International Human Rights Law WEEK 2: LEGAL INSTITUTIONS AND ENFORCING HUMAN RIGHTS.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
CIVIL & POLITICAL RIGHTS
Advertisements

INTERNATIONAL HUMAN RIGHTS MECHANISMS
Introduction to the United Nations Human Rights System
SOURCES OF EU RIGHTS LAW Article 6 TEU indicates three sources for EE Human rights law. 1) EU Charter of Fundamental Rights, Which was proclaimed in Nice.
Lesson Objectives: I will be able to explain the doctrine of parliamentary supremacy I will be able to consider limitations on the doctrine of parliamentary.
Human rights protection and the European Union
European protection of human rights 1.Council of Europe and the European Convention on Human Rights 2.European Union and the Charter of Fundamental Rights.
Sources Of Human Rights
EU: Bilateral Agreements of Member States
EU: Bilateral Agreements of Member States. Formerly concluded international agreements of Member States with third countries Article 351 TFEU The rights.
Announcements LSJ Study Abroad Opportunities: -updates posted at the following website, look for February and March 2006 deadlines for September 2006 programs.
International Law: Unit 6 Human Rights Mr. Morrison Fall 2005.
UNIVERSAL HUMAN RIGHTS
CHAPTER 1 The sources and institutions of employment law.
The UN human rights system and indigenous peoples
INTRODUCING PROTECTION OF HUMAN RIGHTS 21 November 2011 Barbro Svedberg.
Testing your knowledge
Human Rights Lecture 18.
EU joining the ECHR New opportunities under two legal systems EQUINET HIGH-LEVEL LEGAL SEMINAR Brussels, 1 – 2 July 2010 Dr. Mario OETHEIMER EU Agency.
Human Rights 101 Key Concepts and History Oklahoma City, Oklahoma October 19, 2012 Co-Hosted by USHRN Member, IITC.
The Human Rights Act 1998 Mechanism Sections 1 and 2 of the HRA 1998.
Human Rights Act 1998 The European convention on human rights The European convention on human rights The Convention rights The Convention rights How does.
Announcements Final Study Guide posted on course web page. Response Question due in Section tomorrow.
Identifying Human Rights The protections offered by the ECHR and the Human Rights Act 1998 Brayne & Carr: Law for Social Workers: 10e Chapter 3.
Course: European Criminal Law SS 2009 Hubert Hinterhofer.
Non-Discrimination and Gender Equality Ideas, Principles and Best Practice on Working from a Human Rights Based Approach Utilizing the International, Regional.
HUMAN RIGHTS AND U.N. SYSTEM Raminder Dhiman, MBA-IB.
JáN KIMÁK LEGAL CONCEPT OF EQUALITY IN INTERNATIONAL & NATIONAL LAW
Announcements -Final Study Guide will be posted the beginning of next week. -Thursday, May 31 class will be a review session.
17 September 2008Maria Lundberg, NCHR1 JUR 5710 Institutions and Procedures Regional protection Europe.
Human Rights` An Overview International Relations Fall, 2014.
OT 5.1 At the end of this session, you should be able to u explain the main sources of human rights law and the main human rights instruments u name some.
The UPR within the context of the UN Human Rights System.
5 September 2007Maria Lundberg, NCHR1 JUR 5710 Institutions and Procedures UN Treaty bodies.
International HR Law International HR Law Historical development Historical development Institutional framework Institutional framework Principal instruments.
Acquis communautaire Community Acquis DEFINITION.
1 EU LAW WEEK 3 INSTITUTIONS OF THE EU. 2 INSTITUTIONS Institutions of the EU Principal Institutions Advisory Institutions 1.European Parliament 2.The.
United Nations Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights The individual complaints procedure under the treaty bodies.
Basic concepts in Human Rights
Parliamentary Supremacy/Sovereignty. What is Parliamentary Supremacy (sovereignty)? Established in Bill of Rights 1689 Explained by Dicey (1885) – as.
HUMAN RIGHTS AND INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS (IR 421).
CRIMINAL LAW OF THE EUROPEAN UNION 1 April 2015 THE LISBON TREATY AND CRIMINAL LAW Dr. sc. Zoran Burić Department of Criminal Procedural Law University.
European Labour Law Institutions and their Competencies JUDr. Jana Komendová, Ph.D.
Presentation to the Portfolio Committee on International Relations and Cooperation 9 May 2012 The Roles of Parliament in the Implementation of Human Rights.
HUMR5140 Introduction to Human Rights Law Autumn 2015 Lecture 7: Regional Human Rights Systems: Europe.
EUROPEAN CONVENTION ON HUMAN RIGHTS Regional protection of human rights.
HUMAN RIGHTS LAW Ahmed T. Ghandour.. CHAPTER 3. THE UNITED NATIONS & HUMAN RIGHTS II: OTHER INSTRUMENTS & PROCEDURES.
The European Convention of Human Right Corso di inglese giuridico (M-Z) Prof.ssa C. M. Cascione Università degli Studi di Bari ‘Aldo Moro’ Lezione n. 10.
International Coordinating Committee of National Human Rights Institutes (ICC): Mandates and Structure 1.
HUMAN RIGHTS: 1 LAST MEETING  Last meeting we have discussed the following topics:  1. The course description.  2. The course goals.  3. Human rights.
VICTORIAN CHARTER OF HUMAN RIGHTS AND RESPONSIBILITIES.
M O N T E N E G R O Negotiating Team for the Accession of Montenegro to the European Union Working Group for Chapter 31 – Common Foreign, Security and.
The European dimension Corso di inglese giuridico (M-Z) Prof.ssa C. M. Cascione Università degli Studi di Bari ‘Aldo Moro’ Lezione n. 9.
Introduction to the UN human rights system UN TRAINING FOR TRANS ACTIVISTS SEPTEMBER 2015.
History.... Right up until 1998 the UK did not have a bill of rights giving its citizens rights to certain basic freedoms. However, as early as 1950 the.
Lost in Translations – An Examination of the Legal & Practical Problems Associated with the Implementation (or Non-Implementation) of Directive 2010/64/EU.
International Human Rights Law (LG 332) Topic 8: Regional Systems 1- Europe.
HUMAN RIGHTS AND INTERNATIONAL LAW. Sources of International Human Rights Law How are Human Rights protected at the international law? Treaties are the.
Human Rights in Complaints Handling and Inquiries: Perspectives from the Equality and Human Rights Commission Jonathan Timbers – Policy Manager, Equality.
International Human Rights Law
Institutions Acting in the Social Policy and their Competencies
European Labour Law Institutions Acting in the Social Policy and their Competencies JUDr. Jana Komendová, Ph.D.
FUNDAMENTAL HUMAN RIGHTS A MULTILEVEL SYSTEM OF PROTECTION
European actions.
The European Convention of Human Rights
Fundamental rights.
The European Human Rights System
Introduction to protection of human rights under the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms Lucia Berdisová Department.
Fundamental rights.
The right to access to justice between EU Charter and ECHR
Presentation transcript:

International Human Rights Law WEEK 2: LEGAL INSTITUTIONS AND ENFORCING HUMAN RIGHTS

Agenda for Today 1.How to Read a Legal Case 2.Monitoring and Enforcing Human Rights o The United Nations o The Council of Europe and the European Court of Justice o The Human Rights Act and the Idea of a British Bill of Rights 3.Concluding Discussion

How to Read a Legal Case

o Material Facts (& Procedural Background) o Relevant Legal Issues o Summary of Legal Arguments & Application of Law to Facts o Decision (Judgment and Concurring and Dissenting Opinions)

How to Read a Legal Case Read the CJEU press release on Shrems judgment issued on 6 October 2015 o What are the material facts? o What was procedural background? o What was the relevant law that the Court of Justice was required to consider? o What was Maximillian Schrems’ main legal argument? o What was the Data Protection Commissioner of Ireland’s main legal argument? o What was the court’s decision? o How did it reach that decision (application of law to facts)?

Monitoring and Enforcing Human Rights

United Nations Charter of the United Nations 1945 Universal Declaration of Human Rights 1948 (48 countries) ◦not legally binding ◦interpretative aid to the Charter ◦most widely translated document (300+ languages) International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR) (Arts 3-21 UDHR) (168 parties) International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (ICESCR) (Arts 22-7 UDHR) (165 parties)

UN Organisational Structure Security Council ◦Responsible for maintenance of international peace and security ◦Humanitarian intervention (enforcement action) ◦Condemn violations of HR ◦Sanctions (S Africa, Iraq) General Assembly ◦Broad powers to deal with human rights ◦Declarations (not legally binding) ◦Receives and considers reports made by treaty-monitoring bodies through Economic and Social Council ◦Human Rights Council – a state that commits gross and systematic violations of HR can be suspended from membership by 2/3 vote of General Assembly (Libya) International Court of Justice ◦Sits in the Hague. ◦Only adjudicates on disputes between states (Bosnia-Herzegovina v Yugoslavia (Serbia and Montenegro)) ◦Issues advisory opinions on definitions and interpretations of Conventions International Criminal Court ◦Sits in the Hague. ◦Jurisdiction over individuals accused of particularly serious international crimes, e.g., genocide, crimes against humanity, etc.

UN Treaty-Monitoring Bodies Human Rights Committee ◦Monitors implementation of the ICCPR (periodic reporting) ◦Mediates inter-state complaints ◦Investigates individual complaints under Optional Protocol ICCPR (quasi-judicial procedure but not legally binding) Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights ◦Monitors implementation of the IPCESCR (periodic reporting) ◦Gross and systematic violations of HR can be suspended from membership by 2/3 vote of General Assembly (Libya)

UN Treaty-Monitoring Bodies Committee Against Torture Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination Committee on the Elimination of Discrimination Against Women Committee on the Rights of the Child Migrant Workers Committee Committee on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities Committee on Enforced Disappearances

Council of Europe & the ECHR Founded in 1949 – 10 member states European Convention on Human Rights 1950 …as the governments of European Countries which are like-minded and have a common heritage of political traditions, ideals, freedom and the rule of law to take the first steps for the collective enforcement of the rights stated in the Universal Declaration…

ECHR and the Margin of Appreciation Handyside v United Kingdom (1976) It is not possible to find in the domestic law of the various Contracting States a uniform European conception of morals. The view taken by their respective laws of the requirements of morals varies from time to time and from place to place, especially in our era which is characterised by a rapid and far-reaching evolution of opinions on the subject. By reason of their direct and continuous contact with the vital forces of their countries, State authorities are in principle in a better position than the international judge to give an opinion on the exact content of these requirements as well as on the ‘necessity’ of a ‘restriction’ or ‘penalty’ intended to meet them. BUT, The ‘domestic margin of appreciation…goes hand in hand with a European supervision (para 49).’

European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) Founded in Sits in Strasbourg. Receives complaints from individuals and States alleging violations of rights protected under ECHR Gives advisory opinions on legal questions arising from interpretation ECHR Inter-State Complaints ◦Ireland v UK [1978] – interrogation methods employed by UK on IRA suspects amounted to torture, inhuman and degrading treatment in breach of Article 3) Individual Complaints ◦

European Union Originally 3 European Communities: Treaty of Paris 1951  European Coal and Steel Community Treaties of Rome (TFEU) 1957  European Economic Community + European Atomic Energy Community Maastricht Treaty 1993  European Union All 28 member states of the European Union are also members of the Council of Europe and bound by the terms of the ECHR

Charter of Fundamental Rights Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union (2000) ◦Incorporated into the Treaty of Lisbon 2007 ◦Affirms universality, indivisibility, democracy & rule of law ◦Codifies existing rights enjoyed by European citizens ◦Rights to be recognised and applied by the institutions of the Community and by the Member States when implementing Community law (Art 51) Fundamental Rights Agency established 2007 to collect information on fundamental rights and offer expert advice to EU member states and institutions Proposal for EU to accede to ECHR stalled by ECJ ruling December 2014 – would not be in accordance with EU law

European Court of Justice Established Sits in Luxembourg. Jurisdiction of the court: ◦Requests for a preliminary ruling (Article 267 TFEU) ◦Actions for failure to fulfill an obligation – brought against EU govts for not applying EU law ◦Actions for Annulment – against EU laws thought to violate EU treaties or fundamental rights ◦Actions for failure to Act – against EU institutions for failing to make decision required of them ◦Direct Actions – brought by individuals, companies or organisations against EU decisions or actions

In Summary… United Nations International Bill of Human Rights International Court of Justice (Hague) Council of Europe European Convention of Human Rights European Court of Human Rights (Strasbourg) European Union Charter of Fundamental Rights + Lisbon Treaty European Court of Justice (Luxembourg)

Human Rights Act 1998 Incorporated key provisions of the ECHR into UK domestic law: ◦UK law must be interpreted by the courts, as far as possible, in a way compatible with HRA rights ◦If an Act of Parliament breaches these rights, courts can declare legislation incompatible (but the law remains valid until Parliament acts) ◦It is unlawful for any public authority to act incompatibly with HRA rights ◦Any Minister proposing a Bill must state the Bill is either compatible with human rights or that it is incompatible but that the Government nevertheless wishes to proceed with the Bill BUT consider the doctrine of parliamentary supremacy – parliament is the supreme legal authority, courts cannot overrule the will of parliament, no parliament can bind its successors

In Summary… United Nations International Bill of Human Rights International Court of Justice (Hague) Council of Europe European Convention of Human Rights European Court of Human Rights (Strasbourg) European Union Charter of Fundamental Rights + Lisbon Treaty European Court of Justice (Luxembourg) UK Human Rights Act UK Domestic Courts

Agenda for Today 1.How to Read a Legal Case 2.Monitoring and Enforcing Human Rights o The United Nations o The Council of Europe and the European Court of Justice o The Human Rights Act and the Idea of a British Bill of Rights 3.Concluding Discussion

Next Week 1.Introduction to Equality and Non-Discrimination 2.Review of Case Studies: Article 14 ECHR 3.Concluding Discussion

Thank you! ANY QUESTIONS?