Headwater Stream Restoration in Mined Watersheds of the MAH Todd Petty, Mike Strager WVU Division of Forestry and Natural Resources Paul Ziemkiewicz WV.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

AMD and Extent in West Virginia Patrick Campbell - April 22, 2008.

Advertisements

Muddy Creek Targeted Watershed Initiative: Strategic AMD Restoration Rick Herd, Jennifer Fulton and Paul Ziemkiewicz West Virginia Water Research Institute.

Watershed Scale Approaches to Restoration and Mitigation Todd Petty and Paul Ziemkiewicz.

Washington Department

Moffatt Thomas Lower Boise River Wetlands Restoration Project Sponsor:Pioneer Irrigation District Presenter: Scott L. Campbell Legal Counsel for Pioneer.

Marylands Approach to Success Stories Presented to the Region III States Meeting May 12, 2009 Presented by Jim George.

PRESENTED MARCH 17 TH 2009 BY FRIENDS OF THE CHEAT Water Quality Monitoring & Mapping Assessment for Watershed Scale Restoration Planning in the Cheat.

Strategic Watershed Restoration: An Alternative Future for the Appalachian Coal Fields Todd Petty, Mike Strager, and Michael Hasenmyer West Virginia University.

Mountaintop Mining/Valley Fills in Appalachia. Background Mountaintop coal mining is a surface mining practice used in the Appalachian states involving.

1 Watershed Planning: A Key to Integrated Planning FHWA Environmental Conference Ann Campbell Wetlands Division.

Marmot Creek Research Basin 50 th Anniversary Workshop March , 2013 John Diiwu Forest Management Branch Alberta Environment and Sustainable Resource.

Dan McKenzie ORD Western Ecology Division Corvallis, Oregon Sept. 10, 2004 Dan McKenzie ORD Western Ecology Division Corvallis, Oregon Sept. 10, 2004 Increasing.

Step 1: Valley Segment Classification Our first step will be to assign environmental parameters to stream valley segments using a series of GIS tools developed.

Exploring Trading to Reduce Impacts of Acid Mine Drainage: Cheat River, West Virginia Evan Hansen: Downstream Strategies, LLC Paul Ziemkiewicz, Jerry Fletcher,

Leaf Pack Experiments Aquatic Ecology. Background Historically, most small streams in the eastern United States were forested. Leaf fall from the forest.

Birds as Indicators. Healthy water bodies for a healthy planet.

The adequacy of the existing reserve system for the protection of freshwater ecosystems Janet Stein Fenner School of Environment and Society.

Lec 12: Rapid Bioassessment Protocols (RBP’s)

EcoAtlas: A Technology Tool for Wetland Protection and Management Data Management Workgroup June 6, 2012 Meredith Williams Cristina Grosso.

National Hydrography Data Use and Applications.

Influence of Geomorphic Complexity on Hyporheic Flow and Nutrient Processing Prepared by Dan Baker for CE 413.

Habitat Assessment Modeling: Ecosystem Diagnosis and Treatment

Hydrologic Issues in Mountaintop Mining Areas Ronald Evaldi, USGS-WSC, Charleston, WV Daniel Evans, USGS-WSC, Louisville, KY Hugh Bevans, USGS-WSC, Charleston,

Acid Lakes from Lignite Mines Dan Henderson. Lignite  Brown/soft coal.  Used for steam electric power generation.  Mined in open pits.  Production.

Metric (Family Level) Standard Best Value (95 th or 5 th percentile) Worst Possible Value Expected Response to Degradation Total Taxa180 EPT Taxa120 %EPT91.90.

2012 West Virginia GIS Conference The Nature Conservancy of West Virginia Ruth Thornton Conservation Information Manager.

West Virginia University Natural Stream Restoration Program An Interdisciplinary Program Focusing on Research, Education, and Professional Services in.

ORD’s Environmental Monitoring and Assessment Program (EMAP) Sound Science for Measuring Ecological Condition

Brooten Area Water Use June 19, Brooten – Initial Conflict Study Area.

Extending the National Hydrography Dataset: A Spatial Framework for Water Resources Applications in West Virginia Jackie Strager Natural Resource Analysis.

Region III Activities to Implement National Vision to Improve Water Quality Monitoring National Water Quality Monitoring Council August 20, 2003.

An Application of a Hydrologically Networked Watershed Model for Evaluating AMD Treatment Scenarios Mike Strager, Todd Petty, Brady Gutta, Jennifer Fulton,

1 The Lower Athabasca Regional Plan: A Case Study Biol. 595 Sept. 16, 2009.

Mountaintop Mining/Valley Fills in Appalachia Mountaintop Mining in Appalachia Mrs. Jackson Period 2.

Rhode Island Water Resources Board Water Availability An Overview of Water Supply and Water Resources May 5, 2011.

Dr Richard Johnson, Mountain Environments, UK.  Lead Partner: Germany: Research Institute of Forest Ecology and Forestry  Partner countries: Germany,

A Decade of Working Together on Conservation & Sustainable Use of Canada’s Natural Assets CBS endorsed by FPT Ministers in April 1996 Federal, provincial,

PNAMP Habitat Status and Trends Monitoring Management Question: Are the Primary Habitat Factors Limiting the Status of the Salmon and Steelhead Populations.

Agricultural Headwater Streams and Restoration Opportunities Bradley Wright Bradley Wright City of Ottawa City of Ottawa February 25, 2011.

112.3 Jessica L. Feeser, M. Elise Lauterbur & Jennifer L. Soong Research Project for Systems Ecology (ENVS 316), Fall ’06 Oberlin College, Oberlin OH BackgroundFindings.

Focus on the Headwaters The Shenandoah Watershed Study / The Virginia Trout Stream Sensitivity Study Rick Webb Department of Environmental Sciences University.

The Ohio River Basin Alliance Who We Are and Where We’re Going Martin Hettel, Steering Committee Member.

Urban Water Research Todd Rasmussen Associate Professor of Hydrology The University of Georgia, Athens and Pending Director, Urban Water Research Institute.

Freshwater and Society Module 1, part C. Developed by: Updated: U?-m1c-s2 Water quality degradation

ORSANCO Biological Programs Extra-curricular Updates EMAP-GRE ORBFHP NRSA.

1. The Study of Excess Nitrogen in the Neuse River Basin “A Landscape Level Analysis of Potential Excess Nitrogen in East-Central North Carolina, USA”

Quantifying Stream Ecosystem Responses to Smart Growth: How to Design an Assessment Allison Roy Cross-ORD Postdoctoral Researcher US Environmental Protection.

Ecology of Mined WV Watersheds: Monongahela River to Tug Fork J. Todd Petty, PhD Division of Forestry & Natural Resources Surface Mine Drainage Task Force.

Clean Water Act Mrs. Perryman Mrs. Trimble. Clean Water Act “Restore and maintain the chemical, physical and biological integrity of the Nation’s waters”

STRATEGIES FOR FRESHWATER. CONTEXT FOR STRATEGIES.

Aquatic GAP program in Kansas Keith Gido, Walter Dodds, Chris Guy, Jessica Kemp, and Bob Oakes Kansas State University The Gap Analysis Program

Case Study Development of an Index of Biotic Integrity for the Mid-Atlantic Highland Region McCormick et al

Development of Nutrient Water Quality Standards for Rivers and Streams in Ohio Ohio EPA ORSANCO, October 20, 2009 George Elmaraghy, P.E., Chief.

1 Collaboration on EMAP Stream Condition Assessments in EPA Region 8 Thomas R. Johnson and Karl A. Hermann EPA Region 8.

Managing TDS in the Upper Monongahela River Basin Project WRI 119 Paul Ziemkiewicz, PhD Director West Virginia Water Research Institute 1 West Virginia.

Aquatic Resource Monitoring Overview Anthony (Tony) R. Olsen USEPA NHEERL Western Ecology Division Corvallis, Oregon (541)

Watershed Restoration: Aquatic Resource Conservation at a Watershed Scale Todd Petty Professor of Aquatic Sciences February 4, 2013.

EVALUATING STREAM COMPENSATION PERFORMANCE: Overcoming the Data Deficit Through Standardized Study Design Kenton L. Sena (EPA VSFS Intern), Joe Morgan,

Dr. Patrick Doran, The Nature Conservancy in Michigan. Climate Change: Challenges to Biodiversity Conservation. Chris Hoving, Michigan Department of Natural.

Mountaintop Mining/Valley Fills in Appalachia

Todd Petty, Mike Strager, and Michael Hasenmyer

Puget Sound Watershed Characterization Project

Critical Linkages: Identifying Culvert Replacement Priorities to Maintain Connectivity of Cold Water Streams in the Face of Climate Change Scott Jackson,

Bob Pressey & Stephanie Januchowski

Reclaimed Water Funding

Department of Geology and Geological Engineering

Finnish Environment Institute (SYKE)

Todd Petty, PhD Basic Stream Ecology

J. Todd Petty, Richard Herd, Paul Ziemkiewicz,

It all flows downstream: coming together to explore restoration of upland watershed health on national forest lands in the Upper Green.

Presentation transcript:

Headwater Stream Restoration in Mined Watersheds of the MAH Todd Petty, Mike Strager WVU Division of Forestry and Natural Resources Paul Ziemkiewicz WV Water Research Institute USEPA Eastern Regional Scientist Meeting June 20-21, 2006

Observations 1.We have lost entire watersheds throughout much of the MAH mining districts as a result of AMLs. 2.MTM/VF is occurring on top of historic impacts. 3.If we ignore AML impacts we will not: - understand present day impacts of MTM / VF - effectively manage new mine development - successfully restore impacted watersheds 4.Current stream-by-stream approach to restoration and protection is inefficient and ineffective at the watershed scale. 5.Progress will not be made until we shift to an approach that integrates AML restoration and new mine permitting at the watershed scale.

Important Questions 1.Are there watershed scale consequences that emerge from extensive mining related impacts (“neighborhood” effects)? -eutrophication of downstream waterbodies because of reduced nutrient uptake capacity of mined headwater watersheds -reduced diversity of fishes that depend on watershed scale connectivity of stream reaches 2.If so, what are the mechanisms, are there indicators, and can we find thresholds of impairment below which watershed scale losses can be avoided?

Watershed Scale Impacts # Streams Impacted by AMD Cumulative Biological Impact 1:1 ProtectionRestoration Neighborhood Effect

Important Questions 4.To what extent can restoration be used to recover reach and watershed scale conditions? -all restoration projects are not successful, but improvements can be made by coupling projects together; some will be more effective than others -importance of restoration technology and strategic design -value of stream restoration depends on the quality of the “neighborhood.” 5.What modeling, assessment, and administrative frameworks are needed to manage for watershed scale conditions (move to a “neighborhood planning” approach) ?

Specific Research in our lab 1.Landscape models in mined Appalachian watersheds (quantifying reach and watershed scale conditions, identifying restoration priorities). 2.Watershed scale effects of extensive mining impacts on Appalachian stream fish assemblages (quantifying “neighborhood” effects, identifying indicators of watershed condition). 3.Measuring the effectiveness of acid stream restoration on the Allegheny Plateau (what does and doesn’t work?, what is and isn’t restored?).

Saltlick Muddy Little Sandy Big Sandy Cheat Lake Coal Outcrops Outcrop length Coal type Dip direction Mine information Surface vs Undergr Permitted vs AML Known area Mining and Coal Geology Calculating Reachshed MI:

Effects of Mining Intensity, Mine Position, and Coal Geology on Bug Condition in the Cheat River

Good Stream / Bad Watershed Bad Stream / Bad Watershed Bad Stream / Good Watershed Bad Stream / Bad Watershed Aquatic Neighborhoods

Good Stream / Good Watershed Good Stream / Bad Watershed Bad Stream / Bad Watershed Watershed Scale Impacts f (basin area (80%), spatial position (8%) )

Watershed Indicators: Fishes lost from good streams in bad neighborhoods

REF SOFT HARD AMD

Log Basin Area (km 2 ) Partial Recovery of Biological Assemblages in Restored Acid Streams / Poor Technology or Good Streams in Bad Neighborhoods? Benthic InvertebratesFishes

Conclusions 1.It is possible to predict instream conditions (chemical and biological) continuously on the basis of geology, mining intensity, and mine placement. Can we predict the consequences of a given mining activity? 2.Extensive mining impairment produces watershed scale impacts to fish assemblages. Can we identify thresholds of mining intensity below which watershed scale losses are avoided? Can fishes be used as indicators of watershed conditions?

Conclusions 3.Acid stream restoration is effective in recovering local physical and chemical conditions, but biological recovery is incomplete. Can restoration effectiveness be improved through “watershed design” (systems vs. chemical engineers)? 4.Full recovery and sustainable development in mined watersheds of the MAH will require watershed approaches that integrate restoration, land conservation, and permitting (specific needs may vary from watershed to watershed).