PECHAN 2018 SO 2 Emissions Evaluation for Non-Utility Sources Jim Wilson and Andy Bollman E.H. Pechan & Associates, Inc. Presentation to WRAP Stationary.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Presentation to the Florida Public Service Commission November 29, 2007.

Advertisements

Maine Electricity and Waste Sector Overview The Center for Clean Air Policy January 28, 2004.

U.S. Energy Information Administration Independent Statistics & Analysis Annual Energy Outlook 2014 Early Release Reference Case AEO2014 Early.

Short-Term and Winter Fuels Outlook Guy F. Caruso Administrator Energy Information Administration New York Energy Forum New York, NY October 16,

Identification of BART-Eligible Sources in the WRAP Region A Summary of the April 4, 2005 Draft Report.

1 Co-Product Function Expansion A Methodology for Incrementally Considering the Effects of Co-Products in Multi-Product Systems Paul Worhach, Ph.D. InLCA/LCM.

Professor: Jeffery Perl Mentor: Dennis O’Brien Team Members: Jinrong Chen, Kei Simmel, Hantao Wang, Marzena Zarycki Scribe: Kei Simmel.

The BART Process by Kathy Kaufman and Joe Kordzi September 1, 2005 EPA Region 6.

SEDS Macroeconomic Module Alan H. Sanstad, LBNL May 7, 2009.

VT Department of Forests, Parks & Recreation Wood Energy in Vermont January 2005 VT Department of Forests, Parks & Recreation.

BART-Eligible Sources in the WRAP Region Stationary Sources Joint Forum Meeting November 14-15, 2006 Tempe, AZ.

Slide title Industrial Natural Gas Demand. Slide title The factors affecting EIA’s industrial natural gas consumption forecast  GDP;  Employment; 

U.S. Energy Information Administration Independent Statistics & Analysis The U.S. Natural Gas and Shale Production Outlook for North American.

Advanced Biomass-based Combined Heat and Power System Combined Heat & Power in the Pacific Northwest October 15, 2002 Nathan E. Carpenter Manager, Energy.

Sulfur Emission Trends and Forecast Data compiled, analyzed, and presented by: Chris Bamat Sandy Fergus Ryan Mackin Chris Rolland Presented on May 1, 2006.

THE NATIONAL CLIMATE CHANGE RESPONSE POLICY Mitigation System National Climate Change Response Policy 26 May 2015.

Steven Jay Mueller, President International WoodFuels

Western States Air Quality Study Modeling and Analysis of Oil & Gas Emissions Data University of North Carolina (UNC-IE) ENVIRON International Corporation.

CANADA’S REPORT ON ENERGY SUPPLY AND DEMAND Energy Balances Gary Smalldridge, Chief, Energy Section, Manufacturing and Energy Division May 2009.

Environmental Energy Technologies NEMSinternettalk ppt Re-estimating the Annual Energy Outlook 2000 Forecast Using Updated Assumptions about the.

Air Emission Benefits of CHP Air Innovations Conference August 10, 2004 Joel Bluestein Energy and Environmental Analysis, Inc. Prepared under contract.

Canada’s National Greenhouse Gas Inventory Presentation to the Oslo Group February 2009 Frank Neitzert, P. Eng Chief, Energy Section Greenhouse Gas Division.

NEW SOURCE REVIEW A Perspective from the Forest Products Sector September 2003 Tammy R. Wyles Director, Environmental Affairs.

Copenhagen, 9 february 2006 Combining different data sources in GHG inventories Joost Huurman, Statistics Netherlands.

Emissions Trading Dr. Ken Macken. Emissions Trading Directive The Directive was approved by the European Parliament on 2 July 2003, and by the Council.

STATIONARY FUEL CELLS Economics 101 Jane Price Hill, P. E.February 13, 2003.

1 Austria‘s emission projections Stephan Poupa & Melanie Sporer, 10th Mai 2010.

1 BART in California WRAP Stationary Sources Joint Forum November 15-16, 2006 Tempe, Arizona Air Resources Board California Environmental Protection Agency.

Stakeholders’ Meeting of the Malé Declaration 14 th October 2005, Delhi Compilation of emissions inventories using the Malé Declaration Emission inventory.

Technology Response to the Science and Policy of Climate Change Carey R. Butler, PE, PMP Executive Director, Energy Programs KeyLogic Systems, Inc. With.

WESTCARB Annual Meeting October Portland Oregon Panel 1 CO 2 Sources, Geologic Characterization, and Sink Screening Characterization of WESTCARB.

Gas-Electric System Interface Study OPSI Annual Meeting October 8, 2013 Raleigh, North Carolina.

Lecture Objectives: Finish with example modeling problems –Phase change thermal storage materials –Energy and airflow Interpret energy simulation results.

Natural Gas Update: EIA NARUC Winter Meeting Barbara Mariner-Volpe, Energy Information Administration February 23, 2003.

WRAP States Four Factor Reasonable Progress Lee Gribovicz WRAP IWG Meeting March 10, 2009.

Preliminary Evaluation of Data for Reasonable Progress Montana RH FIP Laurel Dygowski, EPA Region 8 IWG Meeting – April 2007.

April 19, 2004 International Energy Outlook 2004 Guy Caruso Administrator Energy Information Administration Thirty-First Annual International Energy Conference.

Electric Utility Greenhouse Gas Emissions Reduction Initial Rule Development Workshop August 22, 2007 Department of Environmental Protection Division of.

Petroleum Supply and Market Outlook Briefing for the 7 th Annual International Airport Operations/Jet Fuel Conference Orlando, Florida Mike Burdette Petroleum.

SSJF/EF/TDDWG Point and Area EI Project: Review of 2018 Base Case Emissions Projections Emissions Forum Meeting February 7, 2006.

1 WRAP Oil & Gas Phase II Work Plan: 2002 and 2018 Area Source Inventory Improvements and Area Source Controls Evaluation WRAP Stationary Sources Forum.

Non-Utility Floor Allocation for Sulfur Dioxide May 21, 2002 Presentation to the WRAP Market Trading Forum.

Market Trading Forum Update Ira Domsky and Colleen Delaney, Co-chairs.

Status of BART Analyses Implementation Workgroup Meeting April 17, 2007.

WRAP Emission Inventory Status For the Attribution of Haze Project Workgroup Presented by Jeffrey Stocum Oregon DEQ Emissions Inventory Specialist as a.

BART SIP Development: Example from Colorado Rocky Mountain National Park WRAP IWG Meeting, Denver, CO August 29, 2007 Presented by: Ray Mohr and Curt Taipale.

Energy Issues and the Impacts on Freight Transportation Dr. Mark Rodekohr Energy Information Administration May 17, 2006.

U.S. Energy Information Administration Independent Statistics & Analysis Outlook for shale gas and tight oil development in the U.S. For American.

Dutch Reference Outlook Energy and Greenhouse Gases Remko Ybema, ECN Policy Studies Workshop on Energy-related National and EU-Wide Projections.

Application of Fuel Characteristic Classification System to Ph II EI (add-on task to Inter RPO project) Fire Emissions Joint Forum Meeting Spokane, WA.

CHP Project Costs Screening Public Utility Commission of Ohio Public Utility Commission of Ohio Combined Heat and Power: Financial.

Workshop on the Criteria to establish projections scenarios Sectoral projection guidance: energy industries; combustion in manufacturing and construction;

11 Regional Renewable Energy Study Review of Findings and Forecasts Presented to: Climate, Energy and Environment and Policy Committee Metropolitan Washington.

Workshop on the Criteria to establish projections scenarios Sectoral projection guidance: industrial processes Mario Contaldi, TASK-GHG Emanuele Peschi,

ENERGY & CLIMATE ASSESSMENT TEAM National Risk Management Research Laboratory U.S. Environmental Protection Agency Office of Research.

Boiler Operations, Maintenance and Performance Conference.

Workshop on the Criteria to establish projections scenarios Sectoral projection guidance: Residential and services Mario Contaldi, TASK-GHG Emanuele Peschi,

1 Glen Sweetnam Energy Information Administration Houston, Texas November 16, 2007 Outlook for North American Natural Gas Demand.

Pennsylvania Electric Supply GHG Forecast 1 Victoria Clark Stockholm Environment Institute - US Center 5/29/09.

FORECASTED ENERGY CONSUMPTON AND PEAK DEMAND FOR MARYLAND Summer Reliability Status Conference State of Maryland Public Service Commission May 10, 2004.

Sixth Northwest Conservation & Electric Power Plan Draft Wholesale Power Price Forecasts Maury Galbraith Generating Resource Advisory Committee Meeting.

US I/O Model(s) and the integration with other data sets Gregory A. Norris Sylvatica / Harvard University / U. New Hampshire USA.

Revisions to the Rhode Island GHG Emissions Draft Baseline Charles Heaps Stockholm Environment Institute - U.S. Center 11 Curtis Avenue Somerville, MA.

Overview of WRAP Emissions Projections

CURRENT STATUS AND ISSUES OF THE KOREAN EMISSION TRADING SCHEME

Growth and Control for LADCO Round2 Modeling

Illinois Climate Change Advisory Group (ICCAG) Modeling Sub-group An introduction to ENERGY 2020 April 26, 2007.

Ontario’s New System to Price Industrial Pollution Emissions Performances Standards (EPS) March 15, 2019.

2018 SO2 Emissions Evaluation for Non-Utility Sources

Stationary Source NOx and PM Report: An Update Lee Alter Western Governors’ Association WRAP Market Trading Forum Meeting September 19-20, 2002 Snowbird,

Presentation transcript:

PECHAN 2018 SO 2 Emissions Evaluation for Non-Utility Sources Jim Wilson and Andy Bollman E.H. Pechan & Associates, Inc. Presentation to WRAP Stationary Sources Joint Forum Meeting August 2006 E.H. Pechan & Associates, Inc.

PECHAN 2 Presentation Outline  Study Purpose  Methods Summary  Sector-by-Sector Analysis  Overall Results  Findings

PECHAN 3 Study Purpose  Update the SO 2 emission milestones for the 309 States  Non-utility source focus  Milestone sources >100 tpy SO 2 in 2004 at the facility-level

PECHAN 4 Methods Summary  Starting point – 2018 SSJF-sponsored emission projections  MS Excel files posted on SSJF/ projections site »2002 emissions »Growth and control factors »Equation to estimate 2018 emissions  Revised base year emissions to 2004 values where needed

PECHAN 5 Methods Summary (Part 2)  Revised SO 2 emissions and algorithms  Consulted with States/sources  Evaluated economic basis for growth factors  Industry consultations  Revisions made

PECHAN 6 Sectors Versus States States SectorsArizonaNew MexicoOregonUtahWyoming Copper smeltersxxx Lime Manufacturingxx Pulp/paperxx Oil/gasxxx Chemicalsx Refiningxxx Cementxx xx

PECHAN 7 Copper Smelter SO 2 Emission Projections StateFacility Name ERG 2018 Pechan ArizonaASARCO-Hayden18,43834,49021,000 Phelps Dodge-Miami6,8049,84810,000 UtahKennecott Utah9391,6901,000 Total26,18146,02832,000

PECHAN 8 Petroleum Refining  Retirement/replacement algorithm for SO 2 only affects FCCU and industrial boiler emissions  FCCU emissions not represented for 7 of 11 refineries  Pechan allocated SO 2 emissions to FCCUs and revised projections

PECHAN 9 Oil and Gas Production  Issue 1: Volatility in SO2 emissions »Solution: Data review – industry consultation – information exchanges  Issue 2: Regional – State – Sub-state allocation of expected activity growth

PECHAN 10 Oil and Gas Production Emissions Volatility Example: Dynegy Eunice Gas Plant (NM) Permit Limit (1,226 tpy)

PECHAN 11 Emission Activity Projections  Emission Process Specific »Fuel Combustion – improve upon Annual Energy Outlook (AEO) sector specificity »Non-Fuel Combustion – replace industry sector $ sales forecasts with forecast of emission activity

PECHAN 12 Non-Fuel Combustion  Petroleum Refineries »Previous – Total Petroleum Products Supply (national) »New – no change (stakeholder dialogue on validity of AEO regional refining capacity forecasts)

PECHAN 13 Non-Fuel Combustion (cont’d)  Oil and Gas Production »Previous – when available, local new well forecast from Resource Management Plans (RMPs) combined with historic well closure rate; otherwise, regional AEO projections »New – RMP-based projections replaced with AEO growth (milestone sources only)

PECHAN 14 Non-Fuel Combustion (cont’d)  Pulp and Paper »Previous – forecast state-level $ sales in Pulp, Paper, and Paperboard Mills sector »New – U.S. Forest Service forecast of pulpwood receipts at West region Pulp mills

PECHAN 15 Non-Fuel Combustion (cont’d)  Chemicals (Phosphate Fertilizer) »Previous – SCC specific (e.g., $ sales in Concrete, Gypsum, and Plaster Products sector) »New – no growth assumption reflecting phosphate rock production info

PECHAN 16 Non-Fuel Combustion (cont’d)  Cement Manufacturing »Previous – equation relating total $ sales to national cement production »New – national cement production forecast (Portland Cement Assoc) and Pechan regional prodn. share forecast

PECHAN 17 Fuel Combustion  Previous Approach »SCC-specific growth indicators from EGAS (AEO energy forecasts). Major limitation is inventory SCC is often generic Industrial, Commercial, or Electric Utility fuel combustion

PECHAN 18 Fuel Combustion (cont’d)  New Approach »Composite of non-fuel combustion growth and AEO projected change in fuel consumption per $ of facility sector output

PECHAN 19 State-Level Emission Comparisons State Base Year Emissions 2018 Emissions (ERG) 2018 Emissions (Pechan) Arizona27,97047,17033,814 New Mexico17,83721,11921,965 Oregon5,3015,9794,503 Utah9,59710,1769,314 Wyoming37,84745,68542,868 5 State Total98,551130,129112,464

PECHAN 20 Sector-Level Emission Comparisons Sector Base Year Emissions 2018 Emissions (ERG) 2018 Emissions (Pechan) Combined Heat & Power3,8012,620 Copper26,18146,02832,000 Wood/Paper/Pulp5,8976,2474,708 Cement Chemicals/Plastics2,0153,1292,015 Oil and Gas32,90045,52946,574 Refining13,22214,30812,099 Food Glass Metals/Mining/Minerals11,7809,2899,442 Miscellaneous1,1891,294 Subtotal98,551130,129112,464

PECHAN 21 Findings  Base year data issues  New vs. existing source SO 2 rates for non-boilers or FCCUs  Refinery capacity expansion uncertainty  Oil and gas »Upset emissions importance »Calibration of activity growth to regional forecasts