Notes by Jeff Borland Internet Research Torture numbers, and they'll confess to anything. -Gregg Easterbrook.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Evaluating Electronic Information
Advertisements

1 WEB SITE EVALUATION ENGLISH 115 Hudson Valley Community College Marvin Library Learning Commons.
Crime and Punishment Lesson 7-5. Measurement of Crime Crime- acts in violation of the law.
When I receive information, I usually... assume the author is an expert. accept that the information is true. OR do I... consult a credible source to.
When I receive information, I usually... accept that the information is true. OR do I... verify the author’s claims/facts.
The Death Penalty: Why it should be Illegal. Death Penalty Defined  Death penalty or death sentence, which in some cases is also known as capital punishment.
Books such as The Long Thaw explain issues like climate change in language that is easy for the general public to understand. Authors.
A guide. Define your goal What are you looking for?
Websites vs. Databases Glenforest Secondary School Library Resource Centre Primary Source: M. Rosettis, St. Augustine.
What’s Good on the Web and What Isn’t How to Tell Anna Pilston and Matt Fisher.
Don’t Listen to the Village Idiot
Finding Reliable Research on the Internet. So where do I start? Your essays will be comprised of a variety of information, but because we live in a digital.
Research Papers Locating Your Sources. Two Kinds of Sources Primary source: original text, document, interview, speech, or letter (it is the text itself)
Not All Web Pages Are Created Equally.. Why Do We Need to Evaluate Sites Can you tell which is the "real" site? This one: WhiteHouse.gov or this one?
The Internet versus the Reference Section The answers are out there…
English 115 Web Site Evaluation Hudson Valley Community College Marvin Library Learning Commons 1.
Sources of Information for the Research Paper
 Chapter 6: Interacting with Texts (p. 104) › Active Reading (p. 105) › Annotating (p. 105) › Scanning/Focused Reading (p. 107)
EVALUATING SOURCES Finding Credible Websites. Online Research Strategies  The internet is a BIG place full of a ton of information. Some of it will be.
Thinking about what you see Revised March  Books, Magazines, Encyclopedias careful about what they publish (both online and in hard copy) ◦ Difficult.
WEBSITE EVALUATION BECAUSE SOMETIMES, THE INTERNET LIES.
Ms. Mitchell Freshman Composition Andover High School.
What do experts think? What do students think? What do you think?
Justifications for Capital Punishment (Parts II and III) Deterrence and Incapacitation.
Evaluating Websites Do you trust everyone to tell you the truth? Osama bin Laden, Terrorist Was one of FBI’s 10 Most Wanted Fugitives Reward:
Literacy in Information: Evaluating Internet Resources Jennifer Fendrick & Nicole Christensen In order to properly evaluate a website, the.
EVALUATING ONLINE SOURCES. GOAL Identify criteria to evaluate websites. Evaluate websites to determine their usefulness for research & your own personal.
How Do You Know It’s the Real Thing? Evaluating Websites.
EVALUATING SOURCES Finding Credible Websites. Online Research Strategies  The internet is a BIG place full of a ton of information. Some of it will be.
Evaluating Websites Do you trust everyone to tell you the truth? Osama bin Laden, Terrorist Was one of FBI’s 10 Most Wanted Fugitives Reward:
7 th Grade Research Source Requirements. What is a source? Sources are pieces of evidence that will support your research. First hand research is research.
Validation and trustworthiness But what’s the difference.
Database Definition: A collection of verified information that is organized so that you can easily search and find the information you want. NOT A WEBSITE!
Lesson 6, Unit 3 Using the Internet for Research Based on the Plan Ahead educational materials made available by Gap Inc. at and.
Hey there! Have you evaluated? Is that site good enough to cite?
Interactive Skills for Students How to Use What You Find On the Internet click your mouse or hit enter to advance animation.
Jeopardy Thesis statement On the Web Q $100 Q $200 Q $300 Q $400 Q $500 Q $100 Q $200 Q $300 Q $400 Q $500 Final Jeopardy The Introduction Citations.
 Take out the following materials: 1. Your research links if you did not turn them in yesterday 2. Signed Movie Permission Forms 3. Your ALWG text 4.
Guidelines For Evaluating Web Sites. The web is a lot like a flea market--- a large selection of sites to choose from--- but not a lot of order to it.
On Reliable Sources. Citation is key In a research paper, your own opinion doesn’t matter Everything you say must come from cited evidence Evidence: information.
WHO CAN YOU TRUST??. WHAT IS RELIABLE? Dependable Trustworthy.
Pros and cons to online learning By justin chalmers.
Hudson Valley Community College Marvin Library Web Site Evaluation
Is that site good enough to cite?
Reliable and UNRELIABLE Sources
Reliable and UNRELIABLE Sources
Reliable and UNRELIABLE Sources
Credible vs Non-Credible Sources
Using Secondary Sources [Secondary Sources.pptx]
How To: Research Like a Boss.
Source Info Card Workshop in Ecosystem Ecology Insights into Climate Change: Past, Present, and Future First published in 1923, Time.
Don’t Listen to the Village Idiot
Research: Lessons 2 & 3 I can determine the credibility of a source.
Don’t Listen to the Village Idiot
Don’t Listen to the Village Idiot
Don’t Listen to the Village Idiot
Don’t Listen to the Village Idiot
Don’t Listen to the Village Idiot
Don’t Listen to the Village Idiot
Dazed, Amazed and Googled
Credible Sources.
Don’t Listen to the Village Idiot
Reliable and Unreliable Sources.
Is that site good enough to cite?
Formal Research Paper.
Don’t Listen to the Village Idiot
Don’t Listen to the Village Idiot
Don’t Listen to the Village Idiot
Mass Media: Digital Media and Fake News
Presentation transcript:

Notes by Jeff Borland Internet Research Torture numbers, and they'll confess to anything. -Gregg Easterbrook

Notes by Jeff Borland Internet Statistics Pros Pro –Up to date –Easy to access –Enormous amount Con –Reliability? Anyone can put stuff up Data is difficult to attain People may spin the stats Can be outdated

Notes by Jeff Borland Who’s data is it? If you don’t know the source, check it out. If you cant verify it, don’t use it.

Notes by Jeff Borland Who’s data is it? Get data from: –Sources you have heard of: New York Times, other papers Newsweek, other magazines Census or other governmental departments Encyclopedias –Wikipedia is good, but remember its user edited Nationally known research sites like PEW, or ROPER. –If you haven’t heard of it: Find what the agenda of the source is –What is their motivation? Do they have a bias? Find how they collected their data Find what others are saying about the source, if its reputable.

Notes by Jeff Borland Is it relevant? Find the date of the data, some statistics, like political polls need to be very up to date to be relevant. For other data, being very recent, doesn’t matter as much.

Notes by Jeff Borland Is there a spin? Does the site have some bias in the information? A survey of experts from the American Society of Criminology, the Academy of Criminal Justice Sciences, and the Law and Society Association showed that the overwhelming majority did not believe that the death penalty is a proven deterrent to homicide. Over 80% believe the existing research fails to support a deterrence justification for the death penalty. Similarly, over 75% of those polled do not believe that increasing the number of executions, or decreasing the time spent on death row before execution, would produce a general deterrent effect. -from

Notes by Jeff Borland How did they acquire the data? Are there varying estimates? Would the data be hard to get accurately?