Technology to Supply Cellulosic Ethanol and “Green” Electricity April 15, 2010.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
An Institute of Local and Global Consequence Future of Biofuels in Alabama Larry Fillmer Auburn University.
Advertisements

BIOENERGY.
A Potentially Valuable Component of Texas Bioenergy Projects
Heating with Biomass Timothy A. Volk, SUNY ESF SUNY Global Center February 8, 2013.
Energy Efficiency & Renewable Energyeere.energy.gov 1 Program Name or Ancillary Texteere.energy.gov The Future of Biomass-Based Energy: The DOE Perspective.
Progressive 15 Burlington, Colorado April 17, 2009 Bob Mailander.
SamoaFiber Bio Fuel Concepts March Introduction Technology exists and is producing low cost alternative fuels from biomass. Technology exists and.
Growing Energy How Biofuels Can Help End America’s Oil Dependence Jeff Fiedler Natural Resources Defense Council March 22, 2005.
VT Department of Forests, Parks & Recreation Wood Energy in Vermont January 2005 VT Department of Forests, Parks & Recreation.
DynaMotive Energy Systems November 2002 Green Fuels to the World.
Socio-Economic Impacts of U.S. Ethanol Bruce A. Babcock Center for Agricultural and Rural Development Iowa State University.
1. 2 The Problem 75% of our energy expenditures leave the state, versus growing jobs, incomes and revenues here at home. Indiana already imports essentially.
Environmental Sustainability of Biofuel Crops Bill Chism David Widawsky Office of Policy, Economics and Innovation.
Risk Assessment and Economics of Forest Biorefinery Concepts USDA Forest Service Forest Products Laboratory Madison, Wisconsin.
Steven Jay Mueller, President International WoodFuels
Renewable Fuels in Minnesota Commissioner Gene Hugoson.
Economic Models of Biofuels and Policy Analysis John Miranowski,* Professor of Economics Iowa State University *With Alicia Rosburg, Research Assistant.
The New World of Biofuels: Implications for Agriculture and Energy Keith Collins, Chief Economist, USDA EIA Energy Outlook, Modeling, and Data Conference.
Bio-Fuels Project & Industry Introduction Dr. Dawne Martin College of Business July 25, 2012.
Biomass, Biofuels and Hydrogen Sectors in Context of SEDS
Cellulosic Ethanol In-Chul Hwang. What is Cellulosic Ethanol? Ethanol made from cellulosic biomass which Ethanol made from cellulosic biomass which comprises.
Future of the Bioeconomy and Biofuels: Overview, Industry, and Agriculture? Dan Otto Chad Hart John A. Miranowski Iowa State University.
Future U.S. Biofuels and Biomass Demand – Uncertainty Reigns Wally Tyner Purdue University January 25, 2011.
World Feed and Food Supply and Demand Governors’ Agriculture, Energy, and Sustainability Roundtable Governors’ Biofuels Coalition Washington, DC January.
Renewable Energies for Transportation, Electricity and Energy Storage Technologies (Round Table 3) U.S. Policies and Programs John P. Millhone Representing.
Colorado’s Clean Energy Research Cluster: COLORADO ENERGY RESEARCH COLLABORATORY A research collaboration of National Renewable Energy Laboratory Colorado.
The Long-Run Impact of Corn-Based Ethanol on the Grain, Oilseed, and Livestock Sectors: A Preliminary Assessment Bruce A. Babcock Center for Agricultural.
US Renewable Energy Markets: Financial Perspective By Michael D. Ware Advance Capital Markets, Inc. Washington Council of Governments Washington, DC June.
2011 Advanced Biofuels Leadership Conference Virent Energy Systems Lee Edwards, CEO.
ABFC2015 New Orleans, LA – June 9, 2015 Sorghum: An established crop for sustainable, global production.
The Energy Construct Ben Cipiti May 1, 2008 Mid-Town Brews.
Sustainability and Renewable Energy What’s our role?
Resource Planning Georgia Power’s Diverse Plan to Meet Georgia’s Energy Needs AWMA Fall 2010 Conference October 7, 2010 Jeff Burleson Director of Resource.
Biomass Utilization The South’s Industry of the Future Dr Liam E. Leightley FUTURE TRENDS FOR FORESTRY MS SAF ANNUAL MEETING, JACKSON, MARCH 2005.
The Ethanol Boom Colin Carter University of California, Davis Oct 11, 2007.
Economics of Cellulosic Ethanol Production Marie Walsh, Burt English, Daniel de la Torre Ugarte, Kim Jensen, Richard Nelson SAEA Annual Meeting Mobile,
“Growing Biodiesel in Bluegrass Fields”. Background “The American economy depends on petroleum for transportation, which has created energy security concerns,
1Managed by UT-Battelle for the Department of Energy Biofuels in the USA Dennis Ojima.
Liberalization of Trade in Biofuels: Implications for GHG Emissions and Social Welfare Xiaoguang Chen Madhu Khanna Hayri Önal University of Illinois at.
Energy Group Khoa Nguyen Brian Masters Elena Jaimes Zach Walker Charise Frias.
1 Land in: Other Uses In Transition In Switchgrass Crop Lifetime Net SG Addition Of Acres Acres in Switchgrass Yield from Ag R&D Ave Yield in Established.
Licensing Cellulosic Biofuel Technology Today Coskata: Accelerating to Commercialization Wes Bolsen CMO & VP, Government Affairs Coskata, Inc.
Creating and Sustaining Clean Energy Markets Sustainable Energy Fund Energy Service Provider Conference Hershey, PA January 29, 2011.
In the Northwest Martin Tobias CEO & Chairman, Imperium Renewables Biofuels.
Potential for Biomass Energy Development in South Carolina Tim Adams Resource Development Director South Carolina Forestry Commission.
Office of the Chief Economist Office of Energy Policy and New Uses National Agricultural Credit Committee Harry S. Baumes Associate Director Office of.
Key Drivers in the Biofuels Picture for the Near Future Wally Tyner.
First and Second Generation Biofuels: Economic and Policy Issues Wally Tyner With Input from Craig Rismiller, Daniela Viteri, Sarah Brechbill, David Perkis,
4 Corners Biocarbon Alliance Sustainable carbon and energy from biorenewables Production Processing Utilization Environmental and Economic Assessment Education.
Madhu Khanna Department of Agricultural and Consumer Economics
Extension and Outreach/Department of Economics Economics of Ethanol Production: Iowa’s Strengths and Weaknesses Deerfield Retirement Center Urbandale,
2005 OBP Bi-Annual Peer Review Fran Ferraro Merrick & Company Sealaska Corporation Southeast Alaska Ethanol Project Integrated Biorefinery Session November.
Bioenergy: Where We Are and Where We Should Be Daniel G. De La Torre Ugarte Chad M. Hellwinckel.
Forest Knowledge Know-how Well-being Luke’s and VTT’s joint research and innovation programme 2012–2016.
Department of Economics Biofuel Economics Intensive Program in Biorenewables Ames, Iowa June 9, 2009 Chad Hart Assistant Professor/Grain Markets Specialist.
WGA TRANSPORTATION FUELS FOR THE FUTURE INITIATIVE Biofuel Report Summary Biofuels Team - David Terry Transportation Fuels for the Future Workshop Denver,
The Economics of Alternative Biomass Collection Systems David Ripplinger Transportation Research Forum March 14,
Sustainable Aviation Biofuels Workshop Georgia Tech: H. Milton Stewart School of Industrial Systems & Engineering, December 3, 2015.
Tim Maker, Senior Program Director Biomass Energy Resource Center ENSURING FOREST SUSTAINABILITY IN THE DEVELOPMENT OF WOOD BIOENERGY IN THE US Pocantico.
Logistical Efficiency with Dedicated Energy Crops
Bioenergy Supply, Land Use, and Environmental Implications
Session 4: Biofuels: How Feasible Are Large-Scale Goals for Biofuel Penetration in the US and Canada? Ken Andrasko, EPA Session Objectives: Gauge.
Biofuel Demand Projections In the Annual Energy Outlook
Second Generation Biofuels in India – Relevance and Status
Kelly Zering Dept. of Agricultural and Resource Economics
Associate Professor/Crop Markets Specialist
DuPont Biofuels: Building a Sustainable Future
Beyond Ethanol Siouxland Bankers Meeting Storm Lake, Iowa
Presentation transcript:

Technology to Supply Cellulosic Ethanol and “Green” Electricity April 15, 2010

2 Reserve Space for “Tracking” Contents Or Company Logo Company logo OUTLINE  Why biofuels? Drivers Southeast US advantages  Starting up a company Georgia Tech ATDC/Venture Lab Valley of Death  Discussion Fact vs Fiction IMHO If I were King

3 Reserve Space for “Tracking” Contents Or Company Logo Company logo UNITED STATES ENERGY SOURCES  2008 Data

4 Reserve Space for “Tracking” Contents Or Company Logo Company logo IEA – WORLD ENERGY OUTLOOK 2008

5 Reserve Space for “Tracking” Contents Or Company Logo Company logo DECLINING OIL PRODUCTION - CANTARELL

6 Reserve Space for “Tracking” Contents Or Company Logo Company logo KEY GLOBAL ENERGY CHALLENGES  Oil Production Decline Rate  Oil Price Volatility -OPEC/National Oil Companies -Lack of Reliable Data  Global Rate of Investment in Oil Production  Scale of Carbon Solutions  Cost of Usable Energy Storage

7 Reserve Space for “Tracking” Contents Or Company Logo Company logo KEY ENERGY CHALLENGES FOR RENEWABLES  Scale  High Cost  Infrastructure Barriers Capital/Financing/Lag Time NIMBY  Flexibility Limitations Wind, Solar are Intermittent Energy Storage Technology Limits Inefficient Distribution Systems  Sustainability Problems & Unintended Consequences

8 Reserve Space for “Tracking” Contents Or Company Logo Company logo KEY FACTORS FOR SUCCESSFUL BIOFUELS DEVELOPMENT  Scale – A High Impact Solution  Feedstock – Readily Available with Predictable Costs  Low Cost – Compared to Gasoline  Infrastructure – Use Existing or Offer Alternate, Low Cost Option  Locale – Win-Win Relationships  Policy – Mandates for Renewables, High Greenhouse Gas Reduction

9 Reserve Space for “Tracking” Contents Or Company Logo Company logo MASSIVE SUSTAINABLE PINE RESOURCE  Southeastern United States has 192 Million Acres of Timberland  54 % of the total area  88% is Privately Owned  463 Million tons of Small Diameter Softwood in Forest Inventory USDA FOREST SERVICE SOUTHERN RESEARCH STATION Forest Inventory and Analysis Sources: USDA Forest Service,2007 Map Maker 2.1. For Information Visit: Produced July18, 2007.Author Spatial Data Services All Live Merchantable Softwood Tree Biomass Green Tons per Acre of Timberland >35 Tons per acre

10 Reserve Space for “Tracking” Contents Or Company Logo Company logo PHOTOSYNTHESIS STORES ENERGY IN BIOMASS AS CARBOHYDRATES

11 Reserve Space for “Tracking” Contents Or Company Logo Company logo PINE HAS BEST ETHANOL YIELD

12 Reserve Space for “Tracking” Contents Or Company Logo Company logo CELLULOSE – POLYMERS OF GLUCOSE

13 Reserve Space for “Tracking” Contents Or Company Logo Company logo SOUTHERN PINE WOODCHIPS TO ETHANOL  Enzymatic Hydrolysis/Sugar Platform  Power Generation from Lignin Fuel

14 Reserve Space for “Tracking” Contents Or Company Logo Company logo SCALE UP TO COMMERCIAL SIZE PLANT Lab Scale Pilot Operation Demonstration Plant Commercial Plant 100,000 Gal 2,500,000 Gal 56,000,000 Gal Annual Production Proof of Concept TechnologyIntegration Prove Economics/ Optimize Optimize & Drive Costs Lower

15 Reserve Space for “Tracking” Contents Or Company Logo Company logo COMPETITION Biofuels - Second generation Biochemical (Carbohydrate conversion; C6, C5)

16 Reserve Space for “Tracking” Contents Or Company Logo Company logo COMPETITION  Biofuels - Second generation Thermochemical (Syn gas + conversion; Pyrolysis bio-oil) Other

17 Reserve Space for “Tracking” Contents Or Company Logo Company logo COMPANY FACTS  Formed in May 2005 anticipating high growth from energy security & environmental policy changes  Founders have deep industry and entrepreneurial experience  Georgia Tech affiliated company; licensing technology from Georgia Tech and The University of Georgia General Information Funding Information   Prior Funding Rounds: $1.325 million common stock $200,000 state grants   Current Funding from Strategic Partners In Progress

18 Reserve Space for “Tracking” Contents Or Company Logo Company logo SELECTING A PATHWAY  Southern Pine Feedstock Available Year Round at Massive ScaleAvailable Year Round at Massive Scale Low, Predictable CostsLow, Predictable Costs Existing InfrastructureExisting Infrastructure SustainableSustainable  Enzymatic Hydrolysis Process Technology Cellulosic Ethanol & Green ElectricityCellulosic Ethanol & Green Electricity Scale-up Advantages with PineScale-up Advantages with Pine Efficient Approach with Woody BiomassEfficient Approach with Woody Biomass 90+ % Greenhouse Gas Reduction90+ % Greenhouse Gas Reduction

19 Reserve Space for “Tracking” Contents Or Company Logo Company logo MARKETS  Customers Area fuel distributors – Off-take contracts -Chevron, Shell, Marathon, etc. -RaceTrac, QuickTrip, etc.  Distribution Delivery via tank truck to customer area distribution terminal Superior logistics vs. corn ethanol Mandated Market Total biofuels - 36 Billion gal/yr by 2022 Existing Market Corn ethanol – 10+ Billion gal/yr in 2009 Target Market Southeast US E10 gasoline blend: 3.4 Billion gal/yr   Other Markets – “Green” Electricity Customers – Power Generation Cos.   Trends Mandated renewable electricity – 20% Renewable Portfolio Standard Carbon credits (future) Strong public policy supporting liquid transportation fuel & “green” power   Biofuels 3.4 Billion 10 Billion 36 Billion

20 Reserve Space for “Tracking” Contents Or Company Logo Company logo DEVELOPING STRATEGIC PARTNERS  Georgia TechRoyalties  University of GeorgiaRoyalties  Georgia PowerRenewable liquid boiler fuel  Oak Ridge National LabsResearch collaboration  NovozymesProprietary enzymes  Plum Creek Timber Co.Higher pulpwood value  ArborGenProprietary woody energy crops  Genera EnergyProprietary switchgrass energy crops  Davis Oil CompanySupply of renewable transportation fuel

21 Reserve Space for “Tracking” Contents Or Company Logo Company logo MARGINS OF CELLULOSIC ETHANOL PRODUCTION – COMMERCIAL SCALE Revenue Components ($/Gal)  Recent Wholesale Ethanol Price (CBOT)$1.60  Transportation to SE Service Station$0.33  Production Credit (2008 Farm Bill)$0.56  Total Revenue$2.49 Cost Component Description ($/Gal)  Recent Pine Feedstock Cost ($56/dry ton)$0.70  Net Conversion Costs$0.90  Transportation to SE Service Station$0.10  Net Delivered Cost to SE Service Station$1.70 Margin Using Recent Costs($/Gal)  Projected Margin$0.79

22 Reserve Space for “Tracking” Contents Or Company Logo Company logo ETHANOL FROM SE PINE WOODCHIPS – COST ADVANTAGE Oil - $60/bbl ÷ 42 gal/bbl = $1.43/gal Corn - $3/bu ÷ 2.8 gal/bu = $1.07/gal Woodchips - [($28/Green Ton) x (2 Dry tons/Green ton)] ÷ 80 gal/Dry ton = $0.70/gal Woodchips - [($28/Green Ton) x (2 Dry tons/Green ton)] ÷ 80 gal/Dry ton = $0.70/gal 2. Feedstock Cost Calculations :  Pine Woodchips – Low cost relative to alternative fuel feedstocks 1. $28/GT (8+20) GT = Green Ton (8+20) = $8/ton to timberland owner + $20/ton to harvest, chip, deliver wood

23 Reserve Space for “Tracking” Contents Or Company Logo Company logo ETHANOL FROM SE PINE WOODCHIPS – COST ADVANTAGE Oil - $120/bbl ÷ 42 gal/bbl = $2.86/gal Corn - $6/bu ÷ 2.8 gal/bu = $2.14/gal Woodchips - [($28/Green Ton) x (2 Dry tons/Green ton)] ÷ 80 gal/Dry ton = $0.70/gal Woodchips - [($28/Green Ton) x (2 Dry tons/Green ton)] ÷ 80 gal/Dry ton = $0.70/gal 2. Feedstock Cost Calculation Examples:  Pine Woodchips – Low cost relative to alternative fuel feedstocks 1. $28/GT (8+20) GT = Green Ton (8+20) = $8/ton to timberland owner + $20/ton to harvest, chip, deliver wood

24 Reserve Space for “Tracking” Contents Or Company Logo Company logo EFFICIENT USE OF PINE RESOURCE C2 Biofuels Cellulosic Ethanol Plant Biomass Power Gen Plant 1 Ton Pine Woodchips Ethanol Value = $77 Electricity (for export) Value = $8 Electricity Value = $34 = $28 Revenue = $85 Revenue = $85 Revenue = $34 Revenue = $34 Assumptions: Ethanol Price - $1.93/gal Electricity Price - $.06/kwh Electricity Price - $.06/kwh

25 Reserve Space for “Tracking” Contents Or Company Logo Company logo SUSTAINABILITY – THINK LOCAL  Grow, Convert, Consume Within Area Tapping Low Value Components of an Existing Timberland Industry Supply Liquid Fuel/Green Electricity Low Distribution Costs Low Water Usage, Marginal Ag Land, 30 Year Planting Cycle   Washington County Area ~ 60 Mile Radius 5.7 MM Acres 4 MM Acres in Timberland 2 MM Acres in Commercial Timberland 0.4 MM Acres to Sustainably Supply Commercial Cellulosic Ethanol Plant State of Georgia

26 Reserve Space for “Tracking” Contents Or Company Logo Company logo SEEDLINGS FOR PINE TIMBERLAND

27 Reserve Space for “Tracking” Contents Or Company Logo Company logo GROWTH IN GASOLINE – AFFECTED BY RECESSION & HIGH OIL PRICES

28 Reserve Space for “Tracking” Contents Or Company Logo Company logo WORLD ENERGY CONSUMPTION

29 Reserve Space for “Tracking” Contents Or Company Logo Company logo U.S. ENERGY CONSUMPTION

30 Reserve Space for “Tracking” Contents Or Company Logo Company logo EUROPE ENERGY CONSUMPTION

31 Reserve Space for “Tracking” Contents Or Company Logo Company logo

32 Reserve Space for “Tracking” Contents Or Company Logo Company logo INDIA ENERGY CONSUMPTION