Budget Outlook Glen Crawford P5 Meeting Sep 24 2007.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

DOE Office of Science Budget Overview

Advertisements

Briefing to the Commission to Review the Effectiveness of the National Energy Laboratories (CRENEL) Joseph McBrearty, Deputy Director for Field Operations.

FY 2013 Request: Total R&D by Agency Budget Authority in Billions of Dollars.

Department of Energy Office of Science HEP FY08 Budget Status and Issues Robin Staffin preCRB Discussion April

DOE/NSF U.S. CMS Operations Program Review Closeout Report Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory March 10, 2015 Anadi Canepa, TRIUMF Anna Goussiou, University.

Office of High Energy Physics Report to the AAAC Kathleen Turner Office of High Energy Physics (HEP) Office of Science (SC), U.S. Department of Energy.

OFFICE OF SCIENCE Office of High Energy Physics, Cosmic Frontier Mid-Scale Dark Energy Spectroscopic Instrument (MS-DESI) Experiment Fermilab PAC Oct.

Physics Department Meeting June 19, 2008  Safety items: Mike Zarcone  DOE Emergency Management Audit next week  Department news  Budget update  Looking.

Cost, Schedule & Funding Closeout Jan Joint DOE/NSF CD2/3a Review 1 DOE/NSF Review of the Dark Energy Survey (DES) Project SC 6/7 Cost, Schedule.

Department of Energy Office of Science Report from DOE Office of High Energy Physics Report from DOE Office of High Energy Physics Dr. Robin Staffin Associate.

Department of Energy Office of Science Yet Another Report from DOE Office of High Energy Physics Presented to SLUO September 10, 2006 Dr. Robin.

February 19, 2008 FACET Review 1 Lab Overview and Future Onsite Facilities Persis S. Drell DirectorSLAC.

Office of Science U.S. Department of Energy SLAC Users Organization Meeting July 6, 2004 Dr. Robin Staffin, Associate Director Office of High Energy Physics.

A Possible Strategy Towards a Future Lepton Collider Tor Raubenheimer SLUO Annual Meeting September 17, 2009.

Future Planning for SLAC Persis S. Drell. December 5, 2003SLAC Scenarios2 Scenarios Study 2003: Process  Started early in 2003  Inclusive of SLAC faculty,

Department of Energy Office of Science 1 DOE Office of High Energy Physics SLAC User Organization Meeting Dennis Kovar Associate Director of the Office.

October 24, 2000Milestones, Funding of USCMS S&C Matthias Kasemann1 US CMS Software and Computing Milestones and Funding Profiles Matthias Kasemann Fermilab.

Fermilab Implementation of DOE Critical Decision Process FRA Project Management System Presentation by L Edward Temple Jr Head, Office of Project Management.

HEPAP and P5 Report DIET Federation Roundtable JSPS, Washington, DC; April 29, 2015 Andrew J. Lankford HEPAP Chair University of California, Irvine.

3/6/2006FY07/08 DOE Budget Briefing1 FY07/08 Budget Briefing Jonathan Dorfan Director Persis Drell Deputy Director SLAC.

Office of High Energy Physics View on Dark Energy Collaborations Kathleen Turner Office of High Energy Physics (HEP) Office of Science (SC), U.S. Department.

Long Range Planning Pier Oddone September 24, 2007.

BNL Overview DOE Annual HEP Program Review Brookhaven National Laboratory April 17-19, 2006 Sam Aronson.

Impacts of Tevatron Extension Pier Oddone P5 Meeting, October 15 th, P. Oddone, P5 Meeting, October 15, 2010.

Planning for Discoveries in Particle Physics Michael Witherell EPP2010 May 16, 2005.

Department of Energy Office of Science High Energy Physics Briefing to the Astronomy and Astrophysics Advisory Committee Dr. Robin Staffin Associate Director,

US ILC Review by DOE/NSF Apr. 4-6 at Fermilab Consultant reviewers: Ilan Ben-Zvi (BNL/ATF &RHIC) Dixon Bogert (FNAL/NUMI) Isidoro Campisi (ORNL/SNS) Tom.

24 April 2015 FY 2016 Budget Request to Congress for DOE’s Office of Science Dr. Patricia M. Dehmer Acting Director, Office of Science

Office of Science U.S. Department of Energy RHIC Users Meeting BNL; June 8, 2006 Gulshan Rai RHIC/AGS Users Meeting Gulshan Rai Program Manager for Heavy.

Office of Science U.S. Department of Energy FY07 OMB Briefing Draft v1.0.

U.S. Department of Energy Office of Science U.S. Department of Energy Office of Science High Energy Physics Advisory Panel Meeting FY 2009 Budget Request.

P5 and the HEP Program A. Seiden Fermilab June 2, 2003.

27-March-10 LCWS10 - Beijing Global Design Effort 1 Barry Barish LCWS10 - Beijing 27-March-10 “Cost Containment” for the TDR.

Fermilab Neutrino Program Jim Strait Neutrino Discussion at CERN 26 November 2013.

All Hands Meeting FY 2008 Budget Pier Oddone Fermilab December 20, 2007.

Office of Science U.S. Department of Energy Raymond L. Orbach Director Office of Science U.S. Department of Energy Presentation to BESAC December 6, 2004.

24-Aug-11 ILCSC -Mumbai Global Design Effort 1 ILC: Future after 2012 preserving GDE assets post-TDR pre-construction program.

Challenges & Issues for SBNE Nigel S. Lockyer 4/4/14.

11 DOE Office of Science High Energy Physics Program AAAC Meeting October 15, 2009 National Science Foundation Dennis Kovar Associate Director of the Office.

Status Report on ILC Project in Japan Seiichi SHIMASAKI Director, Office for Particle and Nuclear Research Promotion June 19, 2015.

Summary Comments and Discussion Pier Oddone 40 th Anniversary Users’ Meeting June 8, 2007.

Mu2e, August 15, 2007 E Prebys 1 The Steering Group and mu2e Eric Prebys.

Welcome and Presentation of Charge Steve Holmes Accelerator Advisory Committee ( May 10-12, 2005.

Report from the Office of High Energy Physics Glen Crawford Director, Research and Technology Division Office of High Energy Physics LHC Users Organization.

Department of Energy Office of Science  FY 2007 Request for Office of Science is 14% above FY 2006 Appropriation  FY 2007 Request for HEP is 8% above.

News Y2K June 25, Summary of June 12 Face-to-Face Meeting.

Fermilab: Present and Future Young-Kee Kim Data Preservation Workshop May 16, 2011.

P5 Report: The Particle Physics Roadmap 1 A. Seiden Fermilab May 14, 2007.

ILC 2007 Global Design Effort 1 Planning Damping Rings Activities in the Engineering Design Phase Andy Wolski Cockcroft Institute/University of Liverpool.

BNL Overview DOE Annual HEP Program Review Brookhaven National Laboratory April 17-19, 2006 Sam Aronson.

Steering Group Meeting 10:30 – 12:30 am CDT Monday, July 23, 2007 Y2K.

The categories for ILC budget planning are: R&D – work done in laboratories to develop and verify subsystem components. This supports the cost reduction.

SLAC All Hands Briefing: FY2008 Budget Persis S. Drell SLAC Director 1/7/08.

DUNE Collaboration Meeting September 4, 2015 Glen Crawford Research and Technology Division Director Office of High Energy Physics Office of Science, U.S.

DETECTOR RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT Fred Borcherding 1.

CPAD Instrumentation Frontier Meeting October 5-7, 2015 Glen Crawford, Helmut Marsiske Office of Science, U.S. Department of Energy DOE Office of High.

Fermilab: Introduction Young-Kee Kim DOE KA12 (Electron Research)Review June 22-23, 2010.

Workshop summary Outline  Workshop’s aims  Highlights from the presentations (my selection!)  Costing Exercise – What we learnt  Summary - Roadmap.

CPM 2012, Fermilab D. MacFarlane & N. Holtkamp The Snowmass process and SLAC plans for HEP.

Fermilab Budget Briefing FY 2014 Intensity Frontier Proton Research KA Breakout February 28, 2013 Office of High Energy Physics Germantown, MD.

1 CF lab review ; September 16-19, 2013, H.Weerts Budget and Activity Summary Slides with budget numbers and FTE summaries/activity for FY14 through FY16.

Fermilab-India Agreements and Collaboration Shekhar Mishra Project-X, International Collaboration Coodinator Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory Batavia,

Particle Physics Sector Young-Kee Kim / Greg Bock Leadership Team Strategic Planning Winter Workshop January 29, 2013.

FNAL SCRF Review R. Kephart. What is this Review? FNAL has argued that SCRF technology is an “enabling” accelerator technology (much like superconducting.

Head, Office of Project Management Oversight (OPMO)

Yet Another Report from DOE Office of High Energy Physics

Preparations for a Lehman Review

Introduction to Jefferson Lab

Introduction FY09 Linac Ops Review

Prospect of Indo-US Collaboration

Presentation transcript:

Budget Outlook Glen Crawford P5 Meeting Sep

24 Sep 2007HEP Budget FY08 Update for P52 DOE FY2008 Budget + Outyears FY2008 brief review Outyears Inputs for P5 Revised DOE out-year budget scenarios Revised facility ops out-year projections Revised new project profiles (actual+ my guesses)

24 Sep 2007HEP Budget FY08 Update for P53 FY2008: Status  HEP FY 2008 Request is 4% above FY 2007 Appropriation ($782M vs $751M) House mark at President’s Request Senate mark at President’s Request +7M Both have interesting language on JDEM  Expect Continuing Resolution…for how long?  Out-year projections ambiguous (more on this later)

24 Sep 2007HEP Budget FY08 Update for P54 HEP Long-term Trend

24 Sep 2007HEP Budget FY08 Update for P55 HEP program in FY 2008 Overall HEP priorities in FY 2008: Tevatron and B-factory supported to run Last year of B-factory Ops LHC support (Ops and Computing) up 9% as data taking begins Core research program at the universities (+3%) and laboratories (+2%) maintained New initiatives for the future of HEP (see next slide)

24 Sep 2007HEP Budget FY08 Update for P56 Initiatives in FY08 Initiatives for the future of HEP: ILC R&D ($42M  $60M) SCRF infrastructure development continues More new neutrino experiments Main Injector Neutrino Exp’t v-A (MINERvA) Tokai-to-Kamioka near detector (T2K) Stage III Dark Energy experiment (DES) Investment in long-term accelerator R&D increased +$5M

24 Sep 2007HEP Budget FY08 Update for P57 HEP Trends FY2008 Growth continues in R&D and new initiatives Addresses highest priority future facility (ILC) as well as long-term R&D (accelerator science) Also targeted at high-impact physics areas in the nearer term that have relatively well-defined “roadmaps”: Neutrinos Dark Energy The challenge is that HEP budgets only growing at approximately cost-of-living…hard to grow new efforts

24 Sep 2007HEP Budget FY08 Update for P58 Revised Input for P5 Advice inconsistent with likely budget scenarios does not help But boundary conditions have changed, particularly ILC We would also like to know priorities independent of budget Out-year overall budget envelope has changed since last time Was: Growing at few to several % per year Now: ?? Facilities Operations envelopes : Now have better idea of B-factory ramp-down trajectory (at least 1 st phase). FY2010 Tevatron running? Project profiles Revised profiles: actual plans for actual projects; my guesses for others. Did not iterate with NSF. New proposals beginning to surface

24 Sep 2007HEP Budget FY08 Update for P59 Suggested out-year scenarios $ in MillionsFY05FY06FY07FY08FY09FY10FY11 HEP Budget out-years, FY07 Pres Req Alternative HEP out-years (~FY08 Req) Actual “Alternative” assumes 7% annual increase (a la ACI), see following slide

24 Sep 2007HEP Budget FY08 Update for P510 Outyear HEP Profile DOE HEP FY2007 out-year profile is a component of an Office of Science proposal developed with FY2007 Pres. Req. and sent to Congress March 2006 Grows 1-3% (9-10%) per yr in ( ) Actual bottoms-up integration of projects FY2008 “profile” is nominal 7% per yr pro rata Compromise forced by lack of agreement between OMB and Congress on outyear planning Mechanical increase of each SC program by fixed rate Because it is based on FY08 Req., integral funding is less than in comparable FY07 exercise.

24 Sep 2007HEP Budget FY08 Update for P511 Facilities Ramp-down Profiles These are our rough estimates We concur with FNAL estimates of ~$25M (M&S only) incremental to run Collider for one year. Assume: LCLS covers most of SLAC linac ops (2008+). HEP Ops staff at SLAC transition to other activities. FNAL operations for NuMI will continue thru NOvA (2018?) Est. annual savings in $M Year 1Year 2Year 3 Tevatron $215M$185M$165M$155M B-factory35 5 $90M$55M$20M$15M

24 Sep 2007HEP Budget FY08 Update for P512 Project Profiles : Caveats  All numbers are rounded, “planning level”, per experiment (may want >1)  Start and end dates flexible; does not include operations  Unless otherwise noted these are NOT actual project profiles  All $ in Millions and could include contributions from both US funding agencies

24 Sep 2007HEP Budget FY08 Update for P513 Nominal Project Profiles I “Small” projects (Total Project Cost [TPC] <$50M) ProjectYear 1Year 2Year 3Year 4Year 5 Nominal TPC DES (CD-1) Daya Bay (CD-1) Small Dark Matter Expt g

24 Sep 2007HEP Budget FY08 Update for P514 Nominal Project Profiles II “Medium” projects ($400M>TPC>$50M): ProjectYear 1Year 2Year 3Year 4Year 5Year 6 TPC ($M) Ground-based DE Telescope Large DM Expt Double Beta Decay Expt NOvA (CD-2) LHC Detector Upgrades Next Gen Nu Expt DUSEL Phase I

24 Sep 2007HEP Budget FY08 Update for P515 Nominal Project Profiles III Large new facilities ($1B > TPC > $400M) Project Year 1 Year 2 Year 3Year 4 Year 5 Year 6 TPC Space-based Dark Energy Telescope Megaton-scale Nu Detector ILC Pre- construction R&D (US share) ILC US site studies + industrialization

24 Sep 2007HEP Budget FY08 Update for P516 Nominal Project Profiles IV Ultra-scale new facilities (TPC > $1B) Project Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5 Year 6 Out- Year TPC ILC construction (US Share, FY07$) Neutrino FactoryTBD Muon ColliderTBD

24 Sep 2007HEP Budget FY08 Update for P517 What’s Not Included “Super” NuMI Upgrade (0.7  1.2MW) Needs revised profile from lab. TPC $50-100M? LHC Accelerator Upgrade Needs definition of what it is (CERN) Needs definition of US scope Project X No cost estimate yet

24 Sep 2007HEP Budget FY08 Update for P518 Summary Budget outlook (FY08+) is uncertain May clear up in 6 months…or not So are boundary conditions ILC is the elephant in the room Does that change priorities? Particularly, if ILC is delayed or stretched out P5 advice will be most useful in Determining optimal balance of existing research program vs. future opportunities What are the budget implications of different physics scenarios?