Selecting cost-effective measures for achieving the WFD Jonathan Fisher- Senior Water Economist.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Legal issues on shale gas activities raised in petitions received by the European Parliament Committee on Petitions.

Advertisements

Ambition in Action. Ambition in Action Preparing and Presenting an Effective Business Case Presentation to HIMAA July 2010.

LILLE 3. Comment mettre en pratique l’analyse économique exigée par la directive cadre ? Le recueil des préconisations Jean-Pierre Rideau.

Indicative Business Case

Need to Invest Investment Objectives and Case for Change Determine Potential Value for Money Strategic Case: Economic Case: Financial Case: Affordability.

Chinese – EU cooperation on water - Partnerships on Water Challenges 2014 CEWP High Level Conference, 4 th December 2014 Marta Moren Abat DG ENVIRONMENT,

1. 2 Content Principles of the Water Framework Directive WFD and Agriculture WFD and CAP.

The EU Water Framework Directive and Sediments The Water Framework Directive was transposed into law in EU Member States at the end of Nearly two.

Scientific Advice for the Management of Transboundary Marine Eutrophication.

The Times 100 Business Case Studies

Add your Logo in the slide master menu Module IMPLICATIONS WP8- SERVICES WP9-SOCIOECON WP10-VALUATION.

ACTeon Innovation, policy, environment Madrid – WFD Conference April 2006 How to proceed with the Programme of Measures and the River Basin Management.

BIOMASS FUTURES: Biomass role in achieving the Climate Change & Renewables EU policy targets. Demand and Supply dynamics under the perspective of stakeholders.

Performance Management Upul Abeyrathne, Dept. of Economics, University of Ruhuna, Matara.

Is Benchmarking the missing link? Mark Warner Environmental Projects Manager Liesl Truscott BITC Associate / CSR Consultancy Ltd.

The Basis for Decisions on UK Major Transport Projects

Water.europa.eu Indepth assessment economic analysis progress report SCG meeting May 2008 Maria Brättemark, Unit D.2, DG Environment, European Commission.

Implementation of the Water Framework Directive - Uncertainty issues - Michiel Blind, RWS-RIZA.

1 Beyond California Water Plan Update 2005 California Water and Environmental Modeling Forum Annual Meeting, March 3 rd, 2005.

Better Regulation Executive Making regulation work for everyone Introduction to Regulatory Impact Assessment Claire Chaubert February 2007.

UNEP Training Resource Manual Topic 13 Slide 1 Aims and objectives of SIA are to: F analyse how proposals affect people F identify and mitigate adverse.

Information for New Members of Crown Entity Boards Crown copyright: State Services Commission, February

Adaptation knowledge needs and response under the UNFCCC process Adaptation Knowledge Day V Session 1: Knowledge Gaps Bonn, Germany 09 June 2014 Rojina.

BPK Strategic Planning: Briefing for Denpasar Regional Office Leadership Team Craig Anderson Ahmed Fajarprana August 11-12, 2005.

THE PROGRAMME OF MEASURES IN PRACTICE Case study Some elements were picked from "Scoping and testing key elements of the economic analysis for the WFD",

Which role for economics in the implementation of the EU Water Framework Directive ? Arnaud Courtecuisse Artois-Picardie Water Agency Miedzyzdroje, 23.

INTERCONNEXIONS BETWEEN ECONOMICS AND WFD What room and what role for economics?

Consultation on River Basin Planning Guidance Volume 2 and the updated WFD Impact Assessment Rory Wallace WFD Implementation.

CSC 6 February 2008 The Don Catchment as an Opportunity Facilitating Answers to ICM Dr. Jonathan Hillman.

Summary B4. Water and Food Security Session Water-Energy-Food Security Nexus, including capacity building, is the interconnection where many global challenges.

Peter Gondo. Session overview Introduction Why monitor What to monitor How to monitor Exercise: Developing a performance monitoring plan for the FI.

THE ROLE OF ECONOMICS IN THE IMPLEMENTATION PROCESS WFD "eco procedure" in practice.

Corporate Social Responsibility LECTURE 25: Corporate Social Responsibility MGT

Need to Invest Investment Objectives and Case for Change Programme Option Identification and Assessment Analysis Strategic Case: Economic Case: Financial.

Water Framework Directive and the SRDP Jannette MacDonald Land Unit, SEPA.

THE CHARACTERISATION OF A RIVER BASIN DISTRICT Case study on the construction of the baseline scenario Inspired from the Oise case (F) Most elements picked.

Date/event: EEA EIONET Freshwater Workshop 27-28th Sept 2010, Copenhagen Author: Dr Manuel Lago (Ecologic Institute, Berlin) ETC/Water 2010 Overview of.

Project management Topic 4 Business Case.

WHAT IS THE ROLE OF ECONOMICS IN THE WFD PROCESS? A selection of key economic inputs.

Water Framework Directive Implementation and Risk Analysis John Sadlier Water Quality Section.

River Basin Management Planning Cath Preston Senior Planning Officer (River Basin Planning) 2 nd March 2006.

Water.europa.eu Water Framework Directive - a framework for Community action in the field of water policy Marieke van Nood WFD Team, DG ENV.D.2, European.

© WRc plc 2010 Agenda item 3b: Summary of WISE electronic delivery: presentation of an example.

Assessing the Feasibility of Economic Analysis for River Basin Management Plans in the Ribble Basin in England Dr Jonathan Fisher Senior Water Economist.

John N. Lavis, MD, PhD Professor and Canada Research Chair in Knowledge Transfer and Exchange McMaster University Program in Policy Decision-Making McMaster.

Workshop on Disproportionate Costs, 10./ Copenhagen Summary and draft conclusions 11 April 2008.

Date/event: Water accounts and economics workshop, 7-8/10/2010, Copenhagen Author: Dr Manuel Lago (Ecologic Institute, Berlin) ETC/Water 2010 Overview.

HELCOM Baltic Sea Action Plan Northern Dimension and the oceans and the seas Mieczysław Ostojski, Prof. WSS Chairman Helsinki Commission 15th Baltic Sea.

Better regulation in the Commission Jonathon Stoodley Head of Unit C.1 Evaluation, Regulatory Fitness and Performance Secretariat General of the European.

Organizations of all types and sizes face a range of risks that can affect the achievement of their objectives. Organization's activities Strategic initiatives.

Water.europa.eu Compliance Checking of River Basin Management Plans Strategic Coordination Group Meeting, 4-5 November 2009 DG Environment, European Commission.

09 May 2015 TAKE 1.5H TO UNDERSTAND AND SEE THE TYNDP 2016 PROJECTS ASSESSMENTS RESULTS Public webinar.

JMFIP Financial Management Conference

Closing the loop – An EU Action Plan for the Circular Economy

Principles and Key Issues

Proposed CIS Workshop on WFD Economic Issues

MSFD and cost-effectiveness: options for the WG ESA-work programme

Antton Keto, Finland Working session December 21 of 2005

Breakout groups: reporting back

Marine Strategy Framework Directive: implementation process at EU level Gert Verreet – WFD WG Reporting - 31 March 2009.

Costs and Benefits associated with the implementation of the Water Framework Directive, with a special focus on agriculture Summary & recommendations.

ECONOMICS IN THE WFD PROCESS

Pilot River Basin Water Framework Directive.

Objective setting in practice

Alternative Methodology for Defining Good Ecological Potential (GEP)

Water Framework Directive, Habitats Directive and Inland Waterway Transport Marieke van Nood WFD Team, DG ENV.D.2, European Commission.

IMPRESS Guidance and Policy Summary Water Directors Copenhagen, 21-22nd November 2002 Working Group leaders: Volker Mohaupt, Umwelt Bundes Amt Isobel.

Main recommendations & conclusions (1)

CIS – Workshop on WFD Economics: taking stock and looking ahead

ASSIGNING WATER BODY TYPES IN THE WATER FRAMEWORK DIRECTIVE IMPLEMENTATION Wouter van de Bund EC Joint Research Centre, Institute for Environment and sustainability,

Presentation transcript:

Selecting cost-effective measures for achieving the WFD Jonathan Fisher- Senior Water Economist

Outline: points and issues from Guidance Aim = provide basis for discussion of guidance Role and purposes of cost-effectiveness analysis Key Issues and requirements Assessing Effects of options –Challenges Costs and impacts of options –Elements –Challenges

Role and purposes of cost- effectiveness analysis Systematic and even-handed assessments and treatment of costs and effectiveness of options across sectors Help derive packages to achieve various water states in RBMPs and HMWB designation by 2015, 2021 and 2027 Input costs of these packages to determine whether or not they are disproportionate (for derogation decisions - see other Session)

Key Issues and requirements Cover all sectors Cover a wide range of options and measures Encompass all impacts and effects systematically without double counting Be robust and transparent Be practical and proportionate Help refine options

Assessing Effects of options Identify key segments of pressures causing problems Identify gap (risks of not achieve good) Collate info (eg BAT reviews, stakeholder views): –to identify targeted options –to indicate their effects on water status + reducing risks of non-compliance

Assessing Effects of options: Challenges How combine/allow for effects on various parameters affecting good status How allow for uncertainties about effects on key parameters (esp biological) how allow for lags for: –option to be implemented –target stakeholders to respond –full effects on water status (+ synergies) How increase effectiveness over time?

Costs and impacts of options: Elements Financial costs (NPVor EAV) –pro formas – scrutiny - benchmark cost estimates –?Scope to reduce costs - extend deadline? Other impacts: describe + explain why additional: –Economic impacts sectoral or regional employment exchequer costs –who pays –Non-water environmental impacts

Cost-effectiveness: Challenges How assess economic impacts and other impacts? How allow for uncertainties about (lagged) effects and costs and impacts Need to highlight transparently the basis for the estimates –Present ranges and key assumptions How derive and present summary CE measures?

Session Discussions Questions to clarify WATECO approach/guidance Specific illustrative Presentations: –Dietrich Borchardt - Pressures + CE Analysis in Germany –Juha Hunkatukia - CE in international basin (Baltic) –Ian Dickie - Assessing agricultural options –Laure Ledoux - how assess diverse impacts and summarise them Open discussion of these and other issues