CONTENTdm vs DSpace vs Fedora

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Richard Jones, Systems Developer Technical Issues for Repository Software Theses Alive! Edinburgh University Library SHERPA Nottingham.

Advertisements

WikiD (Wiki/Data) Jeffrey A. Young OCLC Office of Research code4lib 2006 Oregon State University, Corvallis, Oregon 15 February 2006.

VuFind Beyond MARC discovering everything else Demian Katz VuFind Developer

IRRA DSpace April 2006 Claire Knowles University of Edinburgh.

Preservation Features in Repository Software PRESERV: Tim Brody University of Southampton.

Possibility in Digital Collection Management Introduction to CONTENTdm TM Hitoshi Kamada University of Arizona Presentation for OCLC-CJK Users Group Annual.

The Future of the Catalog Shelley Hostetler Product Manager, Voyager Endeavor Information Systems.

Richard Jones, Systems Developer Technical Issues for Repository Software Theses Alive! Edinburgh University Library SHERPA Nottingham.

Theo Andrew, Edinburgh University Library Choosing Suitable Open-Source Repository Software Choosing Suitable Open Source Repository Software Theo Andrew.

Richard Jones DSpace for E-Theses th September 2004 DSpace for E-Theses Introducing the results of the Theses Alive! Project.

OCLC Online Computer Library Center Terminology Services Diane Vizine-Goetz OCLC Research.

WikiD (Wiki/Data) Jeffrey A. Young OCLC Office of Research Distributed Service Registry Workshop Warwick, UK 14 July 2005.

Digital Collections: Storage and Access Jon Dunn Assistant Director for Technology IU Digital Library Program

JISC IE Architecture external trends and their potential impact Andy Powell UKOLN, University of Bath

Archiving research data in the cloud or in a local repository Michele Kimpton, CEO DuraSpace CNI Dec 2014.

HyperContent 2.0 JA-SIG Winter Conference December 5, 2005 Alex Vigdor, Columbia University.

The KnowledgeBank: Powered by DSpace Laura Tull Systems Librarian Ohio State University Libraries WiLSWorld July 27, 2004.

CONTENTdm Important Features and Capabilities. CONTENTdm provides an “out of the box” solution to a complex web programming challenge. With minimal customization,

Dspace – Digital Repository Dawn Petherick, University Web Services Team Manager Information Services, University of Birmingham MIDESS Dissemination.

Digital Repository Service ___________________________ Yale University Library Audrey Novak, Head IS&P 7 March 2007.

OCLC Online Computer Library Center CONTENTdm 4.3 Claire Cocco Global Product Manager CONTENTdm October 3, 2007.

Create with SharePoint 2010 Jen Dodd Sr. Solutions Consultant

ETD Repositories Using DSpace Software Andrew Penman The Robert Gordon University 27 th September 2004.

Digital Library Architecture and Technology

Module - Technical Basics

DEF System Architecture XML Web Services Fedora and the Zebra Search Engine in an OAI Eprints Application by Gert Schmeltz Pedersen, DTV

OCLC Online Computer Library Center CONTENTdm ® Digital Collection Management Software Ron Gardner, OCLC Digital Services Consultant ICOLC Meeting April.

The DSpace Course Module – An introduction to DSpace.

University of North Texas Libraries Building Search Systems for Digital Library Collections Mark E. Phillips Texas Conference on Digital Libraries May.

1 1 Scholarly Publishing & Academic Resources Coalition an initiative of the Association of Research Libraries Institutional Repository.

Use & Access 26 March Use “Proof of Concept” Model for General Libraries & IS faculty Model for General Libraries & IS faculty Test bed for DSpace.

Marcus Barnes, Simon Fraser University, June 2, 2012 Drupal with CONTENTdm Digital Collections.

May 2, 2013 An introduction to DSpace. Module 1 – An Introduction By the end of this module, you will … Understand what DSpace is, and what it can be.

IUScholarWorks Technical Overview Randall Floyd Digital Library Program Programmer/Database Administrator.

Core Integration Web Services Dean Krafft, Cornell University

DSpace vs Fedora Ralph LeVan OCLC Research. What Do You Want From a Repository? How do you create your metadata? How do you assemble your objects? How.

OAIS: From Requirements to Reality at OCLC FLICC / CENDI Symposium, Dec Pam Kircher Product Manager, Digital Archive OCLC Digital & Preservation.

How to Implement an Institutional Repository: Part II A NASIG 2006 Pre-Conference May 4, 2006 Technical Issues.

The New DRS Introduction. What is DRS? Digital repository for preservation and access – Maintains integrity of deposited content – Preserves content for.

A wiki is a collaborative web application which allows people to add and edit content using a browser… …it creates communities and empowers users as they.

A Basic Introduction By Scott Phillips 2005/8/7. Agenda What is DSpace and what does it do? The DSpace Information Model Components & Features of DSpace.

The library is open Digital Assets Management & Institutional Repository Russian-IUG November 2015 Tomsk, Russia Nabil Saadallah Manager Business.

HathiTrust: Possibilities Metadata Working Group Cornell University Library March 21, 2014.

A Project of the University Libraries Ball State University Libraries A destination for research, learning, and friends.

VIVA Special Collections Committee GRANT MEETING January 26, 2007 METADATA: The Who, What, Why, Where, and When Bob Vay George Mason University.

Managing live digital content with DuraSpace services Bill Branan PASIG Spring 2015.

William J Nixon Setting up a Repository. Introduction Key Features to consider (and review) Wide Range of Technology Available –Best fit for purpose –Clear.

June 30, 2005 Public Web Site Search Project Update: 6/30/2005 Linda Busdiecker & Andy Nguyen Department of Information Technology.

CONTENTdm A proven solution September A complete digital collection management software solution Stores, manages and provides access for all digital.

The world’s libraries. Connected. CONTENTdm ® Digital Collection Management Solutions Learn what to consider when outsourcing your library’s digitization.

Breeda Herlihy, IR Manager, UCC Library. UCC selected DSpace in 2008 Software selection group Staff from Library IT, Computer Centre, Special Collections,

Building Digital Archives Mark Phillips Cathy Hartman June 6, 2008.

Adapting Sufia for Use in TEEAL-AgriKnowledge Mary Ochs, Director, Mann Library Joy Paulson, TEEAL Project Director USAIN 2016 Conference Gainesville,

Resource Discovery Landscape

Tiewei (Lucy) Liu Metadata Librarian June 26, 2016

Document & Web Content Management

The Hosted Model Charl Roberts Good morning again,

Introduction, Features & Technology

VI-SEEM Data Repository

Detailed search stats from DSpace Solr

Building Search Systems for Digital Library Collections

VI-SEEM Data Repository

Institutional Repository at NIO: Inspiration to Implementation

Choices for Building Digital Libraries

Introduction to DSpace

Charl Roberts University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg

Implementing an Institutional Repository: Part II

Malte Dreyer – Matthias Razum

Implementing an Institutional Repository: Part II

How to Implement an Institutional Repository: Part II

Presentation transcript:

CONTENTdm vs DSpace vs Fedora Ralph LeVan OCLC Research

Data Support Arbitrary Bitstreams? Arbitrarily Complex Objects? Versioning? Local Metadata Elements? Preservation Metadata? Batch Input? Rich Metadata Searching? Full-text Searching?

Arbitrary Bitstreams? CONTENTdm DSpace Fedora yes Can you stick everything in the repository?

Arbitrarily Complex Objects? CONTENTdm yes DSpace Fedora Can you define objects as collections of arbitrary bitstreams?

Versioning? CONTENTdm DSpace Fedora no yes Can objects in the repository be replaced with new versions and still have access to the older version?

Local Metadata Elements? CONTENTdm yes DSpace yes, but they can’t be searched Fedora no Can an institution define their own metadata elements

Preservation Metadata? CONTENTdm no DSpace yes Fedora Does the repository support/generate metadata for preservation purposes?

Batch Input? CONTENTdm DSpace Fedora yes? yes Can you import masses of records?

Rich Metadata Searching? CONTENTdm yes DSpace yes, but only on a few fields Fedora yes, but only on a couple of fields Can you search all the metadata that was entered?

Full-text Searching? CONTENTdm DSpace Fedora yes, by moving the content into the metadata DSpace yes, through Google (in development) Fedora no

User Support User Roles With Privileges? Workflows? Object Marshalling? Arbitrary Bitstream Retrieval? Arbitrary Object Retrieval? Web Interface? Content Easily Integrated Into Web Pages?

User Roles With Privileges? CONTENTdm User permissions on directories DSpace yes Fedora no Users, editors, members, guests, etc.

Mediated Workflows? CONTENTdm DSpace Fedora no, but they have a three step commit DSpace yes Fedora no Can workflow processes be defined for object entry with handoffs between users?

Object Marshalling? CONTENTdm DSpace Fedora yes no Are there tools for collecting together the components of an object?

Arbitrary Bitstream Retrieval? CONTENTdm Only file types recognized by the browser DSpace Fedora What kinds of bitstreams can you retrieve?

Arbitrary Object Retrieval? CONTENTdm Only types defined by CONTENTdm (books, postcards, CDs, etc.) DSpace Web pages only Fedora yes Can you get complex objects back out of the repository?

Web Interface? CONTENTdm yes DSpace Fedora no

Content Easily Integrated Into Web Pages? CONTENTdm yes DSpace no Fedora possible Can institutional web pages easily access the contents of the repository?

Miscellaneous Infrastructure OAI-PMH? Z39.50/SRW? Open Source? Open API’s? Cross-Repository Searching?

OAI-PMH? CONTENTdm DSpace Fedora yes Does the repository support standardized harvesting?

Z39.50/SRW? CONTENTdm DSpace Fedora Z39.50 can be added SRW can be added Fedora no Does the repository support standardized searching?

Open Source? CONTENTdm DSpace Fedora no yes Can the user community also change/fix/enhance the code?

Open API’s? CONTENTdm DSpace Fedora By license SRW for searching Yes Do they have published API’s for searching and updating the repository

Cross-Repository Searching? CONTENTdm Yes DSpace No Fedora Can you search multiple repositories (not just collections) with a single search?

Data Support CONTENTdm DSpace Fedora Arbitrary Bitstreams? ● Arbitrarily Complex Objects? Versioning? Local Metadata Elements? Preservation Metadata? Batch Input? Rich Metadata Searching? ○ Full-text Searching? ● = Yes ○ = Qualified Yes

User Support CONTENTdm DSpace Fedora User Roles With Privileges? ○ ● Workflows? Object Marshalling? Arbitrary Bitstream Retrieval? Arbitrary Object Retrieval? Web Interface? Content Easily Integrated Into Web Pages? ● = Yes ○ = Qualified Yes

Miscellaneous Infrastructure CONTENTdm DSpace Fedora OAI-PMH? ● Z39.50/SRW? Open Source? Open API’s? ○ Cross-Repository Searching? ● = Yes ○ = Qualified Yes

Prioritized List Of New Features Preservation Plan Open Rendering Scheme Open API’s Workflow and User Roles Versioning #1 is probably critical to meeting many users expectations of a digital repository. The rest are desirable for various markets.