Joint CATHIE/TECHQM Workshop, BNL, Dec 14-18, 2009 Huichao Song The Ohio State University Supported by DOE 12/14/2009 Lawrence Berkeley National Lab QGP.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

QGP Viscosity & Elliptic Flow for Multi-strange Hadrons

Advertisements

Dynamic Modeling for Relativistic Heavy Ion Collisions

Huichao Song The Ohio State University Lawrence Berkeley National Lab Viscous Hydro +URQMD In collaboration with S.Bass, U.Heinz, C.Shen, P.Huovinen &

New Results from Viscous Hydro + URQMD (VISHNU) International School for High Energy Nuclear Collisions, Wuhan, Oct 31- Nov.5, 2011 References: Supported.

Elliptic flow of thermal photons in Au+Au collisions at 200GeV QNP2009 Beijing, Sep , 2009 F.M. Liu Central China Normal University, China T. Hirano.

Supported by DOE 11/22/2011 QGP viscosity at RHIC and LHC energies 1 Huichao Song 宋慧超 Seminar at the Interdisciplinary Center for Theoretical Study, USTC.

Effects of Bulk Viscosity on p T -Spectra and Elliptic Flow Parameter Akihiko Monnai Department of Physics, The University of Tokyo, Japan Collaborator:

Hadronic Rescattering Effects after Hadronization of QGP Fluids Tetsufumi Hirano Institute of Physics, University of Tokyo Workshop “Hadronization” in.

Hadronic dissipative effects on transverse dynamics at RHIC Tetsufumi Hirano Dept. of Physics The Univ. of Tokyo QM2008, Feb. 4-10, 2008 TH, U.Heinz, D.Kharzeev,

Mass ordering of differential elliptic flow and its violation for  mesons Tetsufumi Hirano Dept. of Physics, The Univ. of Tokyo Matsumoto, Feb ,

1Erice 2012, Roy A. Lacey, Stony Brook University.

1 Questions about sQGP Carlos Arguello Columbia University 24 th Winter Workshop on Nuclear Dynamics April 10 th 2008.

Measuring initial temperature through Photon to dilepton ratio Collaborators: Jan-e Alam, Sourav Sarkar & Bikash Sinha Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre,

Hydrodynamic Approaches to Relativistic Heavy Ion Collisions Tetsufumi Hirano RIKEN BNL Research Center.

The centrality dependence of elliptic flow Jean-Yves Ollitrault, Clément Gombeaud (Saclay), Hans-Joachim Drescher, Adrian Dumitru (Frankfurt) nucl-th/

WWND, San Diego1 Scaling Characteristics of Azimuthal Anisotropy at RHIC Michael Issah SUNY Stony Brook for the PHENIX Collaboration.

Perfect Fluid: flow measurements are described by ideal hydro Problem: all fluids have some viscosity -- can we measure it? I. Radial flow fluctuations:

Perfect Fluid: flow measurements are described by ideal hydro Problem: all fluids have some viscosity -- can we measure it? I. Transverse flow fluctuations:

Effects of Bulk Viscosity at Freezeout Akihiko Monnai Department of Physics, The University of Tokyo Collaborator: Tetsufumi Hirano Nagoya Mini-Workshop.

S C O T T PRATPRAT MICHIGANMICHIGAN S T T E UNIVRSITYUNIVRSITY T H BTBT PUZZLE PUZZLE Z A N D E X T E N D I N G HYRODYNAMICS HYRODYNAMICS.

Viscous hydrodynamics DPF 2009 Huichao Song The Ohio State University Supported by DOE 07/30/2009 July 27-July 31, Detroit, MI with shear and bulk viscosity.

Viscous hydrodynamics and the QCD equation of state Azwinndini Muronga 1,2 1 Centre for Theoretical Physics and Astrophysics Department of Physics, University.

Viscous hydrodynamics and Transport Models Azwinndini Muronga 1,2 1 Centre for Theoretical Physics and Astrophysics Department of Physics, University of.

Hydrodynamics, flow, and flow fluctuations Jean-Yves Ollitrault IPhT-Saclay Hirschegg 2010: Strongly Interacting Matter under Extreme Conditions International.

Masashi Kaneta, LBNL Masashi Kaneta for the STAR collaboration Lawrence Berkeley National Lab. First results from STAR experiment at RHIC - Soft hadron.

Perfect Fluid: flow measurements are described by ideal hydro Problem: all fluids have some viscosity -- can we measure it? I. Radial flow fluctuations:

The effects of viscosity on hydrodynamical evolution of QGP 苏中乾大连理工大学 Dalian University of Technology.

Longitudinal de-correlation of anisotropic flow in Pb+Pb collisions Victor Roy ITP Goethe University Frankfurt In collaboration with L-G Pang, G-Y Qin,

S C O T T PRATTPRATT M I C H I G A N STATESTATE U N I V E R S I Y T S U N A M I THETHE B T PUZZLEPUZZLE ANDAND T H E R H I C.

Akihiko Monnai Department of Physics, The University of Tokyo Collaborator: Tetsufumi Hirano Viscous Hydrodynamics for Relativistic Systems with Multi-Components.

Workshop for Particle Correlations and Femtoscopy 2011

Csörgő, T. 1 Observables and initial conditions from exact rotational hydro solutions T. Csörgő 1, I. Barna 1 and M.I. Nagy 1,3 1 MTA Wigner Research Center.

Jaipur February 2008 Quark Matter 2008 Initial conditions and space-time scales in relativistic heavy ion collisions Yu. Sinyukov, BITP, Kiev (with participation.

Dynamical Modeling of Relativistic Heavy Ion Collisions Tetsufumi Hirano Workshop at RCNP, Nov 4, 2004 Work in partly collaboration with Y.Nara (Frankfurt),

Akihiko Monnai Department of Physics, The University of Tokyo Collaborator: Tetsufumi Hirano Viscous Hydrodynamics Heavy Ion Meeting December 10.

Zagreb, Croatia, 2015/04/20 Csörgő, T. 1 New exact solutions of hydrodynamcs and search for the QCD Critical Point T. Csörgő 1,2 with I.Barna 1 and M.

Akihiko Monnai Department of Physics, The University of Tokyo Collaborator: Tetsufumi Hirano V iscous Hydrodynamic Expansion of the Quark- Gluon Plasma.

Viscous hydrodynamics Quark Matter 2009 Huichao Song and Ulrich Heinz The Ohio State University Supported by DOE 04/02/2009 March 30-April 4, Knoxville,

Effects of bulk viscosity in causal viscous hydrodynamics Jianwei Li, Yugang Ma and Guoliang Ma Shanghai Institute of Applied Physics, CAS 1. Motivation.

ATHIC2014, Osaka, Japan, Aug.5-Aug.8, /05/2014 The Fluid Nature & Viscosity of the QGP Huichao Song Peking University.

QM2012, Washington, DC, Aug. 13-Aug. 18, 2012 Supported by DOE 08/13/2012 QGP viscosity at RHIC and LHC energies Huichao Song Thanks for discussions with.

Flow fluctuation and event plane correlation from E-by-E Hydrodynamics and Transport Model Victor Roy Central China Normal University, Wuhan, China Collaborators.

Koichi Murase A, Tetsufumi Hirano B The University of Tokyo A, Sophia University B Hydrodynamic fluctuations and dissipation in an integrated dynamical.

Does HBT interferometry probe thermalization? Clément Gombeaud, Tuomas Lappi and J-Y Ollitrault IPhT Saclay WPCF 2009, CERN, October 16, 2009.

Partial thermalization, a key ingredient of the HBT Puzzle Clément Gombeaud CEA/Saclay-CNRS Quark-Matter 09, April 09.

Akihiko Monnai Department of Physics, The University of Tokyo Collaborator: Tetsufumi Hirano Relativistic Viscous Hydrodynamics for Multi-Component Systems.

Peter Kolb, CIPANP03, May 22, 2003what we learn from hydro1 What did we learn, and what will we learn from Hydro CIPANP 2003 New York City, May 22, 2003.

RHIC-II EoS working groupEoS Physics Program #1 1. What physics topics are to be addressed? 2. What observables are sensitive to this physics? 3. Where.

Elliptic flow and shear viscosity in a parton cascade approach G. Ferini INFN-LNS, Catania P. Castorina, M. Colonna, M. Di Toro, V. Greco.

Scott Pratt Michigan State University Have we seen the QGP at RHIC? Scott Pratt, Michigan State University MORE MEANINGFUL QUESTIONS: 1.Have we created.

2Roy A. Lacey, Stony Brook University, SEWM2010 Study of the properties of the QGP is a central goal at RHIC “The major discoveries in the first five.

School of Collective Dynamics in High-Energy CollisionsLevente Molnar, Purdue University 1 Effect of resonance decays on the extracted kinetic freeze-out.

Glasma, minijets, strings  long range  correlations  Venugopalan Ask: how does viscous flow modify these correlations? Viscosity, Flow and the Ridge.

Squaw Valley, Feb. 2013, Roy A. Lacey, Stony Brook University Take home message  The scaling (p T, ε, R, ∆L, etc) properties of azimuthal anisotropy.

3-D Hydro: present and future Tetsufumi Hirano Columbia University Second RHIC II Science BNL, Probes of EOS.

Flow and Dissipation in Ultrarelativistic Heavy Ion Collisions September 16 th 2009, ECT* Italy Akihiko Monnai Department of Physics, The University of.

3 rd Joint Meeting of the Nuclear Physics Divisions of the APS and the JPS October 15 th 2009, Hawaii USA Akihiko Monnai Department of Physics, The University.

Workshop on Flow and heavy flavour in high energy heavy-Ion collisions Inha University, 2015/2/26.

Shear Viscosity and Collective Flow in Heavy Ion Collisions within Parton Cascade Calculations Zhe Xu, Carsten Greiner Trento, Sept. 17, 2009 Institut.

Radiative transport: comparisons between BAMPS and viscous hydro Zhe Xu with I.Bouras, A.El, O.Fochler, F.Lauciello, E.Molnar, H.Niemi, C.Greiner, D.H..Rischke.

Soft physics in PbPb at the LHC Hadron Collider Physics 2011 P. Kuijer ALICECMSATLAS Necessarily incomplete.

PHENIX. Motivation Collaboration PHENIX Roy A. Lacey (SUNY Stony Brook) PHENIX Collaboration I N T E R N A T I O N A L W O R K S H O P O N T H E P H.

Akihiko Monnai Department of Physics, The University of Tokyo Collaborator: Tetsufumi Hirano V iscous Hydrodynamic Evolution with Non-Boost Invariant Flow.

@ Brookhaven National Laboratory April 2008 QCD Critical Point and Its Effects on Physical Observables Schematic Consideration Masayuki ASAKAWA Department.

 Collision of heavy nuclei at relativistic energies leads to formation of Quark- Gluon Plasma (QGP).  Strong confirmation arises from the recent observation.

Hydro + Cascade Model at RHIC

Bulk viscosity in heavy ion collisions

Effects of Bulk Viscosity at Freezeout

Effects of Bulk Viscosity on pT Spectra and Elliptic Flow Coefficients

Fluctuations and Correlations at

Presentation transcript:

Joint CATHIE/TECHQM Workshop, BNL, Dec 14-18, 2009 Huichao Song The Ohio State University Supported by DOE 12/14/2009 Lawrence Berkeley National Lab QGP viscosity from RHIC data -- a hydrodynamic perspective Thanks for collaborations and discussions from U. Heinz; Thanks for figures and discussions from K. Dusling, A. El, S. Pratt, Z. Xu, and many others

What is viscosity Shear viscosity – measures the resistance to flow gradients Bulk viscosity – measures the resistance to expansion Heat conductivity – measures the ability of heat transfer Assume: (RHIC&LHC) act against the buildup of flow anisotropy act against the buildup of radial flow

Ideal hydrodynamics S.Bass Conservation laws: ideal hydro: local equilibrium Input: “EOS” - 4 equations - 5 unknowns -EOS is one of the important factors that influence the expansion of system harder EOS (with larger ) faster expansion

Viscous hydrodynamics S.Bass Conservation laws: viscous hydro: near equilibrium shear pressure tensor bulk pressure: ideal hydro: local equilibrium

Viscous hydrodynamics S.Bass Conservation laws: - Israel-Stewart eqns.

Viscous hydrodynamics S.Bass Conservation laws: - Israel-Stewart eqns. viscous hydro: near-equilibrium system pre-equilibrium dynamics + viscous hydro + hadron cascade Initial conditionsfinal conditions

Viscous hydrodynamics S.Bass Conservation laws: - Israel-Stewart eqns. Input: “EOS”initial and final conditions Bjorken appro. : reduces (3+1)-d hydro to (2+1)-d hydro

Qualitative effects of & on spectra -shear viscosity: flatter spectra -bulk viscosity: steeper spectra spectra The same initial & final conditions: ideal hydro viscous hydro-shear only viscous hydro-bulk only Song & Heinz, 0909

-shear viscosity: flatter spectra; increases radial flow -bulk viscosity: steeper spectra; decreases radial flow radial flowspectra The same initial & final conditions: ideal hydro viscous hydro-shear only viscous hydro-bulk only Song & Heinz, 0909 Qualitative effects of & on spectra

Elliptic flow v 2 -both shear & bulk viscosity suppress V 2 at low P T Song & Heinz, 0909 Qualitative effects of & on V 2

Shear viscosity & elliptic flow V % v 2 suppression Elliptic flow v 2 - V 2 can be used to extract the QGP shear viscosity -For an acurrate extraction of QGP viscosity, one needs very precise V 2 (experimental data & theoretical results)

- V 2 can be used to extract the QGP shear viscosity 20-25% v 2 suppression Elliptic flow v 2 Shear viscosity & elliptic flow V 2 -For an acurrate extraction of QGP viscosity, one needs very precise V 2 (experimental data & theoretical results)

- V 2 can be used to extract the QGP shear viscosity 20-25% v 2 suppression - 10% uncertainties in V 2 translate into 50% uncertainties for the extracted value of Elliptic flow v 2 Example: If v 2 is increased by 10%, one need to increase by in order to describe the same exp. data Shear viscosity & elliptic flow V 2 -For an acurrate extraction of QGP viscosity, one needs very precise V 2 (experimental data & theoretical results)

Extracting from V 2 data Input / parameters for viscous hydro -initial conditions: -EoS: EOS Q, EOS L, EOS L + chemical non-equil. HRG EOS -treatment of hadronic stage and freeze-out procedure: -viscosities & relaxation times: -initial eccentricity (Glauber/CGC ; optical/fluctuations) -initialization for

Effects of initial eccentricity on Luzum & Romatschke, PRC 2008 GlauberCGC -event by event fluctuations: talk by A. Dumitru -Glauber vs.CGC: ~20-30% effect on ~100% uncertainties on

Luzum & Romatschke, PRC 2008 GlauberCGC -Effects from highly viscous & non-chemical equilibrium hadronic stage, bulk viscosity … Effects of initial eccentricity on NOT so fast !

Extracting from V 2 data Input / parameters for viscous hydro -initial conditions: -EoS: -treatment of hadronic stage and freeze-out procedure: -viscosities & relaxation times: -initial eccentricity -chemical composition of HRG -effects of highly viscous HRG -initialization for shear and bulk pressure

Effects of chemical composition of HRG on 30% PCE vs.CE (HRG) Ideal hydro P. Huovinen 07 -PCE EoS vs. CE EoS (ideal hydro): change v 2 by ~30% Partial Chemical Equilibrium (PCE) vs. Chemical Equilibrium (CE)

30% PCE vs.CE (HRG) -Constraining requires: a proper description of partial chemical equilibrium in HRG Glauber CGC 30% P. Huovinen 07 Luzum &Romatschke 08 Effects of chemical composition of HRG on -PCE EoS vs. CE EoS (ideal hydro): change V 2 ~30% influence ~100% Ideal hydro

Effects of highly viscous hadronic stage on -highly viscous hadronic stage: change V 2 ~30-50% influence ~ % -need viscous hydro + hadron cascade hybrid approach 30-50% T. Hirano Ideal hydro

Extracting from V 2 data Input / parameters for viscous hydro -initial conditions: -EoS: (EOSQ vs EOSL) -treatment of hadronic stage and freeze-out procedures: -viscosities & relaxation times: -initial eccentricity -chemical composition of HRG -viscosity of HRG -initialization for shear and bulk pressure

talk by P. Houvinen Effects from softness of EOS 40% 30% Song & Heinz PRC EOS L: Katz 05 lattice data for QGP SM-EOS Q vs. EOS L --more realistic EOS for hydro -- softness of EOS: ~5-10% effects on V 2 ~25% uncertainties on + CE EOS for HRG 0903 lattice data for QGP + PCE EOS for HRG

Extracting from V 2 data Input / parameters for viscous hydro -initial conditions: -EoS: (EOSQ vs EOSL) -treatment of hadronic stage and freeze-out procedures: -viscosities & relaxation times: -initial eccentricity -chemical composition of HRG -viscosity of HRG -initialization for shear and bulk pressure

shear pressure: relaxation times & initialization - is insensitive to initializations of and relaxation time ! Song, Ph.D thesis -when extracting : one can neglect the uncertainties from & initialization of (since is short)

Extracting from V 2 data Input / parameters for viscous hydro -initial conditions: -EoS: (EOSQ vs EOSL) -treatment of hadronic stage and freeze-out procedures: -initial eccentricity -chemical composition of HRG -viscosity of HRG -effects from bulk viscosity - shear pressure: relaxation times and initialization

QGPHRG bulk viscosity and relaxation time Bulk viscosity: Relaxation times: also peaks near T c, this plays an important role for bulk viscous dynamics

QGPHRG bulk viscosity and relaxation time Bulk viscosity: Relaxation times: also peaks near T c, this plays an important role for bulk viscous dynamics Zero initialization: large near T c prevents from growing to large values suppresses bulk viscous effects

QGPHRG bulk viscosity and relaxation time Bulk viscosity: Relaxation times: also peaks near T c, N-S initialization: viscous hydro breaks down ( ) for larger viscous hydro is only valid with small small bulk viscous effects on V 2 large near T c keeps large negative value of in phase transition region this plays an important role for bulk viscous dynamics

Uncertainties from bulk viscosity N-S initializationZero initialization -with a critical slowing down, effects from bulk viscosity effects are much smaller than from shear viscosity bulk viscosity influences V 2 ~5% (N-S initial.) <4% (zero initial.) Song & Heinz, 0909 uncertainties to ~20% (N-S initial.) <15% (zero initial.)

Extracting from RHIC data --the current status of viscous hydrodynamics -initial conditions: CGC vs. Glauber ~20-30% -EoS: EOS Q, vs. EOS L ~5- 10% -chemical composition of HRG : (PEC vs. CE) ~30% -viscosity of HRG (or equil. HRG vs. non-equil. HRG) : ~30-50% -bulk viscosity: ~5% (uncertainties in V 2 )

Extracting from RHIC data --the current status of viscous hydrodynamics GlauberCGC Luzum & Romatschke, PRC initial conditions: CGC vs. Glauber ~100% -EoS: EOS Q, vs. EOS L ~ 25% -chemical composition of HRG : (PEC vs. CE) ~100% -viscosity of HRG (or equil. HRG vs. non-equil. HRG) : ~ % -bulk viscosity: ~20% (uncertainties in ) conservative upper limit:

Extracting from RHIC data --the current status of viscous hydrodynamics GlauberCGC Luzum & Romatschke, PRC initial conditions: CGC vs. Glauber ~100% -EoS: EOS Q, vs. EOS L ~ 25% -chemical composition of HRG : (PEC vs. CE) ~100% -viscosity of HRG (or equil. HRG vs. non-equil. HRG) : ~ % -bulk viscosity: ~20% (uncertainties in ) conservative upper limit: Can we further increase the accuracy of extracted ? YES ! recent progress: Heinz et al. 0907

Extracting from RHIC data --the current status of viscous hydrodynamics GlauberCGC Luzum & Romatschke, PRC initial conditions: CGC vs. Glauber ~100% -EoS: EOS Q, vs. EOS L ~ 25% -chemical composition of HRG : (PEC vs. CE) ~100% -viscosity of HRG (or equil. HRG vs. non-equil. HRG) : ~ % -bulk viscosity: ~20% (uncertainties in ) conservative upper limit: recent progress: Heinz et al To further decrease the uncertainties from bulk viscosity, (or to extract both shear & bulk viscosity from exp. data), one need more sensitive exp. observables

other observables that are sensitive to - v 2 /ε: dependence on system size & shear viscosity -photon spectra -HBT radii … …

Song & Heinz PRC 08 -larger shear viscous suppression of elliptic flow in smaller systems System size dependence of shear viscous effects

Song & Heinz PRC 08 System size dependence of shear viscous effects -the slope of the multiplicity scaling of v 2 /ε is sensitive to the value of shear viscosity -larger shear viscous suppression of elliptic flow in smaller systems

Song & Heinz PRC 08 System size dependence of shear viscous effects -larger shear viscous suppression of elliptic flow in smaller systems -the slope of the multiplicity scaling of v 2 /ε is sensitive to the value of shear viscosity

Song & Heinz PRC 08 System size dependence of shear viscous effects -larger shear viscous suppression of elliptic flow in smaller systems -the slope of the multiplicity scaling of v 2 /ε is sensitive to the value of shear viscosity

Multiplicity scaling of v 2 /ε Song & Heinz PRC 08 -to reproduce the experimental data (slope), a constant is not enough! -the slope of the multiplicity scaling of v 2 /ε is sensitive to the value of shear viscosity

Multiplicity scaling of v 2 /ε Song & Heinz PRC 08 -to reproduce the experimental data (slope), a constant is not enough! -the slope of the multiplicity scaling of v 2 /ε is sensitive to the value of shear viscosity -data indicate: smaller viscous effects in QGP; larger viscous effects in HRG -need viscous hydro + hadron cascade hybrid approach or inputting

other observables that are sensitive to -photon spectra -HBT radii … … - v 2 /ε: dependence on system size & shear viscosity

EM probes: Photons Pion spectra -Viscous hardening of P T -spectra is stronger for photons than hadrons K. Dusling, 0903 Photon spectra -Photon spectra MAY HELP to constrain the 2-d range of QGP viscosity & thermalization time, together with other observables ( V 2 …) -However, earlier thermalization also leads to harder photon spectra (Dusling 0903)

other observables that are sensitive to -photon spectra -HBT radii … … - v 2 /ε: dependence on system size & shear viscosity

HBT radii - is sensitive to the QGP viscosity - HBT HELPS to constrain the QGP viscosity, together with other observables ( V 2 …) S. Pratt QM09 with viscosity without viscosity - However, viscosity is only one of the many ingredients that affect HBT radii (Pratt QM09)

Recent theroetical developments in viscous hydrodynamics (MSU, Frankfurt, Krakow, etc) d viscous hydro: Several groups are working on it - in multi-component systems - 3 rd order viscous hydrodynamics Talk by A. El Talk by G. Denicol Talk by D.Teaney and D. Molnar - P T -dependent of viscous modification of the particle distributions

A short summary BUT: to extract QGP viscosity, one must consider (at least) all the following aspects: - a realistic EOS: EOS L vs. SM-EOS Q, PCE vs. CE - initial conditions: CGC vs. Glauber initialization, optical vs. fluctuations - bulk viscosity: uncertainties from bulk viscosity … … - hadronic stage : viscous hydro+ hadron cascade - is sensitive to A first attempt to constrain from RHIC data indicates

Thank You

EOS

Elliptical flow v 2 -v 2 is sensitive to viscosity, especially shear viscosity Qualitative effects of & on V 2 Change the flow profile during hydro evolution Flow + spectra correc. Spectra correc.: viscous hydro (shear only) ideal hydro viscous hydro (bulk only) (with only flow correction here) A. Monnai talk : spectra correc. for bulk viscosity Song & Heinz, 0909

EM probes: Photons -Photon spectra are more sensitive to QGP shear viscosity than hadrons Photon spectra -Photon spectra may HELP to constrain QGP shear viscosity and hydro starting time -Photon spectra are also sensitive to hydro starting time -More sophisticated theoretical modeling in the future: including photon emitted from hadronic stage with modified photon emission rate, etc ; better experimental data K. Dusling, 0903

-To describe the experimental data, one need to consider the contribution from all kinds of aspects besides shear viscosity S. Pratt QM09

-Heinz, Moreland and Song the effects from different initializations

-Heinz, Moreland and Song the effects from different initializations

Glauber CGC

Glauber CGC