1. The Grading Exercise

2. Seating Chart Conservative Traditional Socialist Undecided (The bad and wrong)

3. PAF101 PAF 101 “A wise man does not contend. Therefore, no one can contend against him. Yield and overcome.” ~Lao-Tzu Module 3, Lecture 3

4. Rules For The Grading Exercise The final policies must be selected from one of the three proposals. Grading policy must be unanimously agreed upon. Or, there must be a unanimous agreement on a voting procedure to reach a decision on the grading policy. Final vote will be a secret ballot. Each speaker must be given prompt and courteous attention. Any disorder will result in a 60 second period of silence. Decision must be reached by 1:30 p.m.

5. Grading Exercise Reflections About the Behavior of Players  Act like dogs (barking to vent;groveling for scraps)  Can’t tell if public interest is a cover for private interest  Lack knowledge and understanding

6. Grading Exercise Reflections About Leadership  Strategic Thinking  Persistent  Guts

7. Grade Exercise Reflections “The only way to get the best of an argument is to avoid it.” Dale Carnegie

8. Grading Exercise Reflection “A wise man does not contend. Therefore, no one can contend against him. Yield and overcome.” ~Lao-Tzu

9. Grading Exercise Reflections About the Process  Minority always shapes outcome in some way  Subsidies too appealing to ignore  Procedural decisions have substantive consequences  Equality is a very confusing idea