EPA: EUROPEAN PRACTICE ASSESSMENT Researcher: Yvonne Engels Project leader: Richard Grol Co-ordinator: Maaike Dautzenberg Financed by: Bertelsmann foundation.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

National manuals Kick-off meeting on Joint Action on the pilot EHES, Luxembourg, 21 January 2010.

Advertisements

Planning and preparing the national HES EHES Training seminar, Rome 11 February 2010 Päivikki Koponen.

Aim of programme to apply the principles of risk management to practical situations and relate these to personal experiences to improve the quality of.

Corporate Records Management (Practitioner) Information Governance Policy Team NHS Connecting for Health.

Corporate Records Management (Practitioner) Information Governance Policy Team NHS Connecting for Health.

Mass Shelter Capability Project

BREAKING THE TABOO I and II – Violence against older women families: recognizing and acting Empowering staff in community health and social services –

Role & Qualities of a Practice Manager. Essential qualities? The thick skin of a Rhino The wisdom of Solomon The patience of Jobe The speed of Superman.

Managing the Performance of Homecare Medicines Services Jane Kelly, Procurement Project Pharmacist Mick Butterfield, Specialist Technician: Homecare Medicines.

AcoRD Implementation Amber O’Malley, CRN Funding and Contracts Manager & AcoRD Business Lead.

Health Line of Business Revised Health Domains January 26, 2005 Outcomes / Domains have been revised.

Laboratory Personnel Dr/Ehsan Moahmen Rizk.

‘Best Practice’ in Police Training? ‘Best Practice’ in Police Training? J. Francis-Smythe, University College Worcester INTRODUCTION.

Home Care Monitoring Guy Pettengell, Head of Operational Contracts.

Clinical Care Pathways (CCCP): Magic or Maze? Norah Bostock Operations Manager: Governance.

Clinical Audit How to make it work Clinical Audit Department Last revised July 2009.

STRATEGIC PLANNING, LEADERSHIP AND IMPLEMENTATION FOR PATIENT SAFETY Michele McKinnon Director, Safety and Quality SA HEALTH.

Surviving Survey and Re-certification. Rural Mississippi Mississippi Stats ◦116 Hospitals ◦154 RHC’s (MSDH website) ◦28 CAH’s (35miles or “necessary.

Nurse Staffing in New Hampshire Implementing a Nurse Staffing Committee NH Staffing Toolkit July 2010.

Assessing child-well-being: perspectives and experiences of Health Behaviour in School- Aged Children (HBSC) Study A World Health Organization Cross- National.

Patient Centered Medical Home What it means for Duffy Health Center Board Presentation September 10 th 2012.

WHAT IS “CLASS”? A BRIEF ORIENTATION TO THE CLASS METHODOLOGY.

CLINICAL GOVERNANCE and MI Services : An introduction National MI Training Course University of Leicester 5 th July 2007 Mark Cheeseman E ast Anglia MI.

 Your name, in what capacity you are here today (work/church/personal interest) and …  What interested you about this workshop or what question would.

Development of Clinical Practice Guidelines for the NHS Dr Jacqueline Dutchak, Director National Collaborating Centre for Acute Care 16 January 2004.

WP5 Outpatient and Home care WP Leader Prof. John Hutton Dept. Health Sciences and York Health Economics Consortium.

Module 5: Quality assurance. What is a quality assurance system? A quality assurance system measures the performance of a service against a range of standards.

Module 3. Session DCST Clinical governance

Future research directions for patient safety in primary care Michel Wensing Wim Verstappen Sander Gaal.

European Supervisory Bodies and Patient Safety Presented by Sandra Eismann (CQC)

Patient Safety in Primary Care The Linneaus Collaboration www. linneaus-pc.eu Aneez Esmail Professor of General Practice University of Manchester (UK)

Studying Quality and Safety in European Hospitals - QUASER 9 th June, 2010 Prof Naomi Fulop Dr. Janet Anderson NIHR King’s Patient Safety and Service Quality.

Unit 1 – Preparation for Assessment LO 1.1&1.2&1.3.

Coordinating Care Sierra Dulaney Lisa Fassett Morgan Little McKenzie McManus Summer Powell Jackie Richardson.

Organisation, Management and Leadership Workshop Sept 2015.

NEAR PATIENT TESTING, DAWN UPGRADE AND INTO THE COMMUNITY IN THREE MONTHS NEAR PATIENT TESTING, DAWN UPGRADE AND INTO THE COMMUNITY IN THREE MONTHS Barts.

EUROCHIP-2 EUROCHIP-2 - The Action Public Health Program EUROPEAN COMMISSION: HEALTH & CONSUMER PROTECTION DIRECTORATE-GENERAL.

Newry & Mourne District Council An Applicant’s Perspective Eddie Newell Senior Building Control Surveyor Building Control Department.

Tynemouth Medical Practice Patient Forum Meeting

Improving Nutrition on the Wards Nutrition and Patient Safety Implementing the 10 Key Characteristics of Good Nutritional Care.

Organization and guideline development April 2010 ACCC The Netherlands.

Understanding general practice Edzell patient group presentation 11 th June 2013.

Health Needs Assessment and Quality Improvement Dr Luc Seuntjens.

Delivering Equality & Diversity Training on-line Glynis Bakker Educational Systems Manager.

Unpacking and Implementing Training Packages Linda Hopkins.

D1.HRD.CL9.06 D1.HHR.CL8.07 D2.TRD.CL8.09 Slide 1.

BMH CLINICAL GUIDELINES IN EUROPE. OUTLINE Background to the project Objectives The AGREE Instrument: validation process and results Outcomes.

Integration of General Practice in Health services Doris Young Professor of General Practice.

4th Quality Conference (4QC) Impact Assessment Study Rui Sousa, PhD Catholic University of Portugal Lisbon, 16 July 2007.

Guidelines Recommandations. Role Ideal mediator for bridging between research findings and actual clinical practice Ideal tool for professionals, managers,

Partnership Health: Evaluation and possibilities for an adapted structure Agenda item 11 Madhavi Bajekal, ONS (UK) PH coordinator Directors of Social Statistics.

Documenting (Driving) Progress in Immunization Injection Safety Philippe Duclos, WHO Presented at the SIGN annual meeting, Cairo, Egypt, Oct th,

Primary Care in The Netherlands: General Practitioners in the Lead Jako Burgers, MD, PhD Dutch College of General Practitioners Common Wealth Fund Webinar.

SUPPORTING PEOPLE PROVIDER FORUMS An overview of Supporting People’s new approach to Performance Monitoring and Quality Assurance.

1 6 th National Children & Young People Survivorship Workshop A GP perspective Una Macleod Professor of Primary Care Medicine Primary care cancer lead,

Dr Sharma’s Practice Patient Participation Group 12 th March 2012.

Learning from patients’ experience Angela Coulter Picker Institute Europe Angela Coulter Picker Institute Europe

QAA COLLABORATIVE PROVISION AUDIT DRAFT REPORT. QAA CPA Process Submission by the University of Self Evaluation Document (SED) (December 2005) Selection.

An Overview on Risk Management

Primary Care Stratified Follow-up of Stable Prostate Cancer Patients

12. Role of national and international technical and funding partners in the implementation of aDSM Multi-partner training package on active TB drug safety.

Lehigh Valley Health Network: Community Care Team Compact

Responses were received from:

Supporting learners with special needs or disabilities through inclusive education RIGA 2 June 2015.

Protecting and improving the nation’s health

REPORTING ON DELIVERY OF EU BIODIVERSITY ACTION PLAN

Primary Medical Care Advisory Team

EuroNHID project Scientific Contents

Video consultations 6 initial steps for setting up video outpatient clinics Clinical team expresses an interest in setting up and are directed to facilitator.

Presentation transcript:

EPA: EUROPEAN PRACTICE ASSESSMENT Researcher: Yvonne Engels Project leader: Richard Grol Co-ordinator: Maaike Dautzenberg Financed by: Bertelsmann foundation Germany

Collaboration Belgium (Flanders), France, Germany, Switzerland, the Netherlands, UK (Wales and England) Bertelsmann Foundation

Aim to develop a practice assessment method that assists family/general practitioners in improving their practice performance

Methods: 1.Literature review 2.Workshops with partners 3.Consensus procedures - with EPA-partners - Delphi 4.Pilot

Good practice management: “Systems (structures and processes) meant to enable the delivery of good quality patient care”

Framework 1.Infrastructure 2.Staff 3.Information 4.Finance 5.Quality and safety

170 indicators, e.g.: Domain:INFRASTRUCTURE Dimension:medical equipment Indicator:The emergency bag is complete

Modified Rand procedure 170 indicators Translation of the draft set of indicators Delphi procedure Rated by 10 GPs / experts in 6 countries

Indicators rated ‘useful’ (of 168) By all countries 62(37%) France103(61%) Germany103(61%) Swiss116(69%) Belgium121(72%) Netherlands125(74%) England/Wales142(85%)

Exercise 1 Which indicators do you rate useful? (groups of about 6 persons, preferably from different countries

A. Information for patients about clinical care: 0 1.An up-to-date selection of books and videos is available to patients 2.A range of leaflets and brochures is available for patients to read in the practice or to take home 3.Translator services are available on request 4.Information leaflets are available in appropriate languages 5.The practice information sheet is available in appropriate languages

B. Non-medical equipment: 4 1.The practice has an operational fax 2.The practice has at least one computer for staff 3.The practice has an internet connection 4.All computers are protected against inappropriate access 5.Every GP has access to 6.Every GP has access to the internet (www) 7.The practice has a telephone system with sufficient inward and outward capacity 8.The practice has a separate emergency telephone line 9.All electronical medical equipment is checked annually 10.All safety equipment (e.g. fire extinguisher) is checked annually

C. Detection of quality and safety problems: 0 1.The practice has undertaken at least one clinical audit in the last year 2.The practice has a critical incident register 3.The practice has a documented process to follow up and analyse critical incidents 4.The practice has a formal consultation process with patients (patient forum or participation group) 5.The practice has a suggestion box for patients 6.The practice has a written patient complaint procedure 7.The written patient complaint procedure is available at the reception

D. Working conditions: 2 1.The practice monitors the workload of its staff 2.The practice monitors stress levels of its staff 3.The practice evaluates team working in the organisation 4.The practice has had at least one away day last year 5.Staff experience a pleasant working atmosphere 6.The practice has a policy which enables staff to offer suggestions for improving practice management 7.The practice has written arrangements to ensure the availability of a locum GP when needed

The Instrument Short self-administered questionnaires: 1.Representative of the practice 2.individual GPs 3.staff members 4.Patients Observer/facilitator visits the practice: 6.Structured interview with GP/PM 7.Checklist 8.(Maturity Matrix)

The pilot Pretest in 3 practices per country September 2003-May 2004: Pilot in 30 practices per country, also in Slovenia, Austria and Israel

Result of the pilot Feedback on individual practice level National data International comparisons.

Visotool/ Startbildschirm

Online-Feedback Basisdaten der Praxis (insgesamt 4 Bildschirmseiten)

Ergebnisse/Dimensionen (Bsp. Infrastruktur: Übersicht)

Ergebnisse/Dimensionen (Bsp. Infrastruktur: Streudiagramm)

To Do list (example)

Patient participation (%) complaint procedure Belgium 3 France 3 Germany 25 Netherlands 75 Switzerland 25 UK 100 Slovenia 77 Austria 55

Survey patient satisfaction (%) (n) Belgium (31)23 France (17) 3 Germany (32)39 Netherlands (32)38 Switzerland (28)64 UK (27)85 Slovenia (31)53 Austria (33)24

Europep GPPractice Belgium (31)9185 France (17)8572 Germany (32)8483 Netherlands (32)8572 Switzerland (28)9190 UK (27)8169 Slovenia (31)9087 Austria (33)9391

Leaflets (%) pract. inf. Belgium41 France42 Germany55 Netherlands88 Switzerland48 England 87 Slovenia48 Austria27

Medical registration ICPC etc Belgium52 France 24 Germany 100 Netherlands87 Switzerland 29 UK 100 Slovenia 100 Austria 12

Patient list (%) Belgium (31) 81 France (29) 0 Germany (32) 0 Netherlands (32)100 Switzerland (28) 74 UK (27)100 Slovenia (31)100 Austria (33) 0

System for recalling patients with: AsthmaDiabetesCHD Belgium France Germany Netherlands Switzerland UK Slovenia Austria

System for recalling populations at risk: CHD Influenza vacc Belgium France 0 0 Germany16 41 Netherlands Switzerland 7 68 UK Slovenia Austria 0 0

Exercise 2 Discuss in small groups: Do general practices in your country have systems to recall A.patients with specific chronic diseases? Why (not)? B.Populations at risk? Why (not)?

What next? Validation of the instrument: (acceptable, feasible, valid, sensitive) Adapted version: next year International data warehouse

EPA-book: January (information Visotool)