Dismantling Masters House with masters Tools: Toward Liberation in Evaluation Rodney Hopson, Duquesne University Center for Culturally Responsive Evaluation.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Understanding Student Learning Objectives (S.L.O.s)

Advertisements

[Imagine School at North Port] Oral Exit Report Quality Assurance Review Team School Accreditation.

USING THE FRAMEWORK FOR TEACHING TO SUPPORT EFFECTIVE TEACHER EVALUATION Mary Weck, Ed. D Danielson Group Member.

Discourses and Framings of Climate Change: What Literatures Do We Need to Review? To realize synergies there is a need to indentify common objectives for.

Practice Profiles Guidance for West Virginia Schools and Districts April 2012.

Local Immigration Partnerships: Systems Planning to Help People.

Fairfield High School NSW - Our National Partnership Journey -

PEG ANAWALT, M.S. EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR, CCCRC - CHESAPEAKE COLLEGE LESLEY FALLON, B.A., COORDINATOR, CCCRC - CHESAPEAKE COLLEGE H. SUSIE CODDINGTON, PH.D.,

Financial support for integrated rural development in the Nitra Self-governing Region Office of the Nitra Self-governing region Department of strategic.

Annual Title 1 Parent Meeting

Review of Maternal and Child Health Service

Conflict Resolution Training for Youth. Virginia commonwealth university Department of educational leadership Program Evaluation APRIL 2013 RAM BHAGAT.

Implementation of the PA Core Standards. Effective Communication Guiding Principle 1 Design and establish systems of effective communication among stakeholders.

SHELLY POTTS, PH.D. UNIVERSITY OFFICE OF EVALUATION AND EDUCATIONAL EFFECTIVENESS ARIZONA STATE UNIVERSITY Quality Assurance Mechanisms.

The NDPC-SD Intervention Framework National Dropout Prevention Center for Students with Disabilities Clemson University © 2007 NDPC-SD – All rights reserved.

Making Evidence-Based Education Policy Ontario Research Chairs in Public Policy Symposium Carol Campbell Ontario Institute for Studies in Education, University.

Today’s Work 1. New requirements for the teacher’s PDP

AIA Web Conference on Culturally Competent Practices in Program Evaluation Considering Culture in Evaluation and Applied Research Rodney K. Hopson Duquesne.

April 6, 2011 DRAFT Educator Evaluation Project. Teacher Education and Licensure DRAFT The ultimate goal of all educator evaluation should be… TO IMPROVE.

Knows and performs Illinois Professional Teaching Standards including working with diverse learners Demonstrates basic competency in planning, instruction,

Promoting Classroom Use of Public Opinion Data Developed by The Roper Center of the University of Connecticut Public Opinion.

Summarizing Community-Based Participatory Research: Background and Context for the Review Lucille Webb, MEd Eugenia Eng, DrPH Alice Ammerman, DrPH Meera.

NMU Towards the 21 st Century Mitchell Klett Alan Willis Ruth Watry Laura Reissner Gary Brunswick.

Capacity building is a strategy and capacity gain is an outcome Capacity building as a strategy needs to be evaluated so that judgements can be made about.

Analyzing and Improving College Teaching: Here’s an IDEA Alan C. Lacy, Associate Dean College of Applied Science and Technology Illinois State University.

Using An Organizational Assessment : A framework to Help Agencies Build on Strengths, Recognize Challenges, and Develop a Comprehensive Work Plan, CWDA.

Educational Research Funding Opportunities W. Eryn Perry.

1 GENERAL OVERVIEW. “…if this work is approached systematically and strategically, it has the potential to dramatically change how teachers think about.

September 12, 2014 Lora M. McCalister-Cruel BDS District Data Coach Bay District Schools Data Analysis Framework.

5. How to Amass Evidence (Evaluation) of Change and its Effects? How does assessment drive transformative change in the classroom, at the department level,

Outcomes Assessment 101 Assessment Showcase 2009: Best Practices in the Assessment of Learning and Teaching February 11, 2009 Gwendolyn Johnson, Ph.D.

Eight Steps to Improving Career Services in Schools, Colleges, and Agencies James P. Sampson, Jr. National Career Development Association Global Conference.

Saginaw KEYS Data Analysis Training for Continuous School Improvement March 20 and 21, 2006 Jacques Nacson Gary Obermeyer.

Community Psychology: A Brief Introduction Society for Community Research and Action (American Psychological Association, Division 27) Council of Education.

Human Resource Management Chapter Ten Copyright © 2015 McGraw-Hill Education. All rights reserved. No reproduction or distribution without the prior written.

Decolonizing evaluation: when the master’s tools are used to dismantle the master’s house Rodney Hopson, Duquesne University ANZEA Conference 2013 Auckland,

Pontotoc City School District. Pontotoc City School District believes LEARNING is a priority, a need, and a desire. To be successful, we must nurture.

Working Definition of Program Evaluation

Mission The faculty and staff of Pittman Elementary School are committed to providing every student with adequate time, effective teaching, and a positive.

Deconstructing Standard 2c Dr. Mike Mahan Gordon College 1.

Association for the Advancement of Sustainability in Higher Education (AASHE) Conference and Expo 2011 David L. Lawrence Convention Center/ 316 October.

2007 Strengthening Student Success Conference, San Jose Dr. Jack Friedlander Executive Vice President, Educational Programs Santa Barbara City College.

Developing Cross-Disciplinary Mental Health Teams in Integrated Care Settings C athy M. Hudgins, PhD, LPC, LMFT Director, NC Center of Excellence for Integrated.

Administrative Retreat: Assessment System Common Assessments to MAP to KPREP June 7, 2013 Woodford County Schools Curriculum and Instruction.

Environmental Risk Assessment: First Application – Climate Change Request for Proposal: Oct Contract Start Date: Dec Completion Anticipated:

CENTER FOR CULTURALLY RESPONSIVE EVALUATION AND ASSESSMENT (CREA) UNIVERSITY OF ILLINOIS AT URBANA-CHAMPAIGN Stafford Hood Director and Sheila M. Miller.

Jonathan Cohen, Ph.D. National School Climate Center: Educating Minds and Hearts Because the Three Rs’ Are Not Enough; Teachers College, Columbia University.

Copyright © Allyn & Bacon 2008 Data-Driven Decision Making and School Leadership: Best Practices for School Improvement Theodore J. Kowalski Thomas J.

1 Curriculum Mapping Overview Transforming Our Teaching And Learning Module 3.

Your Presenters Melissa Connelly, Director, Regional Training Academy Coordination Project, CalSWEC Sylvia Deporto, Deputy Director, Family & Children’s.

AdvancED District Accreditation Process © 2010 AdvancED.

Preparing and Evaluating 21 st Century Faculty Aligning Expectations, Competencies and Rewards The NACU Teagle Grant Nancy Hensel, NACU Rick Gillman, Valporaiso.

Strategic Leadership Share vision of changing world in 21 st century Create processes to ensure school’s identity Create processes to distribute leadership.

Chapter 1 –organizing principle

The Major Steps of a Public Health Evaluation 1. Engage Stakeholders 2. Describe the program 3. Focus on the evaluation design 4. Gather credible evidence.

Partnerships in Information Sharing Susanne Martin Staff Information Systems Analyst California Department of Justice.

Sailing To District Accreditation External Review: October 6-9, 2013… but the journey begins now!

Proposed Areas of Focus & District Priority Board Meeting April 22, 2014 Kevin. L. O’Gorman, Chief Academic Officer Rodney Thompson, Superintendent.

Quality Assurance Review Team Oral Exit Report School Accreditation Sugar Grove Elementary September 29, 2010.

Systems Accreditation Berkeley County School District Accreditation Team Chair Training October 20, 2014 Dr. Rodney Thompson Superintendent.

Understanding Student Learning Objectives (S.L.O.s)

Assessment Small Learning Communities. The goal of all Small Learning Communities is to improve teaching, learning, and student outcomes A rigorous, coherent.

Demonstrating the Value of Stakeholder Input for Evaluation Design, Implementation and Dissemination Yvonne Abel, MS Abt Associates Inc. AEA Annual Conference,

Implementation Science: Finding Common Ground and Perspectives Laura Reichenbach, Evidence Project, Population Council International Conference on Family.

Opportunities and challenges for health impact assessment within the scope of environmental impact assessment Brian L. Cole, Dr.P.H. Health Impact Assessment.

THE ROLE OF RESEARCH IN TELECENTER DEVELOPMENT Why does research matter? Raul Roman Center for Internet Studies University of Washington APEC Telecenter.

Applied Research Consultants: Applied Research Consultants: Assessment Services and External Evaluation.

Developing a Monitoring & Evaluation Plan MEASURE Evaluation.

Human Resource Management

Elements of evaluation quality: questions, answers, and resources

Presentation transcript:

Dismantling Masters House with masters Tools: Toward Liberation in Evaluation Rodney Hopson, Duquesne University Center for Culturally Responsive Evaluation and Assessment Inaugural Conference College of Education at Illinois April, 2013

Vote of Thanks College of Education, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign CREA Inaugural Conference Planning Committee & Conference Team Robert Wood Johnson Evaluation Fellowship Program: OMG Center for Collaborative Learning & School of Education, Duquesne University

Our role as evaluators, in such a time as this

Ancient Susa

Children in modern day Susa

Masters Tools and Masters House What does it mean when the tools of a racist patriarchy are used to examine the fruits of that same patriarchy? It means that only the most narrow perimeters of change are possible and allowable. (Lorde, 1984/1979)

Beyond tools…

Results Lead To Positive Cultural & Sociopolitical Outcomes For The Group Over Time Community Analysis School Analysis Classroom Analysis Program Analysis CIVIC CAPACITY SOCIAL CAPITAL SUMMARY CRE TEAM SELECTION & PREPARATION Funding Technology Materials Physical Environment Stakeholder Groups Frame Right Questions w/ Stakeholder Input Gain Stakeholder Buy In Design CRE Agreement on Evidence? Select &/Or Adapt Instruments Collect Data Mixed Methods) Culturally Trained Data Collectors Analyze Data (Disaggregate) CRE Panel Review Of Findings YES NO District Analysis Produce Report and Presentation CULTURAL INFLUENCES SOCIOPOLITICAL INFLUENCES *CONTEXTUAL ANALYSIS W/ CULTURAL/SOCIOPOLITICAL EMPHASIS *Cultural/Sociopolitical factors are emphasized throughout the evaluation Product Widely Distributed & Results Explained To All Stakeholders Results Useful For All Stakeholders SANKOFA MODEL ©2010 P. Frazier-Anderson, S. Hood. & R. Hopson. All Rights Reserved. Whose assumptions drive our tools?

Who forms the work? Who sets the agenda?

Who informs our work?

Entrance to Africville UAA San Francisco, CA

Africville Relocation UAA San Francisco, CA

Africville news UAA San Francisco, CA

Africville during relocation UAA San Francisco, CA

Relevance Africville

Africville Stakeholders Department of Public Welfare Africville Dalhousie University Halifax Nova Scotia Canada & Beyond City and Municipal Government More government

Relevance Africville

The historical description and evaluation of the Africville relocation had, therefore, to be planned and executed at standards of comprehensiveness, thoroughness, and competence… -Clairmont & Magill, 1971 Responsibilities Africville

UAA San Francisco, CA Action on Africville

UAA San Francisco, CA Responsibilities Africville

UAA San Francisco, CA Africville 2012

UAA San Francisco, CA Africville 2012

UAA San Francisco, CA Africville 2012

Evaluation as liberating Liberation is a value of science. That should be the perspective from which minority scientists seek to advance multiple perspectives, and methodological rigor: not for the purpose of simply predicting, controlling, and understanding, but for the purpose of emancipating (liberating) the bodies, minds, communities, and spirits of oppressed humankind (Gordon, 1999:184).