Learning from a ‘complex’ intervention targeted at a complex group and reported through a heterogenous literature base – a realist synthesis Lhussier M,

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Southern Voices networks Asia Consortium and networks.
Advertisements

| | Learning from EuroHealthNets Health Inequalities Projects.
YMCA Proposal Writing Successful Strategies for Financial Development.
Practical approaches to building and sustaining community capacity
Tools for Policy Influence. RAPID Programme SMEPOL, Cairo, February, Practical Tools.
Implementing NICE guidance
Introduction to the unit and mixed methods approaches to research Kerry Hood.
Intelligence Step 5 - Capacity Analysis Capacity Analysis Without capacity, the most innovative and brilliant interventions will not be implemented, wont.
Integrating comprehensive, active PPIR in CLAHRC-EofE: building impact and relevance Fiona Poland (UEA), Patricia Wilson (UH), Sarah Rae (CLAHRC PPI) CLAHRC-EofE.
Development of a Community SPIRIT ‘The Journey so Far’ Alun E Morgan MPhil Student.
Assessing student learning from Public Engagement David Owen National Co-ordinating Centre for Public Engagement Funded by the UK Funding Councils, Research.
The Well-being of Nations
Community Engagement & Good Practice Foziha Raja EACH Counselling Service.
Evolution of the MS Specialist Nurse Role. Life up to 1997 for UK MS Specialist Nurses MS nurses in post Each nurse covered an overwhelming geographical.
Brendan McDonnell Director CENI Mapping Community Resilience Neighbourhood Renewal Pilot.
Northampton – Development Opportunities a framework for enabling positive change.
Evaluating public RTD interventions: A performance audit perspective from the EU European Court of Auditors American Evaluation Society, Portland, 3 November.
Meredith Newlin, Research Fellow and PhD Candidate Centre for Mental Health Social Research This presentation presents independent research funded by the.
Good Evaluation Planning – and why this matters Presentation by Elliot Stern to Evaluation Network Meeting January 16 th 2015.
Practicing Community-engaged Research Mary Anne McDonald, MA, Dr PH Duke Center for Community Research Duke Translational Medicine Institute Division of.
Program Evaluation. Lecture Overview  Program evaluation and program development  Logic of program evaluation (Program theory)  Four-Step Model  Comprehensive.
Strengthening Church and Government Partnerships for Primary Health Care Delivery in Papua New Guinea: Lessons from the International Experience HPHF Hub.
Improving the uptake of cardiac rehabilitation: using theoretical modelling to design an intervention Mosleh S 1, Campbell N 2, Kiger A 1, 1 Centre for.
Reflective Practice Leadership Development Tool. Context recognised that a key differentiator between places where people wanted to work and places where.
Health Communication, Advocacy and Integrated Strategic Communication. The case of HIV/AIDS Jan Servaes Professor and Chair, Department of Communication.
Community Based Approaches: A review of intervention models and evidence of their effectiveness for preventing maternal-to-child transmission of HIV Joanna.
YMCA Proposal Writing Successful Strategies for Financial Development.
SQA Standards Colloquium 28 February 2013 – Can Qualification Frameworks Provide a Useful Basis for Comparing Qualifications? Aileen Ponton, CEO,SCQF Partnership.
Assessment of Families
Organisational Change Management Services: Insight and Capabilities
European Youth Tackling Obesity Young people leading behaviour change: A social marketing approach to encourage healthy lifestyles.
Northampton – Development Opportunities a framework for enabling positive change.
Commissioning for Culture, Health and Wellbeing Ian Tearle Head of Health Policy Directorate of Public Health, NHS Devon Wednesday 7 th March 2012.
CHCCD412A Cluster 1.  s/pdf_file/0006/54888/CHAPS_Community- Services-Pathway-Flyer_v 4.pdf
Lessons from RAPID’s work on research-policy links John Young.
Mark Dooris Director, Healthy Settings Development Unit University of Central Lancashire Investing for Health.
Bridging the Cultural Divide in Health & Mental Health Care Settings: The Essential Role of Cultural Brokering Programs Tawara D. Goode National Center.
Needs Assessment: Young People’s Drug and Alcohol Services in Edinburgh City EADP Children, Young People and Families Network Event 7 th March 2012 Joanne.
Accountability in Health Promotion: Sharing Lessons Learned Management and Program Services Directorate Population and Public Health Branch Health Canada.
Nursing in the Community: reviewing the evidence base Dr Catriona Kennedy Senior Lecturer Consensus Conference 16 th May 2006.
Supporting families since 1869 Young Carers’ Conference 25 March 2009 Working with families: finding a way to positive outcomes Rose de Paeztron Jacqui.
EVALUATION APPROACHES Heather Aquilina 24 March 2015.
Alliance 4 Useful Evidence Webinar, 1 September 2015.
Addressing ethnic inequalities in health service access, experience and outcomes through the critical mobilisation and application of evidence This project.
Integrating Knowledge Translation and Exchange into a grant Maureen Dobbins, RN, PhD SON, January 14, 2013.
Student volunteers and the volunteer- involving community organisations vinspiredstudents research.
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT and COMMUNITY IMMUNITY Dr BH Fisher MBE PPI Lead for the NHS Alliance Lead for the HELP Project.
Combining Theory and Systems Building Experiences and Challenges Sotirios Terzis University of Strathclyde.
Chapter 4 Developing and Sustaining a Knowledge Culture
Chapter 4 Developing and Sustaining a Knowledge Culture
Using Logic Models in Program Planning and Grant Proposals The Covenant Foundation.
Today.. Overview of my realist synthesis Reflections on the process
Nottinghamshire Health & Wellbeing Board Peer Challenge Cathy Quinn Associate Director of Public Health.
Doing the Right Thing Unlocking the voluntary and community sector’s potential for making change happen in health and care.
Improving skills and care standards in the support workforce: a realist synthesis of workforce development interventions Jo Rycroft-Malone, Christopher.
Guidelines Recommandations. Role Ideal mediator for bridging between research findings and actual clinical practice Ideal tool for professionals, managers,
Engaging with Commissioning Heidi Bellamy Policy Development & Business Manager.
Wander Jager 1 An updated conceptual framework for integrated modelling of human decision making: The Consumat II.
National Professional Standards for Teachers. Focus Role of the Australian Institute for Teaching and School Leadership Background on the National Professional.
true potential An Introduction to the Middle Manager Programme’s CMI Qualifications.
Copyright © 2014 Wolters Kluwer Health | Lippincott Williams & Wilkins Chapter 42 Emerging Theories Debra Tupe.
Bringing Diversity into Impact Evaluation: Towards a Broadened View of Design and Methods for Impact Evaluation Sanjeev Sridharan.
Creating Positive Culture through Leadership (Recovery Orientation) Jennifer Black.
Commissioning for Wellbeing Time banking and other initiatives in Plymouth Rachel Silcock.
By Dr. Talat AnwarAdvisor Centre for Policy Studies, CIIT, Islamabad Centre for Policy Studies, CIIT, Islamabad
Commission on School Reform 13th April OECD - some positives  Above average levels in PISA science and reading  Around average in PISA maths 
By Ali Alkhuraiji, PhD student Supervisors Prof Shaofeng Liu, Dr Fenio Annansingh, Plymouth University. Knowledge Network Modelling (KNM)to Support Decision.
Overview for Placement
Poster 1. Leadership Development Programme : Leading Cultures of Research and Innovation in Clinical Teams Background The NHS Constitution is explicit.
Professor Deborah Baker
Presentation transcript:

Learning from a ‘complex’ intervention targeted at a complex group and reported through a heterogenous literature base – a realist synthesis Lhussier M, Forster N, Carr SM, Northumbria University & Fuse, UK The cultural distinctiveness and particular needs of Traveller Communities mean that outreach forms a key ‘bridge’ between them and statutory health services (To Whom) The cultural background of outreach workers (being a peer) is key to the success of their intervention because it enables them to use the right communication tools (By Whom) The degree of intervention formality and responsiveness to need are key levers for participation (How) Key aims of outreach are to tackle health inequalities through engagement, advocacy and education (What for) This paper reports on a realist synthesis of the literature on outreach interventions for Traveller Communities (TC) ( A thorough search of the literature was undertaken, and key stakeholders, including Traveller Community members, outreach workers and members of Traveller organisations were involved in a number of Expert Hearing events formed an important element of the project. They contributed crucial insights into Traveller Community members’ decision making processes around trust and engagement, helping to validate and refine emerging findings. The literature was overwhelmingly anecdotal, with only one RCT identified. The evidence on outreach was under theorised and lacked process detail. TC are a complex group, defined on a number of lifestyles and ethnic dimensions, described through a literature rich in statements of cultural distinctiveness and need. The emergence of lay or peer roles in public health is an instinctively appealing format in a context of hard-to-reach groups facing increasing inequalities. Outreach is a typical example of this, and the heterogeneous literature base typical of such ill defined and individualised interventions. The key challenges this represented to the review process were linked to teasing out C-M combinations with satisfactory explanatory potential, when O were rarely measured. The development of an explanatory framework required the combination of three sets of substantive theories; a model of person – environment engagement, a typology of individual engagement and a model of trust development. Drawing on these and making extensive use of Expert Hearings to supplement our data – poor literature base led to the development of an explanatory framework with strong face validity and translational potential. Corresponding author: Monique Lhussier, Mobility is a key distinguishing factor of TC, not as a crude lifestyle descriptor, but its impact on the formation, development and maintenance of social networks is key. Trust is a key in explaining why some interventions work. This is not only linked to who the outreach worker is, but also their history of working with TC. Four initial theories: Engagement is an important process tool and negotiation (responsiveness) is part of this. Engagement (behavioural, cognitive, emotional) decision making determines the outcome. Three levels of engagement could be identified (participation, behaviour change, social capital development) MRT: Neufeld’s cycle of engagement* Gradual building of trust and engagement Disengagement entrenched Participation Evaluation Trust building Negotiation * Neufeld J, Rasmussen H, Lopez S, Ryder J, Magyar-Moe J. The engagement model of person-environment interaction. The Counseling Psychologist. 2006;34(2):