1. COBECOS II meeting, 5-7 September 2007, London COBECOS Costs and Benefits of Control Strategies Status of WP2- Data collection at September 2007 Italian case study: GSA 9 bottom trawling fishery Loretta Malvarosa (malvarosa@irepa.org)malvarosa@irepa.org Paolo Accadia (paolo.accadia@port.ac.uk)paolo.accadia@port.ac.uk

2. COBECOS II meeting, 5-7 September 2007, London The case study area: GSA 9. Ligurian and North Tirrenian Sea GSA 9

3. COBECOS II meeting, 5-7 September 2007, London General setting of the fishery GSA 9 bottom trawling fishery is a multi-species and multi-gear fishery. GSA 9 bottom trawling fishery is a multi-species and multi-gear fishery. The fishery is focused on the bottom trawl segment, that is on vessels fishing exclusively or predominantly (fishing days >50%) with trawl nets. The fishery is focused on the bottom trawl segment, that is on vessels fishing exclusively or predominantly (fishing days >50%) with trawl nets. Multi-gear fishery: even if trawling is predominant, vessels are provided, in many cases, by more than a license (in most cases by licenses for gillnets and long-lines). Multi-gear fishery: even if trawling is predominant, vessels are provided, in many cases, by more than a license (in most cases by licenses for gillnets and long-lines). Multi-species fishery: > 45 species. Multi-species fishery: > 45 species.

4. COBECOS II meeting, 5-7 September 2007, London General setting of the fishery – Indicators 1 Target species: first 5 species in terms of value on the average of the last 4 years. They represent, on average, 46% of total landings in value. Target species: first 5 species in terms of value on the average of the last 4 years. They represent, on average, 46% of total landings in value.

5. COBECOS II meeting, 5-7 September 2007, London General setting of the fishery – Indicators 2 Target species: trend in the last 4 years of value of landings (mio ). Target species: trend in the last 4 years of value of landings (mio ). Species2003200420052006 Norway lobster 9.328.449.298.97 European hake 9.664.939.799.73 Striped mullet 7.204.305.256.86 Horned octopus 5.604.146.506.22 Deepwater rose shrimp 4.625.026.286.52 Total target species 36.4126.8237.1138.29

6. COBECOS II meeting, 5-7 September 2007, London General setting of the fishery – Indicators 3 Ratio of demersal Vs. pelagic catch (volume). Ratio of demersal Vs. pelagic catch (volume). Years % demersal % pelagic % total % total 200099.310.69100 200199.320.68100 200299.340.66100 200399.300.70100 200498.941.06100 200597.552.45100 200699.010.99100

7. COBECOS II meeting, 5-7 September 2007, London General setting of the fishery – Indicators 4 Coastline adjacent to fishing areas. Coastline adjacent to fishing areas. Landing ports Landing ports Regions Coastline (km) Landing ports (no.) Liguria34081 Toscana57854 Lazio32730 GSA 9 1.245165

8. COBECOS II meeting, 5-7 September 2007, London General setting of the fishery – Indicators 5 Effort: days at sea. Effort: days at sea.

9. COBECOS II meeting, 5-7 September 2007, London Technical characteristics of the fleet – Indicators 1 Size of the fleet: no. of vessels, tonnage and engine power. Size of the fleet: no. of vessels, tonnage and engine power. Years No. of vessels GRTkW Engaged crew 200042113,42491,6961,136 200137111,41579,4251,115 200234910,59474,4931,034 200334310,40073,2701,008 200434410,60774,017947 200535810,56574,606894 200636110,75075,514947

10. COBECOS II meeting, 5-7 September 2007, London Biological characteristics of the fishery – Indicators 1 Official landings from project fisheries (tons). Official landings from project fisheries (tons). Landings are available by single species since 2003; by group of species (graph) since 2000. Landings are available by single species since 2003; by group of species (graph) since 2000.

11. COBECOS II meeting, 5-7 September 2007, London Biological characteristics of the fishery – Indicators 2 Total estimated removals from sea of stock of target species (includes only landings by other fleets not included in the project; data on discards are not available) – tons, 2003-2006. Total estimated removals from sea of stock of target species (includes only landings by other fleets not included in the project; data on discards are not available) – tons, 2003-2006. Species2003200420052006 Norway lobster 331274290248 European hake 2,0801,1951,9202,330 Striped mullet 1,0645837151,050 Horned octopus 869663940945 Deepwater rose shrimp 323375431462 Total target species 4,6673,0904,2965,036

12. COBECOS II meeting, 5-7 September 2007, London Biological characteristics of the fishery – Indicators 2 Total estimated removals from sea of stock of target species: share of bottom trawlers on all the fleet segments operating in GSA 9. Total estimated removals from sea of stock of target species: share of bottom trawlers on all the fleet segments operating in GSA 9.

13. COBECOS II meeting, 5-7 September 2007, London Biological characteristics of the fishery – Indicators 3 As far as other biological characteristics of the fishery, IREPA has taken contact with relevant national biological institutes in order to gather all the necessary data. As far as other biological characteristics of the fishery, IREPA has taken contact with relevant national biological institutes in order to gather all the necessary data. At the moment we are waiting for data. In our opinion no relevant difficulties will be encountered in collecting this type of data. At the moment we are waiting for data. In our opinion no relevant difficulties will be encountered in collecting this type of data.

14. COBECOS II meeting, 5-7 September 2007, London Socio-economic characteristics of the fishery – Indicators 1 Landings value (mio ). Landings value (mio ). Landings in value are available by single species since 2003; by group of species (graph) since 2000. Landings in value are available by single species since 2003; by group of species (graph) since 2000.

15. COBECOS II meeting, 5-7 September 2007, London Socio-economic characteristics of the fishery – Indicators 2 Prices of target species, 2003-2006 (/kg). Table shows only price of target species. Prices of target species, 2003-2006 (/kg). Table shows only price of target species. Species2003200420052006 Norway lobster 32.8431.4232.2936.24 European hake 8.429.129.418.24 Striped mullet 8.598.367.706.64 Horned octopus 6.836.436.966.60 Deepwater rose shrimp 15.0113.6814.5814.10 Average price target species 10.7211.4911.009.91

16. COBECOS II meeting, 5-7 September 2007, London Socio-economic characteristics of the fishery – Indicators 3 Economic data (income, costs, G.V.A., gross cash flow) – mio, 2002-2003. Gross cash flow is preferred to net profit because the estimation procedure of capital costs is changed in the latest years. Economic data (income, costs, G.V.A., gross cash flow) – mio, 2002-2003. Gross cash flow is preferred to net profit because the estimation procedure of capital costs is changed in the latest years.

17. COBECOS II meeting, 5-7 September 2007, London Management and enforcement of the fishery The text and the data harmonisation related to the management of the fishery is under construction. The text and the data harmonisation related to the management of the fishery is under construction. As far as the enforcement data, IREPA has taken contact with Harbour offices in order to gather all the necessary data. At the moment no data have been delivered. As far as the enforcement data, IREPA has taken contact with Harbour offices in order to gather all the necessary data. At the moment no data have been delivered. Taking into account the level of detail requested by the project on the enforcement data, we think that some difficulties could be encountered in gathering all the data. This could imply, in some cases, the use of estimation procedures. Taking into account the level of detail requested by the project on the enforcement data, we think that some difficulties could be encountered in gathering all the data. This could imply, in some cases, the use of estimation procedures.

18. COBECOS II meeting, 5-7 September 2007, London Modelling ( ;e,f, *) = (e) f ( - *), if *. ( ;e,f, *) = (e) f ( - *), if *. ( ;e,f, *) = 0, if < *, ( ;e,f, *) = 0, if < *, ( ;e,f, *) = (e) fif *. ( ;e,f, *) = (e) fif *. ( ;e,f, *) = 0 if < *, ( ;e,f, *) = 0 if < *, B(q,x, ) - (e) f ( - *) B(q,x, ) - (e) f ( - *) B(q,x, ) - (e) f N = 0, 1. B(q,x, ) - (e) f N = 0, 1. G(x, ). G >0 ( ) age-structured biological model G(x, ). G >0 ( ) age-structured biological model