Models + Frameworks Measurement Efficacy Efficiency Effectiveness

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
PAYING FOR PERFORMANCE In PUBLIC HEALTH: Opportunities and Obstacles Glen P. Mays, Ph.D., M.P.H. Department of Health Policy and Administration UAMS College.
Advertisements

New Challenges in M&E Lets go. Scaling Up Monitoring & Evaluation Strategic Information PROGRAM GUIDANCE RESULT NEEDS OPPORTUNITIES Resources New directions.
A Model for Program Planning in Health Promotion
Copyright © 2004 Sherif Kamel Technology Acceptance Model Sherif Kamel The American University in Cairo.
Clinical-related behaviours of healthcare workers: Determinants of adoption and planning interventions Prof. Gaston Godin, Ph.D. Laval University, Quebec.
The Underlying Theories of Precede-Proceed Model
PROJECT TOPICS. HOUSEHOLD WASTE RECYCLING INTENTION AMONG UNDERGRADUATES Topic 1.
Self-Regulation in Chronic Disease Noreen M. Clark, Ph.D. March 23, 2002.
Implementation Research: Using Science to Guide Implementation of Evidence-Based Practices Brian S. Mittman, PhD Director, VA Center for Implementation.
What is Diffusion? The process of communicating innovation through certain channels over time through members of a social system.
TRAINING FOR ANTIMICROBIAL STEWARDSHIP PROGRAMMES IN HOSPITALS JUNE 2014.
Health Aspect of Disaster Risk Assessment Dr AA Abubakar Department of Community Medicine Ahmadu Bello University Zaria Nigeria.
Technical Models for Health Promotion
CHS 382 Fundamentals of Health Education
Implementing Patient Decision Aids in Clinical Practice October 2014 Dawn Stacey RN, PhD Research Chair in Knowledge Translation to Patients Full Professor,
Some models relevant for planning health promotion programs Ian McDowell March, 2012.
Models of Behaviour Change Matt Vreugde
Behavioral Change Models for Healthcare Workers Objective:  Explore theoretical models that may prove useful for changing hand hygiene behavior among.
Diffusion of Innovations Theory Tyra JanssonTyra Jansson H571 Principles of Health BehaviorH571 Principles of Health Behavior.
LIMITLESS POTENTIAL | LIMITLESS OPPORTUNITIES | LIMITLESS IMPACT Copyright University of Reading IMPACT AND THE SCIENCES Anthony Atkin (Research Impact.
Generating evidence for change: Implementing the post-ICIUM research agenda Dennis Ross-Degnan, ScD Harvard Medical School and Harvard Pilgrim Health Care.
Implementation and Fidelity within a Theory-Driven Framework Greg Roberts, PhD. Vaughn Gross Center & National Center for Instruction The University of.
Barriers and Facilitators of Implementation New York Academy of Medicine Peter Dayan, MD, MSc December, 2012.
1 Patient Decision Support Research Initiatives Dawn Stacey RN, MScN, PhD Assistant Professor, School of Nursing ext
APPROACHES TO HEALTH PROMOTION
Identification, Analysis and Management
Copyright © 2008 Delmar. All rights reserved. Chapter 13 Principles of Health Promotion.
Diffusion of Innovations Gerontology 820 Ashley Waldoch October 18, 2010.
Evaluating Health Programmes
APPROACHES TO HEALTH PROMOTION. Approaches to Health Promotion 1. Medical 2. Behaviour change 3. Educational 4. Empowerment 5. Social change.
Dr Samira Alsenany.  Knowledge must be translated into clinical practice to improve patient care and outcomes  The understanding of care based on evidence.
Copyright © 2006 Elsevier, Inc. All rights reserved Chapter 24 Using Nursing Research in Practice.
Providing the know-how for Closing the Gap: The new research agenda.
Health Belief Model (HBM)
Towards an overall model April, Modeling Decisions Outcome (What are we explaining?) General (e.g., longevity) vs. specific (e.g., MI)? Incidence.
1.3 Modeling process and outcomes Walter Sermeus, RN, PhD Catholic University Leuven Belgium Witten, Fri Session 1: 11:00-12:30 Session 2: 13:30-15:00.
PHSB 612: Interventions Diane M. Dowdy, Ph.D. Spring 2008.
Knowledge to Action. Monitor Knowledge Use Sustain Knowledge Use Evaluate Outcomes Adapt Knowledge to Local Context to Local Context Assess Barriers to.
Librarians becoming competent: Technology acceptance in the workplace Sarah-Jane Saravani LIANZA Conference, Hamilton, 22 October, 2013.
Theory of Reasoned Action
Unified Theory of Acceptance and Use of Technology and the VET sector Sarah-Jane Saravani Shar-e-Fest, Hamilton, 11 October, 2013.
INTRODUCTION. Majmaah graduates should be:  scientific in their approach to practice  proficient in clinical care  professional  community conscious.
rehabilitation services
Behavioral Science HEALTH BELIEF MODEL (HBM) Dr. G.U Ahsan, Ph.D.
Role of Policy in Behavior Change. Contents of the Lecture.
Gaps in Substance Use Treatment Presented by: Rhonda G. Patrick, LCSW, MPA Amy C. Traylor, MSW, Ph.D.
Role of Policy in Behavior Change. Contents of the Lecture.
EHFG 7 October 2005 – Patient Safety & Research UK Presidency Workshop on Patient Safety, EHFG, Bad Hofgastein,7 September 2005 Kevin McCarthy, European.
1 CHRONIC CONDITION SELF-MANAGEMENT FLINDERS HUMAN BEHAVIOUR & HEALTH RESEARCH UNIT THE FLINDERS MODEL.
Georgia Comprehensive Cancer Control Program 3/10/2015 Program Monitoring and Evaluation Activities Short-Term Outcomes Long-Term Outcomes Intermediate.
WHO ICF KNR 279.
Logic modeling. “Would you tell me, please, which way I ought to go from here?” “That depends a good deal on where you want to get to.” said the Cat.
Decoding the Evidence Myth: The Realities of Evidence Based Public Health.
Scottish Improvement Science Collaborating Centre Strengthening the evidence base for improvement science: lessons learned Dr Nicola Gray, Senior Lecturer,
Perceived Attributes Predict Course Management System Adopter Status Gayla S. Keesee, Ph.D. ABSTRACT Rogers’s diffusion of innovation theory provided the.
D Health A1 Development of health promoting services A2 Advocacy, cooperation of organizations A3 Social mobilisation A4 Development of individual skills.
Impact and the Physical Sciences
PRECEDE – PROCEDE THEORY
Overview of Intervention Mapping
ATW 202 Project 2017.
Health Education THeories
Understanding Behavior and Performance In Organizations
ACT Project Methodologies for assessment of coordinated care and telehealth - IFIC 2014 Cristina Bescos, Helen Schonenberg 9/22/2018 ACT Programme.
Behavior Knowledge Behavior.
Behavior Knowledge Behavior.
Cancer Research Early Diagnosis Research Conference: ECR Pechakucha presentation: Feb 2017 Exploring patient and practitioner perspectives of QCancer.
THE PRECEDE-PROCEED PLANNING MODEL
THE PRECEDE-PROCEED PLANNING MODEL
Introduction to Public Health Nutrition
Approaches to improving health literacy in Thailand
Presentation transcript:

Models + Frameworks Measurement Efficacy Efficiency Effectiveness Burden of disease Causation Determinants Implementation Measurement Efficacy Efficiency Effectiveness After P Tugwell, 1985

Selye’s Stress Model

Defining Dimensions of Quality of Life and Health-Related Quality of Life Health Canada-Quality of Life Mayo Clinic- Health-Related Quality of Life

Professional Expertise Model

Models + Frameworks Measurement Efficacy Efficiency Effectiveness Burden of disease Causation Determinants Implementation Measurement Efficacy Efficiency Effectiveness After P Tugwell, 1985

Generic Predictive Model

International Classification of Determinants of Functional Outcomes ICF Model Application to COPD

Theory of Planned Behavior Ajzen, 1985, 1991, 2001

CIHR: Causal Map for Identifying Determinants and Policy Priorities for Obesity in Canada

Public Health Model of Determinants of Diarrheal Disease

Models + Frameworks Measurement Efficacy Efficiency Effectiveness Burden of disease Causation Determinants Implementation Measurement Efficacy Efficiency Effectiveness After P Tugwell, 1985

The Precede-Proceed Model of Health Program Planning & Evaluation Green, Lawrence: Health Program Planning: An Educational and Ecological Approach, New York: McGraw-Hill, 2005. Heath Education, Media, Advocacy Predisposing Lifestyle Quality of Life Health Reinforcing Policy, Regulation, Resources. Organization Environment Enabling

Patho-physiological Models Alternate Therapy Targets for Multi-Drug Resistance in TB

Models + Frameworks Measurement Efficacy Efficiency Effectiveness Burden of disease Causation Determinants Implementation Measurement Efficacy Efficiency Effectiveness After P Tugwell, 1985

Ottawa Model of Research Use Assess + Monitor + Evaluate Innovation Potential Adopters Interventions Adoption Outcomes When the barriers related to the practice environment, potential adopters and innovation have been addressed, strategies are designed to disseminate the new practice for use. Practice Environment University of Ottawa/ CIHR 16

Ottawa Model of Research Use Assess + Monitor + Evaluate barriers & supports interventions outcomes & degree of use Innovation (CPG, tools) Potential Adopters Interventions Adoption Outcomes When the barriers related to the practice environment, potential adopters and innovation have been addressed, strategies are designed to disseminate the new practice for use. Practice Environment University of Ottawa/ CIHR 16

Ottawa Model of Research Use Assess + Monitor + Evaluate barriers & supports interventions outcomes & degree of use Innovation Implementation Interventions barrier management transfer follow-up Potential Adopters Outcomes Adoption When the barriers related to the practice environment, potential adopters and innovation have been addressed, strategies are designed to disseminate the new practice for use. Practice Environment University of Ottawa/ CIHR 16

Ottawa Model of Research Use Assess + Monitor + Evaluate barriers & supports interventions outcomes & degree of use Innovation (guideline) development process innovation attributes Potential Adopters awareness attitudes knowledge/skill concerns current practice Interventions barrier management transfer follow-up Adoption intention use sustained use Outcomes patient practitioner system When the barriers related to the practice environment, potential adopters and innovation have been addressed, strategies are designed to disseminate the new practice for use. Practice Environment structural culture/social patients economic University of Ottawa/ CIHR 16

Ottawa Model of Research Use Assess + Monitor + Evaluate barriers & supports interventions outcomes & degree of use Innovation development process innovation attributes Potential Adopters awareness attitudes knowledge/skill concerns current practice Outcomes patient practitioner system Interventions barrier management transfer follow-up Adoption intention use sustained use When the barriers related to the practice environment, potential adopters and innovation have been addressed, strategies are designed to disseminate the new practice for use. Practice Environment structural culture/social patients economic University of Ottawa/ CIHR 16

Micro-Theories of Adoption Technology Acceptance Model 2 ½% Innovators 34% Early majority 34% Late majority 16% Laggards These physicians could be considered to be early adopters of technology. Research demonstrates that the success of technology diffusion depends on the experience of this group. Also market evidence in NA of substantial rejection rate in e-rx systems, with no real evaluation Within this group, the ability to predict the rate of utilization will be associated with the likelihood of success, the speed of the diffusion, and the magnitude of the benefit for improving safety and qualitiy. Although efficiency and integration issues have been proposed as reasons for failure to utilize e-rx systems, there is sufficient variation in utilization rates to warrant further investigation. Equally important is the fact that drivers of physician behaviour in the current system (including remuneration schemes, access to physicians, lack of integration of care, lack of practice evaluation/measurement of quality and safety). The question remains then, what predicts physicians utilization of e-rx. 13 ½% Early adaptors Time to adoption of innovations

Predicting the Adoption of Electronic-Prescribing e-RX Utilization Practice Characteristics Continuity of Care Practice Volume Practice Size Medication Use Gender Age Computer Experience Information Acquisition Style Perceived Value of Technology Perceived Ease Of Use Perceived Usefulness Social Influence Behavioural Intention Adapted from Venkatesh, Morris, Davis, Davis (2003) User Acceptance of Information Technology: Toward a Unified View, MIS Quarterly, 27 (3), p.447 Explains 4% of Utilization (p-value 0.29) Explains 15% of Utilization (p-value 0.07) Explains 40% of Utilization (p-value 0.001) Explains 86% of Behavioural Intention (p-value <0.001) Facilitating Conditions: Physician Characteristics Explains 23% of Utilization (p-value 0.32) Adjusted R2=8.4% Adjusted R2=82.1% Adjusted R2=3.6% Adjusted R2=29.6% Adjusted R2=0.9%