The Impact of the History of Physics on Student Attitude and Conceptual Understanding of Physics Often the pre and posttest show negative shift in introductory.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
An Introduction to Multicultural Education
Advertisements

College Student Identity and Emotional Intelligence Abstract This research examines the longitudinal relationship between identity and emotional intelligence.
COURSEWORK ON BASE NUMERATION SYSTEMS AND ITS INFLUENCE ON PRE- SERVICE ELEMENTARY TEACHER’S UNDERSTANDING OF PLACE VALUE CONCEPTS BY DOROTHY J. RADIN.
Study on the outcomes of teaching and learning about ‘race’ and racism Kish Bhatti-Sinclair (Division of Social Work Studies) Claire Bailey (Division of.
Increasing computer science popularity and gender diversity through the use of games and contextualized learning By Mikha Zeffertt Supervised by Mici Halse.
Self-Efficacy in a General Education Mathematics Course Dr. Laura Schmidt University of Wisconsin – Stout OPID Spring Conference.
SOCIOLOGY Chapter 1: The Sociological Point of View
Contemporary Mathematics in Context: CORE-Plus Mathematics Project.
Using IOLab to Correct Student Misunderstandings of Newton's Third Law Eric C. Martell 1, Nikki Tipsword 2, Mats Selen 3 1.Millikin University Department.
2008 National CASTL Institute Blogging in the Physics Classroom Gintaras K. Duda & Katherine Garrett.
Context  Learning Problem: Many students are under-prepared for freshman biology courses. They have difficulty using their biology textbook and performing.
Flo Turkenkopf Packer Collegiate Institute Brooklyn, NY Computational vs. Conceptual: The Best Approach to Teaching 9 th Grade Physics.
Building on a Base: tools, practices, and implications from physics education research (PER) S.J. Pollock N.D. Finkelstein Physics Department Thanks for.
Examining the Gender Gap in Introductory Physics Lauren Kost Steven Pollock, Noah Finkelstein Department of Physics, University of Colorado at Boulder.
How do we evaluate how effective we are in helping our students master course material? In promoting our broader educational agendas? -Prelim and final.
Home Economics Teachers’ Readiness for Teaching STEM
RSS Centre for Statistical Education Improving Statistical Literacy in School and Society: The UK Experience Peter Holmes RSS Centre for Statistical Education,
Gender Differences in Students' Perceived Experiences in Introductory Physics Lauren Kost Steven Pollock, Noah Finkelstein Department of Physics University.
Introduction to Workshop 10 Choosing Learning and Teaching Approaches and Strategies.
TEMPLATE DESIGN © Measuring Students’ Beliefs about Physics in Saudi Arabia H. Alhadlaq 1, F. Alshaya 1, S. Alabdulkareem.
Institute for innovation and development of learning process
Modeling Instruction Lessons from America. Mechanics Modeling Workshop 90 hours of professional development consisting of intensive immersion in the mechanics.
The possible effects of target language learning prior to secondary dual language school studies by Anna Várkuti 10th Summer School of Psycholinguistics.
Physics I MOOC – Educational Outcomes David Lieberman*, Michael Dubson ¶, Katherine Goodman ¶, Ed Johnsen ¶, Jack Olsen ¶ and Noah Finkelstein ¶ * Department.
Student Achievement and Predictors of Student Achievement in a State Level Agricultural Mechanics Career Development Event Edward Franklin Glen Miller.
AN EVALUATION OF THE EIGHTH GRADE ALGEBRA PROGRAM IN GRAND BLANC COMMUNITY SCHOOLS 8 th Grade Algebra 1A.
Five Month Retention of Basic Genetics Knowledge Following an Introductory Biology Course Peter Busher and Andy Andres Division of Natural Sciences and.
COLORADO LOTTERY 2010 IMAGE SURVEY Prepared By The Howell Research Group.
CS 1010 Introduction to Computer Science 1. Department of Computer Science and Software Engineering Two Majors Computer Science Software Engineering 2.
Ismaila Odogba Department of Geography and Geology The Impact of Collaborative Testing on Student Learning in an Introductory Level Geography Course INTRODUCTION.
The Impact of CReSIS Summer Research Programs that Influence Students’ Choice of a STEM Related Major in College By: Alica Reynolds, Jessica.
LEARNING PRIORITY OF TECHNOLOGY PROCESS SKILLS AT ELEMENTARY LEVEL Hung-Jen Yang & Miao-Kuei Ho DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIAL TECHNOLOGY EDUCATION THE NATIONAL.
Student Engagement Survey Results and Analysis June 2011.
Physics Education Research-Based Reform at a Multicultural Institution Richard Steinberg City College of New York This work is supported by NSF and FIPSE.
INVESTIGATION OF STUDENT ATTITUDES AND UNDERSTANDING IN GENERAL CHEMISTRY Rachel Egdorf and Dr. Roslyn M. Theisen Department of Chemistry, University of.
Are there “Hidden Variables” in Students’ Initial Knowledge State Which Correlate with Learning Gains? David E. Meltzer Department of Physics and Astronomy.
The Genetics Concept Assessment: a new concept inventory for genetics Michelle K. Smith, William B. Wood, and Jennifer K. Knight Science Education Initiative.
Mathew “Sandy” Martinuk, Rachel Moll*, and Andrzej Kotlicki Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of British Columbia, Vancouver BC V6T 1Z1 *Department.
An Introduction to Physics Education Research Dr. Steven Sahyun UWW Physics PTLG Physics Teachers Lunch Group Presentation.
The Changing Face of Education: How Common Core Impacts Our Curriculum Beth Smith President, ASCCC Oct. 31, 2013.
Integrating Statistics into College Algebra Sheldon P. Gordon
A Preliminary Investigation of Student Perceptions of Online Education Angela M. Clark University of South Alabama Presented at ISECON 2003 San Diego,
What is Teacher Effectiveness and How May it Be Assessed? David E. Meltzer Department of Physics, University of Washington and Seattle Country Day School.
Using Discipline Specific Action Research to Inform Curriculum Development & Classroom Practice A Case Study: Workshop Physics.
The Use of Distance Learning Technology by Business Educators for Credentialing and Instruction Christal C. Pritchett, Ed.D. NABTE Research Session Anaheim,
Educators’ Attitudes about the Accessibility and Integration of Technology into the Secondary Curriculum Dr. Christal C. Pritchett Auburn University
CT 854: Assessment and Evaluation in Science & Mathematics
Using Common Core State Standards of Seventh Grade Mathematics in the Application of NXT LEGO® Robotics for CReSIS Middle School Students.
Attitudinal Factors Influencing Pre- service Teachers’ Pedagogical Philosophies in an Innovative Learning Sciences Course and Curriculum: A Structural.
The Persistence of the Gender Gap in Introductory Physics Lauren Kost Steven Pollock, Noah Finkelstein Department of Physics, University of Colorado at.
Connecticut Algebra One for All
Assessing Gender Differences in Students' Understanding of Magnetism using Magnetism Conceptual Survey Jing Li Department of Physics and Astronomy University.
An Introduction to Multicultural Education
Practices, Practices, Practices… Quickly read the list of practices/portraits. Code each practice/portrait with an: “S” for science “M” for mathematics.
Investigative Science Learning Environment ISLE Andrej Petek Adviser: prof. Gorazd Planinšič Coadviser: prof. Eguenia Etkina Ljubljana, dec
Physics Education Research at CU S.J. Pollock SPS Fall 05 or why do I keep filling out those online surveys at the start of every course?
Research-Based Surveys (Sometimes referred to as: inventories, instruments, or diagnostic tools. )
Major Academic Plan (MAP) Why teach middle school math or elementary school with a math emphasis? Young people need teachers who help them conceptualize.
The effect of teachers' staff development in the use of higher-order questioning strategies on third grade students' rubric science assessment performance.
Gender Differences in Statistical Anxiety Dennis Pearl & Hyen Oh (Penn State University), Larry Lesser (University of Texas, El Paso) & John Weber (Perimeter.
Girls and Physics Chris Meyer York Mills C. I.
Attitudes, Beliefs, and Content Knowledge Edward A. Von Iderstein Kathleen A. Falconer SUNY College at Buffalo.
Laboratory Science and Quantitative Core Requirements.
Major Academic Plan (MAP) Why teach middle school math or elementary school with a math emphasis? Young people need teachers who help them conceptualize.
Changing student attitudes about science and their confidence in understanding real-world connections Annia Fayon Department of Postsecondary Teaching.
Robert P. King Department of Applied Economics April 14, 2017
The Experiences of Female High School Students and Interest in STEM:
Alternate Math Pathways
Promoting the Transfer of Mathematical Skills in Food Science Programmes Colette Fagan November 13, 2018.
Teaching Quantitative Reasoning
Presentation transcript:

The Impact of the History of Physics on Student Attitude and Conceptual Understanding of Physics Often the pre and posttest show negative shift in introductory physics student attitude and interest in learning physics [1]. If the mathematical aspects of introductory physics courses bombard students with equations and calculations, some students, especially those with little to no background in science or math, can either lose interest in the class or just get lost. Some studies have suggested the use of the history of physics in teaching the concepts can influence student overall interest in learning science [2] [3]. We have also investigated this technique to measure students learning of basic Newtonian Mechanics in the context of a course on the history and the development of scientific ideas from Aristotelian to Newtonian mechanics. Would it help with conceptual understanding of some everyday physics experience? Would it shift student attitude and opinion of learning physics as well as creating an appreciation of the science? SARAH GARCIA, APRIL HANKINS & HOMEYRA R. SADAGHIANI Department of Physics, California State Polytechnic University, Pomona, CA INTRODUCTION Conceptual Gain: Figure 1 shows student normalized gain for FCI which is calculated by the equation above. Data indicates the following: 1.All majors showed reasonable conceptual gain and the class average gain was comparable to CPP average FCI gain in introductory physics courses over the past three years [6]. 2.The History and Non-science majors had the highest conceptual gain. We had two math majors in the class; because of the small statistics and opposing results for the two data points (+60% and -67%) we did not include that on the graph on Figure 1. Attitude Shift: The results of CLASS (Table 1) shows a positive shift in five out of the eight scored categories for student attitude with significant shift on “Personal Interest” (13%) and “Sense Making/Efforts” (10%). The overall average shift was also a positive three percent. In summary, teaching physics in the context of its history led to some conceptual gain in our study; it had a positive impact on students’ interest in learning physics and their ability to connect their understanding to real world experiences. This project was funded by The Women’s Education Equity Act research Apprenticeship Program (WEEA). We would like to thank Dr. Barbara Burke for her support. AKNOWLEDGMENTS COURSE & STUDENT POPULATIONS This course discusses the historical development of scientific ideas, the introductory concepts of physics with an emphasis on Newtonian mechanics. It is offered as an upper division general education for all majors or as an advanced elective for physics majors. Twenty eight students from a variety of majors with different backgrounds in science and math were enrolled in the course (see Figure 1). The textbook used was Physics, the Human Adventure: From Copernicus to Einstein and Beyond by G. Holton & S. Brush. METHODOLOGY DATARESULTS AND DISCUSSION Data acquisition began with two Nationally known surveys given at the beginning of the course and again at the end of the quarter as pre/post-tests in order to measure student attitude change and to see if they acquired different techniques for applying Newtonian concepts. 1.Concept Assessment: Force Concept Inventory (FCI) test [4], to measure the students’ ability to apply the concepts of Newtonian Physics to everyday life. 2.Attitude Survey: The Colorado Learning Attitudes about Science Survey (CLASS) [5], to measures students’ initial perception of learning physics. Additional Course Survey was designed to collect demographic data such as gender, major, ethnicity, math and science background, and job status. The course was delivered in an online/hybrid format and the Course Survey contained questions regarding student experience, attitude, and what they liked and disliked of these formats in this and other courses. Figure 1. The average Normalized Gain on FCI for different majors Table I. The average favorable data for CLASS with standard error in parentheses. Figure 2. shows the average shift from Table 1 in each category from CLASS REFERENCES [1] E. Redish, J. Saul, and R. Steinberg, Am J Phy. 66 (3), (1998) [2] H. Erlichson. “Collateral Readings in the Philosophy and History of Physics for the Introductory Science and Engineering Physics Course,” Am. J. Phys. 34 (6) (1966) [3] G. Kortemeyer & C. Westfall, “History of Physics: Outing the Hidden Curriculum?” Am. J. Phys. 77 (10) (2009) [4] D. Hestenes, M. Wells, and G. Swackhamer, “The Force Concept Inventory,” Phys. Teach. 30, 141 (1992) [5] W. Adams et al., “ New Instrument for Measuring Student Beliefs About Physics and Learning Physics: The Colorado Learning Attitudes about Science Survey (CLASS),” Phys Rev. ST Phys. Education Research 2 (2006) [6] S. McCauley, N. Abramzon, & H. Sadaghiani, “Pilot Enrichment Courses to Enhance Student Success in Freshman Physics,” Provost Teaching Symposium (2009) Categories Avg PreAvg PostAvg Shift 1Real World Connection78% (5%)84% (4%)6% 2Personal Interest67% (5%)80% (4%)13% 3Sense Making/Effort69% (4%)79% (4%)10% 4Conceptual Connections56% (4%)55% (6%)-2% 5Applies Conceptual Understanding49% (4%)49% (6%)0% 6Problem Solving General68% (5%)70% (4%)2% 7Problem Solving Confidence67% (5%)68% (4%)1% 8Problem Sophistication45% (4%)44% (3%)-2% 9Not Scored50% (7%)52% (7%)2% Overall 61%65%3%