802.1H Task Group Ballot Draft 0.3 Kevin Nolish Michael Wright.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Sangsung Choi(ETRI) tv SG4TV Slide 1 May 2011 Project: IEEE P Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks(WPANs) Submission.

Advertisements

Doc.: IEEE /1326r1 Submission November 2008 Donald Eastlake 3rd, MotorolaSlide 1 TGs Process, November Date: Author:

Doc.: IEEE /0623r1 Submission May 2009 Jon Rosdahl, CSRSlide 1 Proposal for P&P Change - # Date: Authors:

Doc.: IEEE /0006r0 Submission March 2005 Steve Shellhammer, Intel CorporationSlide 1 What is a CA document? Notice: This document has been prepared.

Doc.: IEEE /1120r2 Submission September 2008 Guido R. Hiertz et al., PhilipsSlide 1 Terminology changes in a nutshell … Date: Authors:

Doc.: IEEE /0953r0 Submission Sept 2009 Adrian Stephens, Intel CorporationSlide TGmb Editor Report - Sept 2009 Date: Authors:

Doc.: IEEE /0953r1 Submission November 2009 Adrian Stephens, Intel CorporationSlide TGmb Editor Report - Nov 2009 Date: Authors:

Doc.: IEEE /2079r0 Submission July 2007 Terry Cole, AMDSlide 1 WG Technical Editors Opening Report (July) Date: Authors:

Doc.: IEEE /0445r0 Submission May 2009 Adrian Stephens, Intel CorporationSlide TGn Editor Report May 2009 Date: Authors:

Doc.: IEEE /854R3 SubmissionSlide 1 July 2004 Sheung Li, Atheros Section 21 Procedure (formerly Procedure 10) Request for P802.11j Conditional.

Doc.: VC1_ _EC_P&P_Update-opening_r0.ppt Submission EC Update on LMSC Governance Date: November 16 th, 2009 Author: Matthew Sherman 1 st Vice Chair,

Doc.: _SEC_Motions_Jul06 Submission July Motion to SEC Motion by: LynchSeconded by: Agenda: 9.02 Date: 07/21/2006 Time: 3:20.

IEEE Working Group on Broadband Wireless Access Roger Marks, Chair IEEE /036.

Page 1Version 1.0 IEEE closing report – November 2009 Plenary IEEE Ethernet Working Group November Plenary Report 20 November 2009 David J.

Doc.: VC1_ _r2_EC_Closing_Motions.ppt Submission 1 st Vice Chair Closing Motions Date: November 20 th, 2009 Author: Matthew Sherman 1 st Vice Chair,

Doc.: IEEE /0008r2 Submission March 2006 Steve Shellhammer, QualcommSlide 1 EC Summary of PAR Development Notice: This document has been prepared.

802.1H Kevin Nolish Michael Wright H Project The reason for the update of 802.1H is, primarily, mandated reaffirmation of the standard. As part.

802.1H Revision Project Kevin Nolish Michael Wright.

Doc.: IEEE /1562r2 Submission Nov 2011 Adrian Stephens, Intel CorporationSlide Nov 2011 Closing Plenary Motions Date: Authors:

Doc.: IEEE Submission March 2006 Robert F. HeileSlide st Session of meetings of the IEEE Working Group for Wireless.

Doc.: IEEE g TG4g - SUN November 2009 Phil Beecher, Beecher Communications Consultants Ltd Slide 1 Project: IEEE P Working Group.

Title: LE TG report for the opening plenary – Session #65 Document Number: h-10/0002 Date Submitted: January 11, 2010 Source: Chair of LE TG: Mariana.

802.16m Closing Report November 11, 2010 Dallas, Tx Session # IEEE m-10/0035.

Doc.: IEEE /0990r0 Submission July 2014 Al Petrick, JPASlide Liaison Report Date: Authors:

Doc.: IEEE /1438r0 Submission November 2008 Jon Rosdahl, CSRSlide EC Material Date: Authors:

Doc.: IEEE /0715r0 Submission July 2009 Stephen McCann (RIM) Slide 1 P802.11u Report to EC on Approval to go to Sponsor Ballot Date: Authors:

11 ITU-R Liaison Group Report to Session #83 Closing Plenary Roger Marks Acting Chair, ITU-R Liaison Group IEEE WG Session #83 Vancouver,

Doc.: IEEE /215 Submission July 2000 David Bagby, 3ComSlide F IAPP RP Meeting Agenda (& Meeting Report) July 2000.

Doc.: IEEE wng0 Submission November, 2013 Pat Kinney, Kinney ConsultingSlide 1 Project: IEEE P Working Group for Wireless Personal.

IEEE r q Submission May 2014 Dietmar Eggert, AtmelSlide 1 Project: IEEE P Working Group for Wireless Personal Area.

Doc.: IEEE /1125r0 Submission September 2010 Marc Emmelmann, Fraunhofer FOKUSSlide 1 How does the (new) Fast Initial Link Set- Up PAR address.

IEEE f Active RFID System Sponsor Ballot Ballot Resolution Committee Teleconference Meeting Minutes October 25, 2011 Mike McInnis Chair IEEE f.

Doc.: IEEE /0674r0 Submission June 2009 Bruce Kraemer, Marvell; Adrian Stephens, Intel Corporation Slide 1 P802.11n report to EC on request for.

Doc.: IEEE /353r0 Submission July 2001 Jim Lansford, Tim Blaney, Mobilian CorporationSlide 1 IEEE 802 Wireless Coexistence Study Group Tuesday.

Doc.: Submission1 IEEE Motions in November Plenary DCN: Title: Request for EC Conditional Approval Date Submitted:

Doc.: Submission1 IEEE Motions in November Plenary DCN: Title: Request for EC Conditional Approval Date Submitted:

Revision of WIPO Standard ST.14 Committee on WIPO Standards, third session Geneva 15 – 19 April 2013 Anna Graschenkova Standards Section.

P802.16q to Sponsor Ballot: Conditional Approval Request 17 July 2014 IEEE Gdoc.

Doc.: IEEE Submission March 2004 Tom Siep, TMS ConsultingSlide 1 Project: IEEE P Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks (WPANs)

Doc.: IEEE /177r0 Submission January 2000 Ian Gifford, M/A-COM, Inc.Slide 1 IEEE P Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks TG1.

Doc.: IEEE /0281r1 Submission James D. Allen (Appairent Technologies, Inc.) Project: IEEE P Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks.

Doc.: IEEE /0792r0 Submission July 2008 Adrian Stephens, Intel CorporationSlide TGn Editor Report July 2008 Date: Authors:

Doc.: IEEE /0905r3 Submission July 2009 Jon Rosdahl, CSRSlide 1 July 2009 Plenary Presentation from WG11 to 802 EC Date: Authors:

Doc.: IEEE /224r3 Submission May 2001 Tom Siep, TMS ConsultantsSlide 1 TG3 Review Procedure Proposal NOTE: All of these recommendations do not.

Title: LE TG Closing Report for Session #60 Document Number: P802.16h-09/0007 Date Submitted: March 12, 2009 Source: Chair of LE TG: Mariana GoldhamerVoice:+972.

Doc.: IEEE Submission March, 2014 Pat Kinney, Kinney ConsultingSlide 1 Project: IEEE P Working Group for Wireless Personal Area.

Doc.: IEEE /0023r00 SubmissionApurva N. Mody, BAE SystemsSlide 1 IEEE Motion at the July EC Closing Meeting IEEE P Wireless RANs.

Tge draft ballot information

Jan Project: IEEE P Working Group for Wireless Local Area Networks (WLANs) Submission Title: Liaison Report, January 2003 Date Submitted:

P802.11s Report to EC on Conditional Approval to go to Sponsor Ballot

December 18 Project: IEEE P Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks (WPANs) Submission Title: TG4i conditional approval package Date Submitted:

P802.11z Report to EC on Conditional Approval to go to Sponsor Ballot

June 2010 doc.: IEEE /0705r0 November 2010

July 2014 doc.: IEEE /25/2018 Project: IEEE P Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks (WPANs) Submission Title:

Liaison Report Date: Author: Jan 2008 Month Year

IEEE Motions at the November Plenary EC Meeting

IEEE Motions in July Plenary DCN:

TG3 Review Procedure Proposal

Submission Title: [Proposed project timeline]

P802.11z Report to EC on Conditional Approval to go to Sponsor Ballot

P802.11z Report to EC on Conditional Approval to go to Sponsor Ballot

IEEE Motion at the July EC Closing Meeting

July Motions Closing EC Meeting 802 Plenary Meeting Hilton Waikoloa Village Hotel & Conference Center Waikoloa, Hawaii, USA July 16, 2015.

June 2010 doc.: IEEE /0705r0 December 2010

P802.11z Report to EC on Conditional Approval to go to Sponsor Ballot

Sheung Li Task Group J Chairperson March 19, 2004

P802.11aq Report to EC on approval to forward draft to RevCom

P802.11j Sponsor Ballot Procedure 10

May 2008 Project: IEEE P Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks (WPANs) Submission Title: [TG5 Motions at Mid-Week Plenary] Date Submitted:

TGaj editor report for Sponsor Ballot

Presentation transcript:

802.1H Task Group Ballot Draft 0.3 Kevin Nolish Michael Wright

802.1H Overview 802.1H is a recommended practice concerning the conversion of protocol indications between various 802.X networks. The version 0.3 of 802.1H is a complete rewrite of the original 802.1H document.

802.1H Project Status Draft P802.1Qay/D0.3 has been released on April 20th. The is the second task group ballot The ballot closed on May 16th. MarMayJulSepJanNovMarMayMarJulSepJanNov May D0.1D0.3 1 st TG2 nd TG3 rd TG Drafts Ballots D0.4 4 th TG D0.5? 1 st WG D1.0? 2 nd WG D1.1?

Current Ballot Results As Of 11 May 2009 Ballot Opened 20 April 09 Ballot Closed 14 May 09 Results –Approve 3 –Disapprove 6 –Abstain 44 ( 2 with comments )

History Of Ballot Results MeetingMarch 09May 09 STILL OPEN July 09Sep 09Nov 09Jan 10March 10 Version and Ballot Type V 0.1 Task Group V 0.3 Task Group V 0.4 Task Group Approve 03 Disapprove 116 Abstain 5744 Total 6853

Current Comment Overview As of 11 May Total Comments –Editorial (E) – 6 –Required Editorial (ER) – 30 –Technical (T) – 6 –Required Technical (TR) – 41 Required comments are those that are necessary to support a disapprove vote and must be addressed by the editor to change or prevent a disapprove vote The breakdown between technical and editorial is at the discretion of the voter.

History Of Comment Types MeetingMarch 09May 09July 09Sep 09Nov 09Jan 10March 10 Version and Ballot Type V 0.1 Task Group V 0.3 Task Group V 0.4 Task Group Technical 26 Required 2141 Editorial 106 Editorial Required 3430 Total 5783

Editorial Comments Breakdown Clean Up Standard Templates Fix Frame Counter Issues – Clause Numbering Change Definitions To References RFC 1042 terminology –Use RFC 1042 Encapsulation Better Align Document With IEEE Style Document. Major problem areas: –Clause 3 –Figures need to be scrubbed –Insert Captions and Figure References

Major Technical Comments The explanation of the various protocol indication mechanisms needs to be better organized into a hierarchy along the following lines: LLC/SNAP is a LLC –With a specific SAP address where the LLC header is followed by a protocol identifier RFC 1042 Encapsulation is a LLC/SNAP –With a specific OUI of and the protocol id is an Ethertype Bridge Tunnel Encapsulation is a LLC/SNAP –With a specific OUI of XX-XX-XX and the protocol id is an Ethertype

Major Technical Comments - 2 Remove some definitions from clause 3 and replace them with references to definitions in other documents. Fix some Frame issues with respect to clause numbers and active cross references.

Major Editorial Issues Need a statement outlining the problem. Mick suggested that this belongs in 1.2, unfortunately clause 1.2 SHALL correspond to the purpose statement in the PAR according to the IEEE standards style guideline. Need to find a home for this. Remove the term LLC/SNAP. Lots of comments on this.

Editor Issues Kevin Nolish is resigning as 802.1H co- editor after the May interim meeting. –Intention is to prepare 0.4 draft quickly and have it balloted at the July Plenary.

Long Term Issues The rewrite of the document will keep us in task group ballot longer than expected. We may need a PAR extension as the PAR expires 31 Dec The extra time in cleaning this document up may push us past this date.