1. Giuliano Augusti Coordinator, EUR-ACE-IMPLEMENTATION project President, ENAEE (www.enaee.eu) International Forum Higher Education Quality Assurance 20-22 November 2007, Moscow, Russia PRO-EAST project final Seminar 21 November 2007 Implementation of EUR-ACE Standards

2. Accreditation of an Engineering Education Programme (according to EUR-ACE and ENAEE) Result of a process to ensure suitability of programme as entry route to the [engineering] profession Periodic assessment against accepted standards Peer review of written and oral information by trained and independent panels including academics and professionals Accreditation of programme, not of Department or University Accreditation of education, not of whole formation 2 Quality of accredited degrees guaranteed at all “levels”

3. The EUR-ACE project (2004/06) elaborated a synthesis of existing national Standards: EUR-ACE Framework Standards for the Accreditation of Engineering Programmes and a proposal for the Organization and Management of the EUR-ACE Accreditation System 3 The accreditation system envisaged by this proposal, and now being implemented, is a true novelty on the global scale.

4. 4 As a first step for implementation of the EUR-ACE system, the former “European Standing Observatory for Engineering Profession and Education” (ESOEPE) was transformed into a registered international not-for-profit Association: the European Network for Accreditation of Engineering Education ENAEE

5. 5 Official birth date: 8 February 2006 First General Assembly: 30 March 2007 Founding members: FEANI (acting Secretariat)RAEE (RU) SEFI CoPI (IT) UNIFI/TREEIEI-EngineersIreland EUROCADRESOE (Ordem...) (PT) EC (UK) UAICR (RO) CTI (FR) IDA (DK) ASIIN (DE) FOTEP/BBT (CH)

6. 6 First General Assembly: 30 March 2006 Second “ “ : 17 November 2006 Third “ “ : 14 November 2007 New members Admitted at the Second General Assembly (17/11/2006) CLAIU MÜDEK (TR) Admitted at the Third General Assembly (14/11/2007) IGIP Envisaged future member BEST

7. 7 At present (2007), ENAEE is implementing the EUR-ACE system, also thanks to two EU projects: Under the “Socrates” programme: EUR-ACE IMPLEMENTATION (in the EU) (2006/08) Under the “Tempus-Tacis” programme: PRO-EAST: PROmotion and implementation of the EUR-ACE STandards (in Russia) (2006/07) ENAEE is involved also in a project under the “Tempus-Meda” programme: LEPAC: Creation of a Lebanese Engineering Programs Accreditation Commission (2006/08)

8. PROmotion and implementation of the EUR-ACE Standards [ PRO-EAST ] A project under the TEMPUS-TACIS programme (October 2006 - November 2007) Participating Institutions: UNIFI, RAEE, FEANI, CoPI, SEFI, TPU Project coordinator: Oleg Boev Deputy coordinator for EU: Giuliano Augusti External experts: Iring Wasser, Ian Freeston. Main aims (both achieved!!!!): Dissemination of the EUR-ACE results Award of the first EUR-ACE labels in Russia (21/11/2007): This is the Final Seminar of the project 8

9. EUR-ACE system KEY POINTS: NOT an European Directive NOT an European Accreditation Board A bottom-up agreement towards a decentralized accreditation system in which: Accreditation is awarded by (present and future) National (or Regional) Agencies that satisfy the EUR-ACE Framework Standards. The EUR-ACE label is “added” to the “national” accreditation, thus giving it an international value The label distinguishes between FIRST CYCLE and SECOND CYCLE DEGREES, in accord with the EQF. 9

10. Six Agencies form the initial “core” of the EUR-ACE system: ASIIN (DE) EC (UK) IEI-EngineersIreland CTI (FR) OE (Engineers Portugal) RAEE (RU) The representatives of these Agencies sit in the EUR-ACE Label Committee tasked with facilitating the development and monitoring the progress of the system 10

11. 11 The initial core of the EUR-ACE system includes six countries (France, Germany, Ireland, Portugal, Russia, UK) with very different educational and professional systems, such to constitute a very significant sample of the EHEA countries, both within and outside the EU. We hope to enlarge rapidly the EUR-ACE system: at a very early stage it should include also Turkey (MÜDEK) and the Netherlands and Flanders (NVAO).

12. 12 EUR-ACE Label Certificate

13. Germany ASIIN: 16 programmes (many HEIs queuing) Russia RAEE: 11 programmes Engineers Ireland: 40 = 30 FCD & 10 SCD UK ECUK: 10 Portugal OE: 6-7 by April 2008 France CTI: 40-50 in 2008 (some remaining difficulties) 13 EUR-ACE Labels Awarded by end 2007 Yesterday 20 November 2007 I had the honour and pleasure of handing the first seven EUR-ACE certificates issued by RAEE to the representatives of the three relevant HEIs

14. On 12 October 2007, in view of the different meanings of Bachelor and Master in different countries, the ENAEE AC has decided to suspend the use of the terms EUROPEAN ACCREDITED ENGINEERING BACHELOR and EUROPEAN ACCREDITED ENGINEERING MASTER and define the programmes as either FIRST-CYCLE EUROPEAN ACCREDITED ENGINEERING PROGRAMME or SECOND-CYCLE EUROPEAN ACCREDITED ENGINEERING PROGRAMME 14

15. Summing up, ENAEE is creating a two-tier system of accredited engineering programmes, distinct into FC and SC: additional qualifications (e.g. for specialized degrees) are not excluded. The experience of old-established national Accreditation bodies is being fully exploited. This approach and the essential distinction into FCD and SCD should make the EUR-ACE system at the same time flexible and simple. Third Cycle (Doctoral) degrees are not (yet) considered. 15

16. Beside EUR-ACE, there exists the “global” system of the “International Engineering Accords” that appears much more complicated: Three different accreditation “accords”: Washington Accord Sydney Accord Dublin Accord Three different “registers”: EMF International Register of Professional Engineers ETMF Internat. Register of Engineering Technologists APEC Register of Professional Engineers 16

17. Moreover, the I-E-A system includes a fundamental differentiation/barrier between “Professional Engineers” & “Engineering Technologists” (which is not in the spirit of the Bologna Process nor of the EU Directive 2005/36 on recognition of professional qualifications… and in many languages is not even understandable…), and at the same time defines all recognized (accredited) “Engineers’ ” degrees as “Bachelor”. 17 Nevertheless, one of the immediate ENAEE challenges is to find a suitable “matching” with the I.E.A. Indeed, two of the EUR-ACE system partners (ECUK, IEI) are founding partners of the Washington Accord.

18. For up-to-date information on the EUR-ACE system, ENAEE and related documents & events visit www.enaee.eu 18

19. Giuliano Augusti President of ENAEE Coordinator of EUR-ACE IMPLEMENTATION giuliano.augusti@uniroma1.it Tel.(+39)06.4458.5155; mobile:(+39)320.4271831 www.enaee.eu

20. 20 Earlier version of the EUR-ACE label certificates: EUROPEAN ACCREDITED ENGINEERING BACHELOR (FIRST-CYCLE DEGREE PROGRAMME) EUROPEAN ACCREDITED ENGINEERING MASTER (SECOND-CYCLE DEGREE PROGRAMME) 20