 The sources patterns were evaluated using a soil-vegetation-atmosphere model (SurfAtm-NH3) that incorporates the response of the NH 3 emissions to surface.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Spatial point patterns and Geostatistics an introduction
Advertisements

Some recent studies using Models-3 Ian Rodgers Presentation to APRIL meeting London 4 th March 2003.
Bridging the Gap Between Statistics and Engineering Statistical calibration of CFD simulations in Urban street canyons with Experimental data Liora Malki-Epshtein.
Running a model's adjoint to obtain derivatives, while more efficient and accurate than other methods, such as the finite difference method, is a computationally.
Setup of 4D VAR inverse modelling system for atmospheric CH 4 using the TM5 adjoint model Peter Bergamaschi Climate Change Unit Institute for Environment.
Factors to be considered in choosing metrics Shengmin Yu Energy Research Institute of NDRC, China Bonn, April 2012 Workshop on common metrics to calculate.
Lwando Kondlo Supervisor: Prof. Chris Koen University of the Western Cape 12/3/2008 SKA SA Postgraduate Bursary Conference Estimation of the parameters.
Managing Ammonia in Agriculture USDA Research Efforts.
Cross Cutting Group B: Ammonia policy context and future challenges Chair: Till Spranger Rapporteur: Zbigniew Klimont Attendees: 13.
European Nitrogen Assessment: Supplementary Material: Powerpoint Graphics to Chapter 5. Source: Sutton, M.A., Howard, C.M., Erisman J.W., Bealey J.W.,
N emissions and the changing landscape of air quality Rob Pinder US EPA Office of Research and Development Atmospheric Modeling & Analysis Division.
Fighting the Great Challenges in Large-scale Environmental Modelling I. Dimov n Great challenges in environmental modelling n Impact of climatic changes.
Integration of sensory modalities
Turning Point At the beginning of the course, we discussed three ways in which mathematics and statistics can be used to facilitate psychological science.
Copyright © 2005 Advantica Inc. (USA Only) and Advantica Ltd. (Outside USA). All rights reserved by the respective owner. Own Use Gas Review of Pre-heater.
Ministry of Food Agriculture and Fisheries Danish Institute of Agricultural Sciences Options for reducing the greenhouse gas emissions from agriculture.
Evaluating the Role of the CO 2 Source from CO Oxidation P. Suntharalingam Harvard University TRANSCOM Meeting, Tsukuba June 14-18, 2004 Collaborators.
1 Mass Flux in a Horizontally Homogeneous Atmosphere A useful tool for emissions and lifetimes. Assume an atmosphere well- mixed in latitude and longitude;
Tianfeng Chai 1,2, Alice Crawford 1,2, Barbara Stunder 1, Roland Draxler 1, Michael J. Pavolonis 3, Ariel Stein 1 1.NOAA Air Resources Laboratory, College.
Measurement of NO 2 Concentration in Ambient Air in Karachi using Diffusion Sampling By Zia-ul-Islam Director, Pak-EPA.
Physics 114: Lecture 15 Probability Tests & Linear Fitting Dale E. Gary NJIT Physics Department.
Characterisation of mixing processes in the lower atmosphere using Rn-222 and climate-sensitive gases P. Schelander, A. Griffiths, A.G. Williams, S. Chambers.
The horseshoe estimator for sparse signals CARLOS M. CARVALHO NICHOLAS G. POLSON JAMES G. SCOTT Biometrika (2010) Presented by Eric Wang 10/14/2010.
AMBIENT AIR CONCENTRATION MODELING Types of Pollutant Sources Point Sources e.g., stacks or vents Area Sources e.g., landfills, ponds, storage piles Volume.
Projection of uncertainties of the climate change scenarios into the estimates of future agrometeorological conditions and crop yields? M. Trnka (1,2),
Ny-Ålesund Seminars, October Black carbon (BC) belongs to what is generally termed Short Lived Climate Forcers (SLCF). This means that the.
Techniques for measuring ammonia emissions from land applications of manure and fertiliser Institute of Grassland and Environmental Research, North Wyke.
Impacts of temporal resolution and timing of streambed temperature measurements on heat tracing of vertical flux Paper No. H11D-1228 INTRODUCTION 1D heat.
EFFICIENT CHARACTERIZATION OF UNCERTAINTY IN CONTROL STRATEGY IMPACT PREDICTIONS EFFICIENT CHARACTERIZATION OF UNCERTAINTY IN CONTROL STRATEGY IMPACT PREDICTIONS.
Detecting change in atmospheric ammonia following emission changes Working Group 2 WG 2.
Advances in Support of the CMAQ Bidirectional Science Option for the Estimation of Ammonia Flux from Agricultural cropland Ellen Cooter U.S. EPA, National.
1 Advances in the Construction of Efficient Stated Choice Experimental Designs John Rose 1 Michiel Bliemer 1,2 1 The University of Sydney, Australia 2.
NH 3 EMISSIONS Intercomparation of different techniques for the storage and application of Slurry M.J. Sanz, Carlos Monter- Fundación CEAM Pilar Illescas,
Outdoor (ISO ) and indoor (ISO 11844) classification
GEOSTATISICAL ANALYSIS Course: Special Topics in Remote Sensing & GIS Mirza Muhammad Waqar Contact: EXT:2257.
Long term and high resolution observations of climate altering halogenated gases are carried out in several research stations worldwide distributed in.
Monitoring and Modelling in the Malé Declaration Kevin Hicks Stockholm Environment Institute (SEI), UK Bangkok, March 2008 Malé Declaration 6 th Monitoring.
Center for Radiative Shock Hydrodynamics Fall 2011 Review Assessment of predictive capability Derek Bingham 1.
Evaluating ammonia (NH 3 ) predictions in the NOAA National Air Quality Forecast Capability (NAQFC) using in situ aircraft measurements William Battye,
Assimilating chemical compound with a regional chemical model Chu-Chun Chang 1, Shu-Chih Yang 1, Mao-Chang Liang 2, ShuWei Hsu 1, Yu-Heng Tseng 3 and Ji-Sung.
4. Atmospheric chemical transport models 4.1 Introduction 4.2 Box model 4.3 Three dimensional atmospheric chemical transport model.
Melanie Follette-Cook Christopher Loughner (ESSIC, UMD) Kenneth Pickering (NASA GSFC) CMAS Conference October 27-29, 2014.
Nitrogen Oxide Emissions Constrained by Space-based Observations of NO 2 Columns University of Houston Amir Souri, Yunsoo Choi, Lijun Diao & Xiangshang.
11 Background Error Daryl T. Kleist* National Monsoon Mission Scoping Workshop IITM, Pune, India April 2011.
The effect of pyro-convective fires on the global troposphere: comparison of TOMCAT modelled fields with observations from ICARTT Sarah Monks Outline:
Experiences in assessing deposition model uncertainty and the consequences for policy application Rognvald I Smith Centre for Ecology and Hydrology, Edinburgh.
Office of Research and Development National Exposure Research Laboratory, Atmospheric Modeling and Analysis Division Office of Research and Development.
COST 723 WORKSHOP – SOFIA, BULGARIA MAY 2006 USE OF RADIOSONDE DATA FOR VALIDATION OF REGIONAL CLIMATE MODELLING SIMULATIONS OVER CYPRUS Panos Hadjinicolaou.
11 September 2015 On the role of measurements and modelling in Dutch air quality policies Guus Velders The Netherlands (RIVM)
Exposure Assessment for Health Effect Studies: Insights from Air Pollution Epidemiology Lianne Sheppard University of Washington Special thanks to Sun-Young.
WCRP Extremes Workshop Sept 2010 Detecting human influence on extreme daily temperature at regional scales Photo: F. Zwiers (Long-tailed Jaeger)
The Use of Natural Abundance of 13 CO 2 to Determine Soil Respiration Components in an Agro-Ecosystem a School of Environmental Sciences, University of.
Peak 8-hr Ozone Model Performance when using Biogenic VOC estimated by MEGAN and BIOME (BEIS) Kirk Baker Lake Michigan Air Directors Consortium October.
NPS Source Attribution Modeling Deterministic Models Dispersion or deterministic models Receptor Models Analysis of Spatial & Temporal Patterns Back Trajectory.
Inverse Modeling of Surface Carbon Fluxes Please read Peters et al (2007) and Explore the CarbonTracker website.
Assessment Methods for Ammonia Hot-Spots (Working Group 3) Expert Workshop under the UNECE Convention on Long-range Transboundary Air Pollution 4-6 Dec.
1 UIUC ATMOS 397G Biogeochemical Cycles and Global Change Lecture 25: Climate, Energy and Carbon Sequestration Don Wuebbles Department of Atmospheric Sciences.
Breakout Session 1 Air Quality Jack Fishman, Randy Kawa August 18.
Micromet Methods for Determining Fluxes of Nitrogen Species Tilden P. Meyers NOAA/ARL Atmospheric Turbulence and Diffusion Division Oak Ridge, TN.
Advances in Support of the CMAQ Bidirectional Science Option for the Estimation of Ammonia Flux from Agricultural cropland Ellen Cooter U.S. EPA, National.
Robin L. Dennis, Jesse O. Bash, Kristen M. Foley, Rob Gilliam, Robert W. Pinder U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, National Exposure Research Laboratory,
Exposure Prediction and Measurement Error in Air Pollution and Health Studies Lianne Sheppard Adam A. Szpiro, Sun-Young Kim University of Washington CMAS.
SUR-2250 Error Theory.
Physics 114: Lecture 13 Probability Tests & Linear Fitting
Nitrogen Deposition: Measurement Techniques and Field Studies
Chapter 2 Minimum Variance Unbiased estimation
Continuous measurement of airborne particles and gases
Parametric Methods Berlin Chen, 2005 References:
Low-Power Annular Denuder System for Measurement of HNO3, NH3 and PM2
Presentation transcript:

 The sources patterns were evaluated using a soil-vegetation-atmosphere model (SurfAtm-NH3) that incorporates the response of the NH 3 emissions to surface temperature (Personne et al. 2009).  To explore the variability of the NH 3 source, four patterns of surface emission potentials (  ) are generated over a period of 28 days (t 0 ): (1) a constant  =  0, (2) a linearly decreasing  =  0 × ( 1 – t /  0 ), (3) an exponentially decreasing  =  0 exp( ‑ 4.6 t /  0 ), (4) a Gaussian  = N(  0,   ).  The multi-source inverse problem was solved based on several samplings and field trial strategies: considering 4 heights over each field, considering the background concentration as known or unknown, and considering block-repetitions in the field set-up (3 repetitions).  The meteorological dataset of the fluxnet FR-Gri site (Grignon, FR) in 2008 was employed.  13 application periods of 28 days each throughout the year  The WindTrax and the FIDES models are used to generate the transfer time matrix between the sources and the receptors D(x i,t,S i ). The concentration at each receptor C(x i,t) is then estimated given the source strengths S j (t) and the background C bgd (t) (eq. 1).  The average NH 3 emission (S j unknown (t)) over the whole application period is estimated from these averaged concentrations (C mod (x i,t)) (eq. 3).  The NH 3 emission (S j unknown (t)) (eq. 3), is obtained from a linear regression. The objective is to find the conditions where S j unknown (t) is close to S j (t), or rather, when C(x i,t) is closer to C mod (x i,t). E VALUATION OF THE INVERSE DISPERSION MODELLING METHOD FOR ESTIMATING AMMONIA MULTI - SOURCE EMISSIONS USING LOW - COST LONG TIME AVERAGING SENSORS Loubet B. (1), Carozzi M. (1) (1) INRA, UMR 1402 INRA-AgroParisTech ECOSYS, Thiverval-Grignon, FR Context Objectives Methods  Perspectives: study of the minimum detection limit by exploring different emission potentials; Individuate the error committed in the estimation of the source by different integration times, heights, source dimensions and patterns, and background concentration values; This study will be continued to analyse further the differences between WindTrax and FIDES dispersion models, although preliminary comparison shows a general tendency of this latter to give larger transfer time. References: ₋ Flesch, T.K., et al., Deducing ground-to-air emissions from observed trace gas concentrations: A field trial. J. of App. Met., 43(3): ₋ Loubet, B., et al., An inverse model to estimate ammonia emissions from fields. European J. of Soil Science, 61: ₋ Personne, E., et al., SURFATM-NH3: a model combining the surface energy balance and bi-directional exchanges of ammonia applied at the field scale. Biogeosciences, 6(8): ₋ Sutton, M.A., et al., A new diffusion denuder system for long-term regional monitoring of atmospheric ammonia and ammonium. Wat. Air Soil Poll.: Focus(1): The NH 3 emission estimation over the integration times results more accurate when surface temperature are low (i.e. during winter) and when high friction velocities (u * ) occur. Sampling integration times of 3 to 6 hours are much more efficient in the estimation of the source with the “integrated inverse modelling method” compared to longer integration times. This efficiency does not vary sensibly from 12 to 48 h; the integration at 168 h took the worst score (Tab. 1). The size of the field is also relevant and it must be related to the measurement heights. For small fields, the error can become high due to the undetermination of the source, as D(x i,t,S i ) tends to zero. The uncertainty, then, can assumes much larger values. Tropospheric ammonia (NH 3 ) is a key player in atmospheric chemistry and its deposition is a threat for the environment (ecosystem eutrophication, soil acidification and reduction in species biodiversity). Most of the NH 3 global emissions derive from agriculture, mainly from livestock manure (storage and field application) but also from nitrogen-based fertilisers. There is still a need for a method easy to deploy under real field conditions, to better characterize the variability of NH 3 emissions with respect to concomitant agronomic practices. This implies many repetitions and the use of the micrometeorological methods is therefore difficult as it requires large fields. One option is the use of the inverse modelling approach such as WindTrax (Flesch et al. 2004) or the FIDES model of Loubet et al. (2010). However such an approach requires to measure NH 3 concentrations at a hourly time step. Unfortunately there are no low cost NH 3 analysers to deploy over several fields. The use of passive diffusion sensors (ALPHA badges, Sutton et al. 2001) is a very easy method to deploy over a large number of locations. However these sensors need a longer time integration to allow sufficient quantities of NH 3 to be captured on the acid coated filters, as a function of the source strength. This work aims at estimating in silico whether multi-source inverse dispersion modelling can be used to infer NH 3 emissions from different agronomic treatment, composed of small fields (squares of 25 m side) located near to each other, using low-cost NH 3 measurements (passive diffusion samplers). This method is thereafter called “integrated inverse modelling method”. Four main parameters are tested : (1) The strength of the sources (2) The height of the sampler (0.25 m to 2 m) (3) The sampling periods (3 hours to 1 week) (4) The application date (13 dates throughout the year) Fig. 3. a) relative root mean squared error (RRMSE; eq. 5) from NH 3 emission generated (S j ) and estimated (S j unknown ) as a function of the friction velocity (u * ), over 13 periods of 28 days and integration times; b) modelling efficiency (EF, see eq. 4) from NH 3 emission generated (S j ) and estimated (S j unknown ) as a function of the surface temperature, over 13 periods of 28 days and integration times. Tab. 1. Mean of the modelling efficiency (EF) from the estimated emission (S j unknown ) and the source (S j ) over the 13 application periods in function of the integration time and the emission potentials (  ). Data at 1 m height. 2 4 (4) (5) a) b) Acknowledgement. This study was funded by Èclaire (EU) and CASDAR-NH 3 (FR). (1)  These concentrations are then averaged (overbars) over a sampling period t ranging from 3 hours to 1 week (eq. 2). (2) Relative error (3) Results The modelled NH 3 emission patterns were variable according to the  pattern (Fig. 1) and the application period. The emission estimated using Eq. (3) is very sensitive to the strength of the emission potentials (  ) from the blocks, especially for low values:  and  * 10² (Fig. 2). For the given field size, the main factor influencing the error in the “integrated inverse modelling method” is the daily NH 3 emission pattern which is mainly governed by the friction velocity (u * ) and the surface temperature pattern (Fig. 3). NH 3 emission potential  constant  linearly decreasing  exponential decreasing  gaussian (a) Time (28 days) Fig. 1. NH 3 emission pattern modelled with Surfatm-NH 3 over a 28 days period (here 1 st March) Fig. 2. NH 3 emission generated (S j ) and estimated (S j unknown ) over different emission potential (  ) in the blocks. Data reported are at 0.25 m height, 3 hours of integration period, in the 28 days period over March. S j (µg/m²:s)  10 2  10 4 