Lecture 6: Ethical Issue

Outline Nature and Relevance Criteria for Making Ethical Decisions Characteristics of Professional Occupations Principles of Ethics for Clinical Engineers The Ethical Significance of Professionalism Ethical Theory and Applied Ethics Ethical Issues of Concern of a Clinical Engineer Human Experimentation

Nature and Relevance Ethics is defined as the study of standards of conduct and moral judgment Deals with human behavior and seeks to establish the principles defining the right or correct course of action in a given situation Specifically deals with sensitive topics such as professional fees, salaries of coworkers, patient rights and professional competency

Nature and Relevance Moral standards should be known, as well as, how they apply to the changes and possibilities created by technology

Criteria for Making Ethical Decisions Codes of behavior established by law Codes of ethics for professional groups (e.g. engineers, physicians, and lawyers, among others) Personal moral code

Characteristics of Professional Occupations High degree of generalized and systematic knowledge Primary orientation to the community interest rather than to individual self-interest High degree of self-control of behavior through codes of ethics internalized in the process of work socialization and through voluntary associations organized and operated by the work specialists System of rewards that is primarily a set of symbols of work achievements and thus ends in themselves, not means to some end of individual self-interest

Principles of Ethics for Clinical Engineers Hold paramount the safety, health, and welfare of the public Improve the efficacy and safety of healthcare through the application of technology Support the efficacy and safety of healthcare through the acquisition and exchange of information and experience with other engineers and managers Manage healthcare technology programs effectively and resources responsibly Accurately represent their level of responsibility, authority, experience, knowledge and education and perform services only in their area of competence Maintain confidentiality of patient information as well as proprietary employer or client information, unless doing so would endanger public safety or violate any legal obligations. Not engage in any activities that are conflicts of interest or that provide the appearance of conflicts of interest and that can adversely affect their performance or impair their professional judgment Conduct themselves honorably and legally in all their activities

The Ethical Significance of Professionalism High degree of generalized and systematic knowledge recognizes knowledge and skills from training and education that has valuable capabilities that may have a significant power to affect lives of the others. Ethical dimensions should be known in order for power not to be abused and misused

The Ethical Significance of Professionalism Primary orientation to the community interest rather than to individual self-interest Occupational skills and knowledge should be dedicated for the use of the public good rather than for self-interest High degree of self-control of behavior Self-regulation should be done to minimize abuse and misuse of power entailed by their expertise since they are the once that are more knowledgeable of the nature and consequences of their expertise

Ethical Theory and Applied Ethics Applied ethics is to ethical theory, what engineering is to pure science Ethical theory is primarily concerned with extending general knowledge Pure science’s main concerned is factual knowledge and ethical theory’s main concern is generalized knowledge of right and wrong, good and evil, virtue and vice, and the like

Ethical Theory and Applied Ethics Applied science seeks to increase ability to act and enhance what can be achieve, applied ethics seek primarily to provide answers that could be implemented to concrete questions about how should we act, what we should we choose to do, etc. Theory without practice is often empty and practice without theory is often blind applies to science and ethics alike

Ethical theory Metaethics Concerned with the analysis of moral concepts and other concepts central to moral reasoning and argument Focuses in clarifying moral terminology Understanding of metaethics begins with conceptual analysis of the necessary and sufficient conditions that must be met for proper use of particular concepts

Ethical theory Normative ethics Efforts to answer the question “How is such knowledge of valid moral standards are obtained? Since knowledge of valid moral standard are required to arrive at valid moral judgments Two schools of thoughts that dominate normative ethics Utilitarianism, a form of consequentialism Kantianism, a form of nonconsequentialism

Ethical theory Consequentialism Holds that morally right action is always the one among the available options that has the best consequences Important implication is that no specific actions or courses of conduct are automatically ruled out as immoral or ruled in as morally obligatory Rightness or wrongness of an action is wholly contingent upon its effects

Ethical theory Utilitarianism Dominant form of consequentialism Two steps to determining what to be done in a situation: Determine which courses of actions are open Determine the consequences of each alternative Morally right course of action is: the one that maximizes pleasure, minimizes pain, or both The one that does the “greatest good for the greatest number”

Ethical theory Nonconsequentialism Deny that moral evaluation is simply and wholly a matter of determining the consequences of human conduct Agree that other considerations are relevant to moral assessment and rejects the view that morally right conduct is has the best consequences

Ethical theory Kantianism Are attempt to capture in secular form the basic tenet of Christian morality What makes human beings morally special entities deserving a unique type of respect? According to Christian ethics only human beings have the intrinsic value due to having an eternal soul and this is the very reason that humans deserve rights that limits how they may be properly treated Central task of this ethics is to specify what is required by respect for the unique dignity of human beings

Ethical Issues of Concern of a Clinical Engineer Patient Selection Confidentiality of Patient Records Benefit-risk analysis for diagnostic and treatment procedures Experimental Instrumentation and Procedures: Informed Consent Dying, Death and Euthanasia

Patient Selection Clinical engineer either directly through communication with physicians or indirectly through his choice of equipment characteristics may limit the suitability of certain patients for diagnostic examination or treatment Clinical engineers become influential in matching patients to hospital systems and in so, they assume a part of the overall responsibility for the patient selection process

Confidentiality of Patient Records Personal and medical records frequently contain sensitive information, discretion must be used in the use and publication of such data Codes of conduct may specify limitations on release of patient data Personal and medical data are confidential until appropriateness and justification for release are established

Benefit-risk Analysis for Diagnostic and Treatment Procedures Medical procedures instituted for the ultimate benefit of the patient are associated with significant risk, which are documented for procedures (e.g. radiotherapy and catheterization) Clinical engineers must objectively assess system capabilities, expected reliability and in particular any significant attendant risks. Clinical team must decide in each case or for class of patient disorders, whether the risks of contributing to the development or advance of pathological conditions are outweighed by the benefits anticipated

Experimental Instrumentation and Procedures: Informed Consent When human subjects are used for research in new instrumentation systems, “informed consent” for their participation should be obtained to afford legal protection with respect to patient rights to give patients enough information to make a rational decision whether or not to participate Informed consent in brief consists of adequate written or oral explanation to the would-be subject of the objectives of the procedures to be used. In any case of patient instrumentation, with new or relatively untried devices, care should be taken to see that the patient has been informed.

Dying, death and Euthanasia The clinical engineer with the major role in instrumentation may be called upon to provide information that will in part affect decisions whether or not to continue a treatment to extend a patient’s life Euthanasia is the deliberate termination of an individual’s life for the individuals own good

Euthanasia Critical issue is whether the quality of a human life can be so low or so great a liability to the individual that deliberately taking action to hasten death or at least not to postpone death is morally defensible. Central moral issue raised is whether the quality of the individual’s life is sufficiently compromised by neocortical death to make intended termination of that life morally permissible

Euthanasia Another important issue is respect for individual autonomy whereas it is the notion that competent adults should be free to conduct their lives as they please as long as they do not impose undeserved harm on others

Active vs. Passive Euthanasia Active Euthanasia When a person is killed Death is the result of an act of commission The motive is the person’s own good Passive Euthanasia When a person is allowed to die Death is the result of an act of omission

Involuntary and Nonvoluntary Euthanasia Involuntary Euthanasia It hastens the individual’s death for his own good but against his wishes Destroy a life that is valued by its possessor Nonvoluntary Euthanasia Hastening of an individual’s death for his own good when the individual is incapable of agreeing and disagreeing

Human Experimentation Therapy is to provide benefits to individuals Experimentation aims to expand the boundaries of scientific knowledge Therapeutic vs. Nontherapeutic experimentation Therapeutic experimentation A course of action is undertaken in respect to the subject for the purpose of determining how best to procure a medical benefit to the subject The purpose is to determine how best to benefit the patient Nontherapeutic experimentation Is the acquisition of new information The purpose is to generate new knowledge

Human Experimentation Practice and Research Practice Refers to interventions that are designed solely to enhance the well-being of an individual and that have a reasonable expectation of success Uses a proven technique in an attempt to benefit one or more individual Research Activity designed to test a hypothesis to permit conclusions to be drawn and thereby develop or contribute to generalizable knowledge Studies a technique in an attempt to increase knowledge

Human Experimentation Nonvalidated Practice Selected course of action is to benefit the patient Primary purpose is to benefit the patient while making clear that it has not been shown to be safe and efficacious “A practice might be nonvalidated because it is new; i.e. it has not been tested sufficiently often or sufficiently well to permit satisfactory prediction of its safety or efficacy in patient population. An equally common way for a practice to merit the designation “nonvalidated” is that in the course of its use in the practice of medicine there arises some legitimate cause to question previously held assumptions about its safety or efficacy.” – Robert Levine

Mini-Case

List three typical ethical issues of concern to the clinical engineer. Research on ethics for clinical engineers or biomedical engineers in other countries . List three groupings of criteria for deciding the ethical status of a given situation. Research the following theories and their application in field of engineering consequentialism nonconsequentialism utilitarianism Kantianism List three typical ethical issues of concern to the clinical engineer.

Get a host hospital and do the following: Interview a biomedical engineer or clinical engineer Identify any ethical issues from their experience How does the management of the hospital resolve the issues

References ACCE Code of Ethics, http://www.accenet.org/ and Dyro, JF, et al. American College of Clinical Engineering Clinical Engineering Handbook 600-609, 2004. Bronzino, J.D. (Ed.). (1992). Management of medical technology: a primer for clinical engineers. Boston: Butterworth-Heinemann Code of Ethics for Engineers, National Society of Professional Engineers (NSPE), www.nspe.org Jendrucko, RJ & Favoriti, RE, (1979) Legal, Professional, and Ethical Aspects, in Clinical Engineering; Principles and Practices; Ed. J Webster & A. Cook, Prentice-Hall, NJ Online Ethics Center for Engineering and Science, http://onlineethics.org/ Webster, J.G. & Cook, A.M. (Ed.). (1979). Clinical engineering: principles and practices. Englewood Cliffs, N.J..: Prentice-Hall, Inc.