Joint BPS and ESS/ITS ATC/AFC Subcommittee Update November 2007 – January 2008 February 5, 2008.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Business Practices Subcommittee Update October 23, 2012 DRAFT.
Advertisements

Standards Review Subcommittee Update October 23, 2012 Draft.
BPS / NERC TLR Drafting Team Subcommittee Update November 2007 – January 2008 February 5, 2008.
Standards Review Subcommittee Update February – April 2008 May 13, 2008 DRAFT.
Business Practices Subcommittee Update August 17, 2010.
Standards Review Subcommittee Update February 1, 2011.
Business Practices Subcommittee Update October 26, 2010.
Business Practices Subcommittee Update February 2, 2010.
Business Practices Subcommittee Update February 1, 2011.
Standards Review Subcommittee Update October 27, 2009.
Standards Review Subcommittee Update May – August 2008 August 19, 2008.
Standards Review Subcommittee Update 2008 Review November 4, 2008 DRAFT.
Business Practices Subcommittee Update April 30, 2012.
Business Practices Subcommittee Update February 3, 2009.
WECC Operating Committee Report WECC Member Meeting April 20, 2006.
Western Electricity Coordinating Council Status of NERC Standards Activity WECC PCC Meeting March 6-7, 2008.
Implementation Council Meeting Structure and Resources Background: The Implementation Council (Council) roles and responsibilities are described in the.
Duke Energy Carolinas Quarterly Stakeholder Meeting Independent Entity Services Thursday, August 26, :00 to 3:00 p.m. EDT.
2009 Performance Assessment Member Representatives Committee Meeting October 28, 2008.
Physical Security CIP NERC Standing Committees December 9-10, 2014.
MAC Committee Update Robert Kondziolka, MAC Chair.
Joint Electric Scheduling Subcommittee Update August 20, 2013.
Andy Meyers OC Update ISAS April 2014 Salt Lake City, UT.
Duke Energy Carolinas Quarterly Stakeholder Meeting Independent Entity Services Thursday, December 2, :00 to 3:00 p.m. EDT.
Duke Energy Carolinas Quarterly Stakeholder Meeting Independent Entity Services Thursday, May 13th, :00 to 3:00 p.m. EDT.
Business Practices Subcommittee Update May 4, 2010.
Resale Business Practice Standards 3 Options remain.
1 Free Template from MFR…. Uh…  How do you get a man to stop biting his nails? Make him wear shoes.  What do you instantly.
Business Practices Subcommittee Update Executive Committee Meeting February 18, 2014.
Standards Review Subcommittee Update November 2007 – January 2008 February 5, 2008.
Planning and Community Development Department Housing Element City Council February 03, 2014.
Duke Energy Carolinas Quarterly Stakeholder Meeting Independent Entity Services Thursday, May 19, :00 to 4:00 p.m. EDT 2 nd Quarter 2011.
July 2008 CPS2 Waiver SDT Technical Workshop for Draft BAL-001-TRE-01 Judith A. James Reliability Standards Manager TRE.
Why Proposed TC Procedures? Define how TC reaches “completion” of what OASIS calls “Committee Specifications” TC procedures lead up to the OASIS process:
Background Management Council (MC) was briefed on approach in early Feb 2003 and approved it Agreed that every Service Group (SG) will participate in.
Business Practices Subcommittee Update Executive Committee Meeting February 24, 2015.
Electronic Scheduling /Information Technology Subcommittees (ESS/ITS) Update 2008 Review November 4, 2008.
Joint Electric Scheduling Subcommittee Update April 29, 2014.
Entergy AFC Stakeholder Meeting February 16, 2005 Houston, TX.
Duke Energy Carolinas Quarterly Stakeholder Meeting Independent Entity Services Tuesday, July 21, :00 to 3:00 p.m. EDT.
Anglophone West School District Education Council Sustainability Study – Bath Elementary and Middle Schools Executive Summary April 23, 2015.
Business Practices Subcommittee Update Executive Committee Meeting October 20, 2015.
NAESB WHOLESALE ELECTRIC QUADRANT BUSINESS PRACTICES SUBCOMMITTEE ACTIVITIES UPDATE TO JOINT ELECTRIC SCHEDULING SUBCOMMITTEE JANUARY 5, 2012 BY ED SKIBA.
Standards Review Subcommittee Update August 17, 2010.
Joint Electric Scheduling Subcommittee Update February 18, 2014.
Joint Electric Scheduling Subcommittee Update October 29, 2013.
Joint Electric Scheduling Subcommittee Update April 29, 2014.
Business Practices Subcommittee Update Executive Committee Meeting April 29, 2014.
Joint BPS and ESS/ITS ATC/AFC Subcommittee Process February 13, 2008.
1 Briefing on the Draft Call for Projects and Schedule for the Air Quality Conformity Assessment for the 2011 CLRP and FY TIP Technical Committee.
Business Practices Subcommittee Update October 27, 2009.
Business Practices Subcommittee Update Executive Committee Meeting August 18, 2015.
11 HPSA and MUA/P NEGOTIATED RULEMAKING A DRAFT ROAD MAP HOW DO WE GET FROM HERE TO WHERE WE NEED TO BE? November 17, 2010 Edward Salsberg, HHS Representative.
ERCOT Transmission Planning Process Overview and Recommendations November 6, 2002.
Standards Review Subcommittee Update August 19, 2014 Co-Chairs Rebecca Berdahl, BPA Marie Knox, MISO.
Business Practices Subcommittee Update August 16, 2011.
Business Practices Subcommittee Update Executive Committee Meeting February 23, 2016.
Standards Review Subcommittee Update February 3, 2009.
North America Energy Standards Board Craig L. Williams, Specialist Ld./Sr. MIC Meeting March 23, 2016 La Jolla, CA W ESTERN E LECTRICITY C OORDINATING.
Business Practices Subcommittee Update
Business Practices Subcommittee Update
Business Practices Subcommittee Update
Standard Review Subcommittee Update
Standard Review Subcommittee Update
North America Energy Standards Board
Assigned to the WEQ OASIS and WEQ OASIS/BPS Subcommittees
Assigned to the WEQ OASIS and BPS Subcommittees
Standards Review Subcommittee Update
Assigned to the WEQ OASIS and BPS Subcommittees
Standards Review Subcommittee Update
Presentation transcript:

Joint BPS and ESS/ITS ATC/AFC Subcommittee Update November 2007 – January 2008 February 5, 2008

2 Free Template from 2 November Exec. Comm. Direction Directed BPS/ESS/ITS to complete and post recommendations for formal comments so that the Executive Committee could approve at February 5, 2008, meeting: –ATC/TTC Narratives –Actual Peak Load Provide response summary to formal comments received for recommendation WEQ 2007 AP Item 2(C) Modifications to WEQ 001 to Comply with Modifications to 18 C.F.R and 37.7 within Order 890 Review list of ATC information which could be made publicly available

3 Free Template from 3 Meetings held since November Meeting –November 7, 2007 Face-to-Face –November 19, 2007 Web Conference –November 26, 2007 Web Conference –December 3, 2007 Web Conference –December 10, 2007 Face-to-Face –December 17, 2007 Web Conference –January 3-4, 2008 Web Conference –January 11, 2008 Web Conference –January 16-17, 2008 Face-to-Face –January 18, 2008 Web Conference –January 28, 2008 Web Conference

4 Free Template from 4 Accomplishments Since November Developed draft summary response to formal comments received for recommendation WEQ 2007 AP Item 2(C) Modifications to WEQ 001 to Comply with Modifications to 18 C.F.R and 37.7 within Order 890 Posted list of ATC information for informal comments Updated 890 Work Plan to align numbering with 2008 Annual Plan Updated 890 Work Plan to include additional cites from FERC Order 890-A based on listing provided by NAESB Tracking tools to monitor progress –Action item list –Motions list –Parking lot –Project plan

5 Free Template from 5 Status of Recommendations ATC/TTC Narratives –WEQ-001 OASIS requirements 95% complete –Remaining work: WEQ-002 OASIS Standards and Communication Protocols WEQ-003 OASIS Data Dictionary WEQ-013 OASIS Implementation Guide Finalize WEQ-001 OASIS Requirements Load Forecast –Work papers were submitted in October – December –Draft recommendation posted January 11, 2008 –Work papers were submitted on recommendation (recommendation was not posted for formal comments) –Co-chairs proposed alternative approach to shorten recommendation development process

6 Free Template from 6 ESS/ITS/BPS Future Meetings Scheduled February 13 Face-to-Face February Web Conference March Face-to-Face March 28 Web Conference March 31 Web Conference April Face-to-Face April 30 Web Conference May 1 Web Conference May Face-to-Face May Web Conference May Web Conference June 12 Face-to-Face July 8-9 Web Conference July 17 Face-to-Face

7 Free Template from 7 WEQ - Meeting Comparison

8 Free Template from 8 WEQ - Meeting Comparison BPS/ESS/ITS and ESS/ITS Combined Approximately 75% of people participating in the BPS/ESS/ITS meetings/activities also participate in the ESS/ITS meetings/activities.

9 Free Template from 9 Joint BPS and ESS/ITS Dynamics Common terms with different meanings Significant regional operational difference result in multiple interpretations of the requirements Team wants to dive into details (we’re behind schedule so let’s roll-up our sleeves and get busy) Best document possible (considerable time spent on editing the document) Re-thinking previously agreed to changes in language (new motions to revise approved language) New participants joining in the middle of the recommendation development process (education process/readdress issues) Lack of documentation on previous decisions (different perceptions on what the subcommittee agreed to include/not include in the revised business practices/recommendation)

10 Free Template from 10 Future Approach for Recommendation Structured Development Approach: –Agree to recommendation concepts (1 day) Review 890, 890-A General consensus of scope Conceptual documents, work papers –Draft recommendation (done outside of meeting – requires 1 week) –Subcommittee reviews/revises draft recommendation (1 day) –Informal comment period (done outside of meeting requires 2 week window) –Subcommittee responds to informal comments/revises recommendation (2 days) –Second round informal comments – discretion of subcommittee based on the extent of changes to recommendation (done outside of meeting requires 2 week window) –Subcommittee responds to informal comments/revises recommendation (1 day) –Final review – vote out of subcommittee (0.5 day) Schedule WEQ Annual Plan items for specific meetings –Meetings will be extended if meeting objectives are not met Approach is aggressive and iteration of early activities may impact schedule Optional

11 Free Template from 11 Future Approach for Recommendation Benefits –Identifies interim activities and milestones required to complete a recommendation –Provides a framework for improved status reporting on 890 activities –Sets expectations for subcommittee members Structured approach may require modifications/adjustments as the process is being implemented

12 Free Template from 12 Proposed BPS & ESS/ITS Schedule

13 Free Template from 13 BPS & ESS/ITS 890 Annual Plan Items Summary AP Items completed By June 1, 2008 –(2.b.v.1) ATC components –(2.b.v.3) ATC/TTC narratives –(2.b.v.4) Underlying load forecast assumptions –(2.b.v.5) Actual daily peak load AP Items under development by June 1, 2008 –(2.b.iii.1-3) Capacity benefit margin (CBM) –(2.b.iv.1-3) Transmission reliability margins (TRM) AP Items to be scheduled with direction/accountability from WEQ Executive Committee and Board –(2.b.ii.1) Accounting for counterflows –(2.b.ii.2) ETC complementary business practices –(2.b.v.2) Data exchange for ATC modeling –(2.b.vi) Complement to NERC transfer capability standard –(2.b.vii) TTC and ATC methodologies and values –(2.c) Transparency reporting and related functions –Postbacks (required for NERC)

14 Free Template from 14 Next Steps BPS & ESS/ITS will implement structure approach for completing Annual Plan Items Direction from the Executive Committee and Board –How to proceed Maintain status quo recognizing the issue will need to be addressed in the future. Continue conversations with FERC about steps required to meet deadlines. Reassignment of priorities: –Reprioritization of BPS/ESS/ITS annual plan items. –Defer ESS/ITS work since this work is not on a FERC deadline. –No additional assignments until WEQ Annual Plan items with FERC deadlines are complete. Additional options from the Executive Committee. –Identification of additional resources to meet deadlines –Support of structured approach being implemented May result in greater number of formal comments being submitted to Executive Committee.