Emerton & Polkinghorne on the continuing value of natural theology ~ slide 1 Emerton on arguments for God from nature & science zNorma Emerton. “Arguments.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Recent versions of the Design Argument So far we have considered the classical arguments of Aquinas and Paley. However, the design argument has attracted.

Advertisements

The Design Argument Richard Dawkins – ( ) Richard Dawkins, FRS, FRSL (born 26 March 1941) is a British ethologist, evolutionary biologist and popular.

Chapter 12: Is There a God?.

Without God, the World Wouldn’t Work (Psalm 104) Kirk Bertsche Grace Bible Chapel January 9, 2011.

RZIM’s Interactive Youth Apologetics

1 REVELATION. 2 OCR A2 Philosophy of religion Specification on revelation.

January 14, 2014 Exam 1: Friday 1/17/14  BRING YOUR BIBLES!!!!!!!!!

a) AO1 – Knowledge and Understanding Explain in detail Use technical terms (and explain them) Include quotations Link back to the question Make sure your.

The Study of God, Jesus Christ, and Holy Spirit..

Creation, Science & the Bible Dr. Robert C. Newman.

Design/Teleological Argument

Faith & Reason: Kierkegaard, Clifford, & Aquinas ~ slide 1

Polkinghorne on science & theology - 1 John Polkinghorne on science & theology FIntroduction GIan Barbour’s 4 ways of relating science & religion [Religion.

Polkinghorne on God & cosmology ~ slide 1 John Polkinghorne on cosmology & God 4 John Polkinghorne. Quarks, Chaos, and Christianity. Fortress Books, 1996.

The Teleological Argument

A Questions AO1 – Knowledge and Understanding – one side. Explain in lots of detail 20 mins Approx 2 sides Link back to the question Make links between.

The Teleological Argument The idea that there is evidence of design in the universe which suggests a designer.

A Questions AO1 – Knowledge and Understanding – one side. Explain in lots of detail 20 mins Approx 2 sides Link back to the question Make links between.

Does God Still Speak Today ? Just Looking. Does God Still Speak Today ? Just Looking 1.through the world we live in 2.through the Bible 3.through conscience.

The Teleological Argument October 7 th The Teleological Argument Learning Objective: To analyse the argument from Design, considering its strengths.

Chapter 1 Our Loving God: Father and Creator.

The Design Argument In his book, Natural Theology, William Paley presents the classic expression of the Design Argument. Comparison of a watch and human.

Ch. 1: God’s Good Creation: The Beginning of Salvation History

Alister McGrath, Christian Theology: An Introduction

Perspectives on Religious Belief: Evidentialism-1  Definition: belief in God must be supported by objective evidence  Natural theology: attempt to prove.

Origins: Where do we come from? Evolution/ Creation Intelligent Design.

Knowing God Through Creation Chapter 1 Lesson 1. Read Daniel 3:52 When did you first realize that God exists? How do you know that God exists?

DOCUMENTARY BY BEN STEIN *WAS THE DOCTOR IN OSMOSIS JONES *PLAYED DR. NEWMAN IN THE MASK *PLAYED RUGG IN CASPER * HOST OF WIN BEN STEIN’S MONEY Expelled.

Recent versions of the Design Argument. Describe the teleological argument for the existence of God. 4KU An argument for the existence of God or a creator.

Darwinian evolution & religion ~ slide 1 Darwin, evolution, & religion zWhat are the issues? u1. Challenges to the methods & nature of science yDarwin’s.

It is reasonable to infer the existence of God from the fact that the world is as it is; just like the cosmological argument. We are going to consider.

Belief & Science. Exam Preparation (1) 1. Explain what Christians mean by “Revelation”. (4) 2. Outline the strengths and limitations of “revelation” as.

Haught's process theodicy ~ slide 1 John Haught’s process theodicy zFrom John Haught. Responses to 101 Questions on God and Evolution. NY: Paulist Press,

Scientific Revolution. Scientific Awakening During the Middle Ages Scholarly ideas were based on ancient Greek thinkers. People thought the Earth was.

The Teleological Proof A Posteriori Argument: A argument in which a key premise can only be known through experience of the actual world. Principle of.

Science as a challenge to God. Who made the most important contribution to the science & religion debate? Copernicus Brahe Kepler Galillei Newton Hubble.

The Argument from Science (Intelligent Design) If the earth shows evidence of design, there must be a designer. For every house is built by someone,

THE WATCHMAKER AND THE WATCH Natural Theology. Drawing of inferences and proofs regarding God from the natural world.

1.The argument makes it likely that there are lots of worldmakers. Strength: Man made things often require many creators. For example a house needs many.

Humanism A cosmology that derives its beliefs and values from human experience without reference to the divine. Focus on Human Reason, not Divine Revelation.

The Scientific Revolution (16 th and 17 th century) Nicholas Copernicus Heliocentric model challenges both established science and the Church Opens the.

Aquinas on the existence of God ~ slide 1 Aquinas on the existence of God zAquinas’s arguments for God âAquinas’s famous 5 arguments appear in both the.

Teleological arguments for God’s existence

Aquinas's 2nd & 5th arguments for God - 1 Aquinas’s arguments for the existence of God zAquinas’s famous 5 argument appear in both the Summa Theologica.

The Cosmological Argument for God’s Existence or how come we all exist? Is there a rational basis for belief in God?

Dr. Sally Jessie Springer "To conclude, therefore, let no man out of a weak conceit of sobriety, or an ill-applied moderation, think or maintain, that.

History of the Church II: Week 15. Modern Challenges to the Church  Three challenges to the church emerged in the late 19 th century: liberalism, evolution.

HUME’S ASSESSMENT OF NATURAL RELIGION --Summing up Text source: Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion, part 12.

Aquinas on the existence of God ~ slide 1 Aquinas on the existence of God zAquinas’s arguments for God âAquinas’s famous 5 arguments appear in both the.

What is Enlightenment? How did science in the 18th century increase the power of the state while at the same time eroding its authority -- especially given.

Inductive Argument Premise = The world appears to have order and purpose. The world is complex, which is evidence that it has been designed. If the world.

Chapter 1: The cosmological argument AQA Religious Studies: Philosophy of Religion AS Level © Nelson Thornes Ltd 2008 Revision.

Two central questions What does it mean to talk of, or believe in, God? –Is talk about God talk about something that exists independently of us? Or a way.

Under attack: Where do theists go now? Abandon the argument Reject theism Base theism on Something else Personal faith Revealed theology Different theistic.

Origins of the Natural and Social Order 1.Creatio ex nihilo 2. Rejecting Cosmological Speculation 3. Cosmology Today.

Religious Studies RELIGIOUS STUDIES OCR Specification 4. Challenges to Religious Belief.

Starter: Mix-Pair-Share

Responses to the Design argument

Impact of the Scientific Revolution

Emerton on arguments for God from nature & science

AO2 Questions Evaluating the Teleological Argument

The Anthropic Principle

Genesis and Science Can they be reconciled?.

In pairs, attempt to describe an object in the room by saying what it is not…. It is not red…..

Unit 7 Review What you need to Know.

What conclusions could we draw from each of these photos

Chapter 21 the Enlightenment and Revolutions

The Teleological Argument

Presentation transcript:

Emerton & Polkinghorne on the continuing value of natural theology ~ slide 1 Emerton on arguments for God from nature & science zNorma Emerton. “Arguments for the Existence of God from Nature and Science.” In Science and Theology: Questions at the Interface. Eds. Murray Rae, Hilary Regan, & John Stenhouse. Grand Rapids, MI: William Eerdmans, zThere is a long tradition in Western Christianity of appealing to nature for reasoned support for God. yAnd there is scriptural support to this appeal. xPsalm 19:1 xRomans 1:20

Emerton & Polkinghorne on the continuing value of natural theology ~ slide 2 Emerton on arguments for God from nature & science yEmerton offers a brief history -- the Church Fathers, Augustine, Moses Maimonides, Aquinas, among many others. yThe Scientific Revolution brought a new attitude toward nature, that it is worthy of study. xThe immense popularity of the two-book metaphor -- Francis Bacon, Galileo, Newton, Robert Boyle

Emerton & Polkinghorne on the continuing value of natural theology ~ slide 3 Emerton on arguments for God from nature & science xThe new sciences enhanced arguments for the existence of God from nature by adding precision & accuracy to the evidence for design. xFor Bacon, Boyle & others, the exploration of nature using the new sciences was a way of glorifying God. Boyle: “When with the help of anatomical knives and the light of chymical furnaces I study the book of nature... I find myself exclaiming with the psalmist, How manifold are thy works, O God, in wisdom hast though made them all!”

Emerton & Polkinghorne on the continuing value of natural theology ~ slide 4 Emerton on arguments for God from nature & science xFor Newton, natural theology (arguments for God from nature & science) did not complement revelation, but supplanted it (79). Comments on Newton’s unorthodox theology. yThe Enlightenment criticism of design arguments. xDavid Hume’s classic challenge yYet natural theology remained popular xPaley’s Natural Theology of 1802

Emerton & Polkinghorne on the continuing value of natural theology ~ slide 5 Emerton on arguments for God from nature & science yBut Darwin’s Origin (1859) severely challenged design arguments. xYet even Darwin ended the Origin with a statement which expressed the ongoing hold of the design argument. See p. 82. xBut Darwin’s appeal to the design argument seems to have faded over time. See his 1976 statement about Paley’s argument (83).

Emerton & Polkinghorne on the continuing value of natural theology ~ slide 6 Emerton on arguments for God from nature & science yDoes this history give us some guidance about the uses of natural theology today? xThe “pure cosmological argument” seems to still have standing. Emerton claims that it will never be challenged by science (83).  What about the argument from design? It is powerful on an emotive, non-intellectual level & this is not to be despised (84). The argument brings out the value of beauty as a pointer to God.

Emerton & Polkinghorne on the continuing value of natural theology ~ slide 7 Polkinghorne’s comments on Emerton zJohn Polkinghorne’s comments on Emerton’s paper y1. Arguments from nature & science for God are limited. They may lead us to a cosmic architect or great mathematicism, but not to the God of scriptures. y2. These arguments are always vulnerable to alternative explanations. There is a risk in tying theology too closely to science. y3. Most design arguments fail to take into account the dark side of nature.

Emerton & Polkinghorne on the continuing value of natural theology ~ slide 8 Polkinghorne’s comments on Emerton yYet there is a value in these arguments. People are struck by the rational beauty of the universe & by its delicately balanced fruitful history in a way which “suggests” some intelligence behind it all.” (98) yAnd the new natural theology claims less; it claims intellectually satisfying understanding, not proof. Theism explains more than atheism.  The new design argument based on the anthropic principle explains the “fabric of the universe, not specific processes in nature.”

Emerton & Polkinghorne on the continuing value of natural theology ~ slide 9 Polkinghorne’s comments on Emerton yFinally, the new natural theology acknowledges that creation involves a kenosis of divine power. xAn evolutionary universe is one which is allowed by its creator to make itself. xThis view of God’s relation to universe gives chance a proper role. xAlso gives us a glimmer of an answer to the problem of theodicy (99). World is allowed to make itself and such a world will have blind alleys & ragged edges.