TDG 2008 Report Illness scripts for improving clinical reasoning Anna Lee, Tony Gin, Charles Gomersall, Warwick Ngan Kee, Gavin Joynt, Anthony Ho, Juliana.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Manual Evaluation: Are we doing what we think we are doing?

Advertisements

Residents as Teachers: Strategies for Improving Peer Based Education in a Community Based Residency Program Bernard Birnbaum, MD Kim Marvel, PhD Kristen.

Using Computer-Simulated Case-Based Scenarios to Improve Learning Department of Health Professions College of Health & Public Affairs University of Central.

A quasi-experimental comparison of assessment feedback mechanisms Sven Venema School of Information and Communication Technology.

Integrating e-learning into your practice Stuart McGugan Educational Developer Centre for Lifelong Learning

IMG Supervision Explained Webinar. About GPSA GPSA is the national representative body that unites GP Supervisors by promoting recognition for supervision.

THE CBA ASSESSMENT CULTURE SURVEY The most important reason for the emphasis on assessment in the college is to meet AACSB and CSU requirements.

Evaluation Results Aug 28 Seminar. Question I 1. Instruction: Rate aspects of the workshop on a 1 to 5 scale by selecting the number corresponding to.

Mary Ann Cordeau PhD, RN. From participating in this presentation the participant should be able to: Define assessment and validation as they relate to.

Pilar Muñoz, José-Antonio González, Erik Cobo, Lluis Jover JORNADES D’INNOVACIÓ DOCENT A LA UPC: Presentació de resultats dels projectes MQD ICE 28/06/07.

CPSC 203 ITBL Project CPSC 203 ITBL Project Fall 2005-Fall 2006 Fall 2005-Fall 2006 Working with Haskayne School of Business Working with Haskayne School.

Lecture 1: IntroductionIntro to IT COSC1078 Introduction to Information Technology Lecture 2 Overview James Harland

TDG Report Illness scripts for improving clinical reasoning Anna Lee, Tony Gin, Charles Gomersall, Warwick Ngan Kee, Gavin Joynt, Anthony Ho, Juliana Chan,

Principles of Teaching and Learning in Clinical Settings Professor Hossam Hamdy University of Sharjah.

How was the course organized? Faculty present: Lectures, small groups, and labs. Students prepare: Problem-based learning issues, journal article reports,

A PRESCRIBING CURRICULUM FOR AUSTRALIAN MEDICAL STUDENTS Smith AJ, Hill SR,Tasioulas T,Cockayne NL. National Prescribing Service, Sydney & Clinical Pharmacology.

UIUC College of Medicine: Teaching Curriculum

Designing LAMS templates for medical education Bronwen Dalziel School of Medicine University of Western Sydney.

Measuring for Success Module Nine Instructions:

Assessment of Communication Skills in Medical Education

Pharmacology in Nursing Education Purpose of the Research  To evaluate the utility of web-based pharmacology modules on students’ acquisition of knowledge.

FITNESS IN COMPUTER EDUCATION. DISTANT EDUCATION.

Continuity Clinics as Medical Home Hawaii Dyson Initiative Louise Iwaishi, MD March 5, 2005 Hawaii Dyson Initiative.

Establishing Content Validity of a Novel Written Examination to Assess Medical Students on the Surgery Clerkship A Berlin MD, A Reinert BA, A Swan-Sein.

New Advanced Higher Subject Implementation Events Chemistry : Unit Assessment at Advanced Higher.

BY: KRIS M. IRWIN, PH.D. WARNELL SCHOOL OF FORESTRY & NATURAL RESOURCES THE UNIVERSITY OF GEORGIA NATIONAL PLT COORDINATORS CONFERENCE DEADWOOD, SOUTH.

eLearning Need a new challenge? Are you a highly motivated individual? Ready to apply your instructional skills in an eLearning environment? Are you comfortable.

/ 31 1 The 2nd Central Asian Medical Education Conference Karaganda, October, Integration of Learning Objectives.

Dr. Samar Sinno Amal Farhat Lebanese University Educational Measurement for Continuous Professional Development March 26 and 27, 2011 Broumana, Lebanon.

Oct. 11, 2011– May 8, 2012 Facilitators: Carol Mayer & Ginni Winters.

New Advanced Higher Subject Implementation Events Statistics Unit Assessment at Advanced Higher.

The Plenary The National Literacy Strategy The Plenary.

Qualifications Update: Psychology Qualifications Update: Psychology.

Unpacking the Elements of Scientific Reasoning Keisha Varma, Patricia Ross, Frances Lawrenz, Gill Roehrig, Douglas Huffman, Leah McGuire, Ying-Chih Chen,

Clinical Reasoning and Problem Solving

Maps: What they tell us Chris P. Daniels Geography Upper Cluster (EBD) Chris P. Daniels

Ian Yang 1, Barbara Swadling 2, Robin Bradbear 1, Laurel Hatfield 1, Peter Stride 1, Mark Livett 1, Morgan Wright 1, Peter Baker 2, Fiona Lake 4, Lisa.

INNOVATIVE LEARNING METHODS FOR RATIONAL DRUGS PRESCRIBING. ITTHIPANICPONG C.,CHOMPOOTAWEEP S., CHONGTRAKUL P., NANTAWAN P., THAMAREE S., WITTAYALERTPANYA.

Year 4 Report for Curriculum Day 2007 based on Year-4 Committee Meeting held Jun 2007.

Supporting the Net Generation Learner Professor Eeva Leinonen – Deputy Vice Chancellor.

Problem-based Learning Cherdsak Iramaneerat Department of Surgery Faculty of Medicine Siriraj Hospital 1PBL.

STUDY SKILLS COURSE MEDICAL EDUCATION DEPARTMENT COLLEGE OF MEDICINE.

Active learning –Students create, answer, discuss and rank questions –High student engagement –Benefits from large class numbers –Minimal instructor intervention.

Institutionalizing Quality Improvement in a Family Medicine Residency Fred Tudiver, MD East Tennessee State University.

Longitudinal assessment of a novel curriculum’s impact on attitudes about psychosocial issues in ob/gyn and surgery Jonathan Schaffir, MD; Nicole Verbeck,

15 th May 2008 Virtual Patients as a Tool for Assessment Presented to Medbiquitous Conference 2008 Presented by Emily Conradi, e-Projects Manager Jonathan.

Future Wars in Europe Sergiy Shtukarin. Presentation contents Summary of Content Educational Aims Learning Outcomes Module Evaluation Lecture Titles Seminar.

Generating and Testing Hypothesis Jose Razo. Description and Effect size The application of knowledge on to a certain topic or scenario and formulating.

Qualifications Update: Computing Science Qualifications Update: Computing Science.

Developing Clinical Skills using a Virtual Patient Simulator in a Resource-limited Setting G. Bediang, C. Perrin, M.A Raetzo et al. Medinfo 2013 (Copenhagen),

Applying Principles of Learning Diane Ebert-May Department of Plant Biology Michigan State University Assessment.

© University of California San Francisco Medical School Finding Clarity : Setting Goals and Expectations David Irby, PhD Amy Garlin, MD Brad Sharp, MD.

An Online Self-Directed Research Curriculum Adrienne A. Williams, PhD Shana O. Ntiri, MD, MPH.

Graduate Program Completer Evaluation Feedback 2008.

A Longitudinal Curriculum in Motivational Interviewing WT-04 Clara Keegan, MD University of Vermont Medical Center.

Undergraduate Students Experiences of Studying Nursing/Midwifery at NUI Galway Evelyn Byrne, Bróna Mooney, Frances Farrelly, Eimear Burke.

DEVELOPMENT OF AN ELEARNING PLATFORM ON CLINICAL EMBRYOLOGY FOR MEDICAL STUDENTS: A PILOT STUDY Dr.W.C.D.Karunaratne MBBS, MSc (BioMedical Informatics)

Patient safety: the undergraduate curriculum Dr Rona Patey Head of Division of Medical and Dental Education / Consultant Anaesthetist.

The Effect of Faculty Presence on Small-group Learning and Group Dynamics in a Family Medicine Clerkship Miriam Hoffman, MD; Joanne Wilkinson, MD; John.

Dr.Reem Al Khalifah Assistant professor Pediatric endocrinology Dr.Malak Al Ghamdi Assistant professor Genetic metabolic Course Coordinators:

Family Medicine Online Penn State College of Medicine Shou Ling Leong, MD Department of Family and Community Medicine Penn State College of Medicine.

Alice Fornari, Ed.D. Francesco Leanza, M.D. Janet Townsend, M.D.

Librarian Led Technology Sessions Participation in EBM Conference

Efficacy of asynchronous teaching (flipped classroom) model in point-of-care ultrasound for medical students and first year emergency medicine residents:

Jacob Prunuske, MD, MSPH STFM Predoc 2009

Beat Steiner, MD, MPH Lisa Slatt, MEd

Appropriate Use of Formative Assessment in a Lecture-Based Course

VIRTUAL/REMOTE LABS By Dr. Sandip Kumar Raut Lecturer in Tabla

Enquiry Based Learning (EBL) and Human Rights

Presentation transcript:

TDG 2008 Report Illness scripts for improving clinical reasoning Anna Lee, Tony Gin, Charles Gomersall, Warwick Ngan Kee, Gavin Joynt, Anthony Ho, Juliana Chan, Lex Vlantis, James Griffith, William Wong, Coleman Fung

Project objectives To develop and implement a teaching module to improve 4 th year medical students’ clinical reasoning skills To assess students’ level of clinical reasoning skills

Teaching intervention (Feb 2008) Rotation to 4 th year Family Medicine module Short lecture on clinical reasoning and illness script theory (0.5h) Small group work on “problem representation” using thinking aloud approach with teacher (1.5h) Individual guided computer work using clinical reasoning scenarios (1.5h)

Example of clinical reasoning problem Pull down menus

Deliverables Developed and debugged a web-based clinical reasoning scoring system using clinical scenarios from University of Queensland that were previously validated against GPs Developed workshop materials (tutors and students manuals) Conducted workshop in Feb 2008 Assessed effectiveness of workshop at end of CFM rotation in April 2008

Assessing students’ learning outcome StudentsBegin rotationTeaching packageEnd of rotation InterventionDiagnostic Thinking Inventory (25 min online) Clinical reasoningDiagnostic Thinking Inventory + clinical reasoning scenarios on web (2 hours) ControlDiagnostic Thinking Inventory (25 min online) Self-directed learning Diagnostic Thinking Inventory + clinical reasoning scenarios on web (2 hours)

Diagnostic Thinking Inventory P=0.64

Clinical reasoning problem score P<0.001

Student feedback with Workshop StatementMedian (IQR)* The “thinking aloud” approach was helpful for improving my clinical reasoning skill 5(5-5) Completing the web-based clinical scenarios helped improved my clinical reasoning 5(5-6) Overall, I am satisfied with the course5(5-6) *1=strongly disagree to 6=strongly agree

Conclusions Certain aspects of clinical reasoning improved Identification and interpretation of relevant clinical features and hypothesis generation improved BUT inconclusive about improving flexibility of thinking and organization of knowledge