilities of the Finance Support Team Policy Setting – Define Savings/Benefits – Provide tools.

1 Why Choose Solar? Solar costs are coming down Solar panels are getting better and better Electricity costs are rising Solar panels last +25 years.

April, 2002Energy Audits1 April, 2002 Ryan Stroupe, Pacific Energy Center DeAnza College: ES 76 Energy Reliability and Your Organization Energy Auditing.

“Do Green” Two Options: Prescriptive Custom Prescriptive- -Must be running a MODULATING ROTARY SCREW AIR COMPRESSOR -Must be 75 Horsepower or Less Custom-

Arizona Early Intervention Program IDEA 2011 Requirements -Screening-

Administrative Review & Restructuring. 1 The President’s Charge Review administrative organization and delivery of administrative services at all levels.

1 DVBE Incentive Workshop To meet or exceed the 3% DVBE goal in State contracting.

Accounting & Financial Analysis 1 Lecture 8 Budgets.

Including a Water Factor for ENERGY STAR Qualified Clothes Washers Tony Gregg, P.E. Water Conservation Program City of Austin.

Program Overview Public Buildings Enhanced Energy Efficiency Program (PBEEEP) This program was made possible with funding from the U.S. Department of Energy.

Project Development Meet with customer and establish budget and required ROI Gather utility data and operational information Feasibility study/high level.

Serves Local Distribution Companies Manages Small Business Lighting for 18 LDCs Largest evaluator of Retrofit Programs - 26 LDCs TRC tool and support.

Center for Energy and Environment Development of Utilities Conservation Programs and Cost Effective Analysis Sheldon Strom Russ Landry, PE, LEED® AP Executive.

Self-Directed Energy Contracting Saving Your Buildings and Your Money.

Summary of the current California Public Utilities Commission Energy Efficiency Proceeding (R ) Coordination with UC Davis Center for Water and.

Comparison of CA Evaluation Protocols, CA Framework, IPMVP and CPUC Policy Manual* A preface to group discussion *In terms of how they define.

Energy Services Harsha Holalu Ramakrishna Energy Extension Specialist Department of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering.

Energy Project M&V: Reports that Add Value October 27, 2015.

Slide 1 B O N N E V I L L E P O W E R A D M I N I S T R A T I O N Presented by: Todd Amundson, BPA Jane Peters, research into action Ryan Fedie, BPA Update.

B O N N E V I L L E P O W E R A D M I N I S T R A T I O N Developed by Navigant Research Team Final: 11/22/15 Agricultural Programs’ Logic Model.

AIE Task Force Energy Services Wednesday 27 April 2011.

Procurement to Pay (P2P) Initiative March 2014 “Supporting and Enabling Strategic Sourcing”

Energy Efficiency Forum State of California/Investor Owned Utility Partnership Program Date: September 27, Partnership. A Unique Opportunity.

Barriers to Implementing Energy Efficiency at Small and Rural Utilities Jennifer Anziano and Ryan Firestone August 19, 2015.

Energy Efficiency Update Before the Senate Energy, Utilities & Communications Committee Part 2 May 17, 2011 – State Capitol Robin Smutny-Jones Assistant.

DISPATCHING DIRECT USE Achieving Greenhouse Gas Reductions & Energy Savings.

1 The Power to Make a Difference Sustainable Energy Fund Workshop Bethlehem, PA March 23, 2012 Information in this presentation subject to change.

Office of Major Project Development (OMPD) Overview November 2015.

Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of BGE’s DSM Programs Marshall Keneipp, PE Summit Blue Consulting, LLC Prepared for: Energy Efficiency and Conservation Stakeholders.

Demand-side Management (DSM) as a Resource Midwest Energy Policy Conference October 2015 Bill Grant, Deputy Commissioner Division of Energy Resources.

CenterPoint Energy Proprietary and Confidential Information Eric Johansen, PE CenterPoint Energy’s Conservation Improvement Programs January 2016.

Appending appending is a pre-requisite for developing marketing success; it creates multi-channel touch indicate connect to customers.

 ENERGY. EFFICIENCY. EASY SIMPLIFYING & ACCELERATING REVENUE GENERATION FROM ENERGY EFFICIENCY SUSTAINABLE ENERGY FUND 2 ND ANNUAL ENERGY SERVICE PROVIDER.

1 W-E Calculator 2.0 Workshop Experience Implementing the W-E Calculator Jill Kjellsson Program Manager – Industrial, Ag and Water April 6,

1 Detailed EM&V Approach for each of BGE’s Proposed Conservation Programs January 10, 2008.

BLACK HILLS ENERGY 2016 Energy Efficiency Portfolio Annual Results Overview December 8, :00am – 12:00pm MST Mark James – Energy Efficiency Program.

NC AWWA-WEA 97th Annual Conference

Utah Water Conservation Forum – 5/12/2017

Energy Affordability Policies and Programs in New York State

PROJECT DELIVERY METHODS

Systems Analysis and Design

Technology Maintenance

Presentation transcript:

Center for Energy and Environment Cost Effectiveness Determination & Benefits and Resources Russ Landry, PE, LEED® AP Center for Energy and Environment 212 North 3rd Ave, Suite 560 Minneapolis, MN November 12, 2010

Center for Energy and Environment November 12, 2010 Cost-Effectiveness for SB2030 Projects SB2030 Legislation Standard “…cost-effective based upon established practices used in evaluating utility conservation improvement programs [CIP programs].” Complicated set of CIP program cost- effectiveness calculations How to be Sure Your Project is Cost- Effective?

Center for Energy and Environment November 12, 2010 Ensuring Cost-Effective SB2030 Projects SB2030 Program Team Review for Omission of Common Cost-Effective Measures Approve Variance Where Appropriate Project Design & Development Team Design Energy Efficient Building with Reasonable Cost-Effective Upgrades If SB2030 not Achieved for Bonded Project, Use Cost-Effectiveness Variance Procedure SB2030 Program Team Set standard at Generally Achievable Level Defined Simplified Cost-Effectiveness Calculations for Projects

Center for Energy and Environment November 12, 2010 SB2030 Program Team Development of Cost-Effectivenss Safeguards Confirmed Standards Can be Achieved Cost- Effectively for a Variety of Projects Simplified Project Cost-Effectiveness Calc Performed Analysis of Wide Variety of Assumptions & CIP Cost-Effectiveness Tests Defined Simplified Variance Eligibility at a Conservative Level  Does Not Force “Non-Cost Effective” Upgrades  Allows Variances for Some “Cost-Effective” Upgrades Work with Project Teams Throughout Design  Reality Check on Cost-Effectiveness of Measures  To Avoid Surprises

Center for Energy and Environment November 12, 2010 Project Team Variance Procedures for State Bonded Projects If Design to Achieve SB2030 Standard is Suspected of Not Being Cost-Effective, Look at Questionable Upgrades Building energy simulations for savings Project-specific cost estimates from: -Contrator(s)-Project engineer -Project architect-Third-party estimator Apply for Variance Where Upgrade Simple Paybacks are >15 Years (Before Rebates) Follow calculation procedures defined in downloadable Calculation of Cost-Effectiveness for Variance Application (E1C) Submit documentation via the tracking tool

Center for Energy and Environment November 12, 2010 Questions on SB2030 Cost-Effectiveness Safeguards?? SB2030 Program Team Review for Omission of Common Cost-Effective Measures Approve Variance Where Appropriate Project Design & Development Team Design Energy Efficient Building with Reasonable Cost-Effective Upgrades If SB2030 not Achieved for Bonded Project, Use Cost-Effectiveness Variance Procedure SB2030 Program Team Set standard at Generally Achievable Level Defined Simplified Cost-Effectiveness Calculations for Projects

Center for Energy and Environment November 12, 2010 Benefits and Resources for SB2030 Project Teams Developer Questions How do we reach SB2030 Standard? How do we pay for added design fees? How do we pay for higher captial costs? How do simulations get done?

Center for Energy and Environment November 12, 2010 Benefits & Resources for SB2030 Project Teams SB2030 Program Team  Limited 3 rd Party Check on Design Approach with Building Strategy Checklist (E1D)  Coordination with Utility Program Support Utility CIP Program Support  Design Assistance Programs  Incentives for Installation of Upgrades

Center for Energy and Environment November 12, 2010 Current Utility Program Support Design Assistance Programs Assistance with Simulations  Full service or financial support for your consultant  Evaluate design alternatives early on  Document final design performance Support for Added Design Costs Financial Incentives for Improvements Prescriptive for Specific Measures Based on Energy/Demand Savings Calculated for a Specific Project

Center for Energy and Environment November 12, 2010 Potential Future Utility Program Support Simplified Small Building Approach Optional prescriptive approach Simplified energy performance calculators as alternative to full simulations Bonus Rebates Tied to Achievement of SB2030 Standards Support for Commissioning and/or Ongoing Building Operations

Center for Energy and Environment November 12, 2010 Getting Utility Support for a Project Get in Touch with Local Utilities to Ask What standard programs do they have? What additional custom services and rebates can they provide? Why not more? SB2030 Program Team Can Help Coordinate and Encourage Utility Support Lead team contact:Russ Landry of CEE