Mutual Accountability: Meaning and Challenges Tony Killick.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

1 A Framework for Common Action around shared goals Presentation by Harald Lossack, GTZ on Behalf of OECD/DAC ENVIRONET PEP Meeting 15 June 2006.

Advertisements

A worms eye view of aid architecture…. Gaps and Challenges for Reform beyond the Paris Agenda Andrew Rogerson, Overseas Development Institute.

Presented at the ECOSOC 2012 Development Cooperation Forum 1 st High-level Symposium Bamako, Mali 5-6 May 2011 by Timothy Lubanga, Assistant Commissioner.

Working Together for Greater UN Impact Repositioning the UN in a changing aid environment The case of Country xxx July 2005 Harmonization & Alignment to.

ENGAGING STRATEGICALLY WITH NON-STATE ACTORS IN NEW AID MODALITIES 7th July 2011 DEVCO-Europeaid – D2 civil Society.

EuropeAid ENGAGING STRATEGICALLY WITH NON-STATE ACTORS IN NEW AID MODALITIES SESSION 1 Why this Focus on Non-State Actors in Budget Support and SPSPs?

Towards a new leading paradigm of effective aid ? Alina Rocha Menocal, ODI Presentation prepared for the Southern Voices Workshop ODI, London, November.

Mutual Accountability The PRS approach/ Paris Declaration and the Africa Partnership Forum Donor CommitmentsInstruments for Transparency & EnforcementThird.

Session 1 UK Department of International Development.

Aid effectiveness and donor behaviour Karin Christiansen CAPE, ODI 13 th May 2004.

1 Session 3: Aid instruments and the PRSP Finnish Aid in a PRS Context Helsinki Workshop May 2003.

Harmonized support to scaling up the national AIDS response Ini Huijts 7 th June 2006 ODI meeting, London.

1 Modalities for Supporting PRSs Finnish Aid in a PRS Context Helsinki Workshop May 2003.

Why Mutual Accountability? Aid effectiveness requires country ownership, including in donor coordination Contradictions: (a) power imbalance, (b) broken.

Eastern and Southern Africa Challenges and Opportunities for Rural Development Sector-wide Approaches:

Ownership, Dialogue and Conditionality Richard Batley May 2006.

Capacity Development for Cooperation Effectiveness in Latin America and the Caribbean OAS Subregional Workshop for Cooperation Effectiveness: Caribbean.

Seminar for the European Commission Political Economy at Work Session 12: Reflections from a practitioner: undertaking analyses jointly.

Commonwealth Local Government Forum Freeport, Bahamas, May 13, 2009 Tim Kehoe Local Government and Aid Effectiveness.

Ongoing Work of the Joint Venture on Managing for Development Results (JV MfDR) Stefan Schmitz, Senior Policy Advisor Aid Effectiveness OECD Development.

Making the Most of Aid for Trade OECD Practitioners Forum Frans Lammersen.

ECA/OECD-DAC “Mutual Review of Development Effectiveness” in the context of NEPAD Briefing for DAC Evalunet Paris, 3 June 2005.

Indigenous and Tribal Peoples | | Inclusion of indigenous peoples in development and poverty reduction strategies.

And who are accountable? Seminar discussion with World Bank S. Møgedal Who sets priorities Health systems hit by AIDS:

1 Donor coordination and effectiveness of aid to agriculture Effectiveness in Aid to Agriculture Czech action to strengthen food security Glopolis / FoRS.

TRADE UNION CONSULTATION LOME 27-28/11/2012 INTERNATIONAL DEVELOPMENT AGENDAS.

Statistics and cooperation: Rome, 24 November 2005 Statistics to Inform Development Policy: the Role of PARIS21 Presentation by Antoine Simonpietri, PARIS21.

Train4dev Training for Development September-December 2006SWAP Joint Learning Event1 Supporting Sector Programmes Senior Level Session Transport Sector.

Aid for Development Effectiveness -Managing for Development Results- Terence D. Jones UNDP Third International Roundtable Managing for Development Results.

CIDA and CSOs in Effective Development Nicole GESNOT Canadian delegation to the OECD May 14, Brussels.

National Consultation on Aid Effectiveness 2 nd October, 2007 Hanoi.

Reporting on Children’s Progress Robyn McIlroy – Kirn Primary School, Dunoon Barrie Sheppard – National Parent Forum of Scotland.

Implementation of decentralisation support: Donors as change agents Harmonisation, Decentralisation and Local Governance.

Achieving the health-related Millennium Development Goals Simon Wright.

Session Overview Introduction course structure Introduction participants Declarations and guidelines on (support to) DLG Decentralisation and aid effectivenss.

Supporting country evaluation systems A view from the donor community Megan Grace Kennedy-Chouane OECD DAC Network on Development Evaluation April 2011.

ppt Partnership skills Knowledge Professional skills Personal skills and attitude.

COMI-CREV Kenya and CSOs in Effective Development Dr Joseph Amunga Deputy CEO Comi-Crev Kenya November 5, 2013 – Nairobi.

Political economy of decentralisation processes in Africa Neo Simutanyi Centre for Policy Dialogue, Zambia EU Regional Seminar on Decentralisation & Local.

Experiences and Prospects of International Development Agencies New Zealand Agency for International Development NZAID July 2006.

PARIS21 Involvement at HLF4 on Aid Effectiveness Board meeting OECD Conference Centre 27 April 2011.

Reflections on the new Aid Architecture: how did we get to where we are Philip Amis International Development Dept at CLGF meeting in the Bahamas May 2009.

Presentation at the European Seminar on CSO Development Effectiveness, Vienna, 10 and 11 March 2010.

Aid to Africa ： New Opportunities and Challenges for Japan ’ s ODA Izumi Ohno GRIPS Development Forum ODI London Workshop/March 31, 2005.

“AID EFFECTIVENESS AND HEALTH Challenges and opportunities Marielle Hart Action for Global Health.

Roundtable 3: Enriching the Paris Declaration Democratic Ownership: Alignment, Co-operation and Harmonisation.

Accounting for Partnership in MSP Evaluations Dr. Gordon Kingsley School of Public Policy Georgia Institute of Technology.

1 CAPACITY AND ITS DEVELOPMENT: NURTURING AND UNLEASHING CAPACITY: New challenges in light of Programme- Based approaches International Policy Workshop.

Promoting Mutual Accountability in Aid Relationships Paolo de Renzio Overseas Development Institute.

Joint Evaluation of the Paris Declaration, Phase 2Core Team IRG Meeting 30 Nov 2009 Key conclusions & follow-up actions DRAFT Core Evaluation Team.

Slide 1 Civil Society Policy and Practice in Donor Agencies GSDRC study commissioned by DFID, February 2010 Size and position for cover image Lone Sorensen,

A donor’s perspective in Aid for Trade Roles, Realities & Shared Responsibilities Elena Immambocus International Trade Department DFID.

SWA’s Role in Improving Aid Effectiveness in the WASH sector SWA Country Processes Task Team Geneva, November 2013.

Towards Aid Effectiveness The Role of the Donor Community

Africa Region Accra High Level Forum Preparatory Consultation Workshop Summary of Group 3 Discussions on Harmonisation and Alignment April,

Regional Seminar ENP, Russia, Yemen & Iraq Introduction to Wg3 Needs resulting from WG1&2 discussions & conceptual clarifications Baku, February 9-11,

Options for Sector Wide Approaches (SWAps)

NATIONAL DEVELOPMENT COOPERATION FRAMEWORK

Country-led Development Evaluation The Donor Role in Supporting Partner Ownership and Capacity Mr. Hans Lundgren March 2009.

Brief summary of main findings of the phase 1 evaluation

IHP+ First Steering Committee Meeting 15 January 2014

KEEPING A DEVELOPMENT FOCUS: THE CHALLENGES IN ENSURING POLICY COHERENCE FOR DEVELOPMENT: A UGANDA’S PERSPECTIVE Presented by: Pius Bigirimana, Permanent.

Aid for Development Effectiveness -Managing for Development Results-

International Aid Systems-Saasa

Alignment and Results in Development Co-operation

Background Initiated by the MDB Working Group on MfDR 2004

Effective Aid Management: Twelve Lessons from DAC Peer Reviews

Donor Perspective on Aid Effectiveness (a short recap of our commitments) Mary Cobb 2 February 2011.

(Further) Improving Development Cooperation

Management for Development Results

Presentation transcript:

Mutual Accountability: Meaning and Challenges Tony Killick

THREE STRANDS IN PUSH FOR MUTUAL ACCOUNTABILITY 1. Concerns about aid effectiveness Stress on co-ordination Harmonisation- alignment Work of the OECD/DAC Rome & Paris 2. (Related) Decline of faith in older modalities (projects, expert-driven TA) Reinforced by PRSP movement/MDGs

3. Loss of confidence in conditionality-based relationships; desire to develop alternatives 3. Loss of confidence in conditionality-based relationships; desire to develop alternatives Stress on owership & dialogue the rhetoric of partnership Mutual accountability as application of logic of partnership

CHALLENGES: mixed incentives (a) For recipients * Benefits of better aid/lower transactions costs (but how to enforce?) * Opportunity for ownership/leadership But: * Danger of ganging up, extended control * Distortion of accountability

Mixed incentives (b) For donors More effectiveness and influence, improved dialogue/access, better information BUT: * Gets in way of some objectives * Complicates their accountability * Reduces policy autonomy, pushed in potentially unwelcome directions (inc. decentralisation)

AND: * Raises issues of inter-agency relations (e.g. who leads?). Peer pressures may be unwelcome. * May be inconsistent with HQ policies, political sensitivities BASIC QUESTION: Is language of partnership more than rhetorical?