Summarizing as Retrieval Strategy versus Re-reading. Which Learning Activity Works Best? Kim. J. H. Dirkx, Liesbeth Kester, and Paul. A. Kirschner Centre.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Timothy Shanahan University of Illinois at Chicago onliteracy.com 10 KEYS TO HIGHER LITERACY ACHIEVEMENT: SOME DOS AND DON’TS.

Advertisements

How does this support the Common Core Standards? Common Core Standards (CCS): 1. Cite strong and thorough textual evidence to support analysis of what.

ITEC 715 Week 13 Computer Foundations for Instructional Multimedia.

Training Objectives.

Improving Learning Results for Every Student.  Students with disabilities are challenged in comprehending expository texts (on and below grade level).

Analytical Thinking and Writing In All Subject Areas Expository Text Structure: Cause-Effect.

REVISED BLOOM’S TAXONOMY BY FAIZA RANI DA MHS PHASE- IV REVISED BLOOM’S TAXONOMY BY FAIZA RANI DA MHS PHASE- IV.

Making It Stick: The Science of Successful Learning and Memory Roddy Roediger Science of Learning Education Writers Association May 1, 2015.

Bloom’s Taxonomy Evaluation and Planning. Do Now  Why are elderly people being denied Swine Flu vaccines?  In what ways have hospital workers’ and.

Mr. Vivek Bindra Director - Global ACT

Designing Competency Based Training with Bloom’s Taxonomy Michele B. Medved Learning in the News

What would I tell the staff? Literacy PD with Ken Kilpin Thursday 22/08/2013.

Comprehension Strategy Routine Cards

2008 History and Social Science Standards of Learning: Using Student Engagement To Support Active Learning and Assessment January 2013.

CSR strategy (modified) R.A.M. strategy extended.

At the end of my physics course, a biology student should be able to…. Michelle Smith University of Maine School of Biology and Ecology Maine Center for.

Preview Strategy Before you read – Brainstorm and Predict 1. Think about the topic of the passage. 2. Write down everything you already know on the Learning.

Workshop#9 Reading Part II Strategies on how to read for comprehension Presented by Garine Palandjian.

 Increasing the amount of hours spent studying and doing homework on a daily basis  Increasing the amount of work completed while studying on a daily.

1 Focusing on the FCAT Test-Taking Strategies Grades 3-5 Nancy E. Brito, Department of Assessment , PX47521 Information.

Please check, just in case…. Announcements: Office hour appointments filling up – get yours today! Don’t delay on getting started on next TWO assignments.

Bloom's Taxonomy: The Sequel (What the Revised Version Means for You!)

Search and Comprehension Processes in Learning from Text Cerdán, R., Vidal-Abarca, E., Gil, L., Gilabert, R., & Martínez, T. University of Valencia.

Working Memory Capacity and Mobile Multimedia Learning Environments: Individual Differences in Learning While Mobile Adviser : Min-Puu Chen Presenter:

CSR: A READING STRATEGY. RESEARCH PROCESS Google  Teacher Vision  Google  Klingner & Vaughn article.

Day 3. Standards Reading: 1.0 Word Analysis, Fluency, and Systematic Vocabulary Development- Students apply their knowledge of word origins to determine.

HOTS = Higher Order Thinking Skills

AP Language and Composition Mr. Eble

MTSS & Formative Assessment Mitch Fowler August 2013

What Am I Reading? Presented by Garine Palandjian

The Effects of Generative Testing on Text Retention and Text Comprehension Kim J. H. Dirkx, Liesbeth Kester, Paul A. Kirschner Centre for Learning Sciences.

Presented by Denise Tarlinton Pupil Free Day Monday 14 July, 2003.

Strategic Reading Step 2 SCAN. Review from yesterday Preview- practice with Hamlet Oedipal Complex.

Using Reading Strategies Houghton-Mifflin Reading Back to School Grade 3.

Column #1 In the left column, they can write their predictions. Especially when you first use this organizer, have students focus on some of the basic.

Does this learning goal focus on what the student will do? Objective: Conservation of energy A.Yes B.No C.Depends on context.

METACOGNITION MAN Super-Powerful Reading Strategies!

The Reading Process English I Notes. The Reading Process / consists of 3 steps / Before / During / After / complete activities before reading to set the.

Thursday, December 6, 2012  Sentence Combining  Comparison Writing  Honors: Summary  Homework: Read for AR, Exercise 2 (1-5)

Writing a Critical Essay Standard Grade Points to Note Your essay is a response to a specific task – you MUST focus on this task! Avoid simply retelling.

MH502: Developing Mathematical Proficiency, Geometry and Measurement, K-5 Seminar 1 September 28, 2010.

Literacy Lesson 4: “On My Own” Short Writing Tasks November 18, Period 1.

Reciprocal Teaching Organizer Predicting: I think ___________will happen because__________________________________________________________ _______________.

Student Objectives Students will determine the meaning of unknown words using context clues. Students will utilize GO/Short ACT -like English passages.

Literacy Lesson 3: Reading Response Questions

Bringing “Buds into Bloom’s” Creating a garden of higher level thinking Presented By Linda Romano Newburgh Enlarged City School District.

Workshop#4 Reading to Read Tips on how to read for understanding.

Our Norms Delay distractions Problems come with solutions Presume positive intentions Take responsibility for your own learning & growth One Big Red,

1 Focusing on the FCAT Test-Taking Strategies Grades 6-8 Nancy E. Brito, Department of Assessment , PX47521

1 Focusing on the FCAT Test-Taking Strategies Grades 9-11 Nancy E. Brito, Department of Assessment , PX47521

1. RUN ON SENTENCES 2. INCOMPLETE SENTENCES 3. PAST/PRESENT TENSE CONFUSION Summaries- General Observations Friday October 14th.

Classroom Strategies That Work. Questions, Cues, and Advance Organizers Helping Students Activate Prior Knowledge.

Traditional vs. Alternative Assessment Assessment is the process of finding out how well students have mastered the curriculum.

Welcome to Watauga County Schools Professional Development High School Healthful Living and Physical Education March 15 th and 16th.

Data Structure Visualization Vikrant Colaso Kunal Garach Anuj Shah.

Differentiating with Bennie Farrell Boone Kristen Kluka Kim Laughary Todd Noorman.

We asked several hundred students about which study strategies they used on a regular basis. The top 11 answers are on the board.

U2 – KU120 Pre-Reading Strategies Angela Lavine, PhD.

Spaced learning and retrieval practice for robust learning

85. BLOOM’S TAXONOMY “Bloom’s Taxonomy is a guide to educational learning objectives. It is the primary focus of most traditional education.”

Critical Reading Charting the Text.

Chapter 8 Using secondary data

H.O.T. Questions High Order Thinking Questions

Reciprocal Teaching By J. Thorne Summer 2011.

Reciprocal Teaching: Strategies for Improving Reading Comprehension

Understanding, Explaining, and Evaluating sources

Chapter 8 Using secondary data

Bloom's Taxonomy Talking Round Corners Creating Evaluating Analysing

“Day E” April 30, :51 - 8:51 Math 8:53 - 9:53 Science

Presentation transcript:

Summarizing as Retrieval Strategy versus Re-reading. Which Learning Activity Works Best? Kim. J. H. Dirkx, Liesbeth Kester, and Paul. A. Kirschner Centre for Learning Sciences and Technologies Open University of the Netherlands

The Testing Effect Roediger and Karpicke (2006)

The Testing Effect Long research history (Gates, 1917; Rothkopf, 1960; Spitzer, 1939) Wordlists of unrelated wordpairs In 2006 renewed interest for the testing effect (Roediger and Karpicke, 2006) Since then also interest for learning from expository texts and ecological settings But still focus on retention of factual information/ verbatim text However………

The Testing Effect and Modern Education Creating Evaluating Analysing Applying Understanding Remembering Bloom et al., 1956

Research Question Can the testing effect be replicated for more higher order learning goals (i.e., understanding/comprehension) using summarization as retrieval activity?

Method and Procedure 32 fourth-year secondary school students Within-subject design 2 expository texts (± 500 words) General Question test with 10 questions (Andre, 1979)

Method and Procedure Learning PhaseTest Phase Read text 1 (6 minutes) Sudoku puzzle Re-read or Summarize text 1 (6 minutes) Sudoku Read text 2 (6 minutes) Sudoku puzzle Re-read or Summarize text 2 (6 minutes) General question tests (10 questions; 12 minutes)

Examples In order to measure comprehension a general question test was constructed using the categorization of Andre (1979). The questions required participants to combine information from more than one idea unit. Question 1: ‘Explain how the liver can recover from steatohepatitis’. Question 2: ‘The author says in the text that people often eat more food than they need. Can you explain why this surplus food is stored and not excreted?’

Scoring Relevant Idea Units Expert summary; Divided in Idea Units; How much of these Idea Units were included in the students’ summaries? Post Test Idea Units All Idea Units of the general questions test; How much of these Idea Units were included in the students’ summaries?

Results (1) Figure 1. Mean number of idea units retrieved during summarization

Results (2) Figure 2. Mean general question test score

Discussion The summaries of students were of low quality (verbatim) Initial retrieval was low Might training help? Do students need more time? Or is the testing effect not applicable to higher order learning goals?

I invite you to attend my EARLI presentation When: Today; o’clock Where: Building 1, Seminar Room F What: A presentation of my 2nd study in which we trained students, gave them more time and also investigated the effect on traditional learning goals (knowledge)