1. 2006 CNS/ATM Conference - Integrating Military and Civil CNS/ATM 1 TCP/IP over Aeronautical Data Links 2006 Integrated Military and Civil CNS/ATM Will Ivancic NASA Glenn Research Center wivancic@grc.nasa.gov 216-433-3494

2. 2006 CNS/ATM Conference - Integrating Military and Civil CNS/ATM 2 Network Design Triangle PolicyArchitectureProtocols Security $$$ Cost $$$ Mobility Scalability Maturity Bandwidth QoS SYZYGY Engineering © 2004 Syzygy Engineering – Will Ivancic

3. 2006 CNS/ATM Conference - Integrating Military and Civil CNS/ATM 3 NASA’s Request for Comments on the Global Air Space System Requirements

4. 2006 CNS/ATM Conference - Integrating Military and Civil CNS/ATM 4 Current View of the Global Airspace System Current Global and National Airspace System Stove-piped communication systems Disjoint set of networks Currently not globally network centric Evolved over time with limited concern for network security Security by obscurity Closed systems Insufficient bandwidth to support security measures Safe and Secure Air Traffic Control methods have evolved in reaction to changes in technology, capacity and use Current methods are reaching limit of scalability FAA - Bringing Safety to America’s Skies Mission is to provide the safest, most efficient aerospace system in the world. Responsible National Airspace System, not funded to address global issues. Movement toward Network Centric Operations Cross network security Authentication, Authorization, Accounting and Encryption Required changes in Policy!

5. 2006 CNS/ATM Conference - Integrating Military and Civil CNS/ATM 5 Issues Systems and solutions being proposed for National System only Global Security issues being ignored or at least not emphasized. Divided and conquer design approach being performed prior to understanding of global issues Global system has not been a requirement (An important issue when considering security implications) Ultimately Who Pays? Airlines and stock holders End users via a combination of taxes and airfare

6. 2006 CNS/ATM Conference - Integrating Military and Civil CNS/ATM 6 Global Airspace System Requirements 1. Must be value added Cannot add cost without a return on investment that meets or exceeds those costs. 2. Must be capable of seamless global operation. 3. Must be capable of operating independently of available communications link. Must support critical Air Traffic Management (ATM) functions over low-bandwidth links with required performance. 4. Must use same security mechanisms for Air Mobile and Ground Infrastructure (surface, terminal, en router, oceanic and space) Critical ATM messages must be authenticated. Must be capable of encryption when deemed necessary Security mechanisms must be usable globally Must not violate International Traffic in Arms Regulations 5. Must operate across networks owned and operated by various entities Must be able to share network infrastructure 6. Must make maximum use of standard commercial technologies (i.e. core networking hardware and protocols) 7. Must enable sharing of information with proper security, authentication, and authorization Situational Awareness Passenger Lists Aircraft Maintenance 8. Same network must accommodate both commercial, military and general aviation.

7. 2006 CNS/ATM Conference - Integrating Military and Civil CNS/ATM 7 Design Concepts Must be IPv6 based. Must be capable of a prioritized mixing of traffic over a single RF link (e.g. ATM, maintenance, onboard security, weather and entertainment). Must utilize IPsec-based security with Security Associations (SAs) bound to permanent host identities (e.g. certificates) and not ephemeral host locators (e.g. IP addresses). Must be capable of accommodating mobile networks. Must be capable of multicasting Must be scalable to tens of thousands of aircraft

8. 2006 CNS/ATM Conference - Integrating Military and Civil CNS/ATM 8 Consensus IPv6 is *the* way to go, virtually everyone agrees. There seems to be consensus that links should be shared, and the system should be provider- independent, and this makes QoS a requirement. There is a need for some type of mobile networking (mobile-IP, NEMO, ad hoc) Placement of home for mobile-IP or NEMO is being addressed, but needs further study. Everyone agrees that some work is still to be done cleaning up IPsec multicast, envisioning the certificate architecture, and figuring out how exactly to do QoS.

9. 2006 CNS/ATM Conference - Integrating Military and Civil CNS/ATM 9 Value Added Lower Telecommunication Costs of IP-based networks as compared to dedicated point-to-point links Competition among information providers Economies of scale Lower development costs for new applications and maintenance due to standardization of interfaces

10. 2006 CNS/ATM Conference - Integrating Military and Civil CNS/ATM 10 Link Independence Most important considerations for this is not technical, but related to cost, safety, and politics Facilitates globalization and supports positive ROI Requires change in policy Change in use of spectrum World Radio Conference to allow use of other frequencies for air traffic control messages Air Traffic Controller is now networked. These are some very different modes of operation from what the aeronautics community is comfortable with.

11. 2006 CNS/ATM Conference - Integrating Military and Civil CNS/ATM 11 Security Mechanisms Encryption mechanisms should be limited to those that are free of ITAR restrictions Other counties also have regulations restricting the exportation of cryptography technology These regulations may limit the ability to realize cost and schedule advantages that could be gained by using a single set of proven security infrastructure software throughout the world. Multicast and current IPSec implementations do not necessarily work well together. Support for IPSec-base security with Security Associations bound to permanent host (multicast group) identities (e.g. certificates) Location, control, and responsiveness of the authentication authority servers is critical.

12. 2006 CNS/ATM Conference - Integrating Military and Civil CNS/ATM 12 Further Studies and Investigation QoS related to mixing ATM traffic with other information Much research is needed regarding network mobility Networking ATM traffic for use over multiple links and service providers Mobile-IP, NEMO and Ad Hoc networking Route Optimization Placement of Location Manager (Home Agent) Ping-pong routing QoS and delay issues Multi-homing (use of best available link) To load balance or not to load balance? Make before break or not? Application of Ad Hoc type networking for Oceanic to extend networks (MANETs or Mobile-IPv6)

13. 2006 CNS/ATM Conference - Integrating Military and Civil CNS/ATM 13 Internet Protocol Performance over VDL-3 This work was performed by Jim Griner, Brian Frantz and Russ Jirberg Under the Weather Information Communications project

14. 2006 CNS/ATM Conference - Integrating Military and Civil CNS/ATM 14 This work was performed by Jim Griner, Brian Frantz and Russ Jirberg Under the Weather Information Communications project System Diagram

15. 2006 CNS/ATM Conference - Integrating Military and Civil CNS/ATM 15 Data Link Layer Mapping

16. 2006 CNS/ATM Conference - Integrating Military and Civil CNS/ATM 16 Application Protocol Data Unit Delivery Time

17. 2006 CNS/ATM Conference - Integrating Military and Civil CNS/ATM 17 Messages Received vs. Signal Quality Parameter (SQP)

18. 2006 CNS/ATM Conference - Integrating Military and Civil CNS/ATM 18 Message Delivery Time (QoS)

19. 2006 CNS/ATM Conference - Integrating Military and Civil CNS/ATM 19 Flt. #2Flt. #3Flt. #4Flt. #5 TTMs Sent136122217444 TTMs Rec’d.136122217444 TTMs Lost0000 Retransmissions: at the TCP layer562034 at the DLS layer55324993 Table 6. TCP and DSL of the turbulence messages. Message Reliability

20. 2006 CNS/ATM Conference - Integrating Military and Civil CNS/ATM 20 Modular Cost-Effective Extensible Onboard Architecture for Secure Mobile Communications

21. 2006 CNS/ATM Conference - Integrating Military and Civil CNS/ATM 21 Communication Management Unit (CMU) SATCOM AERO-1 System SATCOM AERO-H/H+ System VHF Voice/DATA System HF Voice/DATA System GateLink File Server Subsystem Printer ARINC 741 ARINC 761 ARINC 740/744 ARINC 719 ARINC 753 ARINC 716 ARINC 750 Terminal Ethernet (Optional) Typical ACARS Onboard Network

22. 2006 CNS/ATM Conference - Integrating Military and Civil CNS/ATM 22 Typical ACARS Onboard Network

23. ATN Island Routing Domain Confederation ATN TRD ATN Backbone RDC ATN TRD ATN ERD ATN Island RDC Mobile RD Another ATN Island ERD – End Routing Domain RD – Routing Domain RDC – Routing Domain Confederation TRD – Transit Routing Domain

24. Communication Management Unit (CMU) SATCOM AERO-1 SATCOM AERO-HH VHF Voice/DATA HF Voice/DATA GateLink INMARSAT Swift 64 Connexion by Boeing WiFi Max Cellular Future Links Mobile Router Cryptography and Firewall Traditional Avionics Display Passenger Services IP-Based Transitional Architecture

25. SATCOM AERO-1 SATCOM AERO-HH VHF Voice/DATA HF Voice/DATA GateLink INMARSAT Swift 64 Connexion by Boeing WiFi Max Cellular Future Links Mobile Router Cryptography and Firewall Operations LAN (Avionics) Communication and Display Passenger Services Air Traffic Management LAN Sensor Controller (Optional Display) IP-Based Architecture with ATC and AOC Separate

26. 2006 CNS/ATM Conference - Integrating Military and Civil CNS/ATM 26 Mobile Router Cryptography and Firewall Operations LAN (Avionics) Communications Sensor Controller and Display Passenger Services Air Traffic Management LAN Radio Link 1 Radio Link 2 Radio Link 3 Radio Link 4 Radio Link N IP-Based Architecture with ATC and AOC Combined

27. 2006 CNS/ATM Conference - Integrating Military and Civil CNS/ATM 27 High speed link int2 int3 Routing Policy int1 Low latency link Reliable link ATC AOC P-DATA Home Agent Policy-Based Routing, All Links Active

28. 2006 CNS/ATM Conference - Integrating Military and Civil CNS/ATM 28 High speed link int2 int3 Routing Policy int1 Low latency link Reliable link ATC AOC P-DATA Home Agent Policy-Based Routing, Critical Link Active

29. 2006 CNS/ATM Conference - Integrating Military and Civil CNS/ATM 29 High speed link int2 int3 Routing Policy Home Agent int1 Low latency link Reliable link ATC AOC P-DATA Policy-Based Routing, Passengers Link Active

30. 2006 CNS/ATM Conference - Integrating Military and Civil CNS/ATM 30 The WAVE server can be used to tie together disparate radio systems for emergency communications Generic (unmodified) Cessna 152 Network Centric FAA Control Tower Generic F15E Interceptor Network Centric DoD Control Tower Twisted Pair Solutions WAVE ™ Server Cisco IP Interoperability and Collaboration System (IPICS) Secure Mobile Networking Emergency Communications Over Disparate Radios The Internet Land Mobile Radio Connection to tower radio base station Civilian UHF Voice Communications DoD VHF Voice Communications Cessna 152! You are violating national airspace! Respond immediately and follow me to the nearest airport!