1. RRI in practice: the results of a Europe-wide consultation Steve Miller University College London www.rri-tools.eu

2. | Consultation Workshop D2.2: Analysis of Opportunities, Obstacles, and Needs of the Stakeholder Groups in RRI Practices in Europe What does each stakeholder think are the opportunities and obstacles in moving towards RRI? What are each stakeholder’s ideas of practical measures to help implement RRI?

3. | Consultation Workshop D2.2: Analysis of Opportunities, Obstacles, and Needs of the Stakeholder Groups in RRI Practices in Europe Same workshop in 22 countries 411 participants from 30 countries Sept-Dec 2014

4. | Consultation Workshop Plan for today: Activity 1: Identify opportunities, obstacles Activity 2: Identify tools to help Present findings of the workshops Discussion of points arising

5. | Consultation Workshop Exercise 1: Obstacles and opportunities for RRI Stakeholder group Initials Civil Society Organisations C Education Community E Industry and Business I Policymakers P Researchers and Innovators R In stakeholder groups, think about the opportunities and obstacles presented by RRI. One person from each group should be prepared to feed back.

6. | Consultation Workshop Exercise 2: Solutions Look at the RRI Tools and find some tools that will help you achieve the opportunities offered by RRI and tackle the obstacles. If you know of any other resource that is not in the toolkit, please upload it now Is there anything else that could help you? We need more money... So what did we find?

7. | Consultation Workshop Opportunities

8. | Consultation Workshop “In the long term a process like this can avoid significant problems that might arise – like GMOS” Industry, Italy “Transparency of all results – publishing good and bad results – would create a more accurate evidence base for policy” Policymakers UK “To raise questions that have never been addressed” CSO, France “Innovations in business models and new market niches” Industry, Spain

9. | Consultation Workshop Obstacles

10. | Consultation Workshop “Ideas gathered under RRI are unclear and everyone understands them in a different way” Researchers and CSO, Poland “What is my financial interest in putting energy into it?” Industry, France “Would RRI slow down the evidence finding process and thus slow down policymaking” Policymaker, UK “Research is not predictable so how can we be responsible” Researcher, Italy

11. | Consultation Workshop Actions

12. | Consultation Workshop “Develop clear criteria and a roadmap for accessing RRI” Industry, Switzerland “funding for structured meeting places – new or old – such as courses, events, pilot projects” Policymakers, Sweden “RRI should be embedded in higher education and teaching. This needs adapted curricula and teaching methodologies for societal responsibility” Education, Germany “Creating a map of ‘benefits’ which would clearly present potential benefits that different stakeholders engaged in the RRI process could gain” CSO Poland

13. | Consultation Workshop Policymakers:

14. | Consultation Workshop Industry and Business:

15. | Consultation Workshop Civil Society Organisations

16. | Consultation Workshop Researchers

17. | Consultation Workshop Education

18. Discussion