The Interaction of Private and Public Labour Regulation: A Case Study of Better Work Indonesia Regulating for Decent Work Conference 2015 Geneva, July.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

HOW TO FORM A PARTNERSHIP Training Unit 3.2 National, transnational and local networks.

Advertisements

Procurement Mainstreaming Process in Indonesia. Figures about Significance of Public Procurement Public procurement in Indonesia is around 8 % of GDP.

Learning from Existing Evaluation Practices on the Impacts and Effects of Intellectual Property on Development Geneva 6th/7th October 2011 Evaluation Section.

IAEA International Atomic Energy Agency Introductions; Objectives and Scope of the Course Tr aining course on Authorization and Inspection of Uranium Mining.

1 Department of State Program Evaluation Policy Overview Spring 2013.

HRD as a Tool for Good Governance in Cooperatives

Industry's Role in Promoting Best Practices A Collaborative Approach to Food Safety Global Food Safety Policy Forum Washington DC September 16, 2011.

Better Care Network Child Protection in Crisis Learning Network Bi-annual Meeting October 8 th, 2013 ©Josh Estey/CARE © UNICEF/HQ /LeMoyne.

Donald Macrae Vilnius, June 18, 2013 The Growing Importance of Inspection & Enforcement in Regulatory Reform IFC Investment Climate Advisory Services Project.

Examples of Best Practices: Anti- corruption Strategy of the TCA Musa KAYRAK Senior Auditor, CISA.

University of Macedonia Regional Development & Policy Research Unit.

Policy Response – the Case of Norway Dag Terje Andersen Minister of Labour and Social Inclusion.

LOCAL SYSTEM OF INNOVATION CENTERED ON AUDIOVISUAL PRODUCTION Marcelo Matos Fluminense Federal University and RedeSist - IE/UFRJ.

Institutional and Policy Mapping for Small-Scale Producer inclusion in Modern Markets.

HUMAN RESOURCE MANAGEMENT OVERVIEW Human Resource Management William Holmes College of Public and Community Service University of Massachusetts at Boston.

International Regulatory Capacity Building Global Curriculum Project.

1 PRESENTATION TO THE PORTFOLIO COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SERVICE AND ADMINISTRATION Report on the management of the Subsidized Motor Transport Scheme 10 November.

PART I Management Audit: Concept, Principles and Approaches

Social responsibility and ISO Pr. Sophie Robin-Olivier Ecole de droit de la Sorbonne Université Paris I.

Bratislava October 2007 PAR - AC CoP Meeting Anti Corruption Regional Programme Regional Programme.

Mechanism Design for Voluntary Supply Chain Responsibility Initiatives Bruce Paton San Francisco State University Greening of Industry Network Conference.

MENA-OECD Investment Programme Draft Policy Considerations on Incentives Working Group 3 Meeting Cairo, Egypt 6-7 September 2006.

ACADs (08-006) Covered Keywords Commission, regulation, advisory, standards. Description This presentation provides general information about each of the.

1 Hsin Chu, August 2012 Regulatory Impact Assessment Charles-Henri Montin, Senior Regulatory Expert, Ministry of economy and finance, Paris

Overview of UNITAR/ILO GHS Capacity Building Programme in ASEAN UNITAR/ILO Global GHS Capacity Building Programme.

Australia-Vietnam: Strengthening Capacities for Self-monitoring, Reporting and Recordkeeping in Ho Chi Minh City Do Hoang Oanh Dept. of Natural Resources.

Gap Analysis of Ongoing Youth Employment Efforts.

Supporting a Better Local Business and Investment Climate – AN OVERVIEW – SIMON WHITE Strategies and Practices Toward a More Enabling Business and Investment.

Improving Coverage and Management Effectiveness of the Protected Area System in the Republic of Moldova Maria NAGORNII Head of the Analysis, Monitoring.

The Evolution of Innovation Policy: Theory and Practice By Jan Fagerberg, Aalborg University, University of Oslo and University of Lund

“The Informal IS Normal” Marty Chen WIEGO Network Harvard Kennedy School Panel on OECD Publication PREM Learning Event April 29, 09.

Consultant: CMDC Joint Venture Reflections on draft Recommendations for Revision to Administrative Regulations: By Norman Sheridan, Legal & Institutional.

Environmental Compliance: Channels of Enforcement Presentation by Nick Johnstone and Pascale Scapecchi National Policies Division OECD Environment Directorate.

Webinar—26 June 2013 Geneva, Switzerland.  Messages from the ILO Director-General  Outcomes of Main Committees ◦ Social Dialogue ◦ Green Economy ◦ Demographic.

Implementing the WIPO Development Agenda: Comparing National Approaches to Promoting Coherence Between Public Policy Objectives and IP Laws ICTSD Roundtable.

Introduction 1. Purpose of the Chapter 2. Institutional arrangements Country Practices 3. Legal framework Country Practices 4. Preliminary conclusions.

The European agenda on improving the efficiency of employment and social policies: Bratislava, December 2011 The example of social experimentation.

Agricultural Producer Groups in Poland Ilona Banaszak IDARI project Humboldt University Berlin.

South Asia Labour Conference Summary of Recommendations.

Women in Markets A Systems Perspective Some Things to Consider Presented by Mary Morgan For CARE International July 1,

SA AIDS Conference Pre Conference session 06 June 2011 Strategic Partnerships through Social Dialogue in implementing HIV and AIDS Policies and Programmes:

Incorporating Rights Protection Mechanisms into Temporary Worker Programs: Experiences, Lessons Learned, Challenges, and Possibilities Regional Conference.

Health and safety: Challenges of the new Strategy Lothar Lißner Kooperationsstelle Hamburg IFE (KOOP) EMPL Introductory Workshop Policy areas and current.

Promoting Labour Standards in Global Production: Selected ILO Experiences Anne Posthuma International Institute for Labour Studies, ILO.

Communication in Small Groups Chapter 2. Groups Fundamental to Civilization Evolutionary downsides –Parasites and disease –“Free riders” exploiting the.

Labor Cooperation in the Framework of the CAFTA-DR Supporting the institutional strengthening of the Ministries of Labor and Enforcement of Labor Laws.

International Considerations In Research Administration Presented by: Artemis Koch, Executive Director, Global Support Services 1.

SEL1 Implementing an assessment – the Process Session IV Lusaka, January M. Gonzales de Asis and F. Recanatini, WBI

Pilot Project on implementation of SEA for regional planning in Ukraine Prof. Dr. Michael Schmidt Dmitry Palekhov Brandenburg University of Technology.

Integrated model and tools for Capacity- building in Trade Facilitation or Electronic Business UN/CEFACT 10 th. Session AND.

Consultancy:Profession or Business Gian E. Casartelli The World Bank.

1 Quality Indicators of Regulatory Management Systems Stéphane Jacobzone, Chang Won Choi, Claire Miguet The views are the author’s responsibility OECD.

Russian Cooperative compliance program – Tax monitoring Ivan Rodionov Head of Tax Performance Advisory, Russia and the CIS.

National framework for student assessment student assessment is laid down in the School Act (Act no. 561/2004 Coll. The School Act determines basic conditions.

Educating young trade union leaders in Negotiation Skills and Collective Bargaining in VGCL 3 Pham Van Tuan Viet Nam general confederation of labour (VGCL)

Strategy for Promoting a Culture of Compliance Working Groups Meeting - IACML Washington, D.C., May 19-21, 2009.

Indonesia in Perspective’s Study Case Corruption in IndonesiaCauses of CorruptionLesson Learned.

Networking in a globalized world RALI Conference, Baku, Azerbaijan, November, 2012 Mr.Elnur Sultanov Head of Social Security Policy Department, MLSPP.

The Context of Child Poverty Policies in Indonesia

ILO global research Improving the performance of individual dispute resolution systems: A global perspective Ohrid, FYROM 18 October 2016 Minawa Ebisui.

Improving the Garment Sector in Lao PDR:

National Social Dialogue

Introduction to Market-System Mapping

ITC-ILO/ACTRAV Workshop A Trade Union Training on Labour Law Reforms, ILO Standards and Trade Union Agenda (8 – 12/08/2011, Bangkok) Workshop Orientation.

22 May 2018 Sofia National Survey ‘Fine-tuning the Interventions of the GLI EA for Better Targeting of Labour Inspection’

Study on National Standards Capability

Decent work on plantations Sri Lanka’s TEA sector

An example for theory-based evaluation ERDF Berlin

THE LABOUR ADMINISTRATION AND INSPECTION PROGRAMME LAB/ADMIN

National Union Management Consultation Committee - Drug Manufacturing Inspection Transformation May 16, 2017 Regulatory Operations and Regions Branch.

Presentation transcript:

The Interaction of Private and Public Labour Regulation: A Case Study of Better Work Indonesia Regulating for Decent Work Conference 2015 Geneva, July 2015 Ockert Dupper Research Officer, Governance Department, ILO Colin Fenwick Head, Labour Law and Reform Unit, ILO

Institutional motivation Choice of BWI as case study Choice of analytical model(s) Research methodology Purpose: map interaction of private and public actors; identify how regulatory institutions can optimise efficiencies and profit from complementarities Examine mechanics and qualities of interaction; NOT effect of interactions on labour conditions; OR how rules and norms develop and change over time The Interaction of private and public labour regulation: A case study of Better Work Indonesia 2 Project overview

Theories of regulation Decentered regulation in practice: how do PCIs interact with state-based regulatory action? Qualities and character of interaction Mechanisms and mechanics of the interaction Kolben’s “regulatory dialogism” The Interaction of private and public labour regulation: A case study of Better Work Indonesia 3 Theoretical framework

Source: Kevin Kolben, “Dialogic Labor Regulation in the Global Supply Chain, forthcoming Michigan Journal of International Law (2015) Y Axis = Institutional formality; X Axis = Subjectivity and Practice The Interaction of private and public labour regulation: A case study of Better Work Indonesia 4 Regulatory dialogism

Service model Assessments Advisory services Training BWI Established in July factories (PEs) Indonesian textile industry 90% located in Java 55% in West Java alone BWI has presence in 15 of 500+ districts The interaction of private and public labour regulation: A case study of Better Work Indonesia 5 Background: Better Work Indonesia

Structure Directorate-General of Labour Inspection Development (Ditjen Binwasnaker) Inspectorate decentralized NB: Proposed recentralization Characteristics Resource constraints: 300 / 508 districts have inspectors <1% of enterprises serviced by labour inspectors (ILO, 2013) Ratio of inspectors to workers: 1/47,000 (even below ILO ideal for less-developed countries – 1/40,000) Low motivation; high turnover (60%); limited accountability Inadequate training and technical capacity Corruption Innovation: ‘Labour Norm Cadres’ The Interaction of private and public labour regulation: A case study of Better Work Indonesia 6 Background: Labour inspection in Indonesia

The Interaction of private and public labour regulation: A case study of Better Work Indonesia 7 Application of the analytical model to Indonesia FORMAL AND INTENTIONAL PAC Secondment of inspectorate officials Bipartite ad hoc committee Enforcement and training FORMAL AND INTENTIONAL PAC Secondment of inspectorate officials Bipartite ad hoc committee Enforcement and training FORMAL AND UNINTENTIONAL Little evidence MoMT has facilitated some formal contact between BWI and dinas FORMAL AND UNINTENTIONAL Little evidence MoMT has facilitated some formal contact between BWI and dinas INFORMAL AND UNINTENTIONAL Displacement Relative scope of influence Methodology (Uncoordinated) complementarity Free up state resources? Comparative advantage? Indirect strengthening INFORMAL AND UNINTENTIONAL Displacement Relative scope of influence Methodology (Uncoordinated) complementarity Free up state resources? Comparative advantage? Indirect strengthening INFORMAL AND INTENTIONAL Bipartite ad hoc committee BWI / dinas INFORMAL AND INTENTIONAL Bipartite ad hoc committee BWI / dinas

Interaction altered & shaped how labour inspection conceptualised / managed in practice BWI has strengthened the inspectorate (even if mostly ad hoc) Displacement not a risk (but may well be elsewhere) Findings reinforce other empirical studies on public / private compliance Empirical reality more complex than theoretical arguments would accommodate What ‘works’ vary significantly according to country and context What ‘works’ may often be discovered through trial and error and persistence of interaction More field work needed to verify Possible replication in other BW countries? The Interaction of private and public labour regulation: A case study of Better Work Indonesia 8 Some preliminary conclusions