Jochen Weller XLI Recontres de Moriond March, 18-25, 2006 Constraining Inverse Curvature Gravity with Supernovae O. Mena, J. Santiago and JW PRL, 96, , 2006

Jochen Weller XLI Recontres de Moriond March, 18-25, 2006 Supernovae Measurements The expansion of the Universe is accelerating !  SNe allow measurement of distance - redshift relation at large redshifts: The expansion of the Universe is accelerating !  Perlmutter et al.; Riess et al.; Knop et al.; Astier et al.

Jochen Weller XLI Recontres de Moriond March, 18-25, 2006 Dark Energy  Simplest explanation; consistent with SNe, CMB, LSS, clusters of galaxies,...  Cosmological Constant problem: Why  << (TeV) 4 ?  Why now:  m    ?  Maybe something else...

Jochen Weller XLI Recontres de Moriond March, 18-25, 2006 Maybe gravity is standard at short distances...

Jochen Weller XLI Recontres de Moriond March, 18-25, 2006 but gets modified on large distances...

Jochen Weller XLI Recontres de Moriond March, 18-25, 2006 New Gravitational Action Simple approach: F(R) = R+mR n

Jochen Weller XLI Recontres de Moriond March, 18-25, 2006  Well known for n>1  early de Sitter e.g. Starobinsky (1980) n<0  Interest here: Late time modification  n<0 (inverse curvature)  modification becomes important at low curvature and can lead to accelerated expansion [Capozziello, Carloni, Troisy (’03), Carroll, Duvvuri, Trodden, Turner (’03), Carroll, De Felice, Duvvuri, Easson, Trodden, Turner (’04)]  Simplest model (  1/R) ruled out by solar system data [Chiva (‘03), Soussa, Woodard (‘03),...] but: accelerated attractor: [CDDETT] H dH/dt

Jochen Weller XLI Recontres de Moriond March, 18-25, 2006 The new model  Flat metric  Corrections negligible in the past (large curvature), but dominant for R   2 ; acceleration today for   H 0 (Again why now problem ?)  Late time accelerated attractor [CDDTT’04]  Passes solar system tests and no ghosts under certain circumstances (see Karel van Acoleyen talk on Friday)

Jochen Weller XLI Recontres de Moriond March, 18-25, 2006 Modified Friedman Equation  Stiff, 2nd order non-linear differential equation, solution is hard numerical problem - initial conditions in radiation dominated era are close to singular point.  Source term is matter and radiation: NO DARK ENERGY  Effectively dependent on 3 extra parameters:

Jochen Weller XLI Recontres de Moriond March, 18-25, 2006 Solving the Friedman Equation for n=1  Numerical codes can not solve this from initial conditions in radiation dominated era or matter domination  Approximate analytic solution in distant past

Jochen Weller XLI Recontres de Moriond March, 18-25, 2006 Approximation and Numerical Solution  Very accurate for z ≥ few (7), better than 0.1% with H E 2 =8  G/  the standard Einstein gravity solution at early times.  Use approximate solution as initial condition at z=few (7) for numerical solution (approximation very accurate and numerical codes can cope)

Jochen Weller XLI Recontres de Moriond March, 18-25, 2006 Dynamical Analysis   is fixed by the dynamical behavior of the system  Four special values of   For    1 : both values of  are acceptable  For  1     2 :  =+1 hits singularity in past  For  2     4 :  =-1 hits singularity in past  For  2     3 : stable attractor that is decelerated for  <32/21 and accelerated for larger .  For  3     4 : no longer stable attractor and singularity is reached in the future through an accelerated phase. For small this appears in the past.

Jochen Weller XLI Recontres de Moriond March, 18-25, 2006  Include intrinsic magnitude of Supernovae as free parameter: Degenerate with value of H 0 or better absolute scale of H(z). Measure all dimensionful quantities in units of  Remaining parameters:  and    1 leads to very bad fits of the SNe data; remaining regions Fit to Supernovae Data low high

Jochen Weller XLI Recontres de Moriond March, 18-25, 2006  Fit to Riess et al (2004) gold sample; a compilation of 157 high confidence Type Ia SNe data.  very good fits, similar to  CDM (  2 = 183.3) Universe hits singularity in the past

Jochen Weller XLI Recontres de Moriond March, 18-25, 2006 low high Combining Datasets  In order to set scale use prior from Hubble Key Project: H 0 = 72  8 km/sec/Mpc [Freedman et al. ‘01]  Prior on age of the Universe: t 0 > 11.2 Gyrs [Krauss, Chaboyer ‘03] marginalized 0.07 < m < 0.21 (95% c.l.); require dark matter

Jochen Weller XLI Recontres de Moriond March, 18-25, 2006 CMB for the Brave Small scale CMB anisotropies are mainly affected by the physical cold dark matter and baryon densities and the angular diameter distance to last scattering

Jochen Weller XLI Recontres de Moriond March, 18-25, 2006 Angular Diameter Distance to Last Scattering For the brave: Angular diameter distance to last last scattering with WMAP data - might as well be bogus !

Jochen Weller XLI Recontres de Moriond March, 18-25, 2006 No need for dark energy !  Inverse curvature gravity models can lead to accelerated expansion of the Universe and explain SNe data without violation of solar system tests and being ghost free. No need for dark energy !  Use of other data sets like CMB, LSS, Baryon Oscillations and clusters require careful analysis of perturbation regime and post - Newtonian limit on cluster scales (in progress)  No alternative for dark matter !  No alternative for dark matter ! But only studied one functional form (n=1) ! But see Karel van Acoleyen talk on Friday. Conclusions

Jochen Weller XLI Recontres de Moriond March, 18-25, 2006 The Model vs Dark Energy  Require also small parameter:   Ghost free version has only scalar degree of freedom: is there a simple scalar-tensor theory ?  Is there any deeper motivation for this model ? “If at first an idea is not absurd, there is no hope for it”

Jochen Weller XLI Recontres de Moriond March, 18-25, 2006 Baryon Oscillations as Cosmological Probe  Measuring acoustic oscillations of baryons with SDSS large scale correlations  angular diameter distance scale to position of oscillation peak at z = 0.35 Eisenstein et al. 2005

Jochen Weller XLI Recontres de Moriond March, 18-25, 2006 Using Baryon Oscillations for the Invincible  angular diameter scale to acoustic peak at z=0.35 Growth of Perturbations ???

Jochen Weller XLI Recontres de Moriond March, 18-25, 2006 Putting it all together  Combined constraints form SNe, H 0, Age, WMAP and BAO