Putting Customers in the Driver’s Seat! Shaping Loads through Inverted Block Rates APPA Business & Financial Conference September 24, 2007 Austin, Texas.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Winter Heating Season Presentation To: Delaware Public Service Commission June 17, 2008.
Advertisements

William B. Marcus JBS Energy1 Gas Rate Design and Energy Efficiency Presentation to NASUCA Conference June 15, 2010 William B. Marcus, JBS Energy, Inc.
APPA Business & Financial September Time of Use and EZ-3 Price Plans A Presentation to APPA Business & Financial Conference Savannah, GA September.
Time-of-Use and Critical Peak Pricing
Energy Savings Opportunities in Controls, Lighting, Air Conditioning, Water Heating and Refrigeration Chuck Thomas, P.E. CEM Lead Engineer.
Keystone Energy Efficiency Conference 2011 September 20, 2011.
Fuel Cost Adjustment and Implementation Methodology The LES Story Presented by Keith C. Brown Vice President and Chief Financial Officer Lincoln Electric.
DROUGHT PRICING – LESSONS LEARNED A Presentation to 2003 RMSAWWA / RMWEA Joint Annual Conference by Kerry Kuykendoll Manager of Rate Administration Denver.
Jefferson County PUD 1 Presented by: Gary Saleba, President EES Consulting, Inc. A registered professional engineering and management consulting firm with.
Greening Your Electricity: How you can choose clean energy March 2nd, 2015.
ANALYZING YOUR ELECTRIC BILL Bob Walker Met-Ed November 7, 2007.
1 City Light Rate Design- Review Presentation to Review Panel January 2013.
March 9, 2009WMLP 1 Renewable Energy/Energy Conservation Survey WMLP Presentation To Board of Selectmen Monday, March 9, 2009.
Power Rates - Review Rate Applications Group LADWP Rates & Contracts
The Efficiency of Energy Efficiency Program Tom Van Paris Vice President-Member Services & Communications October 18, 2012.
Arizona Corporation Commission Natural Gas Workshop September 8, 2005 Presented by David Hutchens, General Manager, Fuels and Wholesale Power Joe Salkowski,
Choosing the right deal for you Dual fuel Getting your gas and electricity from the same supplier Many suppliers offer a discount if you opt for dual fuel.
CONSUMER PROTECTIONS AND SERVICE QUALITY March 14, 2011.
TVA Generates Power and sends it down Transmission Lines to Newport Utilities Distribution Substations TVA Newport Utilities Substations Distributes the.
Fortis’ Residential Conservation Rate (RCR) How Rural Customers Are Subsidizing Lower Rates For Urban Customers.
City Of Phoenix Water Rates June 30, 2011 Denise Olson Deputy Finance Director Finance Department.
California Statewide Pricing Pilot Lessons Learned Roger Levy Demand Response Research Center NARUC Joint Meeting Committee on Energy.
ARIZONA CORPORATION COMMISSION NATURAL GAS FORUM SEPTEMBER 8, 2005 CITY OF MESA UTILITIES DEPARTMENT FRANK McRAE RESOURCES DIVISION DIRECTOR.
So it all boils down to ‘$ and Sense’ No matter what your motivation energy conservation can be argued form both the dollar and sense position.
Managing Retail Rate Changes Presented by Walter Haynes, Sr. Project Manager, Patterson & Dewar Engineers Central District Power Accountants Association.
Rate and Revenue Considerations When Starting an Energy Efficiency Program APPA’s National Conference June 13 th, 2009 Salt Lake City, Utah Mark Beauchamp,
Honey, I’m Home - How Are Electricity Prices for Tomorrow? Lawrence Kotewa Project Manager, Community Energy Cooperative April 13, 2005 Community Energy.
UGI Utilities – Electric Division Energy Efficiency & Conservation Collaborative Meeting June 9, 2010.
Regulatory Responses to Natural Gas Price Volatility Commissioner Donald L. Mason, Esq. Vice-Chairman of NARUC Gas Committee Vice Chairman or the IOGCC.
© 2007, Itron Inc. VELCO Long-Term Demand Forecast Kick-off Meeting June 7, 2010 Eric Fox.
Technical Conference on Net Metering Load Research Study November 5, 2014.
Utah Cost of Service and Rate Design Task Force
CFC: Created and Owned by America’s Electric Cooperative Network Electric Rate Concepts In an Era of Change Oregon Statewide Directors Workshop Rod Crile.
Grayson Rural Electric Cooperative Corporation 2006 Load Forecast Prepared by: East Kentucky Power Cooperative, Inc. Forecasting and Market Analysis Department.
Carbon Footprints Rick Munro Broderick Nickelberry Jr
PG&E Winter Bill Programs and Plans Low Income Oversight Board Meeting September 17, 2008 Sacramento, CA.
10 TIPS TO HELP STUDENTS SAVE MONEY BY LIA MURRAY-DRIVER.
September 24, 2007Paying for Load Growth and New Large Loads APPA September 2007.ppt 1 Paying for Load Growth and New Large Loads David Daer Principal.
Rate Design Indiana Industrial Energy Consumers, Inc. (INDIEC) Indiana Industrial Energy Consumers, Inc. (INDIEC) presented by Nick Phillips Brubaker &
Santee Cooper Encouraging Energy Efficiency APPA National Conference June 15, 2009.
APPA’s Financial Planning for Municipals Mark Beauchamp, CPA, CMA, MBA September 27, 2005 Business & Finance Workshop.
ENERGY STAR Patrick Kelly, ENERGY STAR, Renewable Energy and Climate Change program Manager July 14, 2007 Partnering with ENERGY STAR.
10 Turn off Lights Not in Use Motion Sensors simple ways to go green
EMV Results for online Energy Education Study conducted by Lei Wang, PhD October 2011.
Benefits Of A Green Home Main Menu. Navigation/Menu Quit.
Blue Grass Energy Cooperative Corporation 2006 Load Forecast Prepared by: East Kentucky Power Cooperative, Inc. Forecasting and Market Analysis Department.
MODULE 11 NYMEX. NYMEX HISTORICAL RATES The NYMEX provides utility pricing for customers who have not chosen a supplier. The utility pricing listed on.
Rate Policy Discussion Presentation to Review Panel November 1, 2013.
Government’s Evolving Role in Resource Planning and Environmental Protection Arthur H. Rosenfeld, Commissioner California Energy Commission April 19, 2002.
The Impact of Marginal Cost Pricing on Electric Utility Revenues – A Quantitative Case Study By John Kelly Presented at the Rutgers University Center for.
Presented to the City of Dover, Delaware June 6, 2006 Revenue Requirements, Cost of Service and Rate Adjustments for the Electric Utility.
Tonight’s Agenda  Project Overview  Existing Parking Summary  Post-It Note Exercise & Discussion  Parking Management Toolbox  Small Group Breakouts.
City of Palo Alto Utility Rate Changes FY 2013 Facility Managers’ Meeting August 16, 2012 Ipek Connolly, Senior Resource Planner.
Program Overview Solar resource will be built by j uwi, (pronounced “you-vee”), a developer based out of Boulder, Colorado. Solar farm will be located.
Solving the Energy Puzzle Understanding the Rules of Energy Delivery Electricity Natural Gas Tariffs Solar Combined Heat and Power Generation Distribution.
Town of Lochbuie Water 2015 Water Rate Options Presented to the Town of Lochbuie Board of Trustees Raftelis Financial Consultants, Inc. December 16, 2014.
Customer Concerns with Implementing Demand Rates NASUCA and NARUC Conferences Austin, Texas November 2015 David Springe Consumer Counsel Kansas Citizens’
Water Efficiency in Business. 2 Anglian Water 3 Anglian Water currently supply the same amount of water as we did in 1989 Managed demand: Metering /
Erin Buchanan Iowa League of Cities Annual Conference
Wyoming Utility Efficiency Exchange October 4, 2008 Rob Morris
Time of Use Rates: A Practical Option – If Done Well
Implementing Budget-Based Rates
Springfield Utility Board Proposed 5.0%
City of Sioux Falls Water Conservation Plan and its Effect on Current Water Usage November 2017 Tim Stefanich – Environmental Engineer Darin Freese – Water.
May 2018 Proposed Electric Rate Increase - First Public Hearing
Water Cost-of-Service
City of Lebanon, Missouri Electric Department
Island Energy Advisory Committee Board
Water Rates Public Hearing
Beartooth Electric Cooperative Rate Design Analysis
Presentation transcript:

Putting Customers in the Driver’s Seat! Shaping Loads through Inverted Block Rates APPA Business & Financial Conference September 24, 2007 Austin, Texas Sheila Boeckman Manager of Business Operations & Development Waverly Light and Power

In Waverly, Iowa 4,958 customers  31 MW System Peak Home of Wartburg College Concern for environment Help meet new load requirements with Energy Efficiency programs Price Signals become important

Goals Send price signal “Energy Efficiency Counts” Put Customers in the Driver’s Seat Reduce Greenhouse Gas emissions Move Customers closer to cost of service  Board goal is 85% for residential class  Reduce interclass subsidies  Reward those with low usage

Customer Driving their bills We want to directly influence  Energy Efficiency measures  Usage habits  Purchasing habits  AND have happy / comfortable customers

Waverly Light and Power

37% 38% 17%10% 73% 27% AVG Home w/ AC

Zero in on Cost of Service Summer peaking Utility  Differentiate between seasons Inside this rate class  Home Based Businesses  Line extensions = no cost to customer Larger lots, spreading out in rural areas  Transformers serving fewer customers kVa per home, Now 7 kVa per home

Send the price signal... and pay WLP’s bills! Be aware what revenue is at risk Take it slow, find out if customers will respond to signal with reduced usage We can tweak over the years

A few tricky wickets Don’t penalize low income customers  Lowered 1 st tier rate from $.087 to $.085 all year  Meant to reward low usage vs. low income Watch out for Electric Heat customers  Retained flat rate in winter w/ heating discount  They still have inverted summer rate

The Big Tricky Wicket Marathon Water Heaters  Remember, we lowered the rate on 1 st tier usage  Users with timer historic $14 / month discount In reality, due to lowered 1st tier rate we should have also LOWERED discount  Get serious, this won’t fly  Customer perception = we promoted using Electric Water Heaters and now are punishing them!  Talk with them person to person

Residential Inverted Rate Move to a 4 tier rate July 1, 2007  June - September Maintain current flat rate at other times Price increases as kWh usage rises Customer Charge increase $2 / month  Overall 3% Utility revenue increase

New Rate Design July 2007 Customer Charge $10 a month all months Winter Flat Rate $0.085 all kWh’s used Summer June through September:  First 600 kWh used$  Next 500 kWh used$  Next 400 kWh used$  Over 1,500 kWh used $0.1701

Under $2 per month in summer $2-$17.50$18-$47$48 and up

Board puts money in beliefs November Board meeting  8 decision makers  5 Board, 1 Guest Board, 2 City Council Liaisons Orally presented personal usage habits  1 = 2 nd Tier customer  7 = 4 th Tier customers With one of the 7 using the 8 th largest average on system in this rate class GO FOR IT!

The Drivers Seat Campaign Send Key Account budget lettersNOV ’06 On Board agenda 3 timesNOV ’06, MAR, APR ’07 Key Accounts NewsletterMAR, APR ’07, JUNE ‘07 Press Releases MAR, APR ‘07 Employee MtgsMAR, APR ’07, JUNE ‘07 Set date for public hearing MAR ’07 Hold public hearingAPR ’07 60 day notice by direct mail APR ’07 Internal Utility and City distributionNOV ’06 & Each Month New rate schedules mailed APR ‘07

The Drivers Seat Campaign (con’t) Website postings MAR-JULY ’07 Public speaking engagementsMONTHLY Driver’s manual direct mailMAR ’07 Commercial NewsletterMAY ’07 Post card-direct mail MID JUNE ’07 RadioJUN-AUG ’07

Reaction (so far) During speeches customers cheered!  They all thought they were low tier of course Phone calls during spring mailing  22 customers called asking for Energy Audits  48 total phone calls with questions, not complaints  1 letter to editor about Electric Water Heater usage  7 calls logged as complaints

Put Customers in the Driver’s Seat!