3 What environmental ethics is not It is not an accounting of all laws, statutes, regulations relating to the environment.It is not the construction of markets to determine quantitatively the strength of the preferences individuals and groups have for the environmentIt is not a scientific or even philosophical description of nature as a whole or nature through its parts
4 What is ethics? This is extraordinarily complicated Umbrella Definition (covers a lot)The systematic and critical study of moral beliefs, rules, and practicesBeliefs, rules, and practices considered good, right, or virtuous (or conversely bad, wrong, and vicious)Develops and employs principles such as respect for autonomy, justice, and beneficence (Systematic)This systematic study can issue in the assessment that moral beliefs, rules, and practices come up short to these higher standards (Critical)
5 What is Environmental Ethics? A systematic and critical study of practices, beliefs, and rules applied to the environment that are considered moral, i.e., good/bad, right/wrong, and virtuous/vicious.Much of environmental ethics can be summarized by the diagram in the following slide…
6 Environmental Ethics Rectangle AnthropocentricNon-anthropocentricHolisticAgrarianism: Humans transform nature for agriculture but understand farm as ecosystem (Berry, Jefferson, Jackson)Ecocentrism: “A thing is good if it promotes the integrity, beauty, and stability of the biotic community.”Focus on biotic community conceived holisticallyIndividualisticExtensionism: Individualistic ethical approaches such as Utilitarianism and Deontology are extended to cover non-humans. (Singer for Utilitarianism and Regan for Deontology)Biocentrism: Duties not to interfere with teleological centers of a life. Basic , non-human telos can trump non-basic and even basic human interests.
7 Terms ExplainedAnthropocentric: Centered around humans. (Comes from Greek word anthropo which means human)Humans are the central or sole inhabitants of the moral communityNon-anthropocentric: Not centered around humansCenter could be non human living things or larger wholes such as species, ecosystems, and the biotic community as the organized systems of all living things.
8 Central DebateCan an anthropocentric environmental ethics pay proper attention or assign proper worth/value to non-human living things up to and including the biotic community?Is anthropocentrism compatible with a long term, sustainable human-natural environment relation?Deep Ecologists say noPragmatists (Norton and Westin) say yes
9 Methodological Terms Individualistic Holistic One way to look at it The focus of moral inquiry consists of individuals, whether human or non-human. This includes humans, animals, plants, and other animate and inanimate beings all taken, not as species, but as individuals.HolisticWholes are collections of individuals. Here the focus could be on species, ecosystems, the biotic community, or nature expanded to include the inanimate as well as animate.One way to look at itWhat is the proper subject to which we predicate moral value such as good, right, and virtue?
10 Singer: Animal Liberation Singer picks up on a comment by BenthamBecause animals are sentient, they should count in the utilitarian calculusWhat counts are the pleasures, not the nature of the vessel in which pleasures and pains are occurring.All sentient beings have moral worthSentiency includes consciousness and ability to feel pleasure and painStrict utilitarianism involves choosing that action that maximizes good, i.e., according to hedonistic forms maximizes pleasure (for the long term) and minimizes pain
11 Extended Utilitarianism Continued McDonald’s works with PETA (people ethical treatment animals) and animal suppliers to lessen the pain animals experience in various phases of their raisingTemple GrandinHas autism. But also has special insight into how animals feel. Has developed a “methodology for objectively measuring animal welfare in slaughterhouses and audit protocols based on these measures.”From Weber and Lawrence, Business and Society, McGraw-Hill: 33
12 Regan: The Case for Animal Rights Moral consideration expanded to cover non-human moral patientsMoral patients have “preference autonomy,” that is, preferences (which can be satisfied or frustrated) and the ability to act on themHumans have duties to respect preference autonomy of moral patients (=animals)Since animals have only preference autonomy, they do not have duties correlative to their rights.
13 Paul Taylor: Biocentrism Hursthouse summarizes:“Environmental Virtue Ethics” in Working Virtue edited by R. Walker and P. Ivanhoe. Oxford: 163.Every living thing has a telos = a good of its own. (Fish gotta swim, birds gotta fly)Helping the living thing achieve this telos or preventing it from achieving this telos (=good) benefits or harms itAll teleological centers of a life have “inherent worth as members of the Earth’s Community of Life.”Positive duties to promote the telosNegative duties not to interfere with telos
14 Human Goods / Non-Human Goods Basic Non-Human Good Non-Basic, Non-Human GoodBasic Human GoodBasic human good has priority (Right of Self-Defense) Humans have right to clear wilderness to grow food.Basic human good has priority because a basic good trumps a non-basic good. Humans can cut back tree branches to prevent them from falling and hurting children.Non-Basic Human GoodThe basic, non-human good has priority because a basic good trumps a non-basic good. I ought not cut down trees to create a parking space for my car.Toss up. Some non-basic goods have priority over others. Humans may have a right to preserve a cultural landscape rather than letting it revert back to nature.
15 Complexities of Table It’s a heuristic device, not carved in stone. Sacrificing one good for another is always a last resort.Look hard—really hard—for ways to fully or partially integrate the goods in conflict. (conservation makes it possible to avoid building the destructive irrigation project)Accept trade offs only as a last resort and then try to offset the good sacrificed in another way or at another time.AES’s cogeneration, coal based technology adds CO2 to the atmosphere. But they planted trees in Costa Rica reforestation project to erase carbon footprint.The sacrifice of one good for another may be only necessary in the short term.Try to develop transition measures that render this unnecessary in long term
16 Ecocentrism Aldo Leopold, “The Land Ethic” in A Sand County Almanac. “There is as yet no ethic dealing with man’s relation to land and to the animals and plants which grow upon it. Land, like Odysseus’ slave-girls, is still property. The land-relation is still strictly economic, entailing privileges but not obligations.”“The land ethic simply enlarges the boundaries of the community to include soils, waters, plants, and animals, or collectively: the land.”“A thing is right when it tends to preserve the integrity, stability, and beauty of the biotic community. It is wrong when it tends otherwise.”
17 Different Interpretations of Leopold’s Land Ethic Non-anthropocentricThis is the most prevalent interpretation. Baird CallicottLeopold started out with conservation mentality and changed as a result of the experience in American West (failed to think like a mountain)Byran NortonWithin Pragmatic tradition, Norton argues that nature can be restored and protected from within the anthropocentric perspective.
18 Is the Land Ethic a Virtue Ethic? Focuses on agent instead of the actionAct integrated into the context of the moral career of the agent, a practice or community, and a broader traditionVirtue or excellence is the mean between extremes of excess and defectCourage is the mean between cowardice and recklessnessDispositions or habits that contribute to realizing goods internal and external to a practice or community.Reformulates several basic ideasHappiness is reformulated as harmony with broader contextVirtue moves spot light from the moral minimum to the exemplary (Virtue = Excellence)Deliberation or Reasoning becomes the ability to hone in on moral salience
19 First Land Ethic Virtue: Respect for Nature Old VirtuesOld VicesPrudencePractical wisdomCompassionProper humilitySelf-indulgence & greedShort-sightednessCrueltyPride, vanity, dishonesty, and arrogance
20 Respect for Nature Reconfigured Respect for nature is based on refiguring prudence, practical wisdom, compassion and proper humility around natureFor Hursthouse virtues go deep; inculcating a virtue requires changing…Attitudes toward nature (no longer yucky)Emotions (developing compassion, care, love, awe for nature)Perception (ability to hone in on ways in which actions and policies can harm nature)Educational Program proposed by Hursthouse will take a generation
21 PrudencePrudence: "the midpoint between 'a mad rush into oblivion' and an 'intransigent do-nothingness'"Is the Via Verde a “mad rush into oblivion”Are Puerto Ricans so afraid of damaging environment, etc. that they have fallen into “intransigent do-nothingness”?How do moral exemplars avoid the extreme of reckless action without falling into the other extreme of “paralysis of analysis”?
22 Another Virtue in the Land Ethic? Practical wisdom or judgment:"showing 'sensitivity' to ecological communities and their members and sorting out the rival claims and interests within and among communities. ”Can the construction of the Via Verde be reconfigured to avoid environmental and civic destruction?See Shaw, "Aldo Leopold's Land Ethic” in Environmental Virtue Ethics, edited by R. Sandler and P. Cafaro. Rowman and Littlefield: 100.
23 Two Environmental Virtues from Wensveen Virtues of Position: "Constructive habits of seeing ourselves in a particular place in a relational structure and interacting accordingly.”Designing highways to fit PR geography and landscapeVirtues of Care: "habits of constructive involvement within the relational structure where we have found our place. How widely do we cast our sensors in order to learn what is needed around us?“Being attuned to weak points in the ecosystem and calibrating action to address these vulnerabilities
24 Two More Environmental Virtues Virtues of Attunement: "habits of handling temptations by adjusting our positive, outgoing drives and emotions to match our chosen place and degree of constructive, ecosocial engagement."Can energy conservation be a source of solidarity and also defuse the current energy crisis in PR?Virtues of Endurance: "habits of facing dangers and difficulties by handling our negative, protective drives and emotions in such a way that we can sustain our chosen sense of place and degree of constructive ecosocial engagement."Can Puerto Ricans act resolutely and ethically in the face of environmental and economic crises? (Integration, compromise, and ethical trade-offsWensveen, “Cardinal Environmental Virtues: A Neurobiological Perspective,” in Environmental Virtue Ethics, edited by R. Sandler and P. Cafaro. Rowman & Littlefield:
25 Salient PointsVirtue ethics does not outline a particular action in the face of current environmental situation.Actions, policies, and conduct are integrated into broader contextsMoral career of exemplary environmentalistCommunity values like social justice and attachment to place (PR land ethic values)Traditions: integrating past agrarianism in PR with current post-industrialism
26 More Salient PointsThe value of a virtue approach to environmental ethics is the educational program it outlinesHursthouse“You can’t just decide to have a virtue; virtuous character traits cannot be acquired theoretically by attending lectures or reading books or articles and just deciding to be that way. But they can be acquired through moral habituation or training, beginning in childhood and continuing through self-improvement”
27 Educational Approach Continued “the introduction or discovery of an unfamiliar, ‘new’, virtue would, on the face of it, need to involve the invention or coining of a new term or concept, which named a complex unity of dispositions to act and feel for certain sorts of reasons, and to see and respond to things in certain sorts of ways, which we had discovered, or realized, was a way human beings, given human psychology, could be. And this complex unity would have to be the sort of thing we could conceive of as being inculcated in children as part of their moral education—not totally against the grain, but expanding on and correcting some natural inclination(s) they have.”
28 Some Practical Suggestions From the Pragmatists
29 Begin with Virtue of Humility: 5 key attitudes Pragmatist Framework:Anti-foundationalism: Rejects attempt to base environmental ethics on a definitive account of the inherent value of nature taken in its totality or in terms of its individual inhabitantsFallibility: Conclusions (goals, means, measures) are fallible and require constant testing in laboratory and real world conditions. (Experimental Method with ethics of experimenting)Contingency: For Pragmatists this entails that all problems arise from a context and all solutions must address this context specifically. This makes it difficult—if not impossible—to generalize and transfer them from one context to another
30 Humility Social Nature of Self: Negative Thesis—Destroying nature leads to an identity cruses (identity comes partially from place).Positive Thesis—Place/context (cultural and natural) can be an opportunity to build identity and solidarity.Pluralism: No no single, uniquely correct approach to environmental ethics.Rights—human communities,Utilities—extending moral consideration to animals.Holism—extending moral consideration to ecosystemsBiocentrism—teleological centers of a lifeSometimes one must “think like a mountain”; but other times it suffices to think like a human
31 Wicked ProblemsNorton, drawing from Webber and Rittel, characterizes environmental problems as "wicked." They require an interdisciplinary approach.Difficult to formulate and cover "ill-structured" situations.Specifying requires creativity and imagination.No uniquely correct way of specifying a problem.Not numerical problems. (Non-computability)Have components that admit of quantification and others that resist it.Requires more than just creating shadow markets to quantify willingness to sell and willingness to buy
32 Wicked Problems Non-repeatable. Open-ended Interdisciplinary Solutions must resonate with contextSolutions cannot be wholly transferred between contextsLearning from the past gets us started.Open-endedThere are good and bad specifications but none of these are uniquely good.There are good and bad solutions but no one solution is uniquely good or right.Pragmatists ground this in falliblism and contingency.InterdisciplinaryEconomical, ecological, social, political, technical, and ethical dimensions that must be reviewed and integrated.Ideally different disciplines mutually engage and challenge one another.CollectiveThese decisions require a group getting together, holding a constructive dialogue, developing common ground, and developing trials to test resonance with commonality
33 A Basis for Action?Establish the basis for a unifying dialogue that issues in community environmental actionCommunity Procedural Values: These are values (reciprocity, publicity, and accountability) that, when adopted by a community, help it to structure a fair and open community deliberative process.Economic Values:(1) Willingness-to-Pay: the instrumental value of a resource is set by the price an individual or group would be willing to pay to acquire the resource;(2) Willingness -to-Sell: because WTP undervalues resources (it ties value to the constraint of disposable income) a more accurate measure of value would be the amount that an individual or group would accept from a bidder to take the resource out of its current use and put it to a different one.
34 Sustainability Values Risk Avoidance Values: Precautionary Principle--"in situations of high risk and high uncertainty, always choose the lowest-risk option." 238Risk Avoidance Values: Safe Minimum Standard of Conservation--"save the resource, provided the costs of doing so are bearable."348.Values Central to Community's Identity: Justice, integrity, trust, responsibility, and respect can apply here but they should be taken in their thick as well as thin senses. These values, in their thick sense, depend on the quality of the discourse generated within the community.
35 ConclusionMeta-ethical excursion into defining, provisionally, environmental ethicsA look at four important approaches to environmental ethics: extensionism, biocentrism, ecocentrism, and virtue environmental ethicsExamined (quickly) a pragmatic approach to environmental decision-making that outlines how a community can design environmental “experiments” as vehicles for realizing their deeply held values
36 William J. FreyCollege of Business AdministrationUPRM