© 2007 Rabbi Shalom Richter srichter@yuhsb.org Rabbi Shalom Richter.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Conducting Research Investigating Your Topic Copyright 2012, Lisa McNeilley.

Advertisements

ב. b beth י y yodh ה h he (pronounced hey) ו

Is it rational or irrational?

א. ʾ ʾ aleph (silent, transliterated with an apostrophe)

Visualization Tools, Argumentation Schemes and Expert Opinion Evidence in Law Douglas Walton University of Winnipeg, Canada Thomas F. Gordon Fraunhofer.

The Socratic Seminar. Debate and Dialogue Dialogue is collaborative: multiple sides work toward shared understanding. Debate is oppositional: two opposing.

UWC Writing Workshop Spring Have you received back a graded paper in a class this semester? Did you receive feedback? If so, did you take time to.

Boyce/DiPrima 9th ed, Ch 2.4: Differences Between Linear and Nonlinear Equations Elementary Differential Equations and Boundary Value Problems, 9th edition,

Workshop on Citation: a) Direct Quotation, b) Paraphrasing.

Politeness Theory and Discourse Lecture 7. Objectives After this lecture, students should be able to: 1.Explain the notions of politeness and face 2.Explain.

Foucauldian Discourse Analysis (FDA)

Unit One: The Impact of Craft on Meaning Ms. Barrus – English 10/CP English 10.

Doron Garfinkel, M.D., Svetlana Zludkov, M.D., Sameira Jamal, R.N., Ronit Har-Noy, R.N. Doron Garfinkel, M.D., Svetlana Zludkov, M.D., Sameira Jamal, R.N.,

Present Progressive NEGATIVE. Good Night Mr. Cohen It is night. It’s eleven o’clock. Mr. Cohen is in bed. His eyes are closed. He is sleeping. He isn’t.

Philosophy 220 Kantian Moral Theory and the Liberal View of Sexual Morality.

LESSONS LEARNED FROM NOT TEACHING Peter Liljedahl.

1 Module 5 How to identify essay Matakuliah: G1222, Writing IV Tahun: 2006 Versi: v 1.0 rev 1.

UNIVERSAL DESIGN FOR LEARNING (UDL) Dr. van Garderen Department of Special Education.

Argumentation - 1 We often encounter situations in which someone is trying to persuade us of a point of view by presenting reasons for it. We often encounter.

Copyright © 2002 by Harcourt, Inc. All rights reserved. Topic 3 : Business Objectives Lecturer: Zhu Wenzhong.

Thesis Statements (Or as I like to say, “What’s your point?”)

READING QUESTION TYPES

Leo Tolstoy: What is Art?

Essay Writing in Philosophy

Where questions, not answers, are the driving force in thinking.

The Toulmin Model. Who was Stephen Toulmin?  March 1922 – December 2009  Author, Educator, Philosopher  Created theories to deal with practical issues.

The Purpose of this GONG 5 is to implement a great conversation on the culture of communication through an educational view in the whole institute, and.

Chapter 1: Lecture Notes What Is an Argument? (and What is Not?)

W3C Life Science Ontology Issues Session on Triples and Ontologies.

SUMMARY WRITING You should be able to: 1.take Cornell Notes on the presentation 2.summarize what you have read about in sentences.

Implicit Differentiation

Part I of the Fundamental Theorem says that we can use antiderivatives to compute definite integrals. Part II turns this relationship around: It tells.

The Argument from Religious Experience Does a claimed experience of something divine prove God’s existence?

2012. You must assume that your reader will disagree with you, or be skeptical; therefore, your tone must be reasonable, professional, and trustworthy.

Explicit Textual Evidence. When we read, we are often asked to __________ questions or __________ our ideas about the text.

Citing Textual Evidence

December: Trustworthiness The Hebrew word for Trustworthiness is Emunah Trustworthiness is behaving in ways that show others we can be trusted. We create.

The Socratic Seminar. Debate and Dialogue Dialogue is collaborative: multiple sides work toward shared understanding. Debate is oppositional: two opposing.

Socialization and the Self

Themes in Oedipus Rex EQ: How do authors develop theme in a text? Learning Targets: SWBAT… write an essay that identifies the theme of a text, traces its.

Fact and Opinion To be a good reader, you should be able to tell the difference between a fact and an opinion. Figuring out facts from opinions is something.

CpSc 810: Machine Learning Analytical learning. 2 Copy Right Notice Most slides in this presentation are adopted from slides of text book and various.

Introduction to Senior Health. How you will be graded… Tests/Quizzes Projects - Marriage project OR - One year/five year plan Classwork & Participation.

Critical Thinking  A key academic skill  Required for successful study.

Theme. What is Theme? The main idea or underlying meaning of a literary work. A theme may be stated or implied. Theme differs from the subject or topic.

7 Steps to Integrating Quotations.  It is a piece of a text taken directly from a source  May include things that characters say  May be a statement.

CHAPTER 3 Duane A. Garrett & Jason S. DeRouchie

Insert Presentation Title Here Insert Presentation Summary Here

Conceptual Frameworks, Models, and Theories

Psalms the book of 119:1-72.

Review: Modules 1-12 Phase 1 – Learning to Read Hebrew (Phonetically)

Hebrew Qal Perfect Verbs

Chapter 4 Nouns.

HOW TO WRITE AN OPEN RESPONSE

Learning to Read Hebrew

The Quote Sandwich Miss Romeo English II.

Chapter 5: Prepositions

Biblical Hebrew Starter Kit

Writing a Precis.

English has letters with two pronunciations, for example, the letter “c” in city and cat, or the “th" in this and thing. There are six letters that had.

Hebrew and Torah Bemidbar Numbers 25.1 Brought to you by the letters

Please insert Title Please insert sub-title 1

KAVANAH IN TEFILAH Rabbi Y. Bennett | 12th Grade Mesivta Ateres Yaakov

Bs”d " And all the nation saw the voices..." Exodus 20:15 Is it possible? A new Israeli letter processing patent based on ACOUSTICAL IMAGING.

Psalms the book of 119:

וּ ֹ וֹ ִי ֶי ֵי ֵ ָ ֻ ִ ֶ ַ ּ ְ ֳ ֱ ֲ ז ו ה ד ג ב בּ א ל ך כ ךּ כּ י

By Ken Hyland Journal of English for Academic Purposes (2010)

Presentation transcript:

© 2007 Rabbi Shalom Richter srichter@yuhsb.org Rabbi Shalom Richter

המלך המשפט המלך הקדוש Rabbi Shalom Richter

What are the basic analytical questions one must ask on this גמרא? Please note: As you move forward indicate if you feel this is a basic \ fundamental issue or an issue that requires analysis but it can be viewed as a secondary issue. Highlight any מחלוקת. They usually require analysis. Sometimes (as we have seen in the past), the most basic question in a סוגיא may not emerge from an explanation of a מחלוקת, but it may float to the surface based on a basic assumption that is being made by each מאן דאמר. Rabbi Shalom Richter

Basic issues & challenges: Rabbi Shalom Richter

What is the הסבר of the מחלוקת between ר"א & ת"ק ? ת"ק- רק המלך הקדוש ר"א – אפילו הא-ל הקדוש What is the הסבר of מחלוקת between תוס' & ר"ח as it relates to the four inserts inש"ע ? תוס' – חוזרין ר"ח – אינו חוזר Rabbi Shalom Richter

What do ר"אand ת"ק disagree on? Let’s take another look. What is the הסבר of מחלוקת between תוס' and the תר"י as it relates to the issue of the מחלוקת between ר"א and ת"ק . תוס' - ר"א and ת"ק argue בדיעבד תר"י - ר"א and ת"ק argue לכתחלה Rabbi Shalom Richter

The most basic question: Let’s look at the proof text for ר"א : וַיִּגְבַּהּ ה' צְבָאוֹת בַּמִּשְׁפָּט וְהָאֵל הַקָּדוֹשׁ נִקְדָּשׁ בִּצְדָקָה: Consider the opinion of the ת"ק as taken from our תפלה during the ימים נוראים: וַיִּגְבַּהּ ה' צְבָאוֹת בַּמִּשְׁפָּט וְהָאֵל הַקָּדוֹשׁ נִקְדָּשׁ בִּצְדָקָה ברוך אתה ה' המלך הקדוש This פסוק is the proof text for the ת"ק as well!!! Rabbi Shalom Richter

Rule: While offering a סברא for one opinion, often the ראשון will include the סברא of the other dissenting opinion in his comments. מאירי – שהרי חלק ר"א ואמר אפ' אמר הא-ל הקדוש יצא דכתיב ויגבה ה' צבאות במשפט והאל הקדוש נקדש בצדקה אלמא אף בעת המשפט קראו הא-ל הקדוש Rabbi Shalom Richter

The definition of הא-ל = Almighty One of the expressions of הא-ל is משפט According to the ת"ק the way that בני ישראל defines its relationship with ה' during this time of year must be limited to the concept of משפט Rabbi Shalom Richter

What is the view of ר"א? ר"א maintains that the relationship is not limited to משפט but rather accentuated with משפט מאירי – שהרי חלק ר"א ואמר אפ' אמר הא-ל הקדוש יצא דכתיב ויגבה ה' צבאות במשפט והאל הקדוש נקדש בצדקה אלמא אף בעת המשפט קראו הא-ל הקדוש Rabbi Shalom Richter

Is one חוזר or not? When חז"ל made this תקנה of saying המלך how did they express it? חוזר - תוס' Integrated into the essence (fabric) of תפלה תר"י – אינו חוזר תפלה Addendum Rabbi Shalom Richter

Are we חוזר for the inserts or not? תוס' - חוזר ר"ח – אינו חוזר Rabbi Shalom Richter

Both of these position assume that we are חוזר for המלך… How were the inserts formulated? תר"י – אינו חוזר משפט as it relates to מלכות תוס' - חוזר Any issue related to משפט is integrated in the fabric of ש"ע Rabbi Shalom Richter

המלך המשפט What if the person says מלך אוהב..? Two opinions in the מאירי & תר"י … What is the הסבר ? Rabbi Shalom Richter

How must מלך של משפט expressed? Implicitly Explicitly Rabbi Shalom Richter